Dlf Universal Ltd & ANR v. Koncar Generators And Motors Ltd
!" #$$%!
&! '!( )!*!!$! #$ +$
&! !%",-!.$ /% ! $*!0,.$
!%+! !-%-%1+",.$
!%!+$
2%" !0 !0!3!"/!$,/%/("$3% !" $$!#%! ! !0(!!4 5$!(+%(
!$(" !%+!%(3#$%!
! % 3 % $ /% % /!$ / +$ ! % "! /%%6(/ "$!%#/%%(! $$$%++"($!-7 %.!3!$" .,88 9:%.9; !%!/%!"!$(" !%!+$ $$%! !%3/%! ! "$ %31($!-7 9%.9
!$(!%!$!$%%!" $ ! ! %/!$$#( !#<(!!(+/("$3%$/%
31($!-7 %88 ./! ""4$+$ 5 /("$3++!+!!+!$(-7$78 %88 .
!
"
"
#$
"
=
"
% &
'
!
(
)"
)% &*+ %,
)
-.
/"
) "
!
% + &%,
7
)
% 0)
(
'
!
% 1
'
'
'
%2 $+($ ! % % 4!
5!"
%#3! ##! ++$ .!3!" :!3(" 0 = .!3!!$(!3!.!3!":!3("+$/!$ >
7:%"($0+! %/!$!$($! ( 3
% %& !
'
/ % 4
.5
6 "
( 3
% %& !
784 04/%
.5
0
>
777
"
(
0 )''
3 3
% %& !
% %
. . .% 4
+
'
77 /&%-4
)''
00/7%.- +
3
% %&:
)''
8/.&
$
.5
6 %2 +$ "$6(+3 !%"!$ "
?($0 -! ,*(!0 ! !#$6( % /!$ !6(+/! !!$%(! "!$ .$$"!?($0,*(!0&!%! "$31($!
-7 %88 .
8:%! !,%+! "$ ++"($!-=7 %88 . !0$%/!$, /%%/$#$34%(! 7 &! "$% ! ++"3 !%@0%(! :%++" "$34%+!/ /%$!/ $!$!$$> !"A0%%++"($!
-=7 %88 ./#3" (!0%+$4 % !++"3 !%(!,% +!$+$(# >!!3 !%"!$<6(0 (!5/!$!$% >!!/("$3!"$%!+$ (!%0 BC0(! -%$("$BC 5$ 31+ "$34%+!($!-7
%88 ./$#$ 7 &! "$! +%(! =
, /%%/$#$$%(!+$% ""/0!$! ;
&% %&4
:
:
('
('
'
'
% '
% <
'
3%-%.
+
'
)
% =
% 6 % <
% <
&% %&4 $%7 !
3%.4
3%-%.
+
'
% < +
'
+
> ?
@
+
% <
! 2 "#"4,%! + "$34%+!/ $#$34%(! $!$!$$ 7+$ "$ ++" !6( %#4$! 7:%! !, %6(+!#$+$0$+(3/%+! !/%/!" $ ! !(+ !#<(! !$ <6(0(! $!$!$$ = +$C
7 %$4/%31($!-7 "$34%+!/! ""4 $#$%!" $ !$!#0%! % ! (+ :% !$! +$ 34 % "!$ <6(0 (! $$
= %3%""0$3 !%(!34 "0%! + :%(!%%!$"!$(" !%+!"0% $/%%!3"0%!(0%%++!3C
!$ (" ! % +! % (3#$ % % !" $ !$!#0%! ! 5$!(+
!0(!!4%("$3%$ %/!$@(3#%+!
-78 %88 .,% !0/!$+$ !3"30 $#$$! (! 5%"! ,%%(3#$%% 31 "$ 34 % +! ($! - 7 9% .9 /! $#$34%"!$.$$"!?($0,*(!0 7 @(3#%%#%!" $ ! !!(+ C 7 %%!%$,"!$ (" !%!+$ % (3#$ % - 7 % 88 . "4 $/ $ !
