Rajiv Kumar v. Rakesh Kumar And ORS

   
 

 ! " #

 
 " 

$%&'

"() *+ ,-. / 
 





   


 
 &,  0!1& 2
 2! " 1

3 ), &3 45)(36(/2  3 * +()7)5 &3 2(-3(85(39/ * +() 3)56)) 3

&3  :(.( / * +() 336

 (:5! *(
5( 9    )5  63 )  6))    )  )5  3*3  *()*



/6(*8.)5(3 *+ -3)8 7/7538. (-)*8.

36

<6( )/    (  (66+()  *  8.  )5   +3

")3+)4-3-A5)3(/*3+) 5(8 9  35( 9 3)5 39 ( B . 9  +-) *.  )5
-3) ) )5 )( )2-8  6+) 3  3 C(D () 8. +1(8 3() 3./&(*5-8(

5*3+)   3+ D6(3 ()-3(66 ** )5B

1(3 *+ -  3)56)) 3-8D))*)5()2)((D7( -3*8.57* 7(3(B( )/ -3 ( *)7 *(-95)3 **

=

5(*C+-)*(B*()*;

 ( -3 57 (3(B(  )58( )5B/(3(B( ) * D6(3) )5 63 63).( * D7(9 ((9) 25C+-)*(B

( -3   5  )7   /  (D./  (:  4-D(3  ( *  (3D *  4-D(3/

  9 3 9)7  )53 / (D./(A54-D(3( *" 54-D(3( *)7 *(-95)3/ (D./2-5D(( *25( 5-)7(*8.36 )

<6( ) 3*+(3() +(D 9)5()58 9+(<9(53 ))*) 5(3 )563 63). 7 *8.*+(*<2)((D/5()53/ ( *)563 63).)8.53D )538.7(.  53)( + 5-)7( * =

;

"-3 9)56 +.)53 /36

<6( ) ( 9 )

")3+)4-3-A5)3(/ 

/(9 9)5())5(++-*5(* 39*)5 B 2)((D( *(3(B( 5 39 (B73-8D))*

+ -3) )5+-) 5 9+3 *(66+()

 35( 9 3)5BC+-)*8.2)((D 3  )5 (+( ()  (8)5 9(9 +.) 9))59 ()-3

)5B+ D6(3*3 D +1(8 3() 3./&(*5-8(

5 (D7(( 7*8.)5(3 *+ -3)8 7*D6-9 * 3*3

-3)53-8D))*)5()(*). )5B E-) 

)5+-)*8.36

<6( ) 5(D+(

)89 ) )538. 9(9 +. 38.)5+3D (+ -3)/5 +/)5 39 (B5 -* )85( ** 3) )5 9+3 3)5 6-36  + D6(3 ()-3?)5-D8D63 (66 **)53

 +()5B9  -) )5+-) *. )5+ -3)/)53(3+5( + )   3)(D63   )5+-)/)56(3)) )5*6-)(3(7(. ()83).) 9)C63) 6

5+ + 3+ D6(3  )5-D8 D63  39 ()-3 )63+) (./)5+ -3)5()  3D) 6

* -8)/+( * +3D (+(+( 9 ) 9)53/5 73/  9 )5+3D (+ -3) )5++ -3)/753()

)+<3(  +)5+)9() 7((3(*.6 9 3)5(D -/+3D (63 +* 9 )5(D(+)5 -* )863D))*) + - 5 9+3 (+(/8 )(6(3).

)5+)9() /+ -* )( .(66+()

-66 3) 56(/ 3( +7(6(+*-6 (:-*9D ) )5+ -3) (3( :( 2 95( * ( )53 2)()  - :(8( * )53/ $ ' 1=@@

;   )5  )53  5( */  (3 *  + -    3  36

  -8D))*)5())5 .(6635  3(*8.)56)) 3)5())53 D(.8+5( + )(D63 9 )5B 5(D+( 8)(A +(3 

5+ -3)+( *3+). *)5B)  +1(8 3() 3. 3 C(D ()

+(/)5 9 9 +. )( 7*) 9))5B C(D *3 D +1(8 3() 3./)7 )8(8) + D6) )5 ( *63 )+5((

53 9(). )5D6-9 3*3 +(/))(*/)5(D78D<-*( ( .+(/753 (  + 

D(* -)/)56(3).+( +)9() / -8D)  39 (  * +-D )    + -3)  ( *  )5  )(  )5    

(+(  73/5** )*6-))5() 9 )5+3D ( + -3)(3 )5++ -3)

(3*(3 *+ -  3)56(3)( *63-*)56(63 8 A 5  *6-)    8)7  )5  (D.  DD83  63)( 9  ) 63 63).)8.2)((D$*+(*'( *(3(B( )$*+(*'$7* 7  2)( (D'

 5.73 -3*  8.  -3  / (D./ (A5 4-D(3/ " 5  4-D(3/  (:  4-D(3  ( *  (3D *  4-D(3  ( *  )7  *(-95)3/

(D./2-5D(( *25( 2)((D** =

)+(D*)5() 63 3) 5*()5/5C+-)*( - 39)3*B ;

 ( -3  57(3(B( )7(9 *8.)53 ( *)7 *(-95)3/ C+6)" 54-D(3/(57((83 (*())5())D (3(B( )C+-)* 39)3*B

= ( -3 5)7  / (D./(: 4-D(3( * (3D *4-D(3 25**

@



6

< 6( )*)5-)+(D 95(3 )5(D.63 63).(9 9)5() 8 )52)((D( *(3(B( )** ))()/5 +/55((395)) 5(3 )563 63).

