High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/317/2019dismissed

Kulwant Singh Aulakh Through His G.P.A. Ajit Singh v. Bachan Singh And ORS

2019-01-18Mr. Justice B.S. Walia7 pages

#$%&%'()(*+,

-./0#*$1(*23./#43 5%$($(*%6 7%6).) #'3#*1(*23#*&$3%6) 5%)8*&%*$) + 9:

1;: 6%)%*$+ !6#*2<($1(*23#3(=#>&?'#$%6$3%8%$($(*%6 @@@ %?()(* 8%$($(* 3#) A%%* (/%& .*&%6 6$('/%

$3%

*)$($.$(**&(#6%#&0($31%'$(* 6B.#)3(*26&%6 **%C.6% D &#$%& ,

, 8#))%& A= $3% .6$ !) 6'3*# -#EA<> /%#6*%& (?(/ .&2% 16 (?"> .6&#)8.6 &()E())(*2 $3% #88/('#$(* (/%& A= $3% 8%$($(*%6 .*&%6 ./%

6 )$#=(*2 %C%'.$(* 86'%%&(*2) &.6(*2 $3% 8%*&%*'= $3% '(?(/ ).($ (*)$($.$%& *

, $($/%& #) -./0#*$ 1(*23 ?) #'3#* 1(*23 8%*&(*2 (* $3% .6$ 136( !#3%)3 -.E#6> /%#6*%& (?(/ .&2% 6 (?"> .6&#)8.6 6(% #'$) $3% '#)% /%#&(*2 $ $3% (/(*2 $3% 86%)%*$ 8%$($(*#6%$3#$#)8%6)$#*&$3%8%$($(*%6>6%)8*&%*$)#*& *

* $3% A#)() 62%& #*& #A6('#$%& #*& #*$%D&#$%& #26%%E%*$$)%//&#$%& F

(/%&#).($68))%))(*#)0*%6A= 0#= )8%'((' 8%66E#*'% $3% #26%%E%*$ )#/% 6%2#6&(*2 /#*&

E%#).6(*2 G 4#*#/) E#6/#) 'E86()(*2 (* %'$#*2/% F,> -(//# D"> D "> F ,D "> HH DG"> H D "> -3%0#$ F>-3#$#.*(,#)%*$%6%&(*$3%#E#A#*&(6$3%=%#6

F )($.#$%& (* $3% 6%?%*.% %)$#$% ?(//#2% %6(> %3)(/ #*& ()$6('$

.6&#)8.6> 6 (* $3% #/$%6*#$(?% ).($ 6 6%'?%6= )G >

HD(%) >

HD*#''.*$6%$.6*%#6*%)$E*%=#*& ) >

HD#)&#E#2%)3%)#E%6%)./$%&(*#*%C8#6$%<.&2E%*$#*& &%'6%%&#$%& ,

, 88/('#$(* (/%& A= $3% 8%$($(*%6 .*&%6 ./%

0#) &()E())%& (?(/ %?()(* F F

G (/%& A= $3% 8%$($(*%6 '3#//%*2(*2 6&%6 &()E())#/ #88/('#$(* .*&%6 ./% 0#)&()E())%&A=$3() .6$* F F

,3%)#E%0#) '3#//%*2%&A=$3%8%$($(*%6A%6% *9A/%$3%1.86%E% .6$A.$0#) 0($3&6#0* 0($3 /(A%6$= $ (/% # '(?(/ ).($ $ '3#//%*2% $3% %C 8#6$% <.&2E%*$ #*& &%'6%% ?(&% 6&%6 &#$%&

, .6).#*$ $3%6%$> 8%$($(*%6'3#//%*2%&$3%%C8#6$%<.&2E%*$#*&&%'6%%A=(/(*2).($6 &%'/#6#$(*$($/%&#)-./0#*$1(*23?)#'3#*1(*23%$'*

, 3%6%#$%6>$3%8%$($(*%6E?%&#*#88/('#$(*.*&%6

A%6% $3% /%#6*%& C%'.$(*2 .6$ (% $3% .6$ !) 6'3*# -#EA<> /%#6*%& (?(/ .&2% 16 (?"> .6&#)8.6 6 )$#=(*2 $3% %C%'.$(*#88/('#$(*$(//$3%&%'()(*'(?(/).($$($/%&#)-./0#*$1(*23 ?) #'3#* 1(*23 %$' 8%*&(*2 (* $3% .6$ 136( !#3%)3 -.E#6> /%#6*%& (?(/.&2%6(?"> .6&#)8.66 G

,3%#88/('#$(* .*&%6 ./%

0#) &()E())%& * ,

, A= !) 6'3*#-#EA<>$3%/%#6*%& (?(/.&2%16(?"> .6&#)8.6

F :%#6*%& '.*)%/ 6 $3% 8%$($(*%6 '*$%*&%& $3#$ $3% (E8.2*%& 6&%6 0#) /%2#//= .*).)$#(*#A/% #) $3% 8%$($(*%6D 3#& '3#//%*2%&$3%%C8#6$%<.&2E%*$#*&&%'6%%&#$%& ,

