High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2804/2015dismissed

M/S Balbir Singh And Company v. Jaswinder Singh Mistri @ Bittu

2015-12-07Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih3 pages

" #$%&' () " #$%&' () " #$%&' () " #$%&' () *+,&'"-./ *+,&'"-./ *+,&'"-./ *+,&'"-./ 0"1 0"1 0"1 0"1 2 "

2 "

,34'"-.*5'6557 ,34'"-.*5'6557 ,34'"-.*5'6557 ,34'"-.*5'6557 "

0"1 "

0"1 *# *# *# *# 89* " 89* " 89* " 89* "

'5# *'."5,)4$,5)'5.:55' ;.5.' :'5' $, 3:,:' %,< & ,3455.=74-%5>"+ &'''455. :'5''5>"+ ?;.5.' 5. =74-%5 .74 & ':'54 5. 4-5>"+

99)0 ',1

99)0 ',1 24'4'&-,,4)4,54 @ !)'4'4 &<74-07'1),,4.,'),::$,5%4&< 5.:,5A:55'5,447$,445,4$).,4$ & 4%4 . ', ,-4 &< 5. 5', $7'5 7::'55'4')',4,5.7#B

,'4 , :'74 < 3,< 5. ,'4 , :'74 < 3,< 5. ,'4 , :'74 < 3,< 5. ,'4 , :'74 < 3,< 5. ,::$,5),::$,5+:,5D-:'%5 ,::$,5),::$,5+:,5D-:'%5 ,::$,5),::$,5+:,5D-:'%5 ,::$,5),::$,5+:,5D-:'%5

,4,445,4$':'47$-5.,5,E ,4,445,4$':'47$-5.,5,E ,4,445,4$':'47$-5.,5,E ,4,445,4$':'47$-5.,5,E ,4 $% 5,E '57' 5 :' 5. , %,4 ,4 $% 5,E '57' 5 :' 5. , %,4 ,4 $% 5,E '57' 5 :' 5. , %,4 ,4 $% 5,E '57' 5 :' 5. , %,4 $74-%,5',4&<:,5'%544,5 $74-%,5',4&<:,5'%544,5 $74-%,5',4&<:,5'%544,5 $74-%,5',4&<:,5'%544,5 755:'555%5.'5.,5,::$,5., 755:'555%5.'5.,5,::$,5., 755:'555%5.'5.,5,::$,5.

, 755:'555%5.'5.,5,::$,5., %',&<,45-,-',,5 %',&<,45-,-',,5 %',&<,45-,-',,5 %',&<,45-,-',,5 3.<,44$7%53'5:'47$4,4:'4 3.<,44$7%53'5:'47$4,4:'4 3.<,44$7%53'5:'47$4,4:'4 3.<,44$7%53'5:'47$4,4:'4 3. . 3, ,4- 4$ ,'%,5 . 3. . 3, ,4- 4$ ,'%,5 . 3. . 3, ,4- 4$ ,'%,5 . 3. . 3, ,4- 4$ ,'%,5 . ,44$7%53'335..D34-,4 ,44$7%53'335..D34-,4 ,44$7%53'335..

D34-,4 ,44$7%53'335..D34-,4 ',$. &75 . ., 5 :'47$4 5. ,% ' 5. ',$. &75 . ., 5 :'47$4 5. ,% ' 5. ',$. &75 . ., 5 :'47$4 5. ,% ' 5. ',$. &75 . ., 5 :'47$4 5. ,% ' 5. ',&5D35.%,43,55.,-4 ',&5D35.%,43,55.,-4 ',&5D35.%,43,55.,-4 ',&5D35.%,43,55.,-4 5.$,:'5,::$,5.,&%45,4 5.$,:'5,::$,5.,&%45,4 5.$,:'5,::$,5.,&%45,4 5.$,:'5,::$,5.,&%45,4 ,445,4$35.75.3-,<',,5 ,445,4$35.75.

3-,<',,5 ,445,4$35.75.3-,<',,5 ,445,4$35.75.3-,<',,5 3.< 5. ,% ., 5 & 4 3. 3.< 5. ,% ., 5 & 4 3. 3.< 5. ,% ., 5 & 4 3. 3.< 5. ,% ., 5 & 4 3. ,::$,5+:,5 3, ,4- 4$ ,::$,5+:,5 3, ,4- 4$ ,::$,5+:,5 3, ,4- 4$ ,::$,5+:,5 3, ,4- 4$ ,'%,5 5 , 554 ,3 5.,5 ,445, ,'%,5 5 , 554 ,3 5.,5 ,445, ,'%,5 5 , 554 ,3 5.,5 ,445, ,'%,5 5 , 554 ,3 5.,5 ,445, 4$,345&4<3.5.

4$ 4$,345&4<3.5.4$ 4$,345&4<3.5.4$ 4$,345&4<3.5.4$ 7-.55&,447$43,535.5.D34- 7-.55&,447$43,535.5.D34- 7-.55&,447$43,535.5.D34- 7-.55&,447$43,535.5.D34- :,5+,::$,5'3.$.$745&D35 :,5+,::$,5'3.$.$745&D35 :,5+,::$,5'3.$.$745&D35 :,5+,::$,5'3.$.$745&D35 .%:5474-$)&755.5,5$, .%:5474-$)&755.5,5$, .%:5474-$)&755.5,5$, .%:5474-$)&755.5,5$, 5.,5&,-45.

