← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2476/2015dismissed

Kishan Singh Rahi And ANR v. Hans Raj Since Deceased Th Lrs Bimla Devi And ANR.

2017-03-21Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari14 pages



      

 !"# $%&

'() * + !

,(()! + !

   

                 %)  -.%  ///0. 

   

 !"

     

$%&!"

     //1(21311 4   '                  #   % ! 

 " "  (!&)( )     #) # *+ ,-,../,.  ,0,../,1 ' & (# )( ! ) #2+$ #   .3,/,33- 4 (  &# #  + # +  5 3 ,/& & /1/,.//0 && 6,/6.//3 7     ! +

 )+

) 

  '  &  5 3 ,/ ) /,,/,33- (+ #.8/9:+   &# + '  ( ))

  5 . ;& &   !  ,    %

!< 2 % &    # + ) #

+

&

# !& &)  '    6,,/,330# +

   4    !%   "   

  7##  &

 

     

       ) *  +# ) # *+ 4 #!  #  & +

  &  ,1,/,3=,  )  )(

  (&

 )     '# ! /0/1,33.   &   & 

 5 , '  )# + ,1,/,3=,

+  &    )  

     ! # !  ) ) #  :

   #  & ! # +     4 )!  (! #     "

+)

::&   4  )#     5 ,     

 )      &  .     

 %

!  <  2         & 

+)> & )+ # 

+ 

  +# +< 2 4 &+  +  

 

 ) & 

#&+ 

 + ?  & 

    &  ! # ! & @

#    &()

  <

& &  &&  &  

+) '  &

  %    &  &

 )  

 '#  & &#+ )( %  :

  

 

   

   

  

 

  

    

! "

   



 ## 

 $   

  %  



&

  '  

 

 ! 





   

  (

    

)

*

)" +

, -  

 

 ! 



& 

! "

 . / ?& &?+ )(     &#  "<:8 "<:0!&+(?& & ?+ )(    & #   )   &  #  7  #)

 ! &# &    %

        &     

+  )  

    

 

(    &    

       5 ,   +( 5 6! & &

&

 +#   #

   #  #

& 

 #

+)7  #  ) +

)( &   ! &   # A 5 1! 

 &     !& #       ( +

&     5 8!&&#+ !  +

&+ # + %  '      #    5 .  &    

    # 

B  % # + '4  #B   ' (!  

 $ + 2  + %  (.//6# + 24   +  ' (! 5  4 &

 &

 #  ) )    )      +

     (  )    &  

    !  &  &     +

 )(    +

!    ) # *+   

)  & 

 +  

 !"#$% & '() () # * +, - .'(

//   /01 %

"2/ '   (  3''' -  .4+  5+2  %  !2(#  #   # 5 '6# ( '" /// ' #        & 

  +

 !

 & (     

 %   #      !    (!      +   ) # *+  

# 

)

) 4 )+

    !&+  .//+&(# + 

 # ! 

 )# +

  ()  + '   +  +(!  )       #       + ( &  )      ) +    

  ) +

 )

) "

 ! +

&+ ) ! # !     

&  ) ? 

 )  C*+ 4 

   

& # 

4  +  +

2+$ )  

 

   # )( #  "#    #  # ! + #   )   )()

! # ! #+(

  

 

 (&  

()  



) '  )

 )( " "  ( '+ #   !   (

 +

   #  !

&(  % #  (# '+% &&      ) # *+    !"#$#, 

 *+ # #    ++ ) ) #  % 

   +  *+ 

) # ' 



+

 

 &   (  ) @   &  

  +#&  + '# ! 

"

 #,7#,'% 3 """

(7#,'

/// #, + # '

, ' 0  & ) #     

) 

  % &  

 

&&

+         &

)  + '*+   )    

+ 4# #  & &&   !  &

)   ) #   )    :

+ + &0

 &

  * "

1"

*2# *"

* *  3

3  1

1  *4 5#0

 &67 &  &

  *"

6#

 

*2

 

 "

&      .%   

   2"    &



 &* %   *  "     2   * %  

*

"" ! "

!     #

 #  &

9

 &. +

5"

 %      #

   6

 6 

 :  

#    ;

! 6

   

  " 

&

    &    &#

   9<  5

9  6

 "   

"  

     

  #

    

   





 # "

<! 

&+

2 = "  

        

  9% 

  :#  "! 

  &   

       

&  

    6  6  6

4 #   

!6 

2



  





 6 6 "!  6

! 

"

  &

"

 # "     &# 



  & 

#   &  "

   ; " "   6#

"  

    +

   

&     &    < 

 

 

    

   

  

 &

& "

<!       

"







!

 



<!  

 

 &

2

#

 

 &

!  

"



#



#

 

3

#



 

 #

  

&



  



  &

 &

 4 6



   "

  %           

  &   

 

 

# 

 !!  

"

 " / "  (! &    

)

 #

   ##         ( &     & 

 

 + #  &

 +# # ! &  

? +

 ++&

   C ( +(! C)"?%  8 1 ( 9%  5" :"9. &  

   

    # ,6 B )A)  " !

,313  

$  

;

* 

*

 " >

 ( ,(,(, 

2;



"

# 6  

  "2 %   

 %   



  

   %  



 



 %   

   & 

& 

&      2 %           & 

 



# 



 

   %   

 

4 

!       

