← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2572/2018dismissed

City Mri Centre Pvt Ltd & ANR v. Amarjeet Singh & ORS

2019-02-21Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary14 pages

   



  ! "#  

$ 

    

 

          %#&'(%))()((

    !  "  # $! "   %   ! " &

  $' !  "  #  '  ! "   ( % ! "   )'% # ! " ! &  ***** ()((* 

+   & "  ,-,../,0!

 1  

  !2 1!# 1 

 " ,3& 4  5 1 6  & 78 9"!,:;3 6&  <"<91  # #    .-/../,-

   1    

  

   !  2 1!  # 1  

&

1 

!1   '

 &&"     " ,3& " & 1  =    "  1 #

&

 +  

    #  

    

    

   6

9

     /3/3.//>!#"#     &&" &1=  !2 1 /3/3.//>

 # "   1 

   & 

&&     /./3.//: ?  &    #  1   

 &

"  &    #     "   /./3.//: #  @  A  #

& 

"   

      ""                #&   &      "     ,>/>.//:!  #  

        # 1   #       !"       &,!0.!;>B+=

 "

 + &     ""  & 

  C  8 &  #     &

 &

&

# 

  " &   #     

 

 &  1  !#"    &1  & "  #   & " "  

  C  #&        "    " 

    #       1     "

!  &    " "  & "# &&" "   8

&  #

 #     1       6

 

9   

   1 "   #  $      #      

  # "

 #        

        & B3//+=

 # &!/3/3.//>& 

&,.   

+ /./3./,B!

 # @ " " " 1 4  1 

1    1   "



  C  #   

&

#   #       #       

   #

&

   " & 

   # 1 1  " &  

  C   &   

 1   ? &  #

 &  2 #  # &  1  

 

= , D 

  &  &  " & 

  C  !     

  !

 & EF

. D 

  "  " & " &  

EF  3 D 

  

1  # " " "&  

EF  > D   1 &  ""  #

 &4  5 1 6  & 7 9"!,:;3  1 1  EF  0 D 

 " #"    

   &&  EF  B   &  "  #    1  1        "  &   

" " +   

  !2 1!  "   &" " " " #    "  "  "    &

=  &

 

  

"  1   # 1    #  "  1  4#

! & 

#     &

,

   " &    

 

&

1 

# 1   



  !2 1!    .-/../,-   & !

 1 &  1 

=   

  "

       1  

 1 #   

  #  

& 1  =  2  

1  

 1 #

  

    "  " ! &

1 1   2  & !       "  

&   $  &      &

   " & &    "        "   &          &        

>1 &   

 1 #9#      

  ! & C 

 $  & 

    &

 

" &  #&   #   1 A  "  &   "

1   1  " &    #     

  C   C  &  

   " #       !          #

&&&

" & 

 #          1 " #

&

 C       A "

1    #

 

! & " ,363969& 8 1

 1    "!,:>:6&  < "<9!    "  #A      @  



C   1    &     

 

" 1  &    #

& "&"

    #

& # & 

#     "1             &          #&  &  #!  "&"   1

  " !1   & 1 &   

  

! D=,= 

 D=.=4          #

  #  &   

 !  &   !  #   1        2   !       !#  

  " ! & "

1   &  

 &

 1 && " "   "'

 1 # #    =  &    &  "  ,36396969 &     "!  &     " &   

"

     & 2 '

"&   "-  ./!)01 .

) !2

 2 *

$ 3 43 4$" & &  & "   #  " ,36,9&  " 

C &  &  " A      &" "&"   @

 

  1 &   " 8  " 1    "

1  $    "   "    & 4 <1 

   5 ) "60 "7"1/!  . "7"1

3,4 3 2 84+$  1#     "   &   

  &    &   

   &     !    #

  &    

 # ""     "1     " "1  #&&" "  

  "

&        &    4 <1  

      )1   .   !1 0  /! ""

0 "7 1!3 $ 94,)1   

  1  #        ,-,../,0 .-/../,-!  1  

 1 #1      C  ! +,3& "& 1  =  1   



! 

"  &     1 

"

#  &

  

 + 8@?=,1  

  C 

#  1    " "       6

9!%2=B!689! " ! #$!

 " =./='!2 1 &

#&@  3,!0//+=

 

 &  #   "  .& 

   1 "   &  # "&"   "  ./&  #  "&"  1  1

   !"

 

        " " #"# "

 1     &  & 

! "  

""

   1    !  C  &         

1  "=#

 1    #

& 

 C     

 &  " 1  "  #A

  "&"      

            

& 1     

  " &  1    #    & 1  ! "1 " #

    1 " &    && " #

""   "1     1 "

  

" "1  # &&" " & " "  &   "

! D=, D=.!  "&"    

 !      A  " "    &  " 

&#" 1 #

&

""   & 

  "   

  &  )0 .( 8/!!0  "  "7 1!* + ,

*7:





*;- .0 "7/!) 15 " 

(+

   ;1< 5) "60/! 1!0

.) "60 "7 1!

3,4  3 2 84

" 

   " & #  "    & 

 &   &    #    "     1    @  

  1        &   

 1 #1        

"    

  & #  1  "      

8@ =,!

