High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2920/2015dismissed

Sucha Singh v. Nand Lal

2015-04-30Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain10 pages

#$%& !'( )* +, -

%+ . /% 0 0 !/

1 (+ %1 1 )10 234) *'( 1(35(( 1

'63 )'

35(( 1768)29 ():( 13')(351 (5((

9582 2(3 1)1)'() ,

45'):<(3'1 )=*8( 2* 81(4 )9 2(3'55*'( ):<(35(( 18 )10*( > (3 05***(4?,# 13 1(4.(3*(.&

1<4 (3 '*( '1 (3'( (3 5(( 1 (1) ( '

'219 (( @(3(315 ( >

? 1' (3'

)4 9'81 2-A'

'-9'1'4B>44C751A'

3'()'( 1 =*8( (3'))@'=)'>

;

(1=*8( (3 '219 ( ( 4 )1 ( **' 4 (3 5(( 1 1*) 5'1( 5'<9 ( 1 9 (3 15 ( '

) ( (' '9 8 ( 1*) : 1 (3 12(1'( (3'))@'-4 4C7 35(( 13' 2') ( 2((3'))12(1)4(315 ()'8( 15 :< @'< 5**51 19'

* '219 (( ?

;

3'9 @' )*1) :< (3(1' * 81( ) 68)29 ( )'()

( @' )1*()(3'((35(( 1@=*8((3'))'

))15

( 39 @(3 ' 51 ) 9 (3 '(1 1* 2 (3 :''

* ' * )1'( 4' 2@3*3(315 (75' (* 8)2((3'))

=*8()'

)('A5 (38('

):< 2=*8(

3 5(( 14: 2'221)'2' ((368)29 ('

))*1 (3(1' * 81(4)'55'4@3*3@')9):<(3'1 ) @1'55'( * 81()68)29 ('

))*1)'()-

368)29 ('

))*1 (3'1 ) @1'55'(* 81(@'*3' 2):<(35(( 1:< 20

,?- 4@3*3@')9):<(3* 81() 1)1 )'()

- ?

4(315 ()'55*'( A 519 ( )5 ((3:''

*'* )1'( 4@3*3@'519(() '

) (3 '9 8 ( @' )5 () (3 '9 )'( 31'(14 3 ) '55*'( 8 )11)1 8, 1959 ( 2(368)29 '

))*1 (3' 1')'55*'( 4(35(( 1)'55*'(

)10*( >#& (3*( 11* ) 2(3* (1'*(:*'8(3 )*173 )1')( )5 ((3:''

*'* )1'( @(3 (3 51 )21'

()'

)81(31')( A=( (31 3'9@' )9):<(3* 81(: @)9582 ) 1)1

/'1 ) * 8 1 (3 5(( 1 8:9(() (3'( (3 68)29 ('

))*15'):<(3(1'* 81(

4(@ 9 (3.

(9@'21'

() 1)5 ( (3:''

*'* )1'( 43 @14(3 '9@')5 ():<(315 (7)*13 )1 ?

@(3 8( (31 : 2 '

< '55*'( A 2 =( (9 (3 ': * (31 4 (19 (351 0*( >#& (3*(4(3* (1'*( @'':( :1* ))'

)(3)*13'):* 98 =*8(': 3 * 81(: @@'@1 2 :1 2(3'((31@' (9=):<(3 * 81( 1)5 ( (3'9 8 @143)) ()58((3'*((3'( )81 2(35 *< '55': 1(31('55'(* 81(4(31@' (19('<

(13'1 2'1 )* 8 1(35(( 14) ( '

< 91( (3 8:9 9') 3 :'* '*(4 '9<4 (3'( (3 5(( 1 (1) ( '

'219 (( 1' (351 51(<

? ( )58( 3'()'( 112(1'( (3')) @'>

;

35(( 13' 2')( 2((3'))12(1)4 8( 15 :<@'< 5**51 19'

* '219 (( @' ):<(315 (7)*13 )1 ?

;

3'9@')*1)

, :<(3(1'* 81( 3 51'(5'1( (368)29 (=(1'*(): @+ DE5 2 @ 9< ) 2 (3': 84(38( (35' ()*1)@(3* ( 15 :<@'< 5**51 19'

* (3'219 ()'() >

?@(3'

)1*( ( (3) )'

(( =*8('')) ' 81 (35' ( 8('

)81(31( )1(5 ( 394@(3 '51 ) (@ 9 (3'(11* 2(3:''

* '* )1'( 4' 2@3*3(35' (*'

2((3' ))=*8()'

)( ('A5 (38('

)(31 823 =*8( 51 *) 2

35(( 15111)'55''2' ((368)29 ('

))*1 (3(1'* 81( 3'55'@') > >

(@' ()58() (3'()81 2(35 *< '55'4(31@' (19('< 3'55'@' )9) -

99)'(< (31'(14 (3 15 ( ) '55*'( : 1(3* 81(: @ ?