,A=(/(*2# ).($ 6 &%'/#6#$(* $($/%& #) -./0#*$ 1(*23 ?) #'3#* 1(*23 %$' *

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

, 0#)8#))%&A=$3%$3%* (?(/.&2%16(?"> .6&#)8.6(* (?(/1.($

88/('#$(*.*&%6 ./% 0#)&()E())%& A=$3%/%#6*%&$6(#/ .6$?(&%6&%6&#$%& ,

88%#/86%%66%& #2#(*)$ $3% )#E% A= $3% 8%$($(*%6 0#) &()E())%& A= $3% /%#6*%& &&($(*#/()$6('$.&2%> .6&#)8.6?(&%6&%6&#$%&

G (?(/ %?()(*F F

G(/%&A=$3%8%$($(*%60#)&()E())%&A=$3()

.6$* F F

,:(4%0()%>1:G,F

,0#)&()E())%&#) 0($3&6#0*0($3/(A%6$=$'3#//%*2%$3%%C8#6$%&%'6%%A=(/(*2#'(?(/ ).($*86#=%6E#&%A=$3%8%$($(*%6 G *6&%6$(*?4%$3%86?()(*)

> A$3$3%).($#*&$3%%C%'.$(*)3./&A%8%*&(*2(*$3%)#E% .6$I

"#*&$3% &%'6%%D3/&%6#*&<.&2E%*$&%A$6)3./&#/)A%8#6$(%)$$3%).($$() */=(*).'3'(6'.E)$#*'%)$3#$%C%'.$(*$3%&%'6%%E#=A%)$#=%& $3.23*/=(*%C$6#D6&(*#6='(6'.E)$#*'%)I !

"## $ %%& ' (! )

*) "##+ , #" $3%60()% ($ () 0%//D )%$$/%&/#0$3#$03%*#&%'6%%3#)A%%*8#))%&A=# .6$(*#?.6# 8#6$=> 3% )3./& *$ .*/%)) $3%6% A% #*= %C$6#D6&(*#6= '(6'.E)$#*'%)> &%86(?%& %*<=(*2 $3% 6.($) $3% &%'6%% %C'%8$ 6 2& 6%#)*) 3.)>(*$3%606&)>(*$3%#A)%*'%%C$6#D6&(*#6='(6'.E)$#*'%)>$3% &%'6%%8#))%&(*#?.6#8#6$=3#)$A%#//0%&$A%%C%'.$%&#*& )$#=()*$$A%26#*$%&#)#E#$$%6'.6)%%%6%*'%()#/)E#&%$ $3%&%'()(* *9A/%$3%1.86%E% .6$(* - . / -

) )0 *) 1*) 2 !3 ) 4"1"2((4%%/%?#*$%C$6#'$$3%)#E%()6%86&.'%&#) .*&%6+D

! " # $ " % & " ' ! ( " ! ! ) *!! )

! ! +! " ! , !* - . /! !) *!

" 0 !*- . " ) *! ! 1 " ' ! !! & " %

2 3 4 1 !3 + !

! * ) *! ) *! * ! + , ! ! !*) *! , 5

G ) *! * 6+ !) *! ! 33 373 + !! !

0 + ) 6 ) ! 8 " % ! * ! ! + ! )+ !

" + ! !

5 ! 7! 9 5! 7 )+ !

5! ): *$3%6#)8%'$$3%E#$$%603('3*%%&)*$('(*2()$3#$($ ()*$E#*&#$6=$26#*$)$#=%?%*($3%'*&($(*).*&%6

#6%./(//%&#).)%$3%06&JE#=9()*$$A%'*)$6.%&#)

J)3#//9I!

)) - ) 4+ %#4" , *$3%(*)$#*$'#)%>$3%<.&2E%*$#*&&%'6%%0#)8#))%&A= $3% .6$ /%#6*%& (?(/ .&2% 16 (?"> .6&#)8.6 03(/% $3% ).A)%B.%*$ '(?(/ ).($ () (* $3% .6$ /%#6*%& (?(/ .&2% 6 (?">

.6&#)8.603(/%$3%#88/('#$(*.*&%6

0#)(/%& A=$3%8%$($(*%6A%6%$3% .6$$3%/%#6*%& (?(/.&2%16(?">

.6&#)8.68#6$6E$3%#'$$3#$$3%86?()(*)

#6%*$#$$6#'$%&*#''.*$$3%<.&2E%*$#*&&%'6%%3#?(*2A%%* 8#))%&A=# .6$$3%6$3#*$3% .6$(*03('3$3%'(?(/).($()8%*&(*2> %?%*$3%#88/('#$(*.*&%6

3#)*$A%%*E?%&(* $3%)#(& .6$>A%)(&%)>$3%#'$6%E#(*)$3#$*2&#*&'2%*$6%#)*) 3#?%A%%*8(*$%&.$626#*$)$#=$()*/=(*%C'%8$(*#/'#)%) 03%6%$3%(*$%6%)$<.)$('%6%B.(6%)$3#$)$#=()$A%26#*$%&>$3%60()%> $3%/#0()$3#$&%'6%%D3/&%6()*$$A%&%86(?%&%*<=(*2$3%6.($) $3%&%'6%%%C'%8$62&#*&).('(%*$6%#)*) ''6&(*2/=> (*&(*2 * E%6($ (* $3% 6%?()(* 8%$($(*> $3% )#E%()&()E())%&(*/(E(*% 1;:"

#E($ ;3%$3%6)8%#4(*2H6%#)*%& + %)H

;3%$3%66%86$#A/% + %)H