High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3220/2016dismissed

M/S Ozone Spa Private Limited v. M/S Ambience Hospitality Private Limited

2016-05-23Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh13 pages

!"#$%#&'""(

'&& ! !"# # $

% &'( )

! "# $# %& %'("#)*#+,-(.# +!(%(")+,-( ## (#(")*#+,-(.# *( (/0# )+,-( ))))) "(

'&& !*$ ##"(/- ("" (

+1%2 (/ +##("#,#"3 *#$#,##) 4 ( .

/ ("#-(# #" *-# 5 6#( +#(# ( -#"#(# +-) ,#/ 8 +-9 .( #!# " ##."- 2 "(" #" ( ## *-# :(/(( ;(

" <,#-# +-) 7= ,#/ 8 +-9) ># ,#-# ## ! (!# ("-#/ # (#("/.(/ . ( ! # # "( (

= ( ,#- ( !( = +1%2(%2+-"(

"(?#. (# #"#(" ( +#("#("((",(1(- !((&2 @

6 (/ # #

- (/ ># .

(, ("" (# . %(##--#.# (## #A($ .

#- %(#((""(!#-("/. !",) - # #

- ("" -# / ( (" (#( # (--(- .# ,## 6#( +#(# (-#"#(#+-) (#(# ("" "#.$"

# ( < "# "( ( ("" # (#(" -# (# ( -## !( #/ (#( (# ("" #("(## (#B *#!#"("/# ,#-( !( =) # ((#(#-"(

((&2 @

6 (/ # #

- (/ ># .

(, ("" (# . (##--#.# (## #( !) .

#- (#((""(!#-("/. !",) - # #

- ("" -# / ( (" (#( # (--(- .# ,## 6#( +#(# (-#"#(#+-) +#(# ("" "#.$"

# ( < "# A( ( ("" # (#(" -# (# ( -## !( #/ (#( (# ("" #("(## (#B 6# ( ((-"( "() (/ # ( # " ( #, # ( # " #C#-#. "( ( # /( (!!(-##(#"(# "(6 ,# ( # , # "( . (

# /() #(/ " (""1-( # ( "( .## (, ".# (/ -# ## ,(# " .(" "( (

=( ,#- ( ! (

# /(#(--(-.# -"( "( -(! ! #" 5 D D ( ,# " ( 5 D D +1 %2D (> ## ,(-( !# #- (

= = D +1 %2 # +,-( ## ,(-(# !# ( ( (#" "/ ( = = D

+1 %2= .( (# # "( -(!#((# (1(--# ,## "( 6# ( ###,> (#(# -"( ( #" ( ## :9" $"

# :# *-#7 +-6#!.((# (, ## 6! (#(#-"(# ( !) !( (("(/ +#(" #(" ( -# (, ("(/ (>

# (#-#(# # (# -# ( "-#-(" #(" +1%25+6

( ( .# , !- ( ( ( ("(/ (# # +#( ( ( (#-#( # -# # +#("#("-!## 3#-'%*# ) 3#- 3E ( ( 3#- 3$ E( ) ( (-F#-- # (#(# -# ( .(#,## - ("" ##-# +#("#("6 # () - (!($#,##'- ! # (( # !!#) E ("( :# *- *- ") '(("( 0 *( % (( ) G *3=H - (!(

! :9" *!0#>(A0$%E

3(#) G #,#" D? $ ( ((/(>" 0 *# < #)*(( )

G* #,#"=57"#(-

( (" "(- ! +""( (( # +!( (0*!( ($,#( ) +A= " ( ( # -#-!, (/ $"

#:# ((,# (#(#-) #" ##*-# +- ## #"(("#-(#*-#5 +- # (# (#(# (! ( . "/ ( #"" (""/ #!#/ +##("#,#"3 *#$#,##)4 (,# #! (

6 # ( ( - # ( (!# # ( ( ! . (# -(## ( (#(#-"() " (, !( +#(" #("("(/-# .

! (("(/ #(((-( -# (-!!-6# ( ((#!#"(#(#:

!!#-(#6#(( 0 <( ( ( ( ) G #,#" ) .

# # " +-#(-!"(# ((#("-

(()# -/(#,#"."#""-#-!-#/ .# ##-# (#,## +-#"

6 " (#,#".#""1-# ##-#.# - ,## +-+--# -")# -(( () "" . "/ (! ( # . (# # F#-#/ "(. " ) -(/) ( #! .# !## ( # +#("

#("#"/# (.(" "((.# ( "#(#"#/ ## -!/(># - ,#-#(,(#"("*-# +-6# !# ( # # .# # !(# ( +#(" #(" -# ,#-# -# .

#- 1-"#,"/ ("" .# # ##-# ( (/H(-# " ( ( ## -( #, (/ (,(( # -# !

! # :

!!#-(# 6#( ( -( ( .

