← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2834/2014allowed

Sarla Devi v. Naveen Johar

2017-05-23Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari9 pages



        

 !"#"$%& ' 

    

    (% )*(  +++,*

      





 

  

 

++,* -   !        

    "#       

$$% & 



'    

   () (* $(+*, - ./ "#  &   0"# 



  0 0 0 1

-1  0 -

" "#

 

!   0   *  

1   

1  

 +) (2 +22.   -1  '3   0 -

 "

 

  #1  0

"    !  4  

    

-1  0 -  

0 0

"3

  +.((56 !

0 "  "#  & 

"     0 

 

0

0   # "1

   0

    #

!        



     

    

!! "#

     $ 

    

 !   1 0  %#

    &'"#

     !



 0    

  !    &       

#

        1

 8+9)& !

0 

"



 #   

 0   

 +) : 3" ;" 



 

 +2*2  ,   

  <

</    3

1     40 0 1

  

 0 " =+(> # $  #    

 #    0   1          0

(+ (2 +22%  =   )9((56   *$).

  *?.956   .+$*   .?)?

 ?$((561  

    

  +9 +$ $((9

!   

4            1  #  

+$  

  "  0# 

 1 "

#0    

!   0 # ).((560   -  *%$ .( 0 "          0  # 

 #          1  0    #             ).((56  0  



    1  1  0     0

 1

  +9 () $((2

!    0  1    (9 (?

$(+(       *

0   0 0   1  # 





+$   "

0 1 0 

       8 

6 0 

 -1         

      1            

 -1   0 -



1  



0  1 !       0       "

-1  0 -

  

1  

!  

1

"  "#  "1

-1  '3

  @ A0 :-

"#0# 

  '

0        

  

 -1       0 -   "#0# 

    - 0 

"   

0      #"        0# 

 

 # "

    01 

 0 

 '

0    

 -1  0 



 6-1  0 -

 "#

     

" "#

  

    "

       

  0     1  1

"

 

  31   ( ) *

 %+  *

    

  

 



 

"1

  0

1

  31 0 

 0

0 0  

  # B  -1   

 0    0 1

 0  "



 @    :-     0       1    

    

   0 "#     0 0"#

! & 

 !  0 "   &   4      0    "

  

              " 

  61     3

      

  0  1   1   0    <0

"# C  7  &   

 



4#   1  31

'+./0"

+"$12,/ 

 

 

  0  

0"3

1



 

    

!

31

  , *

 $#"

 %- . (  

0 4 

 

1

  

   0  0  1

1



" 0



"1

 

8+9)&

 # 0 1

 0 "      D 

"  

 

 0 1

"1

  

 ! "

  E+.

'    8+9 ) & &0 

  

     0         

         

    

0 "

     8+9   )  & !   #    F   # "   1#     

        "# 0#    0 

          "#  

  F  1

  0 "#         D 

"    "#  

" 1 B 

   

#   & 

 

 

 !   



#      0  

 

     

 "#14  1



! 1 1#0" "#

 

 # #   "  8  -1" "#     

 1

0   '+29) A$+(,/ '

"   1  1"# 

/

F       1 #F 10 "

1     

B  "

0 "

 1"#      1  ,/  



   1

     

 '         "

  

# 

  "

         7    0  < ,/ !     -    1- 11  1    0          

-   

  

  "

'

" #  



"1 1   

B "

0 "



         3"   

'$((+ A))+,/ '     

  

       

    

"1

  

  "

! "

  

#

0  0"#     

 1

0  ,/   "

   7 ## 0  #

 0

"

4"

 1  #     "

7  1 1 "    -   

   "

 0" "    

   #  "        B     

1 0    "

       0  ,/ 



  

@  GC  '+29$ A*)$ ,/

!       0  

 #  C   &     " "    

1 1

 0 !  00    0   1 3+"$12 ,/ 0  1 # " 0

-1  0 -  "

 

0  1    0   4   0 



0

' 3

/+"$12 ,/ 0        - 

1 

1 0     0     E% @    

" 1  

    8+9$& &

1  

0     "

 1   

 

0     40   0   

0   -   

 #       

 "                    "



 :-    # 

 

0 "



                #  "  

! 

 #           , #/   "#    8+9$,$/ #   





"#

   

 !  -   F   #F  

  "

  "# 

! 6      

1  

0 "

 1    

         0   "

! - F1# 

&  # 0   F -

  8+9$,)/ F  #"  1#

## 0   F #  #

    , #/  

 "1   0    40     # "     #    

  

 "1   

 0     8+9$,)/

 " 

    

 

 

 1               

  0   

 

  

   

 

   0  "   

         "#    

 !   

             

1        8+9)&  #

    0  

0    "

 1    

!       3

 <    ,/      8  +9    )

 1  

1"

 

 

 

0  

! "

     

 "    

3

 "   #    

    #"  

 "

  !    &     &   

    

 

 "  



"   

   "

"#       4   0 "

    &      "#  &  

3   

 1  

0

  *    "

 !  



"

.

0 #1

"#  &     1 

0  

 #  

D    

  0

$) (.

$(+%  4++,*5