High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/231/2013allowed

M/S New Goyal Rice Mills v. Punjab State Coop. Supp. & Mrkt. Fed Ltd. & ORS

2018-05-18Mr. Justice Kuldip Singh3 pages

!"!#$%$&'((

%!) *+$#! $++% ! $ $&!, -!,%.% /!.&012 ! 3!, $4!2.33+$!%&" ,5! $&6!"!, $&7$8$ !" !%3&"!&

97 2 :

72 ,!%!& ';

, .5&" .3 <"4# !< ,3! $ $&!,

,2 &&<"4# !< ,,!%3&"!& =/! /!, /!!3, !,%+#+&!)%33!,8*1!++)!" %!! /!0."68!& > 1!,!!,,!" /!!3, !,,& =/! /!, /!0."68!& %/.+"1!,!3, !"$& /!"$6!% > ;;

;;

72 7

!," -$"! ,"!, " !" ?@ &&!A.,!;; < +!,&!"

$% ,$# ."6!<2&6,.,<$&#%!)/$+!"0."$# $&6.3&33+$# $&$+!" .&"!,2!# $&B,1$ , $&&" &#$+$ $&# <??C<6$&% ),"

" !"CB<3%%!"1*,1$ , ,2/,$22$&$<+!,&!"""$ $&+ $% ,$# &"2!%%$&%."6!! " <)/$+!1%!,4$&6 / #+$8$+!"1*

,5!"/%& /$&6 ")$ /#+$88$++!,D.3""*%+"$&3!&%+! 3+$#*< 54$!) / ,1$ , ,$+!" 3,&.&#! /!),"& /!

;;

6,.&" / %8!#.+"& 1!"! !,8$&!".&"!, /! ,$6$&+6,!!8!& /!,!,!<++)$&6,"!,)%3%%!"';

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

,"!," !"C(<$%%.!"& $#! 2/,$22$&$<+!,&!"""$ $&+ $% ,$# &"2!%%$&%."6!! " ,!%3&")/! /!,/!$%)$++$&6 # %,1$ , ,,& > &4$!))$++$&6&!%%2/,$22$&$<+!,&!"""$ $&+ $% ,$# &"2!%%$&%."6!! " # %,1$ , ,<$83.6&!","!, " !"< 3!,8$ $&6 33$& &!),1$ , ,<$%%! %$"! 2/,$ 2 2$&$< +!,&!" ""$ $&+ $% ,$# &" 2!%%$&% ."6! ! " < $% "$,!# !" ,!%.8! /! ,1$ , $& 3,#!!"$&6% &" %.18$ /$% $&"$&6% ,!3, ),"<$& !,8%,"!," !"?@<3%%!"1*+!,&!" $% ,$# ."6!<2&6,.,/!!!,1$ , ,,,!%.8!"/!,$&6% < ;<1!3$"$& !,8%9/! /&"$6,/,1$ , $& !& ,!

;;

"8$&$% , $4! % &",1$ , ,%9!!% .+!%<B< 1!%/,!"!D.++* 1*1 /3, $!% &%!D.!& +*<,!4$%$&$%++)!" :

(( %05% =/! /!,%3!5$&6 ,!%&!"

!% =/! /!,!3, 1+!