← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/168/2022dismissed

Kuldeep Singh v. The State Of Punjab

2022-02-04Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl20 pages

    

  

 

     



!



 "

#  

      

 $  % 

"

 &  '(

)

$  

& '(



 $ 

#"

 

& ''+& "

# ,- 

!  

 .

////

    

 *   ( 

 

 ( & 

 

 01& 02& 00& 0& 1& & & 3 

4   &  ,

 #

46.

 0 

 

 #  

' & 3 ,

 #

 5

'  36.&

#



  8



  & 7 

  &

 

*    

   

 (

7



& 

 01 

4

 #

 )  7   4 

* &

 #*

&        

:4& ;  

#

  #  #7



& 



(  #7

*

:4   7   4  

#*

&

*

* 

;

*   *  (

<

 

  +( * <



 

$9 

 3 

 (

<

  7& % 7  <

 ,' ; .&

 "   

 

" =*

&  

 )

 #

(  23  

 7    7  *

$9&

7  

 #

  

 

& 

"  &  

 01 

4      4



 

(

= ( "     * > 

 01  

#  

  & 

 #



 



  

  >)

&

 7 

   

   01    * 

"  <

   ) "  

 

   

 .

 

 

  

  .

    !   

"  

 #$$%& 0.

'

  

  () 

!

  

$**"    

 "

0 .

        ' 

 

 

$**$$    

 +**%& 2.

,

  

   !  

 

 $**      

 $+*

 #

 #*

 *

& ?

 

 

 

     * 

 )

 

 01 

4  *     4



*      





 *

&   #

  <

 



  " 7 )

 #

 

  (

 

#7 

& ) )   )

 

 01 

4 

    -  



   

  

#> :4 ,' ; . 

 #

 

#"

@  >   + 

& )

 0&



 

>  

 *



  $ "  

(  ( &



& )  *

$ "   )  $>

7

& )  





 & 

 )

*



*# & )  )

) >  # 

A 

7&  

  #7 "* (

  * 7 

   )

 )

   

7 )

 

&  &

&  &   4  

 * 7  1 "   )

 

* #7

  & )

 

 > * 8

 "  & ) "    & " 7    " 7 & )



 )

 )

   " 7  & " 7 2& ) 

 #

(



   



#

 *

:4

  

 >

*

& 

 "   4



  )    #7

  

  & #

    

*  4    7

* ( #





 

$ "   & *

& )  

>  &

&

   )

>

* ="    

7   



(

&

 &

    (  )

&    " 

* ="  )

 

 >

* '    

:4 )  )

 0&  *

 ) (





&

* ="  )  7

*

  % 7  <

& %

 "  

&

  



 

 

#

) &



 

* ="  )  B (

 0

&

 

   

;

7    3 '     $9 

 3 ,' ; . ) )

" 7 C )    ) 

 & *

  2 * ;

 *  " 7 C ) 

  ) 

 

*&

   * ;  *  #

 "   )

  #7



2

 )

 4" 7 C2 )  

 

# >= 

 " 7 C )     

 

 ' 

 

  

23 ,' ; 0.&  

(

 , & -  .&  



 



" 

&  

 #

(

 ' 

 ?

&  $>

#& ( *   

 &



 

:4  )

   )



"  & 

 #

 

#(  4

  

 *   ( 

*

;

 01

 #

 )  7   '    

:4 )  )

 

 

:4 )



 " 

( #

(

* )

 

 > -

  

#

 

 #

 )

7 )

 

&  &

&     ' 

   &   " 

#

 

 #7

* =" &   ) & ) " 

)

  " 7 C   (

 

#7     4" 7 C2  

  &  

 #

(  

 *

&



 

 

   ,' ; 0. D( &

  

:4 )  )

 

  

 &

* ="  )  

 # 

(

 0





<

  

*  -

 

:4

   )

    

) 

* & )  

*



#(   &

>

& )  )

*    *



    

 01& 02& 00& 0& 1& & & 3 

4

 0 

'  3&   #

#

   &    



  * 4



  

  &

  * 

  

 

 

#

& 

 01  4 -

"  )

#

   #7



   

& )  

 4 !"#$$%  &'!"()  *!)$ , .&

<A#

( %   

 )



 )

 #

   #7

"

#



"

' 

 ?

& 9

E

 

 01=0 4 (   "

*

 

 0  4  ) 

   #

 - & 

#(   

 

 #

 *

    

 )

  *

     

 "  

# ) 5 

        

 

    

  

 !""  #$     

 %

   



 

&    $    '

 (  )   

  

#  

$  *   

 

+,- ."     /   0+    )

  (   

1 '

($  '    

 

1. /  0+

$   

  

  

  

   ) "

+++-2$        $  "

344444 %  

    )

(  

   /               )

(   ) $  ''  54 "6

         

   +, /  0+    

 ' $   1.  / 0+   $        

"#" ("

        ) $    



'    "   $  

       '



 $ 



  "%        #    $      11  "7   '' $ 8      "!



