Harmohan Singh Advocate v. Sukhdyal Singh Grewal And ORS.





   
    

 !"##$ %&'(% ) *( +++

& - &./.

)/0(1%2) *(& 3%2% ,( &.  +++

.4 ,.
 
   55555 &*/ 61!"7&&/ % 8)

&9 7&)/ 2)(%&'%89 &,( 4 &

.4 ,.#%  :"4%&,  7& %;6 &) *(89 && .4 ,.<% 
   

 ./ ,&.4

4 &&'%

%*&

,%, #=#==< &  4..

    /.

 <8  )

,&"=8  (% *%&(  .  4

%;/

/&,.

##
,3%.3 % ) *( & 3%283(

2 %9 *6 ( %22 > 22%  2 *%2(

&.

2/ ( .3 3)',%.% ,?%/&83(%2.

2%, &)/0(1%2) *(& 3%28

% ,#8& .4 ,#(

87% '(% ) *(8 % ,<8 .4 ,  <  (

8  %   %* 9  ) *(  & 3%28  % ,  8 .4 ,    (

 %&  . .    %  ) *(  & 3%2  3( %.  )', %&'

&?%/&) (/8 % ,8& .4 ,(

8 .( %/*(, &   *(%.6

4&9

/ .

2&,( 4%&,

.3(

* *,(&/*(,( 4%4 &60

< 84 &(

8'9  % %442

 / &@

 /2  .

*;/*'

, ( .%9/& ,( . %'

  '%  61  % ,"& .4 ,  #  ( .  %442

  3%.

.,& *21 % 

*,& %62 .8,( /&,9

& A %'

2/.

 ,(%,,( ;/*'

,% 

:, ,    %'

  '%  61  % ,  #   *  .

,  

.( *(21 .4/, 9%2 '.% ,& %62 .83%. ,

%22 & 
'4/* .& &8 / .

2&,( "4 &(%.

/&* ,(%,

34&9  . & &@

 /2  8,( /&,(%.  4,  6/,,4%..%;/*'

, %'

% ,# ..

&,     ,( .  4&4.

  61  2 / .

2  &  ,(  4 &  ./ 
,3/26 %44&4& ,&

 & &@

 /2  %.

&!

 !"#$%$&'()**)+* &,-#&.$/$$+(&'$$)-#$%)+-#$ 01$&')+2%-#$%3)*$43#$-#$%%&115%)+3%)-)+24-#$,6%- (&5&-&+5*-&2$ -#$*6)-4$)-#$%+-#$&001),&-)+ &+5 0&%-5  %    )-*  3+  (-)+  &+'  3)-#6-  3&)-)+2  %  -#$ '$-$%()+&-)+ &+5-#$%76$*-)+/$-3$$+-#$0&%-)$*4(&8$ *6,#%'$%%2).$*6,#96'2($+-&*)-(&5-#)+8 )-4#&.)+2 %$2&%'-*6,#&'()**)+*

!"#$+$.$%&96'2($+-)*0%+6+,$'6+'$%*6/ *$,-)+ !& '$,%$$*#&11/$'%&3+60)+&,,%'&+,$3)-#-#$96'2($+-&+' -#$'$,%$$*#&11/$&%-#$'&-$+3#),#-#$96'2($+-3&* 0%+6+,$'B $  /24 &/.%2,( .4&9  & %2.,( . '% & /6,,(%, , . ,6

* ,( /&,,4%..%

%'

'% 61%4%&,1 ,.42 *. %,( &8,( .4&9 . 21%  %62 % 8,(/.89 .,. /&,,4%..%;/*'

, %'

% 61 '

% . % 6 .% '% %,&1 ,. 

, 6.

&9%,  .

.& *%&'% 612 /&, 4%&%#<,( &

,(%44&9%2%&

%.6 23!

C#$0%.)*)+* %'$%;

61$ 

&*%$0%'6,$'

&/.$40%.)'$ %&96'2($+-+&'()**)+4/6-+-&*& (&--$% %)2#-%&-#$%&*&(&--$% ')*,%$-)+ -#$,6%- "#$%$-#$'$ $+'&+-*#&.$%&)*$'/9$,-)+3#),#2--#$ .$%5%- -#$,&*$4)-)*+-0%0$%&+'96*-) )$'-$<$%,)*$ -#)*')*,%$-)+#$3%'*&5=&+'&8$*6,#&+%'$% &+'=*#3-#&--#$03$%6+'$%-#$%61$)*')*,%$-)+&%5&+' ,&++-/$,1&)($'&*(&--$% %)2#-#)*03$%)*+--/$ $<$%,)*$'3#$%$-#$,&*$)+.1.$*76$*-)+3#),#,&++-/$ ,+.$+)$+-15-%)$'+(-)+6+'$%-#)*%61$B  %& '% 1& 9% , .% %,,

*

3(

(& *(,213

*( /&, ../% /&,,4%..% ;/*'

, %'

% ,# , )'

,( 4 ,.%&

%.6 23!

D#E >& ,/& .( % ,#)/0(1%2) *( & 3%2 . ,'% 61( '4 &. %2216/, .,(&/*(( .%22

&%243 &%,,& 13(.

43 &,'%0 ./ (%'

..,& *21/ .,61,( ,( "

% ,.F DE *&

,  %,   #=#==<  ./*(,  ,  6 &

  61  ,(

42% 3%.%22 21

/, /& 4&6%, 4&

*.

