← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2479/2015allowed

Surinder Mohan v. Baldev Singh And ORS

2019-05-28Mr. Justice Arun Palli14 pages

 

  !

       

"#$%#&

%'(  ()"*"#+, 

-./"#&(/0%#1&()(%*(&2345  ('"'"#(/ 6(/*.* %7&(6-"#80%#&'0(/* (*9#&(#'*  + :5 - 5  -  

 



  



  

 

   

;7%''%#-"#80<   







    



  

  

   !   

  

  #





 

 $%&% 

(   



(   

      



    

) * +

 

     

 

 



 +   , - 

   

 

 

   / 

 0







1    1

 2







 



  + 



 

 $%&% 

 + 



 34

5 %%  

+

 



+       

  

+  

  

  6

  



   

+   

/3"5"377"80+

( 

    

   



  

   

+



+

* 

 

  

 





     

     







  2   

  

+   



  8%   .  





   

 





 :'

 

7 4

 3+;  %&



 

 



 

      

     

 < 8= 3;3

   

+



 

  

+    8%*   

  /0



=  < 8    

=

  + 

 

#  

   



   , > 

 

  



  

 

 



4



 



   ? 

  @ 



    



 

 

 /  

+    0 



 

  

 

 < 8 = /0  >       

")



  

  3+4

5 %%/   +



  

0

    

 



  +  / 0

 %&  

  1

+     

1    

      

  



 



             



 A7 



  3+4

8?

           

 

 5

            

        3+  4

5?%% 

      

+ 

/



   

 

   

0

82  

  

 



               

  

      



?

 $%&%

 

 + 



  

B 5 >

'        

3+ = + 

%8  5%% 5/  

  + 0+    



  

    

"





  +



+

?

 

 <   8  =    3;3                 

  

+     

 >       

        

      

     



     + 



   



      



< 8= 3;3 

 

 + 

$ ) !+









            

 + + 

 



    

"

 

 

    < 8= 3;3



 

    



 $%&%

 







 

  

 

    





.   

  

            

   

   

  

        

    

 



 /

  

  0 8 >+ 

   

    *  1

 

")   

 

 +    

  7





       

 





 





        +  

              

  

")    

   

 

 

  & 7 

")  







  

   /)

 6 C 3 0  

 )

' ;"

2       

D"

#

>0('0(//(#'#'(&%'(& ?

, "*38.*< ")'"'".* %#& %3/")%'(&&).;(#'@ <       

   



  

       

/

 $ 

0       

D" #5

*%/(*.7' ;4% /(*%"&&"*).**"#%#&)#)7.*"#

"#&"#8*#"**.(* <<= %#&=B0")0"#)7.&('0(

?

"#&"#8*#"**.(

%7'0.80"**.(

0%*#'3((# *9()"

")%774/()/&(&"#'0( "#&"#8*%/(%

"/;(&A /7 

   

 $%&%  

   

    

  



   

    

0 2         

")   

 

 

   

  

  



 

    8 

 % 2   

 



 

           

/   0 +

 

         



  :'

 

77777!E! 4

 3+;  %&

+       

D"

#

(*C.&")%'%(       

        

        

  

 

        3 

   

       

 

   

        D97%#%'"#+ 2

#  , 

 

 

    .

 D97%#%'"#+'''''

'''''

'''''

D97%#%'"#+ 2   

     +



  

   

    D97%#%'"#E+ )      +

  

      



  +

           D97%#%'"#E+ )      

 

  

 

 +

  ''''' '''''

''''', !



 

 

 

+ 

 .

     3+4

5 %%

  

  

 

  2

'.

  



    +

  3+= + 

%8  5%% 5 +     



< 8= 3;3  +  +        

      

 

   $

 

    

 *  

     .

 



< 8=

3;3   #

  ,+

 



   

    



     < 8=  3;3     

D"

# (C()'"# 97%"#' 2  



 D"

/0



 

 

@ /

    +  

 .    +

 

'

  @ /0

   

+ 

,   

 

   

  

     



 .   



.    "

 

'

  @ /0

 

   



   @ A/  

   B@ A/0

 

 + 

= %B@ A; +         '

    3      



+

 

 .    "

  

'

 

       

   '

    +

 .    "

     

  '

    '

 

 +   B, 2  /0



  

  

   



  

 + 

     







  

       

D"

#7    

  

 

  =

)



 

 $""%&% 

  

6

(         



    

) * +

 

             

   

    

 +

  ; @)   

+ 

;      ;

 

  7

       



  =



$""%&%   ;   



 ;96) >"5;    

 

 , 4     

  

 



 $%&%

 3 

5  /  



0    



 

 5 >

  



   

 $%&%    

 

   

 

 + 

/      

0 )      

       &      

 

)/ 

 

 

  

   3+4

5 %%





   

0

 $%&%  

      

@  



 1  

      

)  



 

        

)   +    /  0

        



) 2              

          

   

)     /=

 

             

    

 

 

)

' ;"

0     

'  =      <         3   3+ ;   

  D"

# ./''*'%'("'*&()"*"##(%)0"**.("7   

  +

      

  





   

  

 

 , 2 



   

 

   

          

   

 



 

     



'





 . 

   +

     /34

5 %%0

  

  



  

) 



  

  +

  4

 5 7 

+ 

 

  

")       3+4

5 %%  



 





+



  

 

  

 

      

 



< =  3;3    :'

 

7! 4



 

7



   

 

        

 

       2    

 

+ 

< 8=  3;3



 

 

  

 

 '

.

 





  

  

 

      

 

   

     +   +     

7

 

 





 





       + 

    

 

  +

     $ < 

*   

 3=

%8    





3+ C 

"

    

/

 

0      



 3=

5%% 5  





      

 '   

/ ) 8



0       



  

  

 

 

  + 

 2  / "

  

0 

 ) 5 /)

' ;"%

0 

 



 

 3=

$ / 

$5%0

 

 /   0  + '  

 2  

 +  

  4

                  

 

 

 

    

    

 '

.

   

   

 

 8

    

       *  

 

 

         +   

         



 

 "

  



  

 

7 









         

 

   

    

 

  '      

     + 



  

    

< 8=  

    

  

+ 

/< 8= 0

 

  

     

 & 2

*  +

  

)    

+ 

  

+

  

    +

  

  

  

+   



 



     

+   

  

 



) 5



  

 

 



< 8= 

= 3+;  % >+  

.



   

 (  

  

          

+

 





 

'  

   *    







  

/4   0

   ;F    /34

5?%%0 



2

 







+







 



  +    



     >

7 



  

 +  

 

 



2 

  

 .

               

    /  

 

 

0    

  

           

     3

.



  +



 ( =  <  3;3   

    



  

 

    ++ 



    

    ++      

++ 

   

 

 @   

    +

 

     

 .



  7 



 *  











   .   

 # 

,  

 >

7

   



 

  

  

  

 

   *       +   +

  

    

       

       +     



 

 

 + 

+

  

+    



  



  

 

 + @ 7   

  .



  

        

         

    

       +

   4

 

 

    +

 

    

  

 

 

 

 < 8=  3;3 





  

  



 %4,<

 5  -

   F

?

G

F 

 G