!# % !0/!$@(3#%%(!!!$ %% !0/!$ !3","4%%/!$ %""3$#$3$! %(!@,%! !,(3#% 31($!-7 %88 . "$34%+!/!
""4 $#$ 34 % @0% (!
7 @, "!$ <6(0(!%!!"4$!#$%!" $ ! ! <(!(+,%/!$3#$#$$! %(!% $4
!$(" !%+!%$!/%
%(!%1($0#+$34%@93"-(+!#(!87
-(++"#- =D,
%9 > A'
2%@ %! !!$$
!+!0!+% % 1($0#!%% @93"-(+!#(!%$%"$%%$ $!%""3%!" $ !++"40 !!@,%(3#$%%/!$30 $#$$!,% !!++"3"%$ /!$ %("$% 3++"$ :%1($0#+$34%@93"-(+!#(!%
!" (+!$"0/%(/%(#+!!$(+%
8 ! !$#$%/!$ 8 7$%/!$/ "$ "%@0%(!$$!!#%! /+$34%(! ?($0#+$/%! !.!3!$"., 88 $%++"3"
!$(" !%+!%! !!$ !( % 1($0#+$34%$
!@0%(!$$0$
! $ ( :% (! $ " % ! ! !$ 1($0#/("$3!4%%!%$,"!$(" !% !+$%! !!$1($0#+$34"%@0%(!% D$
A =%$%6%B%= ; C ; 2<6( &> $. E<E= E 7 @ % (3#$ % "% @0% (! % %"$ % % !" $ ! ! <(!(+%3!!"4C34 %"!$<6(0(!3%$/%%31($! -7 %88 ./! ""4$$$
7@% "$!/% %(!%!$!+$34%@93" -(+!#(!- &
7 7$$$ 70% 1($0#+$34%"%@0%(!&!0*!-&. (+! :%-+" &/$"$ < !# % !0/!$0 !$34&! 9% .9 - 78 $" /% % ( /% % !0 /!$ !3"$3$0-7/%%%36!$3 "4 $/$ ! !# % !0/!$-78+! $ %/%!%(! $%% !0/!$ !3"($!
%%+!,% !0!3!"/!$%""3$#$3$!
%(! -78"!"4+""(%3 ! !0/!$
$!$ !3"$#$$! %(!,%(! !F(!$!!$ %% !0/!$ !3"($!
%%+! -(%$!# ""4#/%31($!
-7 9%.9! ""4$$$5%31($! -7 9%.9#3$$$ ""4"4
7/% %! + "$34%+!0$#" %31 +($!-7,/ ""4$#$ 5%+!,/%%3$"40%6( %
!0/!$34 "0++"31$%+! ( +! %1($0#&! ("4,%+! "$++"($!
- =7, "%(0% / #3", /%% / $#$ &! "$++"%(!,/%%//%$!/:%! !
%+!!$+!(031($!-7,/%%/! 0$#$34%(! "!$.$$"!?($0,*(!0 $%! !%+! "$%! +,/%%/$#$
7(!0%+$4 % "! ,!#!$!/ +! /%%# $"4 "$ 5%$!$+ %(!,%+!3 +!#$ $!/ 3 34 $"40 % 6( % /!$ !! !0(!!4 "((. !0/!$+$, /%%%3 ($33$0$ !3"%30
5/""3""4F(3" !%$!%"$!, %!" $
! ! !#<(!(+/%! !4+! ($ 3 !%$/%%/!$/ ""4%"$3 !3"34% 5$(!:%!F(!# !%$!"#(5$ (+!4%"$34%@93"-(+!#(!D3
$
'
; %A
'
2887-(++"#
- 77 5 / %$(#$3 ,%(!$ $ 4!$
!/%%"(!! $34%"!$<6(0 (!$!#0%!" $ ! ! <(!(+
7%$4/%%31($!-7/! ""4 $#$ @,! +$#$
2%%!-+C0E$ GE 2%%!+!3" GE