Kiran Dutta v. Chanchal Kumari (Since Deceased) Through Her Lrs And Another


 

      

   

   





  

       !

  

 

  
   
      

   









   

  

 "#$#$%&%''(#)%*#+&,#(-./&.-0-)*#+&1+,*"- #2#*%*#+&)* 0-%.3#*"-)*#+&1  ,+0)+&.+&%*#+&+,.-(%4+,.%4$#&,#(#&5*"- %''-%(

-%0.

+0*"-0-%$+&$2-&*#+&-.#&*"-%''(#)%*#+&*"-$%2-#$%((+3-. %&.*"-.-(%4#$)+&.+&-.

 ! "# "-%''-((%&*
.-,-&.%&*+ #$%550#-6-.%5%#&$**"-7/.5-2-&* %&..-)0--.%*-.  8'%$$-.94*"-,#0$*%''-((%*- +/0*3"-0-94*"- 7/.5-2-&*%&..-)0--.%*-.1 1'%$$-.#& #6#(/#*+ ;+,94 *"- #6#(/.5- 0 #6& !%2/&%%5%0%*%5%."%0#.#$2#$$#&5*"-$/#*+, *"-'(%#&*#,, 0-$'+&.-&*+ !,+02%&.%*+04#&7/&)*#+&3%$0-6-0$-.%&.*"- $/#*3%$.-)0--.

"-,%)*$#&90#-,(-%.#&5*+*"-%''-%(%0-*"%**"-'(%#&*#,,$,#(-.


%$/#*,+02%&.%*+04#&7/&)*#+&%$<#&5,+0$-'%0%*-'+$$-$$#+&943%4+, '%0*#*#+&0-(%*#&5*++/$-+ "#6%#%0<%2/&%%5%0*+*"--=*-&* +,>$"%0-94'(-%.#&5*"%*'(%#&*#,,%&.*"-.-,-&.%&*$%0-$#$*-0$%&.*"-#0 ,%*"-0"+(%%*" .#-. 
 +& ;

 8?   #$ 3#.+3 "%&*#-6# .%/5"*-0$ "%&)"%(/2%0# '(%#&*#,,!#0%&/**%#<$"%-6# .-,-&.%&*$! %&.$+&%0-$"/2%09-)%2-+3&-0$+,*"-$/#*'0+'-0*4  #&)-#<$"% "%02%3%$(-5%((4%.+'*-.94*"-0-%(90+*"-0+,"+(%%*"#&"-0-%0(4 )"#(."++.3"-0-%$%0-$"/2%03-&*2#$$#&5,+0*"-(%$*%9+/*@4-%0$ %&.%$"%&*#-6#%($+.#-.+& *"-'(%#&*#,,%&.*"-.-,-&.%&*$ 9-)%2-+3&-0$+,*"-$/#*'0+'-0*4*+*"--=*-&*+,>$"%0--%)" ))+0.#&5 *+'(%#&*#,,*"-.-,-&.%&*+ $*%0*-.0-$#.#&5#&*"-$/#*'0+'-0*4%&.

)(%#2-.*#*(-+6-0*"-$%2-*"-0-,+0-+&*"#$)%/$-+,%)*#+&*"-%9+6-$/#* 3%$,#(-.3"-0-#&)+&$-A/-&*#%(0-(#-,+,'-02%&-&*#&7/&)*#+&0-$*0%#&#&5*"- .-,-&.%&*$,0+2%(#-&%*#&5*"-$/#*'0+'-0*4%&.)"%&5#&5#*$-=#$*#&5'+$#*#+& 3%$%($+'0%4-.,+0

"-$/#*3%$)+&*-$*-.94.-,-&.%&*+  %''-((%&*!3"+,#(-.

