Ramesh And ORS. v. State Of Haryana
!" "# $ %%&& '#( )*#+ $ % ,# # ) !&-. #"%%&& # '/# ,!0-%(+.1 #&- *#+ #&+ - " - %# %#(
.# -#"
0(4 % ! -!%& 5"#) 6"& 67"" %"7!%"& "") 6"
7# 6 "#%&(.&&6)" -8"&8" - #9"0-&/ 67"""#: "! 7"&* !%& !#!""#"(". 6& # 6!&/:"76 6##6"&:7"
"#" # "()(0) 6" "#-"
() 6"!#!7" %#-"7 ) #!7" !"#!7"
- "# ;/!%+" !#!"#"(#!" %%:) ""7"! -7"""#
"& "#%& ""(&0 " "+:
"# 6") 6"!6.0&7 "0!
* :"6 6.0&7* " 6"!
" /:7" * ##( 7+-;//"! "6#%- " !"6.
0&7 "* " 6"!
#6"!%# -&7# #6""%:* &&7 - "##() ) 6"!( <(#"!
7""#7% "0! - / "(&#:)
6.0&7 "#6"&6" " "" "+"(&6:!%& 5"#) 6" !%"&# #. .* 0(&&"(# (4& "# /&&"!& 8" 7 7 0+)(0) 6" ,=& 8"!.#" 7%(07 " %#7"#6#7 #"% % %&!(#
!#&( "#.&&6 #6# 67"""&6
"/ %&07 "%# "!#"6 " , "+& 8", "+""!# .(# " !%& %#+ *7.#- ( ) 6" ! 7 66#.0+" 8" +7 " " (## " &#&6""0(&0> ""()(0) 6" # ( 6 <(#* -&&"(#(7 7#"# "( !%& 5"#) 6"%#7#,&)
?/"&#%#"!#"# *"&)(0) 6" !%"&"%-6(#"0+*
"7+ 8&7#(# 6-"!%& !#"%&%#+ "6"! @> ,?##7")5?6"A(!#- )* ,& ) ?/"& "# # ### " .6 6 #45 8"5 .6 6 #%% " #! @> ,?40&7("! #(B" %& " 0 7"" #!& 95 @> ,?4 7 ## 8" "%&%#+!% "!%& " % 8" 5 .6 6 # ## ( % % - %#%# 6#(6"%& "%& @> , * (!! %"6#%"# 6"%&(## 7"# " 0+ 7 &+ 6- %"6#%" 8" 5 ## ( B( %# 6 7" #6# (
(#& " * - %#%# 6#%#@> , "#6# *&0& #"
#!"%& *&/ % " @> , 0& 6 6"- "#@> ,
& # @> ,
#!"%&(## &&"#&7# .# &%#& / % . #.#+!!@> ,C0+,=)(0) 6" !%"& 8"5 .6 6 #" .#"0+* D1A "! 0&+&A" #"%(#% 6 6"%!#! >! ("# " .#%%& @> ,"! #%!#!>!
3
-D1A "!" .#%+"%!#!
#%# &%#& 6&""" .6 6 # 8"%#&7/ %
.#.#+!!@> ,* 9(#"#- .6 "7##(0+ %# &06 ) 6" ,=
3
- #. #! - " %& %#+ & 0+ 5 %# &06 ) 6"
%%#" () 6"!-!"-) ;/#!