A 2519 ( )5 ((3:''

*'* )1'( 4@3*3@'21'

() 3'9 8 (@' )5 () (3'9)'< (1)5 ( (3'9 8 (4(315 () '55*'( 8 )11)1 8, 1959 ( 2(368)29 '

))*1 (3(1' * 81( 15<)'() - >

( (3' 1') '55*'( 4(35(( 1('()(3'((368)29 ('

))*1 (3 @1 '55'(* 81(3': *3' 2): 1(3* 81(43 *4((3 ' )5 ':<(3* 81(4(368)29 ('

))*1)'()

3 8): ('<) 31'(1(3'55*'( ):<(315 (7)*13 )1 )11)1 8, 19' )5 ) 0

,?- ) :< (3 5(( 1 @' )9) :< (3 * 81(

31'(14'55*'( )'()- ,

@'):<(35(( 18 )1 0*( > (3*( (35'(3'((3(1'* 81( (3)*1)'()

3')21'

()(@ 9 (3.(9 1)5 ( (3'9 8 3 '9@')5 ()'551 =9'(<9 (3(31'(1@(3 8((31: '

<'55*'( 1=( (94 3 *4(3121'

() ( (3 15 (3'):* 9 18*(8 8'

)(3'219 (( )1)( : 1* )) 518' (315<( (3'55*'( ):<(35(( 1 3 @(3'( :6*( ):<(35(( 1( (3=*8( @1)9)

- :<(3* 81( ,

)(315 (@')1*()( 8:9((3)1'( ')) 3 1)13' (: 5'*) 1* 1):<(35(( 1 3 3 @(3'((35(( 1@'(1< 2( 9'A' 1(( ('=*8( (3)*15')'2' (39 3* )8*( (35(( 1@'

* 99 ()85 :<(3* 81(@3)9 2(3'55'):<39

(3 @ 2(19+ D'(31(3) )'

(3' (* 9( (3* 81(@(3*'

) 1(<4 '** 8 ( (3'*((3'('(1')9 (3 '219 (( 4) '( '5'1(*8'1 **' 3': 9') '

) * )< :< @'< 2 '55*'( 1 '))( ' ) *4(3 (1'219 (( @' 823(( :) )

9'(1(3 823(21 8 ) 1@3*35'1'(51 *) 2 * 8)3': ('():<(3) )'

0*( > (3*(5**'<51 )(3'( (31 9 (9 21'

() :< (3 * 81( 1 5'<9 ( (3 :''

* ' * )1'( ' )*1 1 5** 51 19'

*4 (3 (9 *'

: =( )) < '81( * 95<@(3(3'94'

'55*'( 8 )1 0*( > (3*(9' (' ': :3' (368)29 ():( 1( A1* ) 2 (3* (1'*( (3'*( (3*'4 9< 5 4(3 5(( 1*'

(('A3(1 (351 0*( > (3*( 3812'1) 2 '129 ( (98 )10*( -> @' * )1) :< .: (3 08519 81(

@31 (3': 5 ) (3'((3* 81(3')*1( 1 9(9( (9( '12(3(9 (3 (9 12 '<=) 121'

()3')=51) G3111 2( 68)29 ( .:(308519 81(

%& '

()

*+,(@' 5 )(3'( =( :< ,)'<' 519: *'(31H81)'*(* 8) (:51 19) :<'5'1(<@(3 (3'(51 ) 1(31' :< )3* (1 4'(3 51 ) 51*1:) (A(351 )51*1:)8 )1(351 (3/9('( *( '

(5'1' (368)29 ('1=(1'*(): @+7 D?

'1'(31('5*(* *1 )0*( -> (3 4 81 5 4*'1<11 ' 81 (3 81((3

5 @1( '12(3(91H81) 1) 2'

'*(51*1:) 1' @):<(3 ) 1 *)81 0*( -> (3 )9'<'((3('2:=(1'*()+7

G31'

<51 )=) 121'

():<(3 81( 1(3 ) 2 '

<'*(51*1:) 1' @):<(3 )4(3 81(9'<4 ()*1( 41 9(9( (94 '12 8*351 ) (=*) 2(31(<)'< ( ('4

(3 823(351 ) 12 '<=) 121'

()9'<3' =51) ;

5' 1') 2 (3': @ 8)3 @(3'(@3 '

< 51 ) 1(921'

():<(3 81( 1) 2'

<'*(4(3 81(3'(3)*1( 1 9(9( (9( '128*3 51 ) (3(9 12 '<=) 121'

():<(3 81( 3'=51) () (1 9(3'

28'295 <) (3 51 (3'((35 @12 ( (3 81()*1( '1< '