$  $  '  "9

  6 $ # :

" %9)

0,%

+$   ;2 5        $  

 

  '$  



   

     +,"            



 

     

  "

         

        

                      

   "7     



     '        $  

      

 

$       $ $             $  



  $                     $

     

         +,9/" 

     

  

"< ,"9  

    $     

  '  %   $ 



   $      ''   

    "

"  $   '

     $     4      *         $

     

"  )

  (   

  $        '    

   1.  /  0+"%  $   

   $

'

   "F

" 

 /*

'

(  



 '

)

(  

   1. /  0+  

  "F

+"/

*     



   "6 '    

#( " )  )

 *

#( 

   



*  

 )

&  ) &



 #

E

 #7

 

 

  

#

 (

 4

#(   &     7 #

 

 *



 "

 **

  

 01  4

  

** *   4  

#

" 7 )  

3 #7  > ,*

. )   

 # *  



  



   

"  )  

 * >





 

* )    *



   

 )

((   G &  

#

  

 7

&  

     &

(  7  " 7 )    7 (

 

#7  )   

# *  

  4  *

( 7 

  ( 

# )

;

 E

  >)

 

 

 01 8

& 

&

 

 

:4

" 

#

  )

 

 > -

( 

 7

 # 

&  ) #



(

7  *

( 



  ( 

#

  >)

&

 #

(  

#(    ' 7& 

" 7 

(  



 

 "  & ) " 

 #

    )

 )

&   ) & 

(

 

#7 4 &

& 

 

#( 

 

*

7 

 *

 

&

 " )  

 ;

"

   #7



   

  &"'(+(%,-)*!)$ , .& )   

     

 "  

# ) 5444444 1"   

    =9)>"



  2



  

.,  .

  1. 

+0 9""/"  $       

    

  $           >/

  

  ?

  "9     

    

 

+, 9""/"  $     

"  %

      $   /

 

 

  

+ 

   +, 9""/"

                 

      "          

  /

/   2

"  

 $ 

$        @ 

 > 12

"      

   $         $ 

       /   

"    

   

"?$ '   2

 + ""   $      $    $

 

  6  

>

  

  

      

 $



 '   "9   

   

$   

$ 





  

"@ 

 >    $  $ "  

  6

$$ 

    

 

   



  

  ">$$ 

    

       

       

 

     $     ">A  2 2$ '

 $      

    

 

  $ $ "

!

 $  $   

 $  "@"9"$   $   4

"='

 $  

      "

 $      "

 "9'     



  "

."6 '

 

% '  



     

    

     

   +, 9""/"$

    

 "?  

    

     '

   '            "?  

                     

 

., .

 1. 

+09""/"

     

    

 

+,9""/"$ 

"&  

 /       

   $ '  

  "

344444

."444444            $    $

      

 



  $  '      /   

"             A '     

 

 $          12

 

    

  B

C    $ 

   

"       4 " "  2

  $  

$    

   $

  "    $    

 $     

             

"   ' 

           

   "         '  

      ' $

      +,  $ '               '      



      "7    ' 

          

 

    $   



  $

    "

344444 %    '  $

 $     $

    $



 .2

"D&) '

   * "

0"    '     

    $              "6

  $



 .2

" "     

$  +"++""9  

    $  A

   A      E  ' "E   1+9""/" 

 ' 

 $   

    E  ' E"  /  5     1+            $  A

   A"

   $

     '   



  E  '   

1+ 9""/"         ' E$   

   1+9""/"          

 

9""/"

," ? A   /  '"  6%9)

/. ;B

B C/&,00C    ' 

   +, 9""/" 

         



  $    

  

      ++ 9""/"  

 

    



 

   

   +, 9""/"



  

       " 9        

 

  $    ' 

0  '    $    "?$ '  $  '  / $

   

   +,     9""/"    ? A   /     

  



    

    "  6

     4  '  $    ' 

 "

      $     $    

 $       "

%

    $             

               * 

   +, 9""/"

    

   

   1.  9""/"9  

(



'"  %9)

1/01;B

/&010B1CC '  '

   

   

"   $    

  $  

    "9$   

 ' 

   "

  '       

 

+, 9""/"$       

$       

   1.  9""/"   '  '

   "

"( 

 ' $     





$  

    

  9 ' $     

 %

   



 

     

   +,9""/"    "    

    

  

  

     $          ">        

       ++  9""/" 

         

   +, 9""/"    

       '



 

   "   9 ' $       

  '          $     +,9""/"6 '    

#( " )  )

#(   & :4 )  

 

 01 

4

 7 

*  

 -

#

   

 

" )  )

 

#7

*



7 " 7 )     #7

   )

 

