High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2105/2017allowed

Amarjeet Singh And ORS v. Des Raj And ORS

2018-04-02Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

!"#$%& '

( )!&*"+,-."-& ""& /&0 !*."-& %1"

!" "!#

&"$ 2&-&!,3!1-4!'1#!"'

&"-%""& 2&!0&!&&!'1#!"'

&&%1" 2&--,,!&4!'+&1#!"4"- 2&/*!5+6!*!'1#!"'

&&%1" 2&!0&!-%&!'1#!"'

&&%1"7 2&2+6-!'1#!"'

&&%1" " 88888 "!# $

- %&" & 1&#"1 !,!" "- &1& 1!"1 7

9:0& ;<='4-&>5!%%#!"&!)1)""-%!" !" "- "!, #&;:!)!" 3;< 2!*" +,-' -! > 1#1 2&-&!, 3!1-4!' !&1 #0 &%&", "- %""& 0>)""1 "-!" "- %""&;%!" ""0"1 "-0" & 1#!&!"4"-#?0"!&%&)!"*0#"""-#" "-!""-!11 @(A 1!"1 @ BB :#0"1>511!"

!0&11!"7'!11<@<A 1!"1 <

:#0"1 >5 11!" !1 @ !0& 11!" !1 )0"!"

@ "&1!1!#"1"->!!1!11'!11

(A 1!"1 @

:#0"1 >5 11!" !0& 11!" ',"11<7

1!"17 7

:#0"1>511!"

!0&11!" !1!11< 1!"1 <@

:#0"1>511!" !0&11!" " >,,!'

0!11'#"'%&!"!1">1,"-&,-""- %!"4"-#?0"!&%&)!"*0#"&"&!,"- 11!"&)"&&,%!#0%4"-0&"-&*0#" &"&!,"-11!"""'"&!&',"'!!""-!1 ?0"-!,!&!)!0&,(C!!<)!&! -!&)"1!114&#-!,1"-,&01 "-!""-&11!" &11!"@4&-!,!5&,-"'"" & !0"-&"5A%4& " 0" "- !1 "- !&!& 2!1 1 &!%&" '!&!&'-C-&'"&#"6!&!!0& 11!"&!5>15!"-!1!14!:#0%&%&"5 "-!&)"1 '>0"4! %0&#-!1"-&0,-11!" 4-#-!#"4!1"&)"-!111!"1 ( BB -!&)"10"4!#""1>511!" !1 @>5,*"4&"""!")""!C,%!"%%')!"!!>"5' #!0!#"'4!"%&%&#0&"!1*0&1#""4!!,1"-!" <<

'))>&"- #01,%!"70!)05 &1"-!"!1)!0&,(C!!<)!&!'1#&>1 !&! "-%&)!&5>*#">1'!"- 4!01&-!51>"!1 !0"-&1"-11!"":#0""-!11-&0"1!"1 <<

>&"-,!"0&-!!+,-9%!"7="4!"- >!"-!&)"1!0"-&"5'11!" !1@:#0"1"-

% !11&!!0!>#1&!" 1!" '<!1 1!%!&!"4&"""!")"

&!,!"-%&)!&5>*#"!115,"-!&)")!1"- %!" 3-"-0"4!%1,&%!"D1#'%""&; %!")1!!%%#!"9:0& ;@=1!"1 7

C, !)1)""-%!""-,&01"-!"4-%&%!&,"-#!& #&;:!)!"11!"D1#'%!"#!)"C4"-!" &0" 1!"1<<

'&10%>5"-11!"'-!1"> %##!5%!11!"-!11!&)"14&:#0"1"- >!"-!1&0"!10&,1"-"&!0&""!11 !&!(9!=!1"- 4,%&!5&%!&!,&!%-$;

& ' (

%* +

%&, %- .

%* -!&)"1!%%#!"4!#""1>511!" !1@>5,*"&%5!1>5&%1">5,%!&!" &%5 -"&!0&"'1)%0,1&1&:0& ;<1)1 "-!%%#!">5-1,"-!""-!%%#!"4!>&"101,# !1'"-&&'!)1)"!">!"1"!,#!">!41!#"'"- !)1)"-01-!>0,-"!""!"!,!1"!""-"!, 11!"D1#!1#"-)!""&4!:1&#&;:!)!" "-4""-11!"!1"-!)>,1"1!!#" %!'1)1"-!%%#!" 2&-&!, 3!1-4!' !&1 #0 & "- %""& 0>)""1"-!""-)%0,1&1&"0"!!>"-5!4 %&*01# 401 > #!01 " "- 11!" ! "- &0" 1!"1 <<

4!!0"#)&!01!1)&%&"!"!#"'"-!) 4!"%!1!0"-&,11!" !1@&:#0","-! 11"-)!&!1)1'4-#--!>#-!,1"-0""1 ""!"!)0""!"&,"-!"0&"-0" 2&!0&! &&!' !&1 #0 & &%1" 2&--,,!&4!'!&1+&0!"1>52&/*!5+6!*!' &%&", &%1" !1 2&2+6-!' !&1 #0 & &%1" " 0>)""1"-!""-!)1)"#!">%&)""1" >!41!""-"!,11!"D1#!"-!#"0)&0" 4!1#1!4!5>!#C"-1!"4-"-4&"""!")"4!1

!"-),!"&5&0"!1#!">%&)""1 " !%%&>!" !1 &%&>!" "- !) )!& - :%& E10

1,#F!#&%&!"1

!)1)"'-!">#)%14"- !1&,-"5'!%%#!"4!1)1!1'"-0'%&!51&!&),"- &1&01&#-!, -!-!&1"-!&1#0&"-%!&"'!%%&!1"- %!%&>C!1"-4"-!""-&&#!1)&""-0>) "-!&1#0&"-%""&'&'"-!)1)"0,-"A"#1 !>)"#00!1401"#-!,!1!"&"-!"0&"- 0"'&'4,""-&0"'"-!11-!>#-!,1- "-&%!&"5401>!">&"5"&!!%>%!"-!)11 4&"""!")"!1&!!&,0)"!""-!%%&%&!""!,4"-&,!&1" "-!)1)"4-"-&"4!>!&&1>5)"!"&"-"&!0&" 0,-"""-!1)1"-!%%#!""-,&01"-!""-#!4! "1&!#"%!

&,,"-#!"-!#"%!#!"> %&)""1""!C!4!5"-!0!>&,-"!%!&"5-0&"!&&?0&1 "1*0"#!1""1%"-#!!"!%!#4-#-&0"1" )#!&&!,*0"#0"#!4!5!%%!&">1!1"&"- !C" !0%-")5!&)"11,'"-)%0,1 &1&"0"!!>"-5!4!1-&>5";!1%%#!" &!)1)""-%!"!410>*#""%!

A;! #""11!"?0!%&%&"

%"""!1!41 '( $ ) *"!# + (,-.

#.1.(',2 34(, 5 64

#.1.(' (1,7 64