%& #0#6)" 7 8"(7# ##6 () 6"!(# 6"(# ##6 -(# &(# ! @> , " " " /% & 0> #!"# &"(-0(7""
&+"/ 7 "(&6"!#.# ()
&!! @> ,;( #) 3"@. """/% & ( #""%! (#- .#7""( 6/"0 %& "(&6"! #.# 8" (!"(#&(#! @> , """/% &
( #""% ## " ""( "(&6"! #.# 8"##- %(#( "&(#! !-&&""#(6#.#"#%.7% 0+ "! "# ! - 7"" 7# / % # .# 6" &%#& 8"%& "%&#.#7#%#%#
#(# "%&
-"%#%#+7%7""* ( 7#%( "&/(% (# 6"(# .6 -" %#& 6 0& 6 6" 7% 7# 9)C-"(0 #%#"##!7 #. #!%& .6 "##!&- "&& 6 "(!"-) ) 6"!7 %#%# & "(#?(&6#9#&- 8"
%# "&& " (# ?(& 6#5&-8" -"(%%&%(! #&(% ""&& &&"(#%#. ( #)
3# , 8" 6" ( #)
5,>&(.&+#0&0+"(#) -&# ?(&6#5&-8" ."##E
!!""(#&# &) ?(65-9"0 5!+0! "#"(#"(;/7 ( 0<(. & %# 66 "!7#
?(. &?( # =" "7#. "(#&# &) ?(6-9"0-" 6"%#! "#6#" ( #)
#7")
5, E5,7&6 ""#(-"#6
E ""!# 6&+-7""-"+%& 6(&+ &! #& 8" 7 " > # . " %#(
(# 6 " (# . - " %#(
>! ! +7&.7 ,=# )"A(!#- ,= # * C 1(%- ,= 0& )(0"" " #- ,=
A " !- ,= * ) " A(!#- ,=E 0& &< ) 6"-,=35"#) 6"-,=)(0) 6"-,= )(/".) 6"- ,= 5 %#&06) 6"-,=1#"A(!# ,= )5 ?6"A(!# ="""%#( . & )! "(7###( #)
# , - 7""&&" #! 6#(! %%# 6 (" ( 7# %( "! 0( "+ " &&6 6""+"0 &&+ .&. " 0+"!%& "+"# #& 7""! *7.#-"( & +.
# "# 6 #6(! - &# #& (# . <(6!
.(!"-) 6"!
) #" ( #)
#7")
E ,# 55 5, "! . ##
( #
3 )# ; D #)
) 7#
#7") 5, 6#(!%# ! # & %+ -
4"
(&%+! (#"#( #6#6#( !%# ! #%# >! ""
E5, 6#(!%# ! # 7+#"
8" (0 . 7# ## #(
(## &+ 8"<(6! ##&"(4 . 66#. "+".&"%# %%&- 7""
76. ") = ". "# &# ( & # " %%&& ( . &# %(+.1 #&#" )*#+ 06 6"#(6""## " .#+ (- !+ 0 " %%&& 4(!"" >%# """0
6.#0+")( &-7"" #!"(#
"#6# 8"##-"%%&B(!"A(!#"0! #((( &+7%%&& #&0#"(# #%%&& 4() 6"! # - "# (6"6 - . 6 #&0&. .&0& "##"7"%#% " 8"(&# . (0+"%#( B(6 .
B( "! !& . & ##0# " (&# . 9(#"#!#) 6"!"6"7% (0+ "! " #.##!"% 0+!/ 6 &(#! 0#"%& "#.#+"0
60+"! %(#( "&(#! *"# 6!.!!"#! ="#7"#6#"() -7 ""#%#% "#! (&&+0&" 5" 0/% ! ""# +! 6%%&" #6 "#7 7#% ! +%# %0&- " %% %#+ " (# 9(#"#!#-7""#"(0 ". 6 -+( 6
!"7"
"# ;/0 6"#- "6"&+( &/&+"%%&& 4() -60( +# " !- 7(&".< "# ( "(& ;#!&&+ ("+%6"-7! &/# /<
"(& 9(#"#!#-" <(#(7" #!7" & B(%0&" <(#+ #0() " 0 (0+() 6" ! %#"%#( ) 6"! ) " ( <(#7""##%.7% 0! - / "(&#* 7"&"7&+ 67 ) " 6. 0&7 " #6" &6 " ; ##% 6 <(#+ "#6"&6"70#.
0+"#-7"" ("%!#!>! ; "#% <(#+"0 #0() 8"##- (0# "! 7""#"7(&&+%# "% "< "#"(0 7 / * %#&70 (006. ()
)"#.06. ("0 -7""77# 6&+ "#0+"#&(# # 6&+- " %%& 7" #6# %%&& 4(!" 0 ="#&&7 7" #6# %%&& 4( ) 8" <(6! "# . ## %0+"#&(## " B( " "#6 #! 6 "# *7.#- %%& & 0+ %%&& 4( ) 6" ! ! ) 6"!%%&& F(0 0& 6# "! 0+ " (# . ##
E 7"& (% 6 " * 0& && " ?(& 6#-9"0#(##7## 6"!
##!/"!( #6"#! 6
!"# =""#%/ 64#
G4; =""#%#0& G4;