> 22& % ) *(& 3%2% ,( %& ,(

/,% ,.

%  , % ,#,,( , 

/,   %22 %*&

,.

4&6%, 4&

*.3 4

*8 ,(

/,% ,.8 % ,8(%% 1 %&% ,&% .4%& ,2

  %,( &8  

/,&    ,(  > 22  (%  6

%44 % ( 3%.% *%.,( 9 &%22

(%&* ,( .,%,

%.& 4& ,%,   & % ) *(& 3%28, .,%,&%,,(%, .,%* D<E )',%.% ,?%/&3 3,( , .,%,&(%.%2& %1 :4   % ,    )',  %&'

&  ?%/&  ) (/8  1 ,  % ,(

/,% ,,( %*&

,,.

22 :"4%&,

4&

*.) G/ 2218/,,(&

/,% ,.8 21 (%.

%'

/,  ,( %*&

,3( %.3 ,(& *%&,,(

,( &8,(  .1 ,,4&9

/,  ,( %*&

, ../ (8%'

  %2 /,,(&

/,% ,. /2 ,(%9 6

'% .%.%'% %, &,( /&,4%&,

/2%&21

 3( H .)',%.% ,?%/&8% ,(

/,% ,% 3 3 ,( , .,%,&8%& .,& *21 ',( F % 8 DE -%2

,1% 2 *%2 ,1%'

61 % ,#,(&/*(( .%,,& 1 .%2./ &.

/.

(%22 *&/ ,(%,

&,( *(,,%'

, ' 3%.3 %,,& 1 &( /24& ;/

*(,,(

/,% ,
, .%2. ,(%, %,,& 1, :, , ,(%%2& %16

*&% , % ,#8(%

61( '  / &.,% *%'/,

.8 , 61 3,(%,,( . ,%..

'42 %.(%.6

,&

4&;

61,(

&"42% % .% ,1% 2 *%2 ,1%'

% , #,(&/*(( .%,,& 1 .1 ,,6 &'

61,( /&,3(

4%&,

.%& ,2 %,(

)'

,( 6.

&9%,  .'% 61,(

23 &  /&,  %&  9 &1  %4,  %   %&  3&,(1    &   3 ,(  .,& * %44&9%2( %& %./ &!

-)*5$--/$$*-&/1)*#$'3#$-#$%-#$$<$,6-&+-*3$%$ #&.)+2&+5%)2#-)+-#$0%0$%-5*&*-0&**&-)-1$)+ &.6%

-#$01&)+-)

6+'$%-#$&2%$$($+-)+76$*-)+")-#-#$#$10

$.)'$+,$4)-)*-/$$*-&/1)*#$'-#&--#$53$%$,(0$-$+-- $<$,6-$-#$&2%$$($+--*$11&+'+15-#$+-#$%)2#- -#$ 01&)+-)

3)11,($)+-0),-6%$B A .1 ,% ,( 3(

((%.6

&1 ,21 /..

61,( /&,( 4&4 &,1 .; , /%'

21 4%&

%&14&4 &,1 ,( % ,.% 3%.6

*/.

%.%3 *(/.



*218  4%&,   (%.  6



  %' *  ,(  2 *%2  (

&.  )/ ,  &  .4

&&'%

,( %*&

,3%. 61,(  %2..

0.

4..

 3(

( % ,6  ,(/,4%&,  >( &,( 4&4 &,1

.4/, .2 *%221./6;

,,4%&,  & , .1 ,% ,( &%.4

,3(

( ., &'

61,( /&, =
, .%2.,6  ,

,(%,,( %*&

,,.

22,( (/.

. #=#==<( ./ ,3%.  ##
,3%. %, &%4 

> %6/,

1 %&.I/  2 ,%, .%'

G/  2%3% % % ,(/.83/2& G/ %;/

 %, &,( 4%&,

.2 %,(

 #
       

        



     

!  "   

   "

  ## 
!8

&4& ,%,     & &  @

 /2       (%.  6

 '%  .  4 &  ,( ;/*'

,8%'

 (%. ,6 / G/ 9 %28 %&% 4.

. (%.

%2& %16

/..

%,2 *,( %&2

&8%/,(& ,1,( %,,& 13((%  .,%, ,   ,%

* %22  %'

 8 . / /. (%22 42 %,(%,./ (%'

/2 ,(%9 6

'%

61( '% /&,( &,(%, .% 43 &%,,& 1(%6


9

3,( '/2,

*%;/

:42%

%&2

&8 %'

 %22 21'% % , # % ,6 .%

G/ 9 %28 %&% 4.

 ## ?

*

3,( ,,%2 ,1% ,.% 

.83(

'%,, .. '42

% '/2, ,& %62 .%& 83( 4%..

& &8 ,3%.3 4%&,,( /&, ,,4%..%

/ & & &@

 /2   ,( .%22 %'

 

% ,# , ,(&/*(( .*

&%243 & %,,& 13(

( .%2. ,(%9 6

 # ) G/ 2218 *&/ , & & '% /, &'

.%'

8,( .4  86

* 9 % 1'

,8

.'


 

     

   J%*/,,K # >(

4&, &.2 %24%4 &.'%16 %223 ,.

;/*'

,L .  >( &,6 &&

4&, &.& ,L < >( &,( ;/*'

,.(/26 4&,  .,L