High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4934/2000dismissed

(O&M)Chhotu Ram v. Hem Raj

2017-09-26Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry11 pages

""#$ % & '&# ($)* +

"&#,""

- "& .

%&$"

..// '&# &)* "& .

%& !

&)""

+ 0 &&# 1 & 2/+ 0 &3#"&4&+ 0 &". &

67#$&+ 0

&"..// 5

&-,,&+& 0 2 " &"

+ 0

&"&. 5

& ) 04#.+ 0 &4#&0"# + 0

&&. 8 5

&#&9",+ 0

&&. 8 5

&"6'&$+ 0 &"../

5 855

&. "

&+ 0 &"../

5 8855

::::

1; "

$$ )# ,$ + 5 "// 9

. , / 0

,#/& ../

""#$2// ./8 + &<+% "6#/9;

(&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ; 0

//$ /&

< ( & ,&$ // 2 " &,& " &

.&.&;2 ""($)* 8< " ;+ ""#$> # ,&$ //+, &/.2& & ; #/;

&, 2 ""#9, && ?

// "($)* (

.#"2& ,&$ //(20&+" ""&2 &/,&$ // "& 0 .;$ <8 "

@9;2; 9 6 & 5 #&"& "&$

,$# 29.

9;($)(&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ;

/; 3". "./2/" 0&($) * ""#$9 $

" // "?

//2//

, &/.2& & ; < 3",&$ //.&0

.#&/# "&#,"

/&9 &&"( )1 /($)* &A# "&9 && &/0"

.#"( )1 / & & &

""#$(20&+""#$ #/ 9&0

/"#," #$9& $. 2& $ =/ $/;+

2& , .#9/ " 2 2..& B ,/ " /; (

2..&

,""#$..& < .& &$"+ "&9 &&/

"&#,"&, =%3" &, /&2& 0 9 62 ""&$&6C& # &#&

+""#$

..&+"& &+"&9 && .& >.&, "

$#& ,"&9 & .&

,+ ",&$ // $/;1/ 0 ,"2>$ &

," "0

.& +"&9 &&. 2& 3"&/0 .& "2& >& # &!

! "!# !$

% '($% )

! % $ % % &%

& &!%% ) *%% ! "!#% & % %%%% +,'-$ ($.

!% !&!%% % "!#/0 //;+($)*

/ ../

# &

& 2 " "5

&9 & 9 &"#&

#9&

*# ,+"

,&"(20&+"$2&) " ,&# ""#&"

,&" "0&& & /)#&

3"& &+($)* $0 ../

9 &"#9&

*# ,+$9/ &$6 ,"2& #/ "#&1 &" #9&

*# ,+"&9 &&/

/ ../

&$6 ," 2& #/ "#&#& ,".&

,9 &"#9&

*# ,+$9/+""#$2#$$ "

/ 9) .&;

""2& / 9/9

# & " &9 & + B> # ",&$ //2

.# 5 2 #&"&

/ """#$"& && "./

9&"&%&$" &, ,.&$

&$"#"& 3"9)

/ 9;""#$2& # 99;

".& & 9 $.&&

/ " " #/ " " - 52

""9) "09

/ &$& " ;& &$ " "

2 &0 #. "9) &

&$ ,"

$9#

/ , "2& 5$;9

"""#$ ..& "#& <3" 2 )#&

/ , 9) (20&+ ""# $

..& 2 .& >.&-& +"$0 ../

& ,

> .&.&

,B>.&.&

,2&

<8 9) 2&

/ &.& 0 $ " ,

8 .&.&

, &..&

,"0

0 /9/ "

/+" /& #9&

*# , $ " 2& #/ " #& 0

)# ,$ ../

/ 9;""#$2/

9;/&

/ &

*# ,+% "6#/2"

/, , / & ""# $ "

/ "

. + 2"

" 2 2"

" $#. &

/&,#$

5"0"& /& # / &".& / ,"-&

# / &". &""#$"$ //2 ,#9$

& /,&$ //2 .& 9 &"&9 &&

/; .;2.& 2"

" #/ 9>$ 9;" &9 &&

3"2& &A# 9&,

&, + "& &+"2& 9

.&/# "//$ /&+"& &&

" & & "./ +"& &+",&$ // 9 1"".& 2&# &$ 6" $2" ,&$ //2> # +"& &+",&$ //

0 ../

9 &"#9&

*# ,29&& 9; $ 0 (&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ; %&$" & .&;

" .&

,+ "& &+

9 # " (&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ; 3"&9 &&"$

" "& " + /& # / & ($ ) * "

#9$ "&/ ,& 9;"&9 && & ;& ,"

" $$09/.&.&;( #&"&#9$ "& /,&$ // 2 #/;.& 9 &"&9 && ." .;"& 2 & & /2 &#& (" #&"&#9$ " ""#$" ../ &.&$

(&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ;6 ,& & "./ ($)* 0

8< ""#$" /> #

0 +

$ ;

9 " 0&//"& / #$ "//$ " .&.&;

.#($)*

, "2& . 9;"&9 && "2" "." .; ",&$ //"9 >"

B>3" &9 && 2 0 ( 6 2 " .& #& "2 " ,&$ 9>"

// #&"&+&

, ")# ,$ .

