← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3087/2012dismissed

Baljit Kaur & ORS. v. Sukhminder Kaur & ORS.

2016-03-16Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

  

      

 !""#$%$&' (#)*+*  ,-$!. /( !)"(%  "!$!$&"( 0"(%/% 12!1/3)2$&4"(. /( !)"(%  "%5&4"&!% 



 ! "#$%&!&%' ("#)*!

 6)"!)"( "5(!"(%,# ,5 5"(%2 78" ,,9"4!%""!)"-/4:2"&!;  8"(""(("4!!)" "5(!"(%(&!;

 6)"!)"(!)"-/4:2"&!%)/,48"("5(!"4$&!)"$:"%!;

("%"&!'

($&4"(-$!1$&:)+4<# !"+ (!)"5"!$!$&"(%

( $!! ,+1"&$(4<# !"9$!)

(= ,$!1) (2 +4<# !"+ (("%5&4"&!% 

( !$&4"(1$&:)+4<# !"(

( 1 &4)"(+4<# !"+ (("%5&4"&!%> &4> ????? &%' ("

+,  @A>

( 7"(  $&  !)"  55,$# !$&  $%  (  $25," 4$&:  !)"  & 2"%   55,$# &!%  %  ("%5&4"&!  %>  &4  >  ,,9"4  %/8-"#!  !  ,,  -/%! "B#"5!$&%  %! &4%4$%5%"4   )"  5"!$!$&"(%  ("  ::($"<"4    !)"  (4"(  4 !"4  *+ 9)"("87!)" 55,$# !$&%""3$&:("%!( !$&!)" 55,$# !$&$,"4/&4"( 1"#!$&>> +) %8""& ,,9"4

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

&#"%+ & 55,$# !$&/&4"(1"#!$&>> 9 %$,"4&&8") , !)(""5"(%&%+& 2",7+1/3)2$&4"(. /(+ %5 ,1$&:) &4 %9$&4"(. /( )" ("2"&!$&"4 55,$# !$&9 %9$!)4( 9&872<$&: & 55,$# !$& (5("5&2"&!!)")" ($&:<$4"(4"(4 !"4!"(EAF7" (%+ & 55,$# !$&9 %$,"4 !!)"8")"%!1/3)2$&4"(. /( &4 %9$&4"( . /(  &  !)"  5("2$%"  !)  !)"  55,$# !$&  %""3$&:  9$!)4( 9 ,    !)" 55,$# !$&/&4"(1"#!$&>> 9 %&!%$:&"4+2/#),"%%!)"$(#&%"&!

9 %&!! 3"&!$%&,7 %5 ,1$&:)+9) ,,":"4,7) 4#25(2$%"4!)" 2 !!"(9$!)!)"4"#(""),4"(%)"(4"(4 !"4*+<$4"9)$#)!)" % $4  55,$# !$& ) % 8""&  ,,9"4+  ) % 8""& #) ,,"&:"4 $& !)"  5("%"&! ("<$%$&5"!$!$&

($&4"(-$!1$&:)+," (&"4#/&%", 55" ($&:&8") ,!)" 5"!$!$&"(A4"#(""),4"(%%/82$!%!) ! ,&:9$!)!)" 55,$# !$&%""3$&: ("%!( !$&!)" 55,$# !$&+ & 55,$# !$&%""3$&:#&4& !$&4", 7

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

( $!! ,+  ," (&"4  1"&$(  /&%",  %%$%!"4  87  (= ,$!

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

1 2  $ 30.

  3,  1/+,( 9)"("$&  $!  ) %  8""&  )",4  !) !  ( 9$!)4( 9 ,!)"%/$!( &7%/#) 55,$# !$&+!)"%! !"2"&!!)"5 (!7 #&#"(&"4  $%  ("C/$("4  !  8"  ("#(4"4+  $&  "%%"&#"  !)"  #/&%",  $%  &! #25"!"&!"<"&(2 3$&:!)"%! !"2"&!&)$%9& (!)"% 3" 8("<$!7+!)"( !$4"#$4"&4$#/,,"4/!87!)"&G8,"1/5("2"/(!$% "B!( #!"4)"("$&8",9'A H  

               

 

                



   

   

 

      

                 

 

       



   

      



    

  

         

      



     ! 

  

 

   "            #  

     



  

 7   ! 

    "      

              "     

   $ )"5("%"&!# %"$% %$2$, (3$&4+9)"("$&&5"(/% ,!)" %! !"2"&! !5 :"E!)"5 5"(83+9)$#)$%"B!( #!"4)"("$&8",9+$! $%!)"&,7!)"#/&%",9)) 42 4"!)"%! !"2"&! &4&!!)"5 (!7'A H%  

%&%' 

 

 %      

      

  

 (



   

  

   #    )      *+,+-  *+,+-  

   .)/ %011' %&%'

*++23$ 6)"&!)"% 2"<"(7#/&%",) % 55" ("4(!)"5"!$!$&"(% &4  2 4"  !)"  %! !"2"&!  !) !  )"  ) 4  &  $&%!(/#!$&%  !  9$!)4( 9  !)" 55,$# !$&+ < ,/ 8,"($:)!!)"("%5&4"&!%$&!)" 55,$# !$&/&4"( 1"#!$&  >>     ) %  8""&  ! 3"&  9 7  &4+  !)"("("+  ($:)!,7 %  !)" 55,$# !$&) %8""& ,,9"487("# ,,$&:!)"(4"(4 !"4)" $25/:&"4(4"(# &&!8"% $4!8"$,,": ,(5"(<"(%"+2/#),"%%9$!)/! -/($%4$#!$& )"("$%&2"($!$&!)"("<$%$&5"!$!$&)"% 2"%! &4% 4$%2$%%"4 ,+368(8  &%'  +,-6 "#)*!