High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/1965/2025dismissed

Tejbir Singh Malik v. M/S Hanuman Trading Company And ANR

2025-01-16Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu4 pages

!"#$!%&'&"() !"#$!%&'&"() !"#$!%&'&"() !"#$!%&'&"()** ** ** ** !+,&-.&(/01&2 ***! & &"(!- '

3!-'4' 5'(46(-$&(/ "67(8($(" 0!- *** !'7"($!( '

)

) 9: * . . .

9: * . . .

9: * . . . -!'!( ) -*'0;!!-<0-,=$;"% !#"- 0!7! & &"(!-* . . =* . . =* . . =* . . =* -!'!( 7! & &"(0',!!(#&1!$4($!-.!% &"(>>?-!$@& 0 .!% &"( A "# 0! 0- &8 /-&2 .4-2'0 .(0& = #"- '0"- = B 0! **.*.*C #"- -('#!- "# %-&6&(1 %"671&( 55= & 1!$ ' B!+,&- .&(/0 1&2 3'5 5' (46( -$&(/ "67(8 ($ (" 0!-C 4($!- .!% &"( A "# 0! !/" &,1!(' -46!( '% =AA #"-'0"- =B% C =#-"6 0! "4- "#1!-(!$4$&%&1/&' - !&-' 1''=(&7 #"-'0"- =B = " 0! "4- "#%"67! !( +4-&'$&% &"( .4,&;&'&"(.#&$"(=&' -&% &($* *

"( !($' 0 1!-(!$ =(&7 0'("+4-&'$&% &"( " !( !- &( 0!%"671&( 4($!-.!% &"(A"# 0!% ' 0!%0!D4! &(D4!' &"(@'7-!'!( !$ 4(+, &"(1(2=.#&$"(=&' -&% &($* ( '477"- "# 0! ,";! %"( !( &"(= 1!-(!$ %"4('!1 #"- 0! 7! & &"(!- 0' -!1&!$ 47"( &+"8 .0(2- &'0- 3'* 0! . &+"8 .0(2- &'0- 3'* 0! .

&+"8 .0(2- &'0- 3'* 0! .

&+"8 .0(2- &'0- 3'* 0! . ! "# ! "# ! "# ! "# -1-

0-20($ ($ (" 0!- 0-20($ ($ (" 0!- 0-20($ ($ (" 0!- 0-20($ ($ (" 0!-= .:

-1* "*A>5= $!%&$!$ "( = .:

-1* "*A>5= $!%&$!$ "( *** *** *** *** * !-$1!-(!$ %"4('!1 #"- 0!7! & &"(!-($ 7!-4'!$ 0! 77!-,""2* >*

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

& &"(!-&'(" @-!= ' " @0 -! 0! %"( !( ' "# !E6&( &"( ' @!11 ' %-"'' !E6&( &"(* "(%!$!$18= -&1&'7!($&(/#"-$!#!(%!!;&$!(%!5#&(1 -/46!( 'H 04'=&('4%0'%!(-&"= 0!7"&( "#+4-&'$&% &"(=&#-&'!$= %( ,! %"('&$!-!$ ,8 1!-(!$ = (&7 = ' 7!- 1@= &(%14$&(/ .!% &"( > !

"# 0! "$! "# -&6&(1 -"%!$4-!= ? I.!% &"( !

"# 0!**.*.J* -2-

?* ;!( 0! %'! 1@ &+"8 .0(2- &'0-C' %'! '47- %& !$,81!-(!$ %"4('!1 #"- 0! 7! & &"(!- &' 1'" (" 0!17#41 #"- 0! #"11"@&(/-!'"(')

& ( 0! %& !$ %'!= (" "77"- 4(& 8 @' /&;!( " %"671&(( 577!11( 0!-!&( " 2! (8 -!6!$&1 ' !7'H1!-(!$ %"(%14$!$ 0! -&1&(0' !H($ 7-"%!!$!$ "$&'%0-/! 0!%%4'!$$!'7& ! 0!#% 0 & @''466"('%'!=,4 &( 0!7-!'!( %'!= 0!-! &' (" '4%0 %"(%14'&"( -!%"-$!$ ,8 1!-(!$ = &11$ !*

&& 7- 0 = &( 0! %& !$ %'!="(C,1! 0! .47-!6!

"4- 0$ 7''!$ "-$!-' @0&1! !E!-%&'&(/ !E - "-$&(-8 7"@!-' 4($!- - &%1! > "# 0!

"(' & 4 &"( ($ 7- &%41-18 ",'!-;!$ 0 F@! %1-&#8 0 0&'"-$!-0',!!(7''!$&(;&!@"# 0! 7!%41&-#% '($%&-%46' (%!'"# 0!%'!($@&11 (" ,! -! !$'7-!%!$!( *G* A* 7- 0 = 0!-! -! 6&E!$ D4!' &"(' "# #% ' ($ 1@ &(;"1;!$ &( 0! 7-!'!( %'!H 0!-!#"-!= 0&' "4- &' (" &(%1&(!$ " %%!7 0!7-8!-"#7! & &"(!-* * (;&!@"# 0!,";!= 0!-!&'(""7 &"(=!E%!7 "$&'6&'' 0!7! & &"(* *

-$!-!$%%"-$&(/18* * "@!;!-= & &' %1-&#&!$ 0 ,";! ",'!-; &"(' ,! (" %"(' -4!$ ' ( !E7-!''&"( "# "7&(&"( "( 6!-& ' "# 0! %"671&( 7!($&(/,!#"-!1!-(!$ =&((86((!-* -3-

!($&(/771&% &"( '

=&#(8='011' ($$&'7"'!$"##* ** ** ** **

. .

41'! 0& K0! 0!-'7!2&(/5-!'"(!$ K0! 0!-'7!2&(/5-!'"(!$ K0! 0!-'7!2&(/5-!'"(!$ K0! 0!-'7!2&(/5-!'"(!$ ) !'

!' 5 "

" K0! 0!--!7"- ,1!

K0! 0!--!7"- ,1!

K0! 0!--!7"- ,1! ) !'

!' 5 "

" -4-