High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2850/2016dismissed

Parminder Singh & ANR v. Ram Singh & ORS

2017-05-12Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh8 pages

Pooja Sharma 2017.05.22 15:28

"# $#!

!$ &!

%'% "# $#!

!%( !$%

!%!$) * +,#'

- ./$!

% * (','($- ./$!

!%( !$% 0 #!( !%!$ !.

(!$ #%2!!

3! ' !

/3! $#! %$ $'$ %!$$ " % !

('"! $!

!5'

!) (%%! 26 .

37' "!7'

-2#- %$

/$ $ 3- .

! 8# /#- $#! ((3 .! 26 !%( !$) ! $% $0' !

!$#%2!!338!

36-$#! /$% $#!/%! !$#$$#!(!$ )(3

3! %'

!/3 $$#!!

!/$$#$$#!6 !: $8!

%$$#!

!5$!$ ;

$#%# !'$ $#!%'

$3 !%'

<3%-4 3%% 8!33% !/3

"$#!:' "

!$ !/ !! $! = % 33!"3-'33 . '

$8%/$!%$! 26$#! ! $%>

3! 26/$ .!

"$#!(3!%$<! $#!(3 $'

"(! !/6

$#!%'

$-((3 8%

3! ' !

!$ $#!8

!$26$< "$#!(3!$#$$#!%'

$3 %/!%$ 3 /( /! 6( (!

$6$ /! $#!((3 8% %%'! !(368%

3! 26$#!(!$ )(3

% ((3 8%338! .

$! 40

-8# /# %%'2:!/$ /#33!"! !%!$(!$ ?! ! /'%!3 $#! (!$ % /$! % $#$ $#!

((3

3! 26$#! ! $% $0#%2!!8 "36 338! %8#!

$8% !$ ! $#!((3 $#$ !%( $! '!

"!/!-$#! !$%'"#$$2! ! $#!8

!$/'3 $2! !! '

"(! !/6

3#! ! $% $0#.!$ !6 !/! '

" !/

" $#!!.

!/!$#$ $#!%'

$( (!

$6 %/!%$ 3 /( /! 6 $'

! $#%2!!

!$ ! $#! ((3 36

3! !$ $#! 8

!$ #! ! $% $ 0 #.! %$$! $#!

((3 $#$%'/#(3!/'3 $2!$<!26$#!

'!$.!

% "#$

" /!$#!( $#!/'%!3?! ! /'%!3 '

$#!

/$! %$#$ $#!2%!

.$ !26$#!$

$ !/$ /$ 6 2!6 (3! "%%$!(3/! $#%2!!2%!

.! $#$$#!( (!

$6 %/!%$ 3 /( /! 68 $#'$ !3 "$#! /$$#$$#!

!8%%'/#(3! "

$#! !

! $%?! ! /'%!33%%'2

$%$#$ $#%3%8 "36 2!!2%!

.! $#$$#! /$%8# /#8!

!$2! ( $! # 3 ! 62!!

'"#$$$#!$ /! $#!/'%!3 $#! !

! $%2'$$#!% !8!

$(3! ! '!$2

$ %3%$#!%'2

3! /'%!3 $#$$#!%'

$8%

3! $#!6!

$#!

!%# 3 ! 63! $#!

!%(!/$ .!!.

!/! $#!((3

0 8

!$8%

3! $$#!2!3$! %$"!8#!$#!/%!

5! "'

!$% ?! ! /'%!3 #% 3% !3 ! '( $#!

:' "

!$% +@23!$#!(!5'

$#!/%!

! "

$%& '"( )#* "& +! , "& "#

$%& "

34 -'# - . #

$%& "'"

) / %&

$%&

= .

3 0%8!33% $# %'

$#!/%!% 0 #/

$%& "'" # , "&

$%&

0 ?4 - )#( "'" -

$%& "

3 = #+*0)

$%& '"'# -*0)

$%& "

?8+!

3 4 -

%'(( # %/$!$ % ?! ! /'%!3 !%( !$% 0 .!#!

!$36 ((%! $#!%'2

!263! ! /'%!3 %'2

$% $#$ $#! (%%! % 8!33 !%!

!/!

!A'

! +! $#! "'

!$% ./! 26 3! ! /'%!3 $#!

!% #.!3%"!$# '"#$#!

('"! $#!