30#**-&$*%*-2-&*%&.'(-%.-.*"%*$"-3%$*"--=)(/$#6-+3&-0#&'+$$-$$#+& +,*"-$/#*'0+'-0*4%$"%&*#-6#"%.-=-)/*-.%B#((#&"-0,%6+/0 /0*"-0 .-&4#&5%((*"-%6-02-&*$#*3%$'0%4-.*"%**"-$/#*+,*"-'(%#&*#,,9- .#$2#$$-.

"-.-,-&.%&*+ $/''+0*-.*"-)(%#2+,'(%#&*#,,%&.'0%4-. *"%*'%0*#-$%0--&*#*(-.*+C@0.$"%0--%)"#&*"-$/#*'0+'-0*4

,*-0)+2'(-*#+&+,'(-%.#&5$%&.,0%2#&5+,#$$/-$*"-'(%#&*#,, %../)-."-0-6#.-&)-3"-0-%$./0#&5*"-'-&.-&)4+,*"-$/#*.-,-&.%&* + 3%$'0+)--.-.%5%#&$*-=
'%0*-%&..-,-&.%&*+ .#.&+*(-%.%&4 -6#.-&)-%&./'+&)+&$#.-0#&5*"-$%2-*"-*0#%( +/0*0-*/0&-.%,#&.#&5 %5%#&$**"-'(%#&*#,,+&*"-2%*-0#%(#$$/-$%&.#&,%6+/0+,*"-.-,-&.%&*$94

@
.#$2#$$#&5"-0$/#*

550#-6-.%5%#&$**"-$%#.7/.5-2-&*%&..-)0--*"-'(%#&*#,, '0-,-00-.,#0$*%''-%(%&.*"-%''-((%*- +/0*0-6-0$-.*"-.-)#$#+&'%$$-.94 *"-*0#%( +/0*%&.%((+3-.*"-%''-%(  -&)-*"-'0-$-&* -5/(%0-)+&.

''-%(

-%0&-.)+/&$-(,+0*"-%''-((%&*"%$%05/-.*"%**"-*0#%( +/0* "%.'%$$-.%3-((0-%$+&-.7/.5-2-&*%&..-)0--#&,%6+/0+,*"-%''-((%&*
.-,-&.%&*$94"+(.#&5*"%*+&-+,*"-&-)-$$%04'%0*#-$# - %0-$"/2%0 90+*"-0+,'(%#&*#,,+ %&..-,-&.%&*$!#$&+*%'%0*4*+*"-$/#*,#(-.94*"- '(%#&*#,,
0-$'+&.-&*+ ,+0'+$$-$$#+&943%4+,'%0*#*#+&9/**"-%''-((%*-

+/0*"%$-00+&-+/$(40-6-0$-.*"-$%#.,#&.#&5  -%0&-.)+/&$-("%$%05/-.

*"%**"+/5"*"-0-3%$%&%6-02-&*#&*"-'(%#&**"%*90+*"-0+,*"-'(%#&*#,,#$ 2#$$#&5,+0*"-(%$*%9+/*@4-%0$9/*&-#*"-0%&4.-)(%0%*#+&#&*"#$0-5%0. 3%$$+/5"*&+0*"-$%#.'(-%.#&53%$'0+6-.94*"-2 "-"%$%05/-.*"%* *"-  #2'/5&-.  7/.5-2-&*  %&.  .-)0--  '%$$-.  94  %''-((%*-  +/0*  #$  &+* $/$*%#&%9(-%&.*"-$%2-.-$-06-$*+9-$-*%$#.- -'0%4$*"%**"-%''-%(9- %((+3-.%&.*"-7/.5-2-&*%&..-)0--'%$$-.94*"-*0#%( +/0*9-0-$*+0-.

