← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2812/2017dismissed

Bal Kishan & ANR v. M/S Surbhi Vatika (P) Limited

2023-01-09Mr. Justice Deepak Gupta11 pages



   



   



!

"

!#$% &'

( )*$ + , *!

!- !

*$ .

 !$

/$ #

)#$2* /3 45 67- . 8 !-! 0"

96 0:

)  ,  $ !" 

         , 

'

:



 

     

 ! "# $%& ' ! ()*+     

,  ,-    .    /01//1 )

%#    #2 %  

.   1013/1

   & 2 %4  %#

  % 

  /  .   # 4   %

 .5   4/1 (1 7//) 7*3  7/36 )!%  .72&/3

  ' & 4&# 8%. 9  2 %

.  :   ;

55

.3% .  5 

.)1,/1,   .  % .   1,/1,  % 5  5    % 5   #5.    .4 % # 4 *  5

55.4 5

 # 5

. .    %    .

<.  

5 %   6 5# 4           .

      1//1

.4

55 

5 

. 1 =# 4     5 # ₹0 1116    # . 

 # /1

 %

     #        .

    5    

     > 5       *   3         .

5  

 # 4    "4  %>  4   %#

5   % . 4  %  5 %#     4

#    

?  

5  

         &            1013/1     

 %    4 1 1 /1

* //1

₹ @ 0 1116  5   .    

 4

    % ₹)/*1116  4

 4         %        //13/1       .     1013/1 4

4   %#     #    5 .   /01//1 )%#  . . 5     % 4 

4 

5   . 5   #   4   =

       . .

#  5

   

 .%

.   

 5    . 5 

 4    



5

55 .A4          #  

5.

. 

<. /

    . . 

 4

   ## #

     # 4 

%> 5   

5.

 5 .

%     & 

. 

  4 

 



.    ) 

. %       #%# 4#    

  

         %#           

            #     4

5    .

 #  . #4

 

. 5 .  

5    4

 #   

 5

   #%

          



         



4 #     #      # 4.#    > .5    %  

5%#

  4

4   %   

          &                       

 #

     . .    #5           #    %             .     %  %#

5  5 

  4  #% # 

#

 

%5

#  5   .

 

  /01//1 ) 0 7  5 4

    %        4 4%#    

      4   .    <. *

( A  

  

%5

   

      

  

1

 *    

.  

    

%

 .   %   .

?  .  #5  "4  4

5        %   .

5%

 .   5,%

 ., %       /!   5   C 

  



 



  

 



       

   

         

            

   

 

                         



  =

 %  4  . 5  5  #    % 4 

4  . .%

 . 

  %#    ;4    %

4   %#   %#    #

/ 

 % =

 

 5      =

 % 

      &#   <)!

#  8D



9

 4 

5 

.  )5  47/1 (1 7//)  7*3D 7/36

  8%. 9  2 %?



5

55 %      1  5

55

3% .  )1,/1,  

. ;3% .   1,/1,  % 5 

0 % .   5 .4 .5

58

   5  <. 3

%      4

 

%#%   5

5 5 4   #5

5

55

   #   4          

# 5

 #    .5

5  

 # 





 1 =#

5

55 



. 1 =#

%> 5   A4 .  



  1 =#

.  5 % .  %

5  5

55 % 



      .A    #5    

 #

  %         5

5  5   #      4  5 1//1

* 1 /1 0.  4  ₹0 1116 5   4   .    01 DE.     #

 %# # 5  

5

55

4   # #   A4 .   %



  

% #5   .

.  %#5 . 

#     8



 ..   > #  #

  # .  5  #

     # 4  #A4 .      #

   5

 #

# 5 . 

#   .  

%  #  A # 

5

 

#4 %   

₹ 1116   

    ₹ 1116 5 

% % %# # #. 5 ₹ 111116 #%#4# <.  

 =    #    #      #     #4 .

  .

 5

55%# 5 F9 



525 # 5 A  5      #% .

. #     4    #₹ /1116  A     

    5

  # 4  5

55

#

%  = #

 %#%

A #    #     #  

 %  %# #   ; .   4

5     

  

% % %# #   8

4   > #%    

 55 . % 

 5



*  %     



 

   there is an immense variety of structures, which could be styled as buildings. However, it is not possible to say that every enclosure of brick, stone work or mud walls covered in by a roof irrespective of the purpose for which it is used and let, is a building within the meaning of the Rent Act.

3 A 

 !"#$%&

'  ",%

 5  &   4  

  .    

     *    

 #<

55 & (

7HHAAA (

A4   =

   5      

4 4 5    

   .

 5 A4 %    C <.  

 !"#     $  %%  

       





 

 

 



     & !'     

   



 

        & 

!' 

 $  %% #   

  

       



!'

     

 (   



$  %%!)  

 (    #   $  % %

#     

  

      #   !

!*              +*#      

   

   



 



, -

!)     , -



          ##  

     -



 





#   , -



!)  &   

   

 

      -

  -

   &  

 -

 

 

 #   

  <. )

-

!'

 

      

 

  ##  

 

    

    !'     

 

     





  

  

, -

    

!) # -

 



#  

 

   



         $  % %!'          

     & 

!'   &   

#

   

              

 

!

A ('!&)*+))' # !,%&-#$ & .,/ .011 / ''0

 ",% 

 5 &      '

2!'!.!(/   C ' .  '

 "#$%&

' 



      

   

 

"



  !'( 

.  , -



    





  

/   /  

$  %"-  0 "   .  " 122!3 

 <. 0

  . /     /   

    

 

   !. 

     .   

         



!)

 

        

              

"!

24 .  > .5  ",% 

 5 & 

 94<  949 

'

3 4    5   =

 4 >    .

   4 %   ,55 ,      / !! $< 5#!&  '  (3)A4

%    .

      4

5  .4 ,55 , 5

5   

  55    

  

    

55  %

 .B  

4    5 4 

5  . 4,55 , ># .      

.     5%

  %    5   #%

 .  4

 

  ,55 ,

) A (  '!&)  *  +))  '     #2!  '!  .!(/          5 4

   . #.4

 . 5

 #   5

4

5  .B 8 .< 5

 #

( ",% 

 5 &     .   

.

<. (

 5      ) #    

            

      



!)

        

/   /  

"!'  

      !

0 7 % "#   4 I 5

 #   

 .J4

    5 I%

 .J    #<

55 & (

4 

   '

2! !.!(/4  $< 5#!

& '  (3) 4 

  ,% !2! !.!(/;B 8 .< 5

 # ( 

4 

 ('!&)*+))'./#2! !.!(/%

  5F5

 #G

 "# 

5# 5     # %    >#5 A

5   5

 #    5

 # %

 5

4 5 4

  %

 .

% %     

  

( A    .

     '

2!

!.!(/('!&)*+))'./#2! !.!(/ ,%!2! !.!(/ 5    



%       5  . 5    

  4  4   %

 .  

%

/1 A    5 

 5     

<.  1

. 5     % 4 

  %        4    #              5#   %

  4

   

#    %       %#        A   

  4   =

 5   .A 

        4       #    .      

% #   5

% #  5   

         .

.   >  

% #%

  .

.    

%   #  

4   5

55     A



% #       

#  5 #     4 .

  % #5 5

 9 



525# 5

 5  4 5     

4 

 5

55

5 %

 . / A 4   

 5 .   

%#     #2 %  %#  A

%  .

#    5  # 4

 "#  // 

  

  %#

 !#$% &'

(

4,  5

   

   6   .C K 67  % C K 67 <.