9; " #9&

*# , "2 " " . &

& "

"&9 &"#9&

*# ,+&9 &"E &..// #& // #&"&+"& /,&$ //"9 .&

9;" # / &"&. 9 &$5 "

& #$ +"&

"&,#$ /& # / &". &

5 "

&,& +

90+".& 0.& "2&

""9 &.& 90 & , ;& ," $$09/ .&.&; .& (&; =&9 0/.$ ./ -

1# /

,,#/ <+"// / & &"

& ,"

"/ @9# /

,> .2 "".&0 #.&$

& 3" .&.&; # 0 " (&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ; //" &.;$ $ (&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ;5 "& &"(&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ;> # 0; "& &3" // / > #"/ & &

/; 5 0 2 " &

+ " &9 && " /; #

""#$$6//&& ,$ & &"./

.# ($)* 5 +""#$2 "2 & ".&.&;(2$&/;//&

, ",&$ 2#/

"2"""#$" $ &.;$ "(&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ; .#& "&" & #$ + @ .;$ (&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ; >$ " # &$ "& ,/""#$ " ,& & &"

//$ & ,"($)* 52" & & 9/& ,"""#$2 "2 & "./ //" ;(" /;,& & &"& ,"# &"//$ /&3"& &/"2& 2 &A# 9&, 5 0 2 "

$ 90+ "/ ""2&

& , ;& ," " $$09/.&.&; &"

& $ + "& &+"2& 2 &A# 9&, !

" #

5 "

&. + # ""& 9/#9& " & & ".//# "//$ /&& # &! -

1 & % & %!& % ! $ $ 2

% %

& %3

% & % %$& $!&&$ % 1 && $% % 2 $ !%% ! 0 5 /& &$"&

, " &

/#"2 "

.& & .&$

+ " .&.&; #/ 9 & && (&; =&9 0/.$ ./ - 1# /

,,#/ <+ / .&0

&"$.& #&5

.#"""#$

../;(&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ; &.&$

& & "./ ($)* 3"& &+ "& " #9$

# / &". &"",&$ 2

# $ 6 9/ 9;9"".&

.#" . , "2& +../

2 #9$ 9 &"#9&

*# ,"

,&"#9&

*# ,+ "

,&""/ " / 6&& & /)#&

3"& &+../

/ 9 &"#9&

*# ,+$9/ ../

# & "- 2

/ &> /#

," $.

".&

,9 &""

,&"#&3"../

2//2 3"& &+"& "#9$

"/& # / % ( ) * %

( ) * %

3"& "#9$

"/& # / (&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ; /; , ;2"

" 0/.

" #&9 & 3" ,&$

, " &9 & /# 2 92 ""#$ ($)* 5 ".&

,+(&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ;&%&$" 2& &A# 9

$./ .&; %

# / &". & #/ . # ;.

"2"$

"&9 &&3"&9 &&,0 &.

""#$(20&+""#$ / ..& 9 &"&9 &&3"&9 && &>$

,//" #$

,"0

.& 9 &"

$+". .6 2& 3"& &+"& "#9$

/& # /

E&"& & 90+"& "&0

. +"$

2 " 8 +

!"#$"

../"9

/ 9;%&$" +"9&"&

""#$ %&$"

/ # 6 , /& "" 9/# 2 & &

/./9& ,8 + &<+=&9 B+% "6#/ "9 & &@//$ /& < 0;

&, 2 ""#9, && 8

1""#&"0

"# +

,"#

9# ".& "#&"&9 &&" , 0 2& 2 "

&. " &

.&.&; < 9) ../ "09

-& # / & " ..// #/

& ;

$ #/&,#$ "2"2" #&& )# ,$ . 9;" #&9/2&&& # %&$" 9&"& ""#$5"9 # " ""#$" ,& & &"./ A# ($ )* 0

,&$ // 8< ""#$" / > # 4 &/%2& & ;+?

//+5 $ ;1

0 ""#$" ../ "(&; =&9 0/.$ #"& ; .&$

& &"./ ($)* ""#$"

/ "& . ",& $# 3". "./ 2/ / 0& "($)*

E#&"& 0 2 " /

$ 2"

"& 9 ,&. +"

../

9# 9

5 0 2 "& + "& . & & & "

#&&

, && 0 9;"#&9/2 ,#/& ../

%& -&, #$9& ../

"0 9

/ $./

#9A# & & .&; &. // " ../

. &$ 90

)# ,$ "# "#$ '

( . )*&%*&+,-&./0123+&., 1&4 &,3

)*&%*&++&- +%.56& &,3