High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/201/2014allowed

Anar Devi v. Moti Lal

2023-01-17Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan12 pages

! " #$"" % & ' #

%( ) &

)*#+,! ")

#" $$ -(,! " ) ....

/ (0," ") 1((0

!,$20 -( "3"0%(,

#4""5$ ,6# $"4 #$")# " 7 08 4 (9! ,: " " $ ) %( "7 $", 0 ;( , )) "46", ((-0,6# $, <$+ "( ") $) ) 4 $

#)(5:1# #4""5$ ,6# $)40 ( / "- (# ")("-"" )" " ") ,"(" 4$$!) 5") ) "") ," ") =# 40" 4) (##)""!$"

,-" $-"" -!"( > ") , (0<"($-""-,- #$" $ ( ""#,-" (0+3# ($-""-," #$" $"$ #( ) , (0, " $%?

5$ , (" ) ($ ##

!(4(""#@# " ,

$ )< "4) " ) ""#!(4(,-""4$!" $, " ,"0") # "

4 )(4(4+ " ;" ))" "))0 A 21) "?(#$"#?"") #) B: C " ), " ) " # " " ) -B:((" "$"# # " ")=#;" ) # " """#) !0 ")1"#6# $0 (-" 7 0&#+4 :: $") ," =#" ) ! ( !"")4#,#","4 #$"" + )4 (( ,6# $:

$$," ))) (- )(0$"), ( $) ( 04+"

$ # + !(4(") >") " )) ""# -"(""-""( 0> ") "4) # D$" )")! " ")> " " ($ $ " ) ) !#(04#"(>""$ "# ( 4 $ # $" ")!> ")"4(+#" " )>") (, !(#!?#"<-($") ," ) " ) 4")4# #") ) :1 $ " " "))#>")("-" ")4# "")$!

) 5") - (($4- $) );" )" ")=# =# 40") ) (# $ " ),") )" 4#($ +#+$" ")"" #!

" 4#($ # " =# "-"(" (0") ;" ) ""$ #) (0!(4(") """)"# ") B: " " "$"# # "") =# $" ,"-(-0 0)0" " ) $ )4#) " ( ## ) !$ $" ),"" "

B: : "A21) " #$ ,E21($-" 40"# ," "$ # !(4(") >" ) (( "# ? #$" $ ," )) 0 (") ;" ) " ( )( ! $ " (($"- )(0-" $"! " ) 2 " )($ " ) , ((-$ # - F"" ") (!)"# ) ) 0 40 -0 ! ) " $ #

")G && F"" ") ) 4(G &

( B /"") (! )" (

# $"# !") , "<"

3# )(&- 0"( ) $" &F#4 $"!9?&F1-""" ) """) $!");") # " ? "3# &F,-"#)) "" ) C 4#(," )$" F #4 $"!F1-""" )"" ! $!"- )(0

2 " $ $# ,( (( ,6# $ #5!# ") $" ), #5-$" )!# " ) #((0,!+#$ : ")- )" )- 4+ " ) "$ #40") " "- !" ) -") " " ")$"+#$ ,($-"", ") -#(4(<)" #$"$0" # E ;" )-$$ !40"+#$ " "())(4 "# ))((#" 0,6# $, -"" - $ ( *#$# ))(( #" 0, 6# $, -" ! +#$ :E

)"))(,"+#$ 1+ )40" (( ,6# $, #((0 "+ ) -" : 5--# ") 1((0( ""<<" "# 40-0($") !),-""-$! )1,-"" )#)) " #$"#( C"!" ( #( ") 4$$ " #$"" C"" (")(( 4- ") )#;" $ # < "+

B )-" $ ") (0"((01) " (0<"3# ") 1((0)) " )(&- 0))$"-4?&F7 "#4 "!9?&F1) "? " -"""" )"") $!" )C"!,)((0)(") " (0 =# (

" " (0 7- ? ($"4"(" )4#" #"< -" $ " =# (

$", %()) $F !"!9?F1-""""#"$ # ) (04$!(4(") ;" (( (0"!#40") ($"")($ 4"") $"($()" " (# " " ) "! 4 =# (

"( + )" ) / " (( ,6# $," )1"<#))("" ) - 4$#")