) ( ))( :=1*) <( 9((3 ) 68(*

01')* (3 81(3'=5' )(3'9:('

* 5 (35 @1=1*':8 )10*( -> (3

! "#$%&'()$&"(3 81( :1)+ D0*( -> (3 )4 (194' @=( (94 (3 12 '51 )=)3'=51)4'

0*( -H8'<:1' 1( 14(3 *( * 8): A):<(3'55*'

(4@3 (3(93') '*(8'<=51) 3'((3'55*'( @') (3 '*'( @3 '! *3@' ((( 23 8) 3' : * )1) )' 2 @(3 (

, -4@3 (@''*(8'<3'1) 3 1)14(3 823 5')'(1(3=51< (3(9=):<(3 12 ' 68)29 (4 @ 8) 3' 51'() 1 9 > - @ )1':(( =(95195( 1< 1'8(81

? 3'55 2@3*3'(3 81(5 @1( )'@(3 ((3'(923('1 :(@ 4( ( *'1<( )*) (3'55' 3 1)1(81 8(4 ( ( : =5) 08*3 51 *)81' 1)14 (3 823 5195( 1<#* )( ')*1'5'1(&'1 *4

(11 194 (3'()'( 1<(2'

(923(58((39 1)1 '

) ' ) )'< 3< ) (4 3 @14 * 95(<( 5' 81(1 9('A 2 ( ('

*1*89('

*@3*33'55 @(3 (3(9=) ='954 ( *'

( : ') (3'(4 (3 '55'

( 3') ('1()@(3(389 < 1)1)( :5')'

)*'9 @ (9:8((85 '

)1 ::):<(3(3)'< 51 843* 8) ('A 1=( (94 1(3'( (3 81(@'5 @1( =( )( 08*3 1)1'1 A(3'@ (3%)'

)(3 1'

''1 @ @3*3 81(3'9 8))(3151'*(*( 9('(8'( 8*3'(3'

)( 3'1( 1)'8( 1 51 *) 24 (3 823' ' 1)13'): 5') > (3 '9 *( (3 )* (3 81(

'9'1A'(3'

<<' 4> #&04@31(3 81()*'1)(3'((3* 5'

)=1* (3681)*( ( 21'

((9( ) '(3 24 (3': * '5**51

( (3 * (1'1< *81(' 24 ) < 2 1 @(33 ) 2 8*3 681)*( 4 ( 21'

( (9 @ 8) 31 ( '9:( (3 681)*( ( =( )(9 ('<=):<( 3 81(' *') (351 *5 H8(<@3 *1*89('

*'1( : ('A ( '** 8 ( 1= 2' 2(3 (9@(3 @3*3'

*1(' '*( ( : ('A 4 (3 81( 1(' ( (3 681)*( ( 17='9 (3'(1'( 19 )*'( @3*3 9'< *('(=( (9 3 @ 25''21 9 (3)* '55 (+ D(@'**5()51 *5('(8( 1<1* 2 I)

0*( -> (3 ) 1 *)81(3'(@31'

; 51 )=) 121'

():<(3 81( 1) 2'

<'*( 51*1:) 1' @):<(3 )4(3 81(9'< ( )*1( 1 9(9( (9 '128*351 )

(3 823(351 ) 12 '<=) 121'

()9'<=51

' 81( =1* (3681)*( *'

21'

((9( ) '(3 24 (3': * '5**51 ( (3 * (1'1< *81(' 24 ) < 2 1 @(33 ) 2 8*3 681)*( 4(3681)*( ( 21'

((9@ 8) 31

('9:((3681)*( ( =( )(9 ('<=):< ( ' 2'* 95 ( 1)1@ 8):'*( 2 )12'1) (3 681)*( (3'( @3 21'

( 2 (9 98('

8<(3 81() ( ((3681)*(

( =( )(9 351 *5 H8(<(3'(@3 9 *1*89('

*'1( :('A ( '** 8 ( 1= 2'

2(3 (9@(3 @3*3'*1(' '*( ( : ('A 4(3 81(1(' ( ((3681)*( ( 17 ='9 (3'(1'( 19 )*'( *1*89('

* @3*39'< *('(=( (9 (3 81(:< ( @ '*() ((3681)*( ( ) 4(@ 8) :) < 2( ((3681)*( @3*3 (3': * ' 2'(51 4(8 ) 8:()< 6 < 1 *9'<' :9')( (3)* (3 81( * + ,- "#&%'((.$"*

/ "##%'((0&! / +! "#2%&'((2&

,3 "4 5

6" .002 %$' (( &4 (3 81( 3') ' **' ( ='9 @3(31(31(1*( 5'*):<(3'9 )9 ( 0*( -> (35 @1 (3 81(( 21'

(=( (9:< ),)'<@'1' ': 3 81(3)(3'('