!$% . 323!$#!

3! #! /$% !3$ "$

" %'

$-$#!

" 8

!$ %'2%!A'!$36

" ((3

!$ 338 "$#!% ! !$ %('$! %(!

( %$ -$#!

(3! "%/2!338! 368#!$#!'

$/ !%$$#!//3'% $#$

%( "!/!-$#!( $6/'3 $ %!$#! 2!

!$#!

3#!( !%!$%'

!/3 $#!

"#$% $#!( !% !$2! !$!

! '/ "!.

!/!

2$#$#!

!%%(!

/%! ! $% $0$#! /$%8# /##.!

4 2!!%'"#$$2! ( $! 2686 !$8!

!2 '"#$$$#!

$ /! !.

'%/'%!32'$$#! /$%8!

!$ !$ !

!$//'$ 2

% %('$!$#$ $#!(3! "%/2!338! $6%$"!

3- /%!

$#!((3 /$ %%'//!%% '3$!%$23 %#$#$ !%( $! '! "!/!-#!/'3 $2

"$#%! /$% !/ $#!% ! !!/!%% 6 :'%$ !/

$#!/%! !( '/! %' !

) #!'

6$6%$"! /!!

"% 338!

$#!

$6$3$!

! # %(3! "% %'/# !

%'/#$!

%% 62!:'%$- 33%'/# !$%%#332!

!% 62!!/!%% 6 $#!('

(%! !$!

"$#!

!3A'!%$ /$ .!

%62!$8!!$#!( !% ! $#$((3 !$%#332!338!

3#%/

!/! -'3!%%$#!'

$/ !%$$#!

//3'% $#$ %( "!/!-$#!( $6/'3 $ #.! %! $#! 2!

!$#!/

3B /

!/!%8 $#$#!8 %C$#!'

6$6%$"! /!!

"%B $#!

! "!%$/ (8!

$338!

$#!

( $6$3$!

! # %(3! "%-8#!

$((! $$#!/'

$$#$$#! !$ %!/!%% 6 $#!('

(%! !$!

$#! !3A'!%$ /$ .!

%6#!( %-26'%! $#!!5( !%% C ! $#$((3 !$%#332!338!

3 #%/

!/! B((! %$(3/!!

2 "$#!(8!

$$ 338 !$ $#!(3! "%

3#%/

!/! #!

( %-#8!.!

-A'3

! $#!( # $ 6!5( !%% 26$#!'%! 8 % C'3!%% $#! /'

$ / !% $ $#! //3'% $#$ %( $! '!

"!/!- $#! ( $6 /'3 $ #.! %! $#! 2!

! $#!

3B$#!

!26/3

"$#$$#!!

2 " %$2%3'$!

$#!'

$- 6

%$/!%%(!

$-338 !$

$#!/

3 ># 3!/%

"$#!$ '!

( !- +D23! $#! (!5 '

! "

" 1 "

2"0! 3#%#!3 %' !

) C096/$4 ===-$#!

!8%%8!!( " !$26 8# /# '3!% 8!

! 8#336

$$! % $#$ !$ $%!3 8% $ (!

23!- 3$#'"# % !$

$8% !$ !36!/$ 4 !5$!% $

6('

(%! 00E3$

$!36$%$

<!23/!$#!?!"

%3$'

!((3 ! $%

!) '/! '3! 26/$

$# ( (!

$$ " !$ $#!

%$ $ 8# /# % $#$ $#! '

$ 6 $ 6 %$"! (!

!$% !%/

2! $#!

9'$ $3%# $$32

'/! 26( %8# /#( !.!$! 6((3

!$$2!338!

3# /

!/! '3!%% $#!'

$/ !$$#!//3'% $#$ %( "!/!

$#! ( $6 /'3 $ #.! %! $#! 2!

! $#!

3$ %$# %( %8# /# 33%

/% 04!3 /!8%(3/! $#!:' "!

$# %'

9 %%/ /%!%'( $# %/%!-$# %'

!3$8 $# $( # 7'%$ /!FG 2# 83%(!< " $#!9!/#2%!

.! %' !

) C '3! $#! ! !3% 8 $# !$

(3! "%96 !$/$-4 ===-$# %( 8% !3!$! $#%" 2!! !%$ ! 26 !$/$

2'$8 $# ! ( % $( !.!$((3

!$2!