 >=* 

*  '

"   )

  # *  

  -

  

*   

** 

   4  #  

#(  

  * (  * 

 #  *

  ) )  )

 )

 * 

*  4

  &

  ( " 7

& 

#  

   *

 &   #

   



 (   **   

 01 

4

& 

&

:4

 #

 

 01

4

 



 "   )

#

  

*

)

 

 > ) 

 " 

#

 

 )

 )

   " 7   " 7 2&

 #

  

 #

(  



   

#

  7  

 

7 )

 

 

&   

 4

& 

 



 "

*

7 



2 -

" &"'!(.  (%,-)  *!)$ ,  .&   



     

 "

 

# ) 5   

*

 $

 " 1"%1"++"D" >'   1

%

 B72 C

$  D 

 9

 



 ?



$ 

   (' /

 

    $   '

      '  /

      $  

@  

  >  

  7  

   6

  

  6$

  

    6  

 > 

      $  @

 $    (   

 

 $#



  "  

  $    

' $      "?



$ ' 



'   $

  /'?  $ $  %



 

$        /   D   /  

 ?   &  "

   

A     $        

             

          ="9")"  $    1"

+"D" >'  



   $    

 

1.- 1 - .- .

     9

     / "  !

      '

   

$  

    

 

. +, 10B  C 1 B$ C 1.B  C

 1 B  C  $  .

 9

  / " 344444

1"444444"

7    

             

  * $ $   "

 344444

"7     ( 

$ ,        

"?    

$       "7 



    *" 7 $ ' $  *@

7 



>



 '      

   1 - . 9

  /

                    

     

 

   



    

  / 

."< -

#(     )

( % 

 







E

&



 #

 *

 '    

 )

#

 

 

 

 " )  )





 )

 )

 

 

 4  &



   #7

 "

# )  

7

) 



&

 

E

  & #

<

 (

 

 02=0  4 -

#( 

 " )   

 *

# 

  

 

&

 )

 # 

* ;

*

  

*

"  ( = E

&



 D(  !%,("(%,-)*!)$ ,  .& )  

     

 "  

# ) 5       

     .1      /  

1 /   

, B 'E/   / EC * 

   1 ""1++.

   











  

 "

"1++    %

   /      D   

 $    



   -    

" 344444 1"444444"9  

 /



         

$ 

 

$  $         

  $  "

       

$  

 

$ 

$  "

344444 0"444444"9   '





'

 $  $ $$ 

$  $ 

  

     

   +,9

  / "D '              '                 ">   

       $ 

$  

"

        

  ' $    "





"

344444 "9 ' $ '  

    



   

"  ?$ '               '   /   

  

4

         

    





  

    "< 4

#(   & #

-   

 

   

 01  4  

  

 #

 

 #7

*

 # 

<

 

 

 

*  *  #7

 

% 

   4

  &   #



"   )

 #

    )

 (

 

#7

& 

&  

$9&

 " 7 

 

 

*  4  

 

 





&

  & ?

 

 #

 )

 #

  

 )  

 #

)

   #   " 7 )     *  & 

 

"

 '

"   

 

  )

#

 ;  " 7 

*&)   (

 

#7 4 &

& 

 

  ) 

7

 

 -

   ) 

 #



 #7



   

#7  

  

"

>

, .



  

7

>

 

*   *  

   

    #   

      &   #7 # 

 4

&

#

 #

#( &

' 

 ?

 )





     

#  

 *

&   # 

 01  4    

 -

)  

 )

  ( 

  4.

-

*  

 

 02=00=0=1==3 4

 0 

'  3

  #

 

 #7

3

 -

8 

' 

 ?

7

;

 01

 #

&

 #

 

 44.



 #

 

    &   ) & 7 

  &  &

 

8   H



 01&

 

 

:4

  & )  )

  *# &

 

   "   

* ="  )

 

 > 444.

8

 "  & ) "   )



 )



 )

 4" 7      ) 

 & )

(

 

#7& *

  2 * ;  * 4" 7       ) 

 

*& *

   * ;  * 4" 7 

 #

  

 #

(&

-   

*

  & 

 #

 



   4!.

'    

:4 )  )

#

#

 )

7 )

 

  &

  

  





** 

   !.

' 

 

:4&  #

 )

   *

  )

 

* & )

* !4.

'

 #

 

 

:4&



 

*  0 #

   

* 5

 * >

&

*



   

;

7  & 3 - & >

  (

#(     *

 &

  *

*    *

 01& 02& 00& 0& 1& & & 3  4

 0

'  3



 &  

 <) &    



#(

 #   ;    

 

 ) )  

 

#

 *

  

#

 *

7 

    

 *   (&  )

  *

 /0000

  $

 1-$+-$")2$!3(%,4"$!)5%$67 $)45 1-$+-$""$25"+!8.$7 $)45