5 @1 (3'( 31 ( (3 81( ( 5' 1)1 (3'( ( * )1 *'1< 1 9( 2 (3 ) 68(* '

51 ( 2':8 (351 * (3 81(*'

(:('A

> '@'<:<58(( 2'

85519( (351 ) 1@3*3'

=( *'

: 21'

() =( :< ) (3 9'=989 51 ) , )'<@' '** 1) 2<3)519: (3 @ 2@ 1)+ D3'9 )9 (9') 0*( ->'*((35 @1 (3 81(( '12(9(3'(9'<3': =) 1 21'

():<(3 81( 1(3) 2 '

<'*(51*1:) 1' @):<(3 ) 3'9 )9 (51 )(3'((3 51 ) 3' ( =*) , )'< ( (' 1 '9 )9 (4 (31 @' 8*3 1(1*( (9

G3(31(3 81(3' 31 (5 @1( =( )(3 (9:< ),)'<(3H8(

G3' ) 8:( (3'((385519(=) 0*( ->*'

(('A'@'< (3 31 (5 @1 (3 81(( 5' 1)1'9'<:

*'1< 1(3 ) 68(* 1( 51 (':8 51 * (3 81( 312) 51'( (3*(

@ 8)')( ':81)(< 0*( 3'4(31 14( : ' @)( 51'(8< =( :< )9'=989 ,)'<4(384*'

:519(()(3'*(* 8) (: 51 19)@(3 ,)'< 11' :< )(3* (1 (35'1(< G'1 ()' 2@(3'*'@31(9 1) 2'

'*(3': 51*1:)8 )1(351 (3/9('( *(@3*3*'

(:=( ))(31 )10*( -> 10*( G'1)' 2@(3'

*'@31(3(9=) 121'

():<(3* 81( 1 51 19'

* '

'*( 51*1:) 1 ' @) :< (3 * 81(

( ( (323( (3': )* 5 ( (3 15 (( '128(3'(' 81(*'

=(9 1(3) 2 '

'*(A9'A 2 )5 (4 (3 ('

( *'4:8( 3'

681)*( ( =( )(3')51 ) @3 '*' 18*3 =( *'1<9') 8( 35 @1( =(3(9 1 ) 2 '

'*(98( 81 5 *'11<@(3((35 @1(

=( ) 8*3 51 )4 )5 ) 2 85 @3(31 (3 5'1(<

)'8(9'A 8('*'( (3'('*( (3 81(@3 3'=)(3(9 31 (3 2 0*( -> (3 1 '

< (3151 (3* )( 822((3'(8*3'

5 @1 =( (9*'

(:=1*) '*'A

'(3'

3'1289 ((3'((35 @1( =( )(9*'

: =1*) @31 (3 '*( H8( (58'() '

* )( ')*13' (951)8 G 1' ( )1'@ ' )( *( )5 ) 2 @3(31 (3 51'<1 1 =( 12'1)( '* )( ' 1)1 1'* )( ' )*1 33'1( (39'((1(3'(@31(3 81(3'(3 5 @1 ( = (9 '

) (3'( 5 @1 ( 128'() :< '

< ('(8( 1<9(4(3' '551 51'(*'(35 @1( =( (3(9=):<( (* 99 21 8 )(3'( (31(3

1(351 %

** 99 )'( (1 *(5'* '

<9('( (35 @1 (3 81( A(3

#953'855)&

9'1*('1(368)29 ( (3 81( -.

" $ / " $

) 0$

!1"2$

" $

1 9'518' (3' 1')68)29 (4(*'1(3'((3 81(3''955 @1( '12(9=) 1) 2'

<'*( (3 (9 12 '<=) 121'

()3')=51) 35 @13': * 11) ( :=1*)( 9((3 ) 68(* '(1'9 )9 ( 0*(

-> 45'* 2'9( ,)'< 1=( (94(3 81((3' 5 @1( =( ((351 ):< )(3'(*'89') 8( (3 *'@31(3(93': (58'() '* )( ')*14(35 @1 (3 81(( =( ) (('A '@'< 3*18=(3'(@31(3 81( 3'5 @1( =(9'

)(3'(5 @1 (128'():<'

<('(8( 1<9( 8*3'(3/9('( *(4(3'5 @1( =( )(3'9

81(314(35(( 1)0

,?- (3* 81(

> -

1 1 ( (3'(4 (3 15 ( 3') '1')< )5 () (3 :''

* ' * )1'( '(1 519

3 =*8( 51 *) 2

19' )5 ) 2'(31* 1) (3* 81(: @3'): 899 ):< (3* 81( ;

3' 1')'55'@')9)

31'(14(3=*8( 51 *) 251 *))81(31

@ 9<' 1'))*8 4) ( )'

<11 1

(3 1)15'):<(3* 81(: @ 35(( 4'** 1) 2<4)9)

#'63 )'& 8)2 , -