"338!

3#%/

!/! -'3!%% $#!/'

$/ !%$$#!//3'% $#$ %( "!/!- $#! ( $6 /'3 $ #.! %! $#! 2!

! $#!

3#!( %-$% !!5$!$-/'

$ 3% 2%3'$! %/ !$ $338 !$$6%$"!8-

((3

3! /

3- $#%$2!

%#8$#$ %( "!/!-%'/# !$/'3 $#.!2!!%'"#$! #!2:!/$ %$( !.!$

.3'%((3 %8# /#

$ !36$#!$

3#!

% 33!"3 $6 B 0=$ %$2!$! $#$$#!( % &'3! #.! 2!! %'2%$$ 336 ! ! 26 $#! !$/$-

E !

%((3 !$%#332!

338!

3#%/

!/! -'3!%% %( '!

"!/!-$#! /'3 $ 2! %! 2!

! $#!

3$ %%'2

$$! -$#$

3 /%! #% /

!/! - ((3 (3! " %#33 2!

338! '3!%%$#!2.! !A'

!$ %%$

! #! ! !

&'3! 8% '!$$#! !/

! $ $#!?8

% /! % $ !5 %$! (

$ $#!

!$8% .<! 26( !% !%$! !36 "$#!

3#$$%# $!$#!3 "$ %(!! '( %(%3

$%- !$ 8% ! 26 $#! " /$- ===- !3!$ " '3!

$#! ! # % !.<! '/# /$ .!

%6;#!% $$ 33.!

$#!/'$ 6 3%3! "$ 26/$$ '

$% - $#!

!- 26 .

3 /! '

! !

!$ /$-

- ( #% 2!! !%$ ! 26

!/"

" $#! (8!

$#! '

$ $ "

$ !$- #8!.!

-8 $#/!

$ 3

$$ 8# /# %/$ ! $#!!8 ( % ! $$#!'3!#! !$ 3% '

%#! 2!388 33" $%#8%$#8$#! /$% !%!$/%!%#8$#$$#!

%8# /# !%'"#$$2! %! 2686 !$26 $#!((!33$%8!

!8!338 $#

<83! "!$#!

/%!

!%$%$#!2%!/! "!/!$#!(

$#!((!33$% %!$ $3 "$#!

$ !3 B +D23!$#!(!5'

$#!/%!

%00#/

+ /$!

"'" - " ( )-

"$ "

$%& "

= ?8 +!

3 0

0#%3 8/!

$ ( !$!

%-8# /# !' !

)

>#!$#!

$#! !$%'"#$

.! ( (!

!/$ .! :'

$#!/%!I >#!$#!

$#! ((3 !$ % 2

!I 0 #! !$%#'3 $/'%!%'/#( !:'

/!$$#!$#!

!8# /#/$2!/ (!%$! !A'$!36 $!

!6 4 !

'% " !$8'3 /$3! $ :'%$ /! 3! $ '3$ (3!3 "$ >#!$#!

$#! ( (%! !$ /%$ $'$ 336

' !$336/#"!%$#!$'

! /# /$!

$#!/%!I

%"!!

3 '3!-$#!/'

$%#'3 !/3 ! !$%

!%# %'

$ $#! ! ! /3

% 8'3 2! 2

! 26

$$ $#! $! ((3 $#! ( !%!$ /%!- $#! !$ %'"#$ $#! 8

!$#%2!!338! $#!"

' $#$$#!(3!$#$$#!( (!

%('$! %/!%$ 3 /( /! 6 $#!# % G # "#/'3 $2!$<! $#!8

!$26$#!! /'%!3 !( !%!$ "$#!

! $%># 3!(%% "$#!

('"! - $#%2!!' !

$<!26 $#! ! $%$#$$#!68 33$3! 6!.

!/! !$ #! :' "

!$% !3 ! '( 26 3! ! /'%!3 $#!

(!$ % !$((3 /23!$$#! /$% /

%$/!% $#!/%! .

!8 $#! /$% 38(% %!5(3 ! 2.!-$#!

$#!/$!$ %! 263! ! /'%!3 $#!(!$ 2!

" !. 6

%#!

!26

%%! *6 -

2 3 (: >#!$#!

%(!< ";

!%!

F!% >#!$#!

!( $23!

F!%