# .( ( -"( # ( ! ,## ( # - (/((.

#- .(# ( #-(# (+#(" #("(# -#-!(-) # ((/ -#

,#-# (,# (#-()# ( "/ (#.# (,#-# ((-( +#("#("6#( ((/( !. (# # ( +#(" #(" -( # ( 1-"

##-# ( -# #-(""/ ,# # ( ( F#.# (,#-# ((/#,># ,## +--( (+#(6 #-#)

( ! :9" *! 6#(( # E!('(( 0+(/( . /) #,#"

G=)'I+""(:(!#"6-0*'6:!H#(-A( ) +6

*D = + !## !( / -" # +#(" #("##I !((.

"(##"#(" . ( /( # ,#. -"( "( ) (!#"/)1-. (# .

#- "# ! (1#

D H ( ( , # ! "( # "#!("/ . ( # /() F# .# ( ,#-# ( ( -( # -# / ( +#(" #("1# "(#-(( "(" !># ,#-# #( +-6(##)## (# "("-"( ! #"# (("#-(# ,#-# ( # #- "( ( ! D) . -/ -# +#(" #(" .# ( .(" 2.(" "( # -( # ## ("" ,#-# -# ) "(.

""/ ###( + #/1-"#,"/-!-# (! 6 (, (-" (#) (2> ( !-#/-" (# -"/) +#("#("-!## 3#-'% *# ) %## +#() 3#- 3E ( ) ( 3#-3$E( )##I !((.

"( (

=) ! .

( 1# D) # "#(". ( # /(. G D D * ( ( ,#- ( ! # --) .(" .".(" "(6# "( ## "( -(# (/ -"( C"("#( !-,# # ( !##1#/ "(#>,#-# ( / (># - ,## +- " ##)(#F/(#/ )##(## #, (/ -,#-# "/ ( .

-" #" (

= ## ,#-# ### #- "( #"" D:.,)# ) ( ! # :

!!#-(# 6#( ( -( ( # - (##!#"(-#-!(-) # ((/ -# ,#-## "" ' -# ) # # # (" .#

!!#-(#6#(( -( (6 (#-() -# # # (-!!- ( ("#-(# #" / -# # #(" "( ( ! . (# -(# ( - (#(# ( -F"/ (-# ,#-# #" ( #(- ##2"(" C <( ( # !(#(#(" ( !( .#"" (, +#( ("#-(# #" *-#5 +#(#(-#"#(#+-.( #!# # # (( = ( #- ( ") F

#".&2 @=<,(# (# -(-(- (" #!!,(" / / -# #- !(- # (( !( -# (#( # ( (" -# #-"/ / (

! *!#

*! " -"(#! -# #- !(- .

#- -( ( (" "# (# # (#(" (#( .#"" (, ( . (" (" .# # (!(/"# ( "# -# #- !(- 6

! !! " #$ % & '

() $ )! *** + ,*) *! " ( ( # -# #- !(- (# ( -(- ( (# -( ( #"(# -# #- !(- "## (# ( (#(-((" (- ("#

-+(#("-"(#(-! (#!#(##"" -("

5<, -# "(" ( (((-/ ( ( ((-# ,#-##,("# #",( (#(# -"( + -!

#$.!%/ 0,+11+1 2,34+ 5 6$7 +1161 3 * # ( ( #/ ## (((#(#-"(.

#- !( -(- ("" ((( !# ! -(-( - (#(#-"(-#,# -(--#6.#"" # (/ # ( ( ,## ## - ("" # (##

."F# #!# 06## ,#-#).

F#(/C(""/ -(#(#

( "(,## ( # - (/ ( ( # #"().

## -(" (""(!( ( #-(#/(#( 7 -# #-F# ( (-( #-#. (# #( -.

#(##.

"(" (-!"(# ( (-!!#(- ! "(( (-(( 2"(# (, .(!"/(#/ # / (! (!( (#

( #,( '*A(( ( /.#"""#(" # ,#- (.("/# ( -"( # "( #"

( ( ,# ( # !.# (- ( /("(.

""/ ( (-/(> # -! +#(

#"(-"( (#(##"

#,("( # -" - / (,# ( (#( (# -# # . (#)###""(!# .

( -"(# #"( (("". (# - ( / ( "( -" "# "( # -" ( "# ( ,(# #:("/9 A(. < "()H <##),"=) )(( 7"(# A(( ;"( ((#- (#("(( !#-""((" (# (#-#(" "(# # "("( ( 6 (! -# ! "( ( -(# ( - ( ( ! - ( / ! ##"//,# (- (6(!#""># # -(#"#/ - (-"( #"((.#"" #(- (! -#(#6!(/(!

2 # # ##J-# (- (-"( # -("

%"(/( #(- ( #- ((-(- (#( "( ( ("" .# # (#(" !(#? ,#-# (#(")1(!#(# # (- (#(#("

#. (# ( ((#. "(" (( (#, "("((-# -! ( # ## (-# ( #(/" (((

() ( -!"# #"( ! /( # #"()(# (#(("(-F"/ # (/ " ( ( (.(" ( (-# -! "" --#(" F# # .

