← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/226/2017dismissed

Bharpoor Singh And ANR` v. Lachhman Singh

2017-01-17Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi14 pages

    

!"!

#!$!

! !!

# ! 

#%& '( )

 



 

   

 

!)  *"+

,!,-!,

!+.



   

 



 !,-!,

!+./ 0%

 !    



  

 "

   #$$%&$' (

)" *+, -.

!  !"   

!  

*

"

/ #"!$$ 0  0 ! "(1002  , 3

4 !

 !

 

!

.

!"   ! "

! 

 !

 !       !!5

 4"



      0"  ! "

! 

"-  !  !"   

!

5 !

 "

 5 "!

   4"  " "-   "  !

 !" "

  4 !

 !

!

*

 

"

  -  . * !"   . 

   "

 -.!!5



  



6"



!  " "

* 0 !

"  



" 0 !

 3

$7+' ("

4-,%$8 6

9 

 4." 

%&&'(8,0( !,+:7  ;"

"

4- <!   .

%&&#($,0( !,'='  4 



%&$%(88,0( !, $$= 6 5 ;" 9

; 

 %&$8(7, 0( !,%$7# > !

4"  ?"

(  , "3 %&$8($,'%8 "



  "

4-

 %&$+(:,+=& 

 ! "

! 

  -! !



 "!"!  

"



"!

     

      0"     

       

     

     

   

 5 "

.   ! -! -   @ "

  -.!  !"  - "

"

 .

 !! !

.  .@. 

5 -

 



5 !5! 5 -. 2-! "0"

%&1 %%02%0%3%4 42%/!5, 55  A" !!     0"   5  

   







5"!

-

-!

/  !  !"  - "

  

!

"

 - " -!



5 !

 "

 

   -"!

  -4    0"  ?   $7#&5   !!  " -

  @"A"

!

"  5"!

-- 5 !

 

5"!

 !. 

.

  



  !!

 !! A". "

   - -. !

<) !.  ! " !!   -   0"

%6%  , 71  % '  % &104 809 '0 , 71/  :  ;  +  5 ?!!5

!5! 5 -. 2-! "0" 42%<(% (",

! 5?"!!   0" .01% .82%0 0 0 4 %0%210#/5=+:>

!03%  & 04 0'1%0% , 71/5=!8 3%9 :5!! 4"



 2-! "0" ,1%210, 714, %3 '00%1%'% ' &10/ 5; ,:

>/  0" 8

+ 4"



6!

2(",!

"

* B      

  

            

                                  

              !"#

$       %         

           & 

  ' (  )   



      %          

       *              

                       

     

                    

        ) 

    

              

   

  +

     , 

 ,    ,     

                $      $   

  +    )        

   $           %  



    $    )

                       

       -    .  

   

 /0 /0 

  ,             %

           

                 



          

       

     )  

    

         

    

      )

   





*        





  !

" #$    

*        

   

                 

     

 2     

          

                                   

*      %

& ' ( 

)!



 * #             .

           '

 &

 & ( 

)+   #$  3 *    $      

  %   -.

2 ',

/0            $           

  

                    

  2-!"0"  7

$% 4"



? 220(%!%& % '0% 26% @% ' &10 4 42%%

%%/5==;,> ;!

"

* (2        

422& 22/ 0     .                    

           $

              

      

2 

      422& 22/ 0        

                

     

                        $            

   2    

         

   

    $                                2    

   

                       2     

              $              

 2                          2                   5       

    2 

    

,        5 

 

     

        2               

  

                          "/0         

    

       422&  / 0          .             

            

         6422& / 0                  

                         

  

2                 $          $

 422&  / 

  

  !!.     0" 20%3 4  %0(1&  , 71/  55;

  >=/  ,891%1  1% '0    4  %0 '  ,%7%0/  ; ! 8 3%9 >=

,&%& 8 3%94  %7'6, 711 A1% / : (:>!

5 !

!"

 )

!" !  - 



-  . "



 C ! 

 5 3 -.  0" 42 (",

"-0

2(",  0" $% 6



05 2(",!

"

* B  )  7        

    -  -. ' & /

+   

$!

(-0* &  -& '0   11+

(- $!

2            

    

   & ##        )   & -## ## 2                        & -###  ) 2

               )         

       

           

  $            

 2                7        2     

   

                   

 2              

              % 

      & /0

       7              @-  5!-   -.  0"

% 60&, 714 802%, 71% ' &10/ ;+:/#0

"

+ .%6 02 0% 6&%4, "%90!77%0A%/ :, + 5

, !3&, 71. 1%04, ,1%1.% &6%' 

:;=  > :

=

>

0

 4"



!  " -.! "

!  