()# )4$! ()# ) #")(<40 )1($-" " +#$ 40 ( #( ) $ )1

! " # - < #" )( " ) -

+4 !$" "" $) "4#($-4$# ()# )" ) -) "-"(4#($,-""-4$# ()# ) # " " ) "4 4( ) #0#"# -""#(4"("" ) 4#(0

()# ) ( )# ) F"( <$ #" 4 ! ( - )( #) +#$ 40"# $%

&'(

* *'*' +'* #,""")4$#

( )# ) $ ) " ( "# () -((" +#$ -

/- " *'*' +'* "-" " (4#($-(#")," 4 4

(4#($"(( (!" " 4 =# % (( $!$(#"4 !""(( ($"+ " ") " ) ( 0# " (

" (0 C""!-<" 40( (( ,6# $-) ) )) ) ,-" - -" $ "!-)40( ( *#$ # ))((#" 0,6# $% ))((#" 0" (0- $(0(0"!4# ) "(-(-"( ! $"$" (( #5$ "+ % ))((#" 0"<- $

E !-" "))" )1) (4#($ " )# "! 0 4$$ C - "( 4

( # % ))(( #" 0")( (#)+#$ )40"# 1 $* 0 %*%

2 -3 2 =#$"((-$4 !

7-! ,-")( (#)) ! !40") ," #"" $(( 0" #" ""),-""( $) ""# $ "")=#4$-" $) ""#" #$")$0 --" " )$4$" , ((0-" -""

$) ("#(# $ 4#

()# ), <) !00, )$ " "0 ( 0" ""0 #;" ,40 $"") -" " " ) " "# "

: )#(<")($"-""") =#" "#$") !-""# " #" - ) ""# ;" )1") #0# )( 4 #$" 0!"-""# ") =#"4$"$

(-" " $ ) ""# 4 ( 2 % #( ") " +#$ -

(((

-2'+

*'(

'* 3 #4 2 -" " ! 0 # #) 4 "# -4 !"-"4#($ #$( ("## ( 4#($,"#$"#4=#(0-) "4#($ ") 4#$" (#")"-#("$" # ) 4#($ ( (" (( (+" ") 4 ()# )C"! 0+#$ ,-4 !"" -"" 4#($ ( (," " D$ $#(4#($4# ( 4#($ ( 4#($ )$ "- " D$ $#(?

D$ $#(?,"4#($ # 4# "--4#(" )("--# ")# )($"#$" !(#! 4! B C",!

) ""4#($- # ()# ) $) "4#($") ($-"" " (0

4 $;" ") #4") " 4#($)#"!$

(# ) #("!" ),-""#4 " !$"-""#$"""(($) "" ")($-""" +$")-"$(( 04- 4""")- # )(0 40 ")

7 ! " 0 :E " ) " )(

# $ H?BH4# 4 !!" $ "4 ) #40" )C" ? -"" - -)(9?&) #40") ," " ""))#"$(( 0"4 $"(0)" 7 "" $) "4#($,") ($ -"" (0 $ % #( ") "# " +#$ $(*('

6''78 )40" # 2B:EB ,-" $(*#$ "# "4 !"-"4#($! (-") (( ,-((#4 (4#($(( (!"" $ #4 =# +#$ $

*9 )40"# 5 B:EB:E" 4 40( #( ") -" $(

*#$"# ($-"+ 4#($(##" ( $4#"4 !"" 4#($#4 ((( (+" "$ #4 =# C@#((/"+#$ "# :!**

$! 3#

9,-""-# 7 08 4 ( 9! ,: ,-4 !"-" ( 4#($-(# ()# )-"#4$" - ) " (( " ,"4#($-#(#4 (4#($" (( (<"+ "$ #"4 ) ( =# E C") (," "$"-"- ) " (( "44 $#" ")" ()# ) "," ,# "4#($ (" )(" )1""

(# 4 ) : ;" ")) !4)# #") "! 04$$&F "")((0 "% ))((#" 0" - " "")- #) #""#(4"

(0"4# )$#- <"4 ($((0 4( ! !(4( " ;" , " +#$ )40"( ))((#" 0,6# $4

# % ))((#" 0,6# $( (0(( ! $"($(!(+#$ )40" (( , 6# $ ;" - " -" ;" ,"+#$ )40))((#" 0,6# $ " +#$ ) 40 " (( , 6# $ ;" ) !" ")-" ) - "")$"+#$ ;" !)((- $(0

" ! ) ((-, "

((#))( ,0,) $(0

/ +

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#