High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2657/2014dismissed

Rajinder Singh v. Punjab State Electricity Board & ANR

2015-12-11Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

!"##$%&%'(#$#)*#+,

!-%'.#+/%'01 #"%"%'#+ 2#+&3&

3'-!*/"!"#4#$"+%$%"5!+.,1#!44 !"%!4! !'"1#+ #&6'.#'"&

!" #$%&'" '& ( !)#$*+"

71#"1#+ #6+"#+&4$!46!6#+&)!5*#!448#."&##"1#-3.0)#'"9 *#+##++#.""1# #6+"#+&+'"9 : 71#"1#+"1#-3.0)#'"&134.*#+#6+"#.%'"1#%0#&"9

+#&#'"( +//!$1.#;,.;$!"#, +"1#6#"%"%'#+ +&##"!/1!+)!,.;$!"#, +"1#+#&6'.#'"& <<<<<

'& ( !)# ,- 1# 6#"%"%'#+ %& !00+%#;#. "1# %)630'#. +.#+ .!"#. ''#=3+# > ,81#+#*5"1#!664%$!"%'%4#.3'.#+/#$"%' "1#'.%!'+*%"+!"%'$",?

,1!&*##'.%&)%&&#. +//!$1.#;,4#!+'#.$3'&#4!66#!+%'0'*#1!4"1# 6#"%"%'#+ &3*)%"& "1!""1# 6#"%"%'#+1!. *"!%'#. !68#+ $''#$"%' /> + +3''%'01%& !$"+5 /%'$# "1# )#"#+ 8!& '" 6+6#+45 +3''%'0,"1#)!""#+8!&+#6+"#.""1# 3'-!*/"!"#4#$"+%$%"5!+.!'.

"1#)#"#+8!&+#64!$#.!'."1#*%44&%&&3#."1#+#!"#+1!.*##'+#034!+45 6!%. ' ??:,"1#)#"#+8!&$1#$@#.*5"1#/ !'.%"8!&3'. "1!""1#&!)#8!&%'+.#+,)3$14#&&"1#&#!4&8#+#%'"!$",*3",18#;#+,' ???:,)#)*#+&"1# 45%'0/A3!. /$1#$@#."1#)#"#+!'.

3'."1!""1#)#"#+8!&%'6+6#+8+@%'0!'."1#&#!4&8#+#!4&%'"!$", *3"%'+)#."1!""1#5.%.'"1!;#"1#$++#$"%)6+#&&%'&"1#&#!4&!'. 834.;#+%5"1#&!)# '???:,!0!%'"1#)#"#+8!&%'&6#$"#.!'. 3'."*#%'8+@%'0+.#+8#;#+,'"1#&!%..!"#,"1#)#"#+8!& +#);#.'"1#6+#"#="0#""%'0"1#&#!4&$1#$@#.!'.,"1#+#+#,"1# .%&63"# !+&# *5 ;%+"3# 6+;%&%'& /#$"%' "1# '.%!'

4#$"+%$%"5$"!'."1#6+;%&%'&/#$"%'"1#+*%"+!"%'$",? 8#+#%';@#. +/!$1.#; 1!& +##++#. " /#$"%' "1# '.%!'

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

*#+#"1#3+"*#48,"1#3+"*#48$34.1!;#+##++#. "1#)!""#+""1#+*%"+!"+!"#+'"%$%'0"1#+#6+",*3""1!"#;#'"1!&'" !+%&#'8%'0""1#!44#0#.''>6+#&#'$#"1#$'&3)#+ +/!$1.#;, ' %'&"+3$"%'&, &3*)%"& "1!" 1%& $4%#'" + 1%& +#6+#&#'"!"%;#834.;%&%""1#B!*'+#$#%6""1#!.;!'

. #=!)%'!"%' "1# )#"#+ +&##"! /1!+)!, 4#!+'#. $3'&#4 + "1# +#&6'.#'"& &3*)%"& "1!" "1# / %& '" !;#+&# " 0#""%'0 "1# )#"#+ #=!)%'#.%'"1#6+#&#'$#"1#$'&3)#+ C##6%'0%';%#8"1#!+#)#'"%'#.!$"&,%')5;%#8,"1# 6#"%"%'3'.#+/#$"%'"1#+*%"+!"%'$"%&6+#)!"3+#$$+.%'045, "1#+#;%&%'6#"%"%'%&.%&)%&&#. 8#;#+,"1#6#"%"%'#+&1!44*#!"4%*#+"5"&##@"1#!+*%"+!"%' %'$!&#!'5!.;#+&#+#6+" */01,) '& ( ! ,-02 #$*+"