!#!



  

!

 "  



 %   #6

6  6  

"

 " 6# # "   

6 #6

     &          9     9     %  

 ? ? ? ? %   

 @ " !#



 :  "

 

 !        

  

 

&   

 

  "

6    #   

 

6    & 

"



  



&

#     9    



&    

   

   A 

2   "



"



& %   & 

 %  

 %   

4 %     

    &

  

 +



# 



%  1(,#   %      

 

    

       %   

6 (,#   

 

  &  ;

#

 

    

 

    &    %            %  & 

& "

!      

  &    %     

*

#   

4 

"



  

#

  

/

 

         



&     2



"

" 

   



" 

#

    

#



#

    



#

 

&

 4 

#  %      



 

 #

  &

  

*  2 

%   &

# 

>

 ( ,(,(,  '# !   & &&  

 

  & 

 1 (,# * 

*  " >

 ( ,(, (, B 

< C . .  

6$

!#6  



 "     

#



(,2;

 %    *

*6

    "  & 

  &

&2 %  

& 







*

* 



  

  

#  &  

  &



6#

 

  &

 6

;

! &

 4#



! &  

      : 

       : 

  # 6 # 





 9"

 6

 :  "

 

"



&  "

 #&

" (,2  

 1(,#  %  

    

!  & 

&    "     

*  %    6(, 

  

"!   

  &

  

#

 

 * * 

 2 #

6  

6

(,   "  

 A   # 

   %       * *      

 #  #

   

&

  3(, 

#         

   # 6     (,         &  2+

 "   

& "

 6   

 

 "   6#



*

 (!,   " <  ! 6+







  "

"

 &   

 (!,4   6 %  





 

      

  %      

  *  

*  #    " >

 ( ,(,(,/ +(! !'+

:  % #6"'   1"

!)

 &   )   +

 + #

+    &

+  

#  #  % 

 &  *+ 

    #   +*  ' )   

'2  +

  : 

        !    &    .   +

     

  &# ! )"+

# <

    " #



&  " ! # 9

 " & 

 2

#  +

 9



% ! #

:

     

  ) #! 6      

  &     3 &6

% !

"

&6 

 +

3 

&6

" 

 +



 &#

 

+

 9



!  "

  &

&  " ;

 "

! 3   &6 

% !

!    "

 "

  &  &! #







% !

" 

 )"+



  

 +

&  +

  : 





  

 

# 

! &  

#)"+

>  "

   !

6!

       

  

& 

! 

 !

 & := "

D   +

  !0!*  (

,:

     < "          %     )    

   4



+



 

 #6  #

 6

!

           /2 )"+





! 

""  "#



 

  2# 

9 

      

    

      )"  +

  2 "  

!"! &)"+

#



  2 

## ! 

 

< & 

 &/2

6

6

     #     )"  +

 

" 

    !     #          !    &    #

 

# 



&6 ;  

!

< 

& 

#  !  

/ '     



  

#)  # 

  +   +&  #   #  & &  

 &   

 +  )# &  )( "?% 4  )  +  

)    #   &  #  &#

  )*  ) 

   # +  

#

)  + ) # +  &       

)?

     



' )  "?%  9 ',;

< %

   &''+"

(  /

' 1$9# #" '"+

.'( % %+29 2"# ( '"  , 

 ## 

  % 



 %

# &&  :?+  #   + ' &) )( % 2 "?

% C= (#'

9' #+ , ' .'( % 32"   1"

/ 

' )    :

$'

6 #

6



!. +

   )"+

   #     &E 

+

AE 

    &  

 

 :



   ! 6    !#             +

A  &

#2

 

;

!  )"+

  !

< 

  

  

 "     & +

A  &

#  " # 

  & # "    +

A  &

#6  !    ! #

  

 

      !  

  "    

 !      "     !  "

&

6

# 6

 

 "

  " <

6









   " #4 ! 6)"+

 ;  

!

< 

 

!. +





    

   

"

 2)"+

    &   

" &

&  &

 

   

!) #! 6 &   "

 &6 

6 " &

& 



  6)"

   +



;  

# 



# 

:

  :

!   "      " 

    .!

#  

   

% #

#   

 



% 

 

 

  )" +

    %             

 

 "   #6    &  ;   #   

  

 



" &

 "

 & '   &)#  &     C> : #1#"(

 '" %  1    1  '"   &  %   # &  #   #    &

)

 # &

&

&' )   

59# 6# #



  6#  6    " &  "  &       

   

6)"+



9     

#  &+

 

D    = (#'

9' #+ , '

.'(  #,  #    "    !



 

        !



9    

  +

  2  )"  +

             < "





  6

 

9



#

!   ! 

  

+

    . +

 2 6

!#6 # < 

 6#)"+

  #  " !



   ! 

  

 4  # 6)"+

!

  %  & ;   # &  < 

   #     &    

+

#  " 

 4# #! 6



       





 /

  

  (!  & ) ! % 

    #  # &     )(        ) & "  (!           +  #//0.& % !4 !

   !  

9 "A 

1 F A

 .

1 F A