← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaARB/7/2019disposed of

M/S H.V. Construction Co v. Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd

2020-02-12Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal3 pages



      

  !"!# 

  &"'" (!()  

*+!,!&- &(  ../( &     ,   0& 0(123&  "!."&   $%$ 4 *+!,!&- &(  ../( &     ,   0& 0(123&  "!."&   $5$ 4 *+!,!&- &(  ../( &     ,   0& 0(123&  "!."&  *)  63*   73

"!"&) *2.""&(1089 &"8'&0"../( & *"".:(/89 &"8'&0""!."&  ;;;;;;;

 738

3# <(&&"!&&"2"&'(/"="0/''&0""!."&(-&&> (!""&="&:""  .>&0""'0!=""!-../("&/"" -!"/'&0"../( & 0""../( &(!="&?""&0"!2".&("!="(1 $%$ 4     $5$ 4  @   

       

   A"="(1(!.!"'&0-10&0"."!"& 22"

&0"!:"' 9"(" "8' &!"="(1&:"'2   0"  ."!"&  ../( &(  0!  =""  '(/"  -"  " &(    '  &0"

BC =(&&( (/(&( &8

D '!0&8&0" &#'..(&2"&'

=(&& 2(&&"/>8&0".&("!"&""(&1""2"&!."?0( 0&0" ../( &?!&"E" -&"'&0""!."&?:'&" 0(1+&" 0/"!! .(."/>(1=>+."&" 02"&08  =/"=/?(18  =/"!./( (1 &"2(&(8.".&('F(& 02="8'(E(18.(&(1!(1?(&(1 '  -&"+F(&  (( &!    &0"  !! (&"  ?:!  (  &0"     F-(!( &(!." /-!"5'&0"1""2"&//&0"(!.-&"!="&?""&0" .&("!?0( 0?""&(!"-&'!- 01""2"&?""&="!"&&/"&0-10&0" 2"'=(&&( (!.-&"!09(1(!"="&?""&0".&("!8&0"../( &&0-10 !"9"/&( "!!"&&&0""!."&!(9:"&0"=(&&( /-!"!-10& ..(&2"&'=(&& 9(1&" "(9">"!.!"&&0"!( &( "!8&0"."!"&../( &(0!

=""'(/"'&0"'"!("/("' '&"0"(1/"" -!"/'&0".&("!8-!&( "=(8 '2"-1"'&0(!-&(!..(&"!&0"!/"=(&&?"9"8!- 0 ..(&2"&  ?-/  ="  !-=F" &  &  &0"  " /&(  &  ="  2"  =>  -!&( " =(-"" &('&0" &?(&0"1&0(!("."" " (2.&(/(&>&!"&&/"&0"(!.-&"="&?""&0".&("! 0"=(&&(!"G-"!&"& 2./"&"&0". ""(1!?(&0(&0" &(2"/(2(&!." ('("-"" &( '&0" & 0"=(&&!0//=".('""(  "?(&0&0" -&0  0"-/"'&0" &8!2""!2>="2-&-//>!"&&/"=>&0".&("! &0"=(&& !."1""2"&"E."!!"=>/"" -!"/'&0".&("!8' &0"!:"'&0" 9"(" "'&0"("!." &(9" /("&!!/!

'&0"=(&&8 &0"9"-"'&0"=(&&(!

BC   .>'&0" &0(! "=" '?" &-!&( " =(

"&#&&0"1(9""!!)$ H48" &$ 0(10 '&"!"":(1&0" 9"(" "'&0"=(&&8&0".&("!" (" &"&.."="'"&0"=(&&I   >&0"&"

!-(&=/"&//  "" //&0"&0""../( &(!="(1  8 $%$ 4  $5$ 4"(!.!"'(&0"=9"&"2!     B 73C !02!0"    <0"&0"!.":(1+"!" ) "!+ <0"&0"".&=/"

)"!+