,*-0"-%0#&5*"-(-%0&-.)+/&$-(%&.)+&$#.-0#&5*"-2%*-0#%(+& 0-)+0.*"#$ +/0*,#&.$*"%*&+.+/9**"-*0#%( +/0*&+&
$/#*-.*"-'(%#&*#,, +&(4+&*"#$50+/&.*"%*"-090+*"-0%0-$"/2%0#$&+*%'%0*49/**"-+*"-0 '%0*#-$*+*"-$/#*%0-)(+$-(40-(%*-.*+"#2%&.*"-0-,+0-*"-#00#5"**+$--< '%0*#*#+&+,*"-'0+'-0*4)+/(.&+*"%6-9--&.-,-%*-. /0#&5*"-)+/0$-+, "-%0#&5#*"%$&+*9--&.#$'/*-.94*"-(-%0&-.)+/&$-(*"%*#&.--.*"- 3"-0-%9+/*$+,*"-90+*"-0+,*"-'%0*#-$%0-&+*<&+3&  /0*"-0%)(+$- %&%(4$#$ +, *"-7/.5-2-&*'%$$-.94*"-%''-((%*- +/0*$"+3$*"%**"- ,#&.#&5+,*"-*0#%( +/0*3%$0-6-0$-.3#*"*"-+9$-06%*#+&*"%*+&)-*"-


3"-0-%9+/*$+,%0-$"/2%0%0-&+*<&+3&*"-0-3%$&+0-%$+&*+#2'(-%. "#2%$%'%0*4*+*"-$/#*%&.%'%0*,0+2#*)+&$#.-0#&5*"-$"%0-+,*"-$%#. '-0$+&*+*"--=*-&*+,C*" $"%0-*"-%''-((%*- +/0*"%$'0+*-)*-."#$ #&*-0-$*%($+94"+(.#&5*"%**"-'(%#&*#,,#$-&*#*(-.*+.-)0--+,$-'%0%*- '+$$-$$#+&943%4+,'%0*#*#+&+,"-0C*"$"%0-#&*"-$/#*'0+'-0*4

*  *"#$  $*%5-  (-%0&-.  )+/&$-( ,+0  %''-((%&*
#0%&  /**%  "%$ %05/-.*"%*%$-'%0%*-%''(#)%*#+&"%$9--&,#(-.94%''-((%&*,+0%../)#&5 %..#*#+&%(-6#.-&)-# - *"-B#((.%*-.@  8?-=-)/*-.94"%&*#-6# 2+*"-0+,*"-'%0*#-$!%&.$--<$'-02#$$#+&+,*"- +/0**+'0+6-*"-$%2943%4+,%..#*#+&%(-6#.-&)-  '-0/$%(+,*"-7/.5-2-&*%&..-)0--'%$$-.94*"-*0#%( +/0* $"+3$  *"%*  *"+/5"  %''-((%&*
#0%&  /**%  %''-%0-.  ./0#&5  *"-  $/#* '0+)--.#&5$  3"+ %($+  ,#(-.  "-030#**-&  $*%*-2-&*9/* (%*-0+&  $"-3%$ '0+)--.-.%5%#&$*  6#.-+0.-0.%*-.  %&.A/%"-0*"-$/#* 3%$.-)0--.     /0*"-0-=%2#&%*#+&+,*"-B#((%&&-=-.3#*"*"- %''(#)%*#+&$"+3$*"%*#*3%$#&,%)*-=-)/*-.94"+(%%*"3"-0-94"-"%. 9-A/-%*"-."#$'0+'-0*4#&,%6+/0+,"#$3#,-"%&*#-6# #&)-&+B#((94 "%&*#-6##$-6-0'0+'+/&.-.94%&4+,*"-'%0*#-$3"+%.2#**-.(4.#-.+&  *"-0-,+0-*"-$/#*'0+'-0*43+/(..-6+(6-/'+&*"-'%0*#-$94 &%*/0%($/))-$$#+&

"/$,#&.#&5&+2-0#*#&*"#$0-5/(%0$-)+&.%''-%(2/)"(-$$ #&6+(6-2-&*+,%&4$/9$*%&*#%(A/-$*#+&+,(%3*"-$%2-#$.#$2#$$-.

 /5/$*

   /(%*# $% B"-*"-0 -'+0*%9(-  -$C+ B"-*"-0'-%<#&5C -%$+&-.

 -$C+