Subhash Chand v. State Of Haryana And Another

 &'()  ,  76752 IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH
&'( - .//0!&! () &

 

       !!!1// 
*              !!!2 
 
 "  

  !%+ #"
  "  #
0
) &
%
) 1



" 0
#2
 %
))3%
4 & 0
 "
5 6
7 1%
)


"
8

) 1

 #$%!


9
"
"

! 
 
!&

"86"  


 




 
 

 
  
  
! 



"

 0


-./
#
$

$ %
 

$ $ +%
 )%


$:

.


 
 
&
# '


 


 



(

$ %
"
!&

)

 

*

%
#

+

#
,

$ ""  + 



 1 


"

"
 "



"
 


 
-./

 

!&

"
" 

&'() 
$

$
6 
 


 
& %


6

"

0

( $ $ %


 



$

$


66

4
 


 

 !2

  &

 
 6 &
!&
"



6 &
66!
  &

&
  

!&

6
"&
;


 %
" 

61

 
!
"" 
!
#
,

$



 
! %

   %
1 

(

$%
"
!&



 )



*

%
#

 <
 

"

16 &
 ! 

!



" 
#


! 

!
 

"

1




 



66



"

! 


$ +

.

  &
6 
 

" 
9

!
"" 

"




 
!&





$%
1%



"
 
6%


!

! 

 
!
!&
"

6"


 %
 
""

" 



1
 
!&
"



"" 

9


" 6"



 +

.




&

!






 6
 

!

"

.

 
 !6



= 
 

" 
 

"





 



! 

!
9 %







%
 
"


(

$%
66


   &%





6"



(

$

! 

!

 


"

 

!

" 
#


&'()3

1

!
 

9
 &

 6%

 

"

  "

2

6
 
!&
4>! 
 "6



   



  

%
6
)""
#


$%




$ $

 /" 

 
 
"%

"
%






1 

" 
# %




$

$
.



 !6


"
" 66
"%

 





16

"&?


 

 66

@ 
 ""

" 

 
!&

"%


 !6




!
?

"


! 

!
 

( 9
" 
#


 
" &
1

" 

 


"
<
 
" 
# 

16 &




!
  &
6" 



9
16

1
 !2

6

  &

 
 6 &
.
%

16

!&
6



1
 
 


) 
 


6

%



 
 

6





 !
6

4


1
"


 



&





&

$

$


!
 

$

$

1
1
6
$

$

$

$
4

  &



 

1 
&
6

 



!
.

 




""
"



%
 
 




 %

 &
?
! 

!

6
 %
1 

(

$
@

!
 !6%





"

! 

!

&'() :

<
 

"
1
!


 ! 




 !
1
!
1






, + 
 1





!&





"%




&

 

"" 

1

 

!

 
!&
4>! 
 "6


1 
" 6
/ 

 &
!
6 

 

 



   !"%



!1


 
 

!

!
6 
 &

 




6
 
 6
 

6

2 
.



!

 1
6
 
 

 1 16




 

 
 1
6 %



 1


= 



!


 %

4







!
2 

 

!
/ 



!
"  " #  $% 

& 

'

 (%



!1

 
 

"" 



"&
! %




 

 




%

 


"%

  






 
 1%

6"

1 



6 


  

!
.

 
!1




!




6
 
 
6 
"


  

 )  



*(++' ( "!+   .
1


""



 


!1

 
 %


 











!
?
 &



"1

!

!






 
6


6%

6 

!%

&'() " 

"1&


!



!

6
" 






  &
6
 
!&
9
"




 
 

!

"






 

6

 

 
 
%
 

6


! %



" 6"



 +

.





1&


 
  

6

 %



 
 

" 
 "

= 


!



1
 

 



!&

"




6
" 





- %




 !6






 

 

" 6"



 +
.

 %

6

!
1&


!&




 

 1 

1 
"




!&
!

 
9
 &

  "
!&

"

 ! 


!
 
  6



! 

"

 




@""
%

1
!
"1

A?

,

A?

 $
"1 &
! 


%

16

1
 
 "


) 







6%

66
 
/"



6


6

6



!
9

 6
6 
1 ! 



!&



!

!
 
&

 = 
 %

6


 
4
   &
 




9


6" 



6








!

&


 4

 



1
6 
&
 

6"

 



 

 6

2 
9

%
 
"


&'()4
(

$%
  


"



1
1


 %




&
 
0
%

1
  

6 
!1
 %

 
 

!

6 
 

 .
1



!
 
!1%

"
"


!
1
&
6 29.05.2024 (MANISHA BATRA)


JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned Yes Whether reportable Yes