Mangal Singh v. Amrik Singh
!" #$%!&#'
&() %!+!,+'
""& -&. /&0,+'
1("
!" "!#
&"$ %&.&!)(#!")
&"'1""& %&2-&/!)(#!")
&"'&1(" 33333 "!# $
""&4( (!" 45.(+/" (6"& & 1""!+!""'/1.+(&(&)7'&68"'65#" (68'/ 4!4"'(#&(!"(99 +&!"+1# #1& &/!# "' !+&/""(!"( :
;)'!(6(/( "7.(6"' " "'+"+6& 1& !# "' /!""&
1("41!"
""."( ! ,." :
;
* 0+ 1# # 1& &/!# "' !+&/" " !
&/"()7'#'7!(#&(68"'"&!.&"(5.(+/"!( (#&(!"(99 )7'&68"'&1("41!"
7!+"7 /"'< "/ " (1" "' 6!!# ! #(&!" 7"' ! .&"'& (&#"""'1""&4( (!""=#.""'!(( !.& "' &1("41!"
'!
&/"(5.(+/"!((#&7!!!( 68"'1""&4( (!"(11! : *: >
&"'1&( "7/"'#.(=1&?'!
&/"(!11! 7! (/( ( 5.(+/" !( (#& (!"( 9 ' +.!& ,#(11!*@ 97!1& &&(6 &"'.&")7'#'7! (/( (5.(+/" (!"( @@ 9.&+ "'1(#8 "' !
&/"( &+.!& !11!) &1("41!"
.6/""( ! !11#!">=.& 4 ?(!"(** 90+1&/ "'.&"
"(1""'6!!#!#(&!")) )
)
A4
* 9) "'"&!.&"1!("'&(&>=.& 4;?"'=#."!11#!" !+7"'/#!11#!")7'#'&!("'.$4 B
!
"
# $% &
'
#
)
*
(
% #) #
*
)
(
' ,)
-
$ !
. /0 1& 2
'3 1$2/ )4 '!
&/"(=#."!11#!"7!65#"("68 "'1""&45.(+/"(6"&"'!""'5.(+/"!((#& "'"&! .&" '!( 6#/ .=#."!6 & 4(1" "' !/."
)
)
A4 !( "' .&" #.( " +&!" "' =" " "' !
&/"(65#"7'#''!6(/((/1.+(&(& #"'1&"&1"" %&.&!)!&(#.!11!&+6'! "'
1""&45.(+/" (6"& .6/""( "'!" "' /1.+( &(& " ."!!6 !7) &) "'& 7! /1(/" & 6!& .1 "' &1("41!"
"(1"+"'6!!#!#(&!")
"'!11!6 &"'27&11!".&"7!1(+=1!!" '!#/&#&('!11#!" &=" "/6& "
&!=#1""'!")"'!6.6/""("'!""'!11!7!(/(68 "'27&11!".&" 9""'6")"'!11#!"#.( '!6/(7"'!1&( "7/"'"'7"'""
(1"+ "' /8 .11&" ' #"") &( .1 "' 1& ,#"* "',1# # #") @ > &'&"B @
#"C?"#"("'!""'"!"."&81&1&("'(#&"6 .=#."!6 "'!11#!" & &# "'#"&!#"& (#&'!("6/()"'(#&'!(6#/.=#."!6 .11&" '#"")''!"!0"'!( "'5.(+/"&(&(68 "'<6,.1&/.&"% &'())*+'
)$ ,- .
'+/)0- ."#"("'!"#!"'1.&#'!& !" (1""'!/."7"'"'!(1&(& .&"'&"7/"'+&!"(68 "' .&") "' .&" #!" ="( "' "/) %+( ) *+'
* 2)/))() 3 $ 4- . '+/)- ." #"("'!"7'&"'(1"'!("6/!(7"'"'"1.!"("/ &="'!("6.+'"6 &"'=1&8 "'1&( &(1") "' (#& 6#/ .=#."!6 !( /!& )+ ) -78)7./6+ '56 * ) 9/ 56) 7 /6+$ ,-:.% "'"'&'!()%&2-&/!)!&(#.!11!&+ 6'! "'&1("41!"