    "

-"

-    5  !"!  4"



 - "

- .

!  

-

" -!  

  

!   ! !5 "!      -)  

   - !.

.



4"

 !5    

    " 

!   3 5!

 !

-.

 D-!"0" %'2%88 '%0%% % '% &104 ,&%& %2 %'8% ' &10/  ;,:;;/

   '%4 !20& +%% (1% '%% ' &10/ >;,:/,&%& 0%4 '

@%/ , :

,&%& %3%&1% 4, % 1+%/ =

 ,:;;

  5  

! 3 -

. -  -.  2-!"0" $$

$% ! 4"



  !2 (", 

 5 3

 ! 

2(",

  !! .2(",5   -

"!!. !!5 

 "

* $$B$%E&       

,   ,       



      

8     2    

9           

 95                

 

           

)              : /0       

           9       

 :/0         

    





  :

/0         

         

 +                        





       

       $      

  /%'%   6

%%,;6 /2& <=!%=>"0 ? 26  3 36

/ <<=/=0%>>0   



   

    

9     

   .  2@ A  / <# 0><-/

08  A               

                         

   $ 

         

       

 0

 "!     "  -

     

      "



!.  !

 !



 3 

! "      

  

 .!

 

 - 

 "

5 @ !.

 "  -. ! 

3

! 5  ! 

"-

!4" - 5  

   -.! 

3

! - "

5!!4"

 5!! !5 '

  /   !! .(%&&',$00 %#+ %=%$%  -C                                 

               6          8 5     

      

 ,      

               9                                                    ,    

       

 9                 

          :          2A  D ,

A  4

/ <- "E"  "= 0A  ;3 '/228&  >)30 F      

    +

9                .    

           

      

    



      = 2

6 3  G 

/ <"#/B0

8& B<>0A &/ 

8& B<")0FA  ,5 

                         2  

 $  $          F; 9%

A  4

%/H

B0/ <" 0 +A& #=B '/228&   B">)0F6          &

A    .  F           *   &  * / <"B/B0+A&-E"0A ;

'/228&

"= 0 F                 

                       "

            ,              3     



        

- 

  A 3  

 

   

 '/ 

I

 22& <=B%=!# F8    

      

     

     

        /

  J 0

  



  

          

 



    

 F F.   



  ,      

   

      







  ,   ;

  ,  

         2& %? 24%  A ; /B##>0E%"- !E)!> -) !

 

  !



!.

   " " 



!.

) $$&&&F*  "  !

!

 !"

3 ."  5 "

  



!4"



 -.!  !" G

  "   - !. !"

"

!   !  !"

!  !" 5"!

-   ) "

- 

 !

-"

5"!





 -! -.     5

  

     "



!.  !

 !  !  "      !.

  !  

*!

 "



  -"!

   5!!

 ?"  "

" 

5 



5 

5 3

4"

5  - "  

-.



 "

 5 .5

  



 0" 5 !) 

" .4"  "

 !%%#

0

"

! "

! 

  5

  !. -



   @" !!5

!5!

5 -. 2-! "0"  !2 (", 

2(",5!!-. 5?"!!   0" ; 

;" 2 

4  2 (",  !

   

-   0" 5"!

-

-! 

 

"

! A" " 

!

 4"  "

  -"  " "  !"

!! A". 5"!

-  !.- 5 !

 

" " 



-

 !!

  "

-  !  !" -" 

"

 .3

4"

 " !! A". "

 -. !

 !

"

 . - -!"

"!  .

 " .  0" 5"!

!!.   3



5 !"

   !



   

- 

 0"    -.!  !"   

  !  "

/ #"!$$00 

!

.

!"  5 !

 ! 

"

! A"

 

"

"  !5.- )  " A"

   3

!

. A" "  

 "!    " 





"!!. !!5

!5! 5 -.  2-!"0" 

 5!!  0"    -   0" !     !"

   !  !  "   ) 4"   

. !55 !

 "

 

   -"!

   ! 9  "

5  0

"!   

 "  

- "! 5    

  0"      5 

   

    -



5 "

."- @" "  !9

  -  "

"!

!.  5    -   -      

   



   5 5      $#$%&$# !,-!,

!+. I%   #  + ,K GKH +   

'

GKH