5-)7(* =

;

"-3 9)56 +.)53 / 59 ) 

")3+)4-3-A5)3((9 9 393. 8 )5)5B "-3 9

)5( 3(* /)5 9+3*(66+() 8 3)5 (3 *+ -3)8 7 35( 9 3)5 39 (B*()*;

 (9*.C+-)*8.2)((D( *+3)( 9 *8( A+5E- 2)(

 (D$*+(*'

5(66+() 7(+ ))*8.)56)) 3+(D )5()( .* +-D ) +-) *. )5+ -3) (++(+(

)85( ** 3) )56 +(-)5 3) 5 39 (B-8:+)<D())3 *6-) +)9() /753)5(*).)53 5() 8*+** 5(*).

)5B+( 8*+** .8.)5

-3)()3)56(3)(*)53 * +  )35(3 9+ -  3)56(3)( *(3 *2)()+ -  (66(3 9 3)5 9+3 /)5+ -3)8 7 - * )5()8( A+5E-/((9* )5(66+() *8.)5 +3/73 :-*+(/5 +/63(.3 35( 9 3)5(D 7(*+ 5 39 (B7(*3+)*) 85( ** 3) )5  9+3 ((*+ 3 3 9)5(D)  + 2+ +1(8 3() 3. 3+ D6(3 ()-3 )5B753)( (65 ) + 6.)53  7(*3+)*) 3)-3 )5 39 (B + -3) 7)5 ;*(. ))5( 3(* 3*3/75+55(8 D6-9 * )5 63 )6))

  )5  -)  *  8.  36

 <6( )/  6++ +5( 95(8 D(*) )5B/ (D./ C+-)*8.()<2)( (D ;

( * )53C+-)*8.(3(B( )

5 +5( 95( 98 D(*8.)56( )/)5 -) 63 )5())5B (3 39*( *(83+()* 5D & 3)5( .(3()3 9  )5-)/  7(9 ) 39)3*   

/  75  )5  +(  7(  ()  )5  )(9     9   36+() 8.)56( )  !.9)) 9)5BC(D *8. + 2+ +1(8 3() 3.)53 -9563 +-) 9(9 +. (+(9 ) 39)3*8.36

<6( )()3 9 )5-)/)5 3) D) 8) 5))58-3*  63  9)5())5B 39*( * (83+()* )563 +-) 9(9 +. (+( ) )5 9 8-)+ +)  * + 5 9 +3D (+ -3)(3

)5++ -3) 3 ++( 8D(*) )5:-*9D )  08)5 2-63D
-3) 25( )4-D(3 ( *( 25(A-)(("/$ '2

;  73/:-*9D ) ++ -3)7 -*83( )+ *)   ( . )52+) ) ; )5 *( * + +)(3()*/8-)) +(

)8(*)5())5(D7 -*8+ +-C+6)(63 **

 2+) )53  3 ++( 8D(*) )5:-*9D )  08)5 2-63D
-3) 4 

3D5( A3 6+) 3  +/  $'
 $
3D ('>=( * -3-3( )52(582)5( &395()F( (3( F*

(3A(5( * )53/ ;$ '
$
'> 

) ))5+(753)563 +-)  (+(7( 9  3)( *)53()3)5+-)7(*/3()53/)(+(753 )5+-)7((3(*.6 9 3(8 -)<?

.(375 7( 9 )39)3* 563D(3.- )5+-)39(3* 9(*). )5 B &336 3)3 D +1(8 3() 3.D(. )8-+ )) 6 )5())5B7( 39*( *(83+()* 5
-3) (3( :(

2 950+($-63(' 6 *)5() +(*). (B5(*8 *+**

+(( *)59 - )53 6 9  )53)9() /)5

6 73) *)3D )59 - ( *(*). 3 )537 )5B +(

)8)) )56 + 5 3*36(*8.)5)3(+ -3)63D)) )56 +)  *)5B)  +1(8 3() 3. )56 (+(/7()(*

3)53( D *(8 / D. 6 /)5D6-9 3*36(*8.)5+ -3)8 7 )9(.-)( (8/5 +/)5(D )(* 56)) )( **6 * /(++ 3* 9.

$(:5! *('

-*9 -. /  DA $3) 6 3)3'