&(.1"'5.(+/"&(&(68 "'<6,.1&/.&")()2'//;<'=/)*+')+)$>>:"
: - .>>"#"("'!"#"'!11!7!#".!" !."!( "'!/7! (7"'"'1&(+68"'=#."+.&")"'& 7!##! &"'&1("41!"
"(1""'!/.") &)"
7!.#&"!7'"'&"'5.(+/"!((#&7.(."!,#" 9* "' &#(.&(/1!6+!".1"'.&"!!( 7'!8!11#!"/("!&+A="("'"/"' +.!& ,#(11!7!!1(+7'"'!11#!"7! (!("'& 7!"&/"!8)"'& &)"'&+!"8!(1&&"8' 65#"7&"/!"!!6) &)"'1""&45.(+/"(6"&(( "/!8!11#!" &&# "'#"&!#" '!'!&("'!&(#. &"'1!&"!(!11&!( "'1!1&60 ' D." &!( 6 & "' .&" &+!&(+ "' !11#!6"8 1& ,#"* @ #"&,#" 9* "' &#(.&(!118 &"'!0 6&"8)6"'"',#"!& ="&!#"('&67$4 B 8/ 0 /6 =888/ . &
#(
5*
(
6 12 7 5
#(
5
(
* )
)
5
)*
5
5
5* #
5
*
5* *
5
,
*
8 5 9 12 7
(0 12* 6 12
*
(
5 *
#
*
1(2 5
5 #
5
)
(
#
*
8
9
5
#
5
) 12 +
5
5
5
)
(0 12* 5*
* )
5
*
5
) 5!6 12
#5
#
:
1(2
#5
*
*
5
#5
12 ,
5 5
# *
*
*
5 ( 1;2 <
5
7 5
5
(
)
' * 5*
* *
5
5
#
5 4
1&.! "'!
&/"(1&)"(""'!"
"'1.&#'!& !"(1""'6!!#!#(&!"7"'"' "/1&#&6(68"'.&")"'(&'!!6&"8"!118""'!/ .&""'!"'#"&!#"&#((!(.#'!11#!")"'.&"/!8 &#("'#"&!#")7'#')!##&(+""'#"" %&-&/!7.( /! "'!" 7' .#' !11#!" 7! /( & &# "' #"&!#")"'!11#!"6'! "'&1("4(#&'(&0+ =" "/.6/""("'/"' %!8) 97!/!"!!6 '#"")/87)""!6!(7'8/1!#() &) =1!!" '! #/ &7!&( ! " 7'8"'6!!#!/." 7! " (1"(7"'"'"/1&( !"!)"'&1("41!"
7!!
&!( ."#/ "'!11!!+!"'/)'#.('!+""'& .( "' !/.")6."4(1" "'6!!#!#(&!"! "' +&(" &!(!(7+) &)"'!"6 &/"'(!"
"'=#." "'!+&/"")(.&+".6"#)" +
"'."!(1!+ "'(#&'!
&/"(7 / .11&"(68"'&!"(#((#.(.""75.(+/")) /))( *+')76; 6;)($ 4-:.-.,) 7 *9);)6)+)/6 *+'% )/+3 /6+$ 4-:. >- . '&1("41!"
)(1"'!+!(#&' !.&) (("(1""'!/." 6!!#!#(&!"!()"'.)"' &!(!(7+7!!#0+'!
&/"(7 / '!6&"&!"(68"'<6,.1&/.&"%+( ) 8) -'=+).1!&!+&!1' " 97'#'&!("'.$4 =12
(
(
0
5
8 0 (
4
*
)
)
)
(
5
,
(*
0
5 8
& 5 > # #?
