← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2663/2016disposed of

Bharti Retail Ltd & ANR v. Ashok Chawla & ORS

2016-07-15Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

 

      

 !!"#$#%&'()*+ ,- # ! #(. /+!0!(,# % ,!-  ! # #%!-$ 1!-$'$ $,2,0(  ,!-$  !$3%/!% $ 



  !"#$% %$&'!"()  4,! ,!- !3- !-$("(33!-$5)6!((0!/ $!! ,!7'/85!% 9  6!-!!--!/  ,! !3- !-$-% 9  4,! ,!- ,!7'/85!% $,'(/6!-!3- !/#% ,!#8!$ 9

-!$!% &

--7 :#%8,!/#+/;" !+ - ,!3! # #%!-$

--'%'3 +/;" !+ - ,!-!$3%/!% $ <<<<< %$&'!

*+

! # #%!-=/!!%/% $-!88-#!;!/ ,!#53'8%!/-/!-+ 0,!-!6)33(#" #%-//# #%(!;#/!%"!,$6!!%/#$5#$$!/% 0 8-'%/$ ,#$'- +;#/!-/!-/ !/>?+#$$'!/% #"! 5 #%%()0# ,-!8-/ $!!2#%83!-5#$$#% 3("!%-!"-/ ,! -!$(' #%$6)0)//# #%(!;#/!%"!,!-/!--!/$ ,'$&=

  



                            

       

   



    

  





    

      

 !

 

   

    "# "

"

$             

    %          

     & '    "#  "

$

'   

           

(

 

        "# "

"

$         

     "#  "

$! !

                            

  !  )    

* !     

  

     

  %    $

+ "

,

-  

.!    

 %

/



--7 :#%8,!/#+(!-%!/"'%$!(33!-#%8%6!,(  ,!3! # #%!-=/!!%/% $$'65# $ ,  ,!0-# !%$  !5!% / !/ >*?0$#(!/6) %27'-+' ,-#$!/$#8% -):5!,0+ -!$(' #%' ,-#$#%8,#5 #(! ,!0-# !%$  !5!% "'(/% 6! 3("!/%-!"-/%-/!- ;#/ !",%#"(67!" #%'%/!- -/!-@

'(! + ,!$5!#$$'8,  6!3("!/%-!"-/%$'33- ,#$ $'65#$$#%+-!(#!$'3% ,!7'/85!%  ,!%A6(!:'3-!5!'- -!%/!-!/#%"

,- + . % -+/*0 +*1203+*+ - ,1*'

445%#

--'%  '3 +  (!-%!/  "'%$!(  -  ,!  -!$3%/!% = 3(#% #$$'65# $ , ;('6(!-#8, ,$""-'!/#%;'- ,! -!$3%/!% =3(#% #$+0,#","%% 6! 2!%0),!("'%#% ,! !;#/!%"!"%% 6!3!-5# !/6)0)//# #%(!;#/!%"!,!-!#$% "53(#%"! ,!!B3-!$$#%C/!$3# !/'!/#(#8!%"!D%/-#8, ()$+ ,! 33(#" #%,$6!!%/#$5#$$!/   ,;!  ,!-/  ,!  (!-%!/  "'%$!(  -  ,!  3- #!$  %/ 33-#$!/ ,!33!-62 :#%"! ,!'- ,$""!3 !/ ,!3-)!- ,!3! # #%!-$ ;#$==;#$-!$(' #%$+5 ,!;#!0 , #%-/!- ;#/ !",%#"( 67!" #%+  3("#%8  %  -!"-/  ,!  -!$(' #%$  6)  0)    //# #%( !;#/!%"!/!$%  % 5'%  0# ,/-0#%8 ,!/5#$$#%-#((#%8

6 '3 ,!("'%!,!%A6(!:'3-!5!'- ,/%""$#% 3%/!- '3%$'"," #%;#!0 ,!7'/85!% "# !/$'3- %/3-!$!% "$!

$E'-!()(($ ,!-!#%

-  ,!  -!8#%8  -!$%$+    5    ,!  ;#!0  ,  ,! 33(#" #% ,!3! # #%!-=/!!%/% $;#$==;#$//# #%(!;#/!%"!E' -!$(' #%$#$3- ()((0!/6)$! #%8=$#/! ,!#53'8%!/-/!-0# , (#6!- )  ,!-!$3%/!% =3(#% #$ "-$$=!B5#%! ,!0# %!$$0, !%/!-$ ,!-!$(' #%$

!;#$#%  3! # #%  $ %/$  ((0!/  #%  ,!  -!5!% #%!/ !-5$$'67!"  3)5!%  *F= 6!3#/  ,!"'%$!(- ,! -!$3%/!% $#% ,!#8,'-  !078'   %$& *+31 !"()