# # - (##(#("6 ##) 1F##).

(- (-#-!(-(- (#1# ># # (#(#B +"(#(# (( ."!(>#,# (# ( #/) ( (## "("(-# -!("( ( #" (((( -!"# #"(! /(# #"() ((# (# ( (" ( -F"/ # (.(" ( (-# -! "" )# #,-(#)

"#(( "" (""!#-# -# .

#(-"(#. (# -#,( -(#"#/ (("" # (( ! - ( / (""-# # -! # (( #-(# ""H #

")#(( G) ""9 ##-#-(# 1# ## "(# # "("(( "" )(>( (

((- #"" (#(# (! (#( -! ( -" 6 3 E( #( ( ( , + (#( ' !)

G=) *!

(, (/ -# "".

(#.(

#"/ ( -# #- !(- ( ! (" ,# -(# () ## (,# #((# #!# -(/) ## (#(#.# (## -#((( (

/(/#,># -"( # #(""(+ ##

(,# #((((# !##F#( ( ###( ,#-# -# / -## ##(() ##-(#,(/(,(( # -# !.

( ( "#:

!!#-(#6#(( -( (- !(.# (,#-# #### "#(" +#("#("/#,># *-#5 +->(/ -# # ""#""--"# (#("-# <,#:

!!#-(#6#(( -( ()# ( " ( ,#-# (#(")1(!## # ((- ( #(#(" ! /-" ## ,#. (# (# ,#-# ((-( (+#(6,#. (,) ##-(# #,(/ (,(( # -# ! ! ("# .# (-F#--C" -( ("" ,#-# -# # -## +#("#(" 6'I+""(:(!#"6-9-( ():9" +1#(.F#G "#(( ((",( 1(- !(( "".&2

@ K'.

# L(#(#"#/J(## -1 ( ("#-(#-#5 +-#(# #)(""(- (#(#"#/ (, -# / - #I #) ( -( " -## +#( <, # # ( (#(# ( ! . (#) ( , # # # -,/ (#(# ( !) - .

-#,#" # # # ).#"" (("#-(#*-#5 +-) (#(#(#)# -!( ##-((" ( #-(#"//("#- ! "# -"(#!-("/ (/(-#("-#("B H ) ( ",( 1(- ! (( ) # -

(/ -&2 @K .""- #I1(!" 2(#("#(& # #"(# # ("#(#"##.

#- #,#(# -#!#("

-? ##!(#!#("#"(# #,-) #-#(" ((#) ## - (" # ) - #" -/? ### (#( # !(? #, #",-/ ( .## !(? , (!(/ !( ( () " (!##(# ( --#-# #-(?( ,#,#-#(-/!( ,/ -#(" ( .

( / (/ -# ( (# ,#-#("/ -# #-(- ##-# ( ,#-#-# #B ( (# ,(# -"("/ ( "( ## ( # F( ,#-# ## ! ( !# ("-#/#"#(" +#("#(" ) "(#(" (# "/"#

!'I+""(:(!#"6-9-( ( --"(#! ## !( .# ( ,#-# (

###"#(" +#(/#,># (#(# -"(# "()- # 6( #E!('9-( () .(((#(# ( ! -"( D (-/ ( ! ( ,# ( (/

# (# ---# (-/( ! #(## (-/( ! ("""/(#(## (--(-.# ,## +- " . 8.# (# (/ # # (/ -(-9 # *-# (-/ +-) .#"" ,# (#(# ( ! # -( ( # -,/ # (/!# ( #"/("("( (# ( ( *- ( # #" / "(" ( (# ( -( (#(#*-#5 +- + (#- # ):9" +1# 'I+""(:(!#"6-9-( ( (F.""- #I 1(!" 2(#("#(,#-#(-/!(# +-("#-(" *( :(/((1("" (((#:(/((1-(/-(!((*-# +-(".# ,#-# ((2*-#

*-# (/ @( ( # # ( #"# ( "( ("" ,#- !1-#(--(-.# ,## #-#B *2*-# *-# ,# (("(".

>,#-

#( (""("/ "") (#-## ( ("

+ -( "(# *-# +-"(,!( " #"(# ( - 1-"#, ##-# "" ,#-# ( ( # # ( #"# ( "( .

#- ,## +- ("#

,## *-# +-(1(!## "# (# "(# . # ( # E!( '9 -( ( ( 'I +"" ( :(!#"6-9-( ()6 #!/"

("#

.# #! (-- "( ## ( # F# .#

(,#-# ###"#(" +#( (/# -## #(##(#(#-# 6,#. .

( (#- #(,) ## !#) ## (#"(#(--# "/#!#(-

8$4"(#9