,5,44$7%53'5 5.,5&,-45.,5,44$7%53'5 5.,5&,-45.,5,44$7%53'5 5.,5&,-45.,5,44$7%53'5 35..D34-,4',$. 7'5.'%').., 35..D34-,4',$. 7'5.'%').., 35..D34-,4',$. 7'5.'%').., 35..D34-,4',$. 7'5.'%').., , ,4 5 :' 5.,5 .3 ,4 4$7%5 ,' , ,4 5 :' 5.,5 .3 ,4 4$7%5 ,' , ,4 5 :' 5.,5 .3 ,4 4$7%5 ,' , ,4 5 :' 5.,5 .3 ,4 4$7%5 ,' ',5 ' =75 ,4 :':' 4$ 5. $, ',5 ' =75 ,4 :':' 4$ 5. $, ',5 ' =75 ,4 :':' 4$ 5.

$, ',5 ' =75 ,4 :':' 4$ 5. $, 5.,::$,5,'<,-7,45.,5 5.,::$,5,'<,-7,45.,5 5.,::$,5,'<,-7,45.,5 5.,::$,5,'<,-7,45.,5 &:$$,<4$45.,%,5'57' &:$$,<4$45.,%,5'57' &:$$,<4$45.,%,5'57' &:$$,<4$45.,%,5'57' 3.$.<,','5&:'47$4,4:'4"$ 3.$.<,','5&:'47$4,4:'4"$ 3.$.<,','5&:'47$4,4:'4"$ 3.$.<,','5&:'47$4,4:'4"$ 5. 44,5 ., ,',4< 4 . 5' 4$ 5. 44,5 ., ,',4< 4 . 5' 4$ 5.

44,5 ., ,',4< 4 . 5' 4$ 5. 44,5 ., ,',4< 4 . 5' 4$ ,4.,4$4.5'4$,4:,5., ,4.,4$4.5'4$,4:,5., ,4.,4$4.5'4$,4:,5., ,4.,4$4.5'4$,4:,5., %',&<,45-,,<',,53.<,4 %',&<,45-,,<',,53.<,4 %',&<,45-,,<',,53.<,4 %',&<,45-,,<',,53.<,4 4$7%53'5:'47$43..44$ 4$7%53'5:'47$43..44$ 4$7%53'5:'47$43..44$ 4$7%53'5:'47$43..44$ ,'%,5 , 5. ,% 3' 3 35. . ,'%,5 , 5.

,% 3' 3 35. . ,'%,5 , 5. ,% 3' 3 35. . ,'%,5 , 5. ,% 3' 3 35. . D34-,4',$.,55.,55%)3,55. D34-,4',$.,55.,55%)3,55. D34-,4',$.,55.,55%)3,55. D34-,4',$.,55.,55%)3,55. 5,-5.:'5,::$,5$,5&,34, 5,-5.:'5,::$,5$,5&,34, 5,-5.:'5,::$,5$,5&,34, 5,-5.:'5,::$,5$,5&,34, -'74%,4755,35.:,55,4 -'74%,4755,35.:,55,4 -'74%,4755,35.:,55,4 -'74%,4755,35.:,55,4 ,445, 4$ .7 35.

75 E:'- ,< ,445, 4$ .7 35.75 E:'- ,< ,445, 4$ .7 35.75 E:'- ,< ,445, 4$ .7 35.75 E:'- ,< :5.%'55.$,)454,< :5.%'55.$,)454,< :5.%'55.$,)454,< :5.%'55.

%'55.:'5,::$,5,4,%.'&< %'55.:'5,::$,5,4,%.'&< %'55.:'5,::$,5,4,%.'&< %'55.:'5,::$,5,4,%.'&< 4%43%<4$7,&F 4%43%<4$7,&F 4%43%<4$7,&F 4%43%<4$7,&F $44<),754&<5.:55'),4$' ''$'<G )?@)

+B.,&:',<4' .75 :'5.,55.')44)3,,<&7',5.:&53 5.:,'5,45.:,5B'%.,44$'5,%,5',55. ':45)3,7:5.:,55;.,57-.55& &'7-.5'$'4&<3,<,445,4$,'$'5, 4$7%5 :'5,- 5 , 5,E ,4 $% 5,E '57' 7&%554&<5.:,5B'%45,'5)5.:':4 4$3,335.5.D34-5.:55',4 $74,3,<&43.5,447$454$,'%,5 $5.,5)7$.4$$74&:'%5545&4 &<3,<,445,4$5.'3)5.,::$,5 %4&<5.:55'3,3.<,-7)7$'5,,4,$D4 %,5', :,'5$7,') ' 5 3, 5 4$4 5.,5 5. '57'3.$.

<,'3'7-.55&:'4$44<) &5.5.:,'5.,4,',4<4,4$$7445.'4$ ,45.%,55'3,E4','-7%53.,,::$,55 ,4,445,4$3,%4 .,5 &- ) 5''$ 3,'',54 E'$ ', =7'4$5 74' '5$ ( 5. 5575 4, 55 &- 44 %'5 ) ,$$'4-<)4%4% * () ! * () ! * () ! * () !

991 0

991 H,- H,- H,- H,-