1--2 ''
@*
#
& * -@
(
0
12
(# * #
(
0
*
8 0 (
.
&
*
(
5
* ) (
0
5 * 12
.
&
) !
=. &
#(
5*
(
6 12 7 5
#(
5
(
* )
)
5
)*
5
5
5* #
5
*
5* *
5
*
8 5 9 12 7
(0 12* 6
0 12
*
(
5 *
#
*
1(2 5
5 #
5
)
(
#
*
8
9
5
#
5
) 12 +
5
5
5
)
(0 12* 5*
* )
5
*
5
) 5!6 12
#5
#
:
1(2
#5
*
*
5
#5
12 ,
5 5
# *
*
*
5 ( 1;2 <
5
4 12
<
( (#
#
8 0 (
( (
8 0 (*
12 #) (#* )
)
%
> ' , 1;2 <
)
) )
4 % &'())8)-'=+).$"'<6,.1&/.&" !&! " :'!'(!.(&$4 =
)
(
)
#
)
%)#* )
5
*
9 )
)
<
)
(
#
)
* )
) 9
8
* )
5 + )
5
5 9
)
# 5
3 #
A * 1-.-2 ''
*
( # !
B<
)
# 5
+
)
(
< C5C
)
)
5*
*
5
5
B
D
8
;E
< '*
(
D
)
EE <*
EE
@E
)
)
(
@;E
'# )
) @;E
* E;E )
5*
0F5 )
.;E* )
0
5 %)#*
#
)
( .;E
.;E < &A
-;E
)
-;E <
0F5
)
5
< <
0
)
( )
'*
( *
)
< <
0
*
5
)
9 <
D* )
<
)
0F5
)
)
5 ) < <
#
#
)
5
.;E <
)
D* )
(
$ 0
0 F5
#
5
9
%# # (# (#
5
0F5
)
*
)
5
)
5
(
D*
0F5 -;E
&
"
# 7G
* 1--.2 - ''
.*
)
)
* )
<
)
)
)
* )
(
*
#
) <
#
#) (# 9
)
0F5 )
9
#
) ) #
0F5*
# 5 (
)* #
$ 0
)
0 F5
; <
*
0F5
)
5 <
)
0 #
0
D*
0F5
5 #) ) 9
%
9
)
< ' ' 9 5*
0F5
$ 0
) <
4
1("41!"
'! " + !8 =1!!" "
/+"'!11#!">=.& 4 ?!
"&(/! "'!11!
!.!&8) 9!"'!11!7! (6 &"'=1&8 /"'
1!+ "'5.(+/"!((#&(!"(99 #!)"'!11#!" '!(6.6/""(7"'!"'&/"'"'& )"'1&(1" "'!11!7!!6"6#(( #"',"!"."" 1&("' 1&#(.& &&(&+"'(#&.=#."!6)/87)"'1& ,#" 9* 7.("#/""'!(!('1 !8(#& '(& &0+=" "/1!&"8#!"!0"'!( "' 1&7'"',"!"."" ("1# 8!8"/"'
!#"&)/87)'!("6#(&(#&&#"1&1#"68"' "&! .&" 7' &5#"+ "' 65#" "' 1""& '.) "' 5.(+/"!((#&(!"(99 +&!"+"'1# #1& &/!#
"'!+&/""'!(6#/.=#."!6 %&.6/""("'!"'#"7+"&".&"'!&" /8 )
A4!+7"'"&"""'&1("41!"
' !
&/"(1&!8& %& !&!(1&1& 7 7'!" '! 6 "#( !6) "' 1""&4 ( (!"(&#"("& .("'!/." ;
)
A4!+7"'"&"
E@F1&!.//1.+(&(&"4!( 1"""!( !7( )+86 +7$ 0 -"!# .
+)(6 ?<
#6/6+=)2 5@+) 7 &@
#6/6+= +/)A &@