   /3/3.//>!

  C   !%2=B!689! " !  #$! " =./='!2 1!#  



,&   & 3,!0//+= 

                ,-  &          G          " " 

#  &         &        @  @  

&,.  4#

"      @       &  0    !      "   ,,

 .  "    # 1 

"1 H  ,,  

= G,, A &.

 1        1 #  "   & & 

       1 "  &          "   

"  " &    & 

   H A   

&   #    

  & "   @ " &" 8@?=,! 

""

    1    A & !   1 

  "

  &&

 " #"# "

 1 " 8@?= ,! &   !1 "     &  & &&

       "  "&" !"

 1 

    " # "

 A   " "

  "

 &%2=B!689!  " ! #$!

 " =./='!2 1!#  



 

1      8@?=,A    1   

@ ,0.;>BC&!    &  & 1  A   & 4 <1 

   )1  . !1 0 '!3);=1 4 &    

 =&"! )1  . !1 0 '!" 3);=1 4! 1   1 & "=#

"  ""      1  && 

1  &   

$   "  

       

 

!   &      "           1  "

   

  " &  #&   "

1   

  " &    

   

" !

 !8@?=,#   @ " 1      8  1 & 1     A & ! " & & !   1 

"

!  1 ! "   "   

"

         

 & " ,36396969&  " 1

"  # " ,36396969& " 

= G63969  

  &

  "                 

  ==== 69  " &   1  &!

69   & # ""  I   ""      1     1 "

I 6"9       "   "    1    #  &&" " &  " "  &  "!   1 H  "&"      " ,3& "  06 9     "  "

  #  "

 1 &  " "  & 

"!# &&" "      0 69       

  C  &     &   +1  # !#

 &1  & "  #  & " " &    

     &    #& & 1  # 6 >1 &   

 1 #9

       & 

 A 

 1   1 

=    #    #     #

& " "      & 

     # "   

  2 1 %   D=, D=.!       "    #     # 

    1     "  "

   "

1 &  " "  & "# &&" "    

"

 1  

   "  "  "       &  " " 

   "

 1   "  "

 &  " "  & "# &&" "    &

"  "

= @  & D=, D=.

  && "   @

    " 1 

  #"    1     1       !      "   &"   " " "  & " !  &&"    =   = A      "  " #       "  "

   "

 1

F1 "  1

     &"&           "      " 

   "    &      &" " 1  1 2 '

"&   "-

.'!" 6

9 &  1 "& "

 " &  "

"  #&     "# 

  &&"  A & !   #       &" "&"   @

     1 &  

  " 4#

!#"  & #          &1="  619 6"9&  "

" 1   !  1   " " " !  1 " &  !   "       

  1="  !619 6"9&  "" 1 $  A1

 # # $   & &" #  #   & $ #    "    

 " ! "  1   "       

   " & 1   # &    &  #&    

1   # 1  1 & "  &

"   " "  & 1    &  %:!0

8 ;!

/!1 5>;.

1;=

"7 " 1

3,43 2 84* ;6 8> !01 0;5 /!);1 "7 1> ;1

343 2 84

* . ;8/!/ 5 ?>;.

1 "7 1!

+3,43 2 849,$ "! 50

/!/ 5 ?>;.

1

34(9 

 &  & 4 <1 

   5

) "60'!" 6

9

   " &   #  "    " & #   <" 6

9!  !&   &      &   &

   ""  & &

    

        & 1     

  # 

&

  1      

 1 " # & 1   

  ! " 

&  =     &

  "  !

"  1#&

 #" # #     

 #

" 

  &  !1   

   

  &

. !## &    #&    & 4  !#"#   # 1 4 <1 

 #      & 4    

& 

   

" !  " &   &     ! "&"    1 "     & 

  # 1@"

1            & 1     &

" "  & 1    &  ;- .

0 "7/!) 15 " 

4(+

"    = @ 

" &  &     # 1@  &  "  ;1< 5) "60'! " 6

9!  # "  1 #1



= GA!"    &  " & 

  

 " &    6

9# 

#       &1 &

" !      1                       & " ,36396969& " 

& 

  1 &   ""  & !  &        & "

+ ,36396969 & "&  &    &

 H A  4 <1  

       % 0.7  ;8!0 "  /! 7;!!

"%;"68

43 4 +* "&" 1

 &  & 

 1  &   #  "   "

& # <& #  <1    (  @  &  & # 1 & 

  # 1  " !# & 1    =     '  

 1 #

#    "  "   

" &  "  "  

"

 1      !



& #

  &" &  &  

11

" 1 #1  1 4 <1 

  

 "7;!

"

18 ;.1=1

"( .

72 8< 1) "60*3

,4$ )+   #  @ " 

   " # 

   & " "

& &&"     #     &  "   & 

 "  " #"

 & & " 1 #1

   

"

 1       ! & 

      ,-,../,0!

 1  

  !2 1   .-/../,-

   1  

  

   !  2 1!  #"  "   &

&

" 1   @ " &

   "  (  1  

,

   ""      #         "

 #

&&  #  

" & ! "

  &   

   =   @()((A   

$  ;76

!-0 D   $ + 

J +( D 

1 J +(