High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2959/2015disposed of

Ram Lal Choudhry Deceased Th Legal Heirs Bishan Dass Chodhury And ORS. v. Vijay Goenka & ORS.

2015-09-29Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih3 pages

!" #"$%&%'(

)* +, -#, ./ #"$" &"#!,.-0,*& 1"!%!%'". 2".&-& 2%3 /"'4 '#!,".& 1"&5'#"'!& ( 6 *7 ** ."&"'!( . '%+, 8+ 9 #:$ !" .!,"5"!%!%'". .2%' /;-) . , 3 '9 #:$ !"

.!,"."&5'#"'!& <<<

=,"!,". ."5.!".& +$ + 5 5".& ) / >" ++8"# ! &""!,"3-#0)"'!? >"."

".."#!!,"."5.!".&.'!? @ =,"!,". !," 3-#0)"'! &,-+# >" ."5.!"# %' !," #%0"&!? <<<

** . + '7"5!")>". A9

9!,%&$-.!, #5 &&"#!,"

++8%'0.#".(

$%&%$&'( ) * +

- . . 2%' / ;-) . , 3 '9 #:$ !"9 , & $ -&"# 55" . '$"'>", + !,"."&5'#"'!& '#&->)%!&!, !," #"&'!55&"!,"5. /".!, !, &>""' #: '$"#>/+" .'"# $-'&"+ .!,"5"!%!%'". '#+"! /" .6&!%)">"0. '!"#! !,"5"!%!%'".!"' '!!, '#:".!,": $ '!5&&"&&%' !," #")%&"#5.")%&"&!!,"."&5'#"'!+ '#+.# , ! >"%'0 &9 !," 5"!%!%' %& #%&5&"# %' !,"

++8%'0!".)&( % 5"!%!%'".!"' '!&, ++$'!%'-"!$$-5/!," #")%&"#5.")%&"& . 5".%# '"/" . .)!# /%"-5! B

CD %% !,""'!%." .." .& ."'!9% '/9&, ++>"5 %# >/!,"5"!%!%'".!"' '!!!,"."&5'#"'!+ '#+.#8%!,%' -. 8""4& .)!# /D %%% 5"!%!%'".!"' '! &, ++ $'!%'-" ! 5 / !,"

-!-." ."'!E)"&'" 5. %!& >/ F!, ":"./ )'!, ! !," ."&5'#"'!+ '#+.# ' !," ":"'! ":"' &%'0+" #"

-+!9 ."&5'#"'!+ '#+.#&, ++>" !+%>".!/!"G"$-!"!,".#". ":%$!%' .!,8%!,D %: 5"!%!%'". &, ++ #"

. / ++ !," "+"$!.%$%!/ '# 8 !". $, .0"& . !," 5".%# ," 8-+# $$-5/ !," #")%&"# 5.")%&"&D

@ : 5"!%!%'". &, ++ : $ !" !," #")%&"# 5.")%&"& '#, '#:".%!& $!- +5,/&%$ + '#: $ '!5&&"&&%'9 .""

.) ++ "'$-)>. '$"& ! !," ."&5'#"'!+ '#+.#9 ' . >"

." !," &!%5-+ !"# # !" %" B

C9 %+%'0 8,%$, ."&5'#"'!+ '#+.# &, ++ >" ."" ! "G"$-!" !," .#". ":%$!%' '#>! %'5&&"&&%'D '# :% 5"!%!%'".&, ++ -.'%&, '-'#".! 4%'0%'!," >:"!".)&9>/8 / '

%# :%!98%!,%' 8""4 .)!# /9 >"

." !," "G"$-!%'0 $-.!9 %+%'0 8,%$, 0 %' ."&5'#"'! + '#+.#&, ++>" !+%>".!/!"G"$-!"!,".#". ":%$!%' 7"5!")>".9

3 ' .-' ++% -#0"