High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2645/2017dismissed

Mohinder Kumar v. Gurnam Singh

2017-04-20Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh9 pages

!"#"

$"%"

$ "

$&' () *

"+*

,#-+ !

.!". "-.

" ##### !". "-.

&'" ( ")

* %+ ,'-

./01 2%

* - 2% & &

+" 3 -" 4 51"

" &%

& 2

" %

"& &" "

& " 2% %" "

" 2 " && !20 ,,0. 2%

7 "

" ,, ,,,7/ " " , +, ,,,7/ %

7 "

. &

" "

& " "

" 8

:2% ,0 2%

(

&* -!

1 !$ ) " &

:2% ,0 &

; "%

&" &&"

" 2%

& & & &

:2% ,0 6

& & <&%</=%$&

& < & = 3 &" " 2

" 2% % &

7 "

&& &

//""

" &

& &"" &%2 &, ,0

" & "

& 2%

) &% " & " 2"

0 - 1& &

+" "

" &%"',> %

& 0 3 & "

&%&

2 "

2%&

&& "

&% &

% & "

"9 ?

&&%

2 2% 8 52&

!"#$& &"

&"& % " 6 %

&% 2< %&%6 29"

&& %

2% "&&

9% & .& " " && %" " &&

9%"" %" " 9

2 &9 6 & "

. "

"" 2 . %"

2 & "

"" 2 2 2%& &" &%

:2% ,0 " " & 2%

" 2&

&" & & <&%</=%

< 2 ""

&6 &% " %

2"&% & ""

7 "

" &%"',> % +

%&&

"&2

A ( &% &2" & && 2 & 2% " &%"',> %)

2. "

% &&

< 2 ""

) "% 2& "

&& & 2 "

&8 ; 2

& < "

2 "" %B

& " 2 &&%

(

&* -!

1!$ 6

%&5 2

% &

& "

& ) 4'( )(*(+" %,& !-. /

8 52& . (

+" 2

/ #12 3 4335 5 $" 5 6 5"5" 7 3' 5"5 "3 "6 * " 5"*5 "3 5"5 * 8 " "3"*5(6 5"5""

""*5 5"5 "34 "6 $ * ""*( 5""" 8 '"3 " 6 ' * * 3 5" 7 5 " (*"6(""3" 8 5 "*6 * *"* * " * *( " 35 * 555 "3 ( 5 95 6 ( 55 *3""3" "3 3 "3 " " : * 6 "'(335 5 *"'5"*5 ' 6 "6 " '(" ("3 5 5' * * 5 "3 (( 5 * 3"5""3 )5 6 *" " 6" 7 8 " * "3 ;5 5 6 5 * 36 ""( (( ( ( * * ' 6 73"* " "36 (55 *"' "3 5( ( 8 5" 3 * 6 55* .

* " 5" 5 * :<35 5 6" 3* 8 :""6 "6 "6 " " * !"

!"'"*" ;*5*5 " 3""355 -6 5"5" 5"6 7 *'*"(;5 " " 5 "3

!"* 6 "53"5"*"( * 5 "3 =" "*"6;5 >5"3 5 ' *33 ' 5 "33:""3 ""3/"335 * 35 ' 7 * " 6 3 * ' ' ("* "*6 5"*" *" *"6;5 '" (;5 " " 865 "6 * 6 !"' * 5*(55" 5 "3

"# $%&%$ ?"$6 !""" '@ 15"( 5"A "6 *'""5"* " 8 35"* " :""3 "* "3" 56 *3"( ( "(3""3 * 5 "* " * 5 6*(6 ' " '"* ' "*"3" 56 * : * * 5 "* "6 * 6 3 * '"3"" * 5 6 "* 5 ( * ( ( '5 55 *" * 5 "* 6 "3 "* " 6 ( * *6 * 8 " 5"* " '5 5" 6 (" * 3 335 5 3" :5( * "' *5 "( " !""5"*" * *

* 8 *5 " 6 * 6 5"3 * " !" "* ;*5"' **5 "6 3"*6 : 5 *"*5 6;5 6 "6 *6 *?(!"

''! # $& ( % "' 5 " B 3 335 5 6 "'" *" 5"*"""3* 7 " "3( 8 ""3 "3 335 5 5"*" 5 * 3" : 5 "3 *5 " ;*5" * !" 6 5" A 3 335 5 "" *"(3 " 6 *" C 5"3"5"*"(* " 6 * *"("*" 3335 5 "' !"" 7 ' *5 ""*5"*" * 8 5"3 "*5 5"* ""3 35*( *( 5 "3 " 6" 3* 3 3" 5"* "1 '

& "

&2&

" " %&" " &"

%.&

&%2%

&&2 2&& % <

" & &&% &%

& " % > ) 4D 5* "3

! ,5

A 8 52& .(2

/ 0-'"3" 33 55 6"6 *'("' " 56 * !" ""' " : * "*"3"" 76 ("* 8 *5 " : 5 *6 ?(!"' " ";*5" 8 "* 5"*"( * 5" 6 * 8 3" 55 * * ( * "* * !" 7 5"3"5"*"""3* 3 * ?(!"'"** ; 5 ** 5 " > * * * 6 *6 "5" C &&%

4= ("'* 5-*57" 9335 %

&!! / 8 52& .( &

. D""

+" 3

CA= &

& 2&

2 9 2 & & 2

&<"2 "

2& %<

" &% ,

:2% ,0

& " E2

,+ " &%"',> %6

&<" %

%""

" &%"

',> %

& " 2" & &&2%

/ *

% &

2..&

&% && ""

&"" "

2 &"" &

2" & && .&

&%"',>

% ""

& " &

2 "

6 2 &%2 2% & &&

" &

"& 8 & &2

" && 2

& 2 < %2% & " %) &2 &%2 2% & && %" *

& ) & " 2

% &&& % %

"34 / 5!". "-.

6 !

$ 78'84.3&9 :;& ( %;

78'843 4'&< %;