← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2041/2018allowed

V.K Mantrao & Son (Huf) And Others v. M/S Select Global Hotel Pvt. Ltd.And Others

2019-03-29Mr. Justice Arun Monga11 pages



      



! "#$ %&'() *

) +,#%&-".!

$%/&0-  &&- + #1.'&2%& &3&/%/&0- 4/&  #(



    



    

   

    

!   !"     # $

%%%%

  

& '

      ( ) *# )* +

- ."( /.  0

""(1  

2 

 &)'

    " 1 " 

( 2 1  3 " 1    "   ,"    " "1



 )+ *) )* + ("1   )+ *) )* +  " * *# )* +

5 * *# )* +

"  

6

 " 5 /"( 7" 8$  , (

  * *# )* +0 ( 8 

      

 



   

 

 !   

"

 # $%    &  '      !

  (&  )   *

    +   !       

       

     

 *%      ( & 

   *

  ,#, -,. /0   0,, -,.

)  

   2  &#'

9 *: *# )* + 1 

 "( "  1

 #* "1

 (

&;'



2  # 4 

 *< *# )* +  , "  ,

 -"  ."( =  >"

1  " 

   1 ,  

 ",1

 (

  7

1  1 " ,"( 4 "  

= 1 "    2"1    

      (  "(  "

 ?$8

3 

"( "

  @      



  !"#$%&'() >" (    1   1



2  # ("     "   "

 "1 >"  

1" =( "



 " 

3   ," 

     (

&$'

 1"(  ( "( " 

 (

&?'

 1 "  1 )< *# )* + (

-8

 -"8 5 3  6    )    *% 5 $ 

          

 &      

 )       -.,--,. & *%     ) 

   

  !   

  ,, -,.

       !

  *   ,, -,. !

  &         &  %    *    ,7, -,. 8 ,7, -,.     *

    +   !       

   

 & !   ,#, -,. 8 ,#, -,.  

 &    !   ,9, -,. (&    ' 

  ,9, -,.     &

 *%       *      

 *% &%       &



   *  % *     * 

  * :

(     *

    ,7, -,.   

+  &

     



  

   ,9,7-,.

 

 &

;  



     

        %4

 &<'

A

 "  ",1 

7

9  "  (

   " 1"( 



 "((  " ( 7

&+'

7 *$ *# )* + 

 " " ",1 ,    " 

," 

&:'

A

 " " ",1       *$ *# )* + ," (  1 2 



=( " #* "1



1 

1= "   =   )+ *) )* + * *# )* +

(

"  "  ( "

& *'

  ",1 1

 "  & '

4 "   ",  1 *$ *# )* +   >"  -"  

" ,    ((     

B@, 7 ** +,   *  -. //01 .  +*

  "23    $&  " #2C +--//+   +, 4*+- 4-5/ 4 4 /*.+*

$ !!'&% 46 - +4*  ('C

7//7   **

$8 /.- & !!)$%&



$//9&%)'

-1

 /:/69+ - *  :+.0:

++9/9+1

/ .+*

 !" $"2&



$//9& )2  (  (   "1, "  1  , B(    1 

 ( ( & )'

,1

     





  7

:  +, 

 94-0      9/-0  $ !""&  ""  46 -  +4*

   )'   +109.+*

  4/:/69+4:/9/ !)$"&  ''!

," (        ( ,"  )+ *) )* +   7

* *# )* +





* *# )* +  "  " " 5

  7 ( "

 1     "

 ,"  )+ *) )* +

 

 

,

(

& #'



 )+ *) )* +

" "1

 11 

 94-0  +109  /"0  1       3 

"  "



?$8 3   

, / + --. ** +,/-:

9.

 $ !"3& 46 - +4* 3!"  " (  )+ *) )* + * *# )* +



"   

7

1  "

 1  1 "1 )+ *) )* + "  ,(

" (

 1 & ;'

 "

 $ --  5 + D" < -- " " 1

=(   1 *   5 + D" < --  =    4  

" 

"   "   

 1   "E



& $'

  

B@, 7

**/

- 7  -$8&* +47  .+*

 !"($ &

 $//9&#(#  

 

 1,= " 

"    B@, 7 " (  " ,  "  

11,  "  1 5 + D" < -- 

1 

"  =  & ?'

 " (" 7 

  =

 ;< --  

1= "  5 + D" < -- 4 "1

 -"    

B@, 7 +%/-%5%6%44%+78%- .0%-%/'0%/-% -%20%8%-6%&9!

)$ .

        & <'

; 

7-  <  .

-+ .0+7 .9 =- /7 .+*

 !"#$#&< 9.

%( )    

  =( 1 ( 1     " "1 "  "   (  >"  =(

 1 ( 1  "   7 ( "

& +'

//9  66 9  + ")3)  +,  !"%  //7  +4*  +, $&+ %' (3+, !""

 @ ;7/+*4:*/+ 

*  +6/ *+    9/*  7/    ;  46*  4/9./7 * /9  *+

 )) *) )* #  

B@, 7 ,   "   ( 1

"(1 "

1   "  ( 

1 9  ,   " 

 

 "1   

"(  & :'

1"( ""

  ( 7 ( " 1  ," 7 1      =

2 # 

 (( " ,( "  ( 1"( , 

&)*'

      11 " 7   ," /   ( *< *# )* +0 1"(  

,

( (    7 "    1,  "1 &) '

6   , 1       ->"  1"(

) *# )* +

- ."( /.  0

""(1   1 >"   ): )* :

!

# .$  :  F =(2 1 F , 1