High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2119/2014disposed of

Harjaswant Singh Alias Jaswant Singh v. Niranjan Singh & ORS

2016-02-01Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

!" #$ %&'!&( ) * !&+!,!"-./!!!,!"-./ ""& 0&' &!+!-./1"/& 23"

!" "!# $ %&

4/"/& 2&"& #!2!2&5!(%!,3""/+'3.5"6 %& &&3""/ 2&"&&"6 7 4/"/&"/+'3.5"/'3%&2&"3"/."6

&"$ 8& -'3/,!&)3#!")

&"/2""& 8&!('/'2"!)3#!")

&9 &23"-!/%-./)) &23":;):;!3:;1 )7) !3< ===== "!# $

'()* / 2""& !..&3 "/ &3& 3!"3 >

) ,/&%("/!22#!" 3'3& &3& ' 7 ?."".@ !3 "/ &3&3!"37

!3 +'3.5"!3 3#&3!"37 )/!%353!3&3&3!"37 7) ,/&%("/!22! 3!.!""/35! "/!22#!")/!% 353 8& -'3/,!&)!&3#'!22!&.%/! "/ 2""&'%5""/!"!?/"!,!&-./,!,& "/!3!3/)3 +'3.5"!33#&3!"3AA

> )B#'"3!3#& !'& "/ 2""&

A)"/!

&5"3+'3.5"!33#&,!#/!.3 %(!?/"!,!&-./!3"/2&#3.)"/2""&),/,!

!&&!(3!!3 3!"),!2&#337

!3"/&!

"& +'3.5"!33#&3!"37 ,!2!3 !22#!"'3& &3& ' 7 "/'",! 3 7 < "!?.'5&'.&'3),/#/!&'5&!"3/&%,$@ !;

/ '55 " & &# "/ 2""& & *7

/,3"/!""/2""&/!3/33 &5"/"# "/ &# -&& !&/"!5 ! / "&! '&"

!3+'&3"/5!""& &7

!3'55"/&.!&3 ,&'3%("/2&#&.!.#(" &#-&& !&59!2&/&2&"3!"3*7

:B4C; "/'55)"/2""&/!& '3""!?"/'55D %;

/2& "/ &#3'&3/!"

%#523,"/)5'#/'55/!"%!

B3 #!"/&,!!#"'!& '!"/!33&."/ 2!",! E'&'?/"&!),/&!'55/!3%"!" 5%!!!3!#"'!("/2""&&3" 5%!!D #;

2&"/+'3.5"!33#&3!"3AA

> )"/

!"/& "/2""&/!3B#'"3!&F'/5"33

!'& /!3'""/&.!&323.!3+'3#!" #!"/ 3."/!22#!"'3& &3& ' !&""@!3)",'3/! !&@&!#/.

#""/ 23.'"!3)"/')2&!( &"". "/&3&'3& #/!. 8&!('/ '2"!) !&3 #' !22!&. %/!

&23" )7"<!39 &23"'%5""/!""/ 23#( "/!

&5"3'",!"/?,3. "/2""&

+ !"/'55,&"!""/#&&#"!33&,/&"/2""&,! &3./2""&/!"B!53&'553 &#-&&) !&59!),/!.3"/!&2&"3G& '!H"/'55 B!5!" "/!3 &#-&&)",'3/!%!#&"!3 ,/"/&"/2& "/ &#3'&3,&#523,"/& "&2#" 23#( "/&'")",'3%5!.!" ,/"/&"/ !"/& "/2""&/!3!#F'&3"/2&2&"(&"!3) "/')2&!( &35! "/&2"" /!/!&3"/!&3#' &"/2!&"!3!22&!3 "/2!2&%? /!

&5"3 !#",'3&!"/!""/2""&/!3 !#F'&3"/?,3. "/+'3.5"!33#&"/5"/

8!() !3 3"/'""/&!

"&/!33&,/#/"/'55 /!3%" 5%!!!32""&!&3" 5%!!"/ #&@B!5!" "/2&' &#-&&)!5() !&/"!5!) "/.'& !#3"#!'3"@!@"/&2&" !3.&# #!"/2""&/!3!(.&!#@!@"/&2&" & '!)/ /'3/!'553"/ &#-&&)!5()!&59!),//! #!'3"/&2&" G& '!H)%'"?,. '(,"/!"#!"/ !

&5"3,"B!53'22&" "/#""5!3 "/!22#!")/,'3.!"/2!)"/2""&33"'55 /5!. !3"3)!5 "/,"/!""/2""&/!3"/ ?,3. "/+'3.5"!33#& 3""3"3

&,"/"/ 3.&3&3%("/"&! '&"!3!,!"/22!"'&"/52'.3&3&!&/&%( !

&53

"5!3#!&"/!""/.5"3"/&3&)5'#/ "/&3&'3&#/!./!!

#""/23.&./" "/'"

#!5.&./""/2&2&"(!.3(,3%(!?/"!,!&-./ 4"/"/!

&5"3%&!")"/&2"" 323 ,-(.)(/$ 0 '"!# * ()12 %&