High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/299/2014allowed

Harvinod Singh @ Vinod Singh v. Jagjivanjit Singh @ Bawa Singh & ORS

2015-12-24Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal13 pages

!" # $

% !& '( )*+, '( )*

"" & ,

!)-!

-"( )*+ !.!( )*!

' "*&

/ ' " 0$

!

""""

! "#

$% &'%(!)* + # % )*

&'%(!) '

%#%-).-( *

/

# $ !% ! %

'

( ) * +

,

- .

''

#$

, 4

,

&

( !0 ! 553 6 , (

&

% ( (

7 (

, ( #%$ (

8 9

:

;:

<

, #3$

&

, 6 7 (

, ( &

( (

!= ! 55

, ( (

(

9

!0 ! 553 #=$

( ,

, &, & (

#.$

(

,

*,& !!. , 9

, :( 8

7 (

, (

.

/

.

=

' : )

2 +

,

#0$ *

,

?

, : &

, ( 9 5 !% ! %

( ( , ( ( , : &

, (

553 4

, /(

& @& ' ( ! !% ! %

#2$

6

2 . !5 ! %

, 9 ,

, <

, , (

7 ( )

3+ &

=

(

& > *

, ( ( (

7 ( != ! 55 7 ( 6 !0 ! 553 &

7 ( (

#5$ 7 (

( 6

.

.

(

2 !3 550 2 !!

, : , (

553 &4 @

# !$ > ,

( !% ! % # $

7 ( (

, , ( != ! 55 6 !0 ! 553

, ( , 7 (

(

6 7 (

.

( 2 !!

@ B !3 550 2 !!

(

(

# $ !0 ! 553

, ( *

, (

( # %$ C

, (

, (

% (

9

&

,

:

& ,

9(

( :(

# 3$ &, , D # =$

& &

( ,

, 6 &

( :( (

&@

,

,, ,

,

&

9 ( ,

! )% 0 ! & )1

. !% -!# 0 )0

2. %3 )%

2+445365,5

& 7'! (( $ 1

%-/ +446685 - .

''

@ ,,

,

&

@

@ (

9 ,

,

& (

(

,

,

&

,,

,,

& ,

& ,

,

(

,

&

&@

( ,

,

@

&

,

,

# .$ D

,

>

& (

(

(

@

@

: -

,

@ &

&

( ,,

,

, &

( ,, ( (

,

9

,(

(

F ( @

4

:

8 F ( ,

@

,G & F

G

@

,

,

4

F

(

G @ ,,

&

6 9

@ 6

:

,

( , , , (

(

@

>

,

((

9 &

>

6

,

- .

''

( 6 ( 9

1 &''- % )%.1

" ) $ !- )% ) )% / +4423

2-13+5 7?& 6 ( (

, # 0$ 9

#%'

! ) )% )1

% '

%' )% /+4+283 2-1389 7?& 6

(

6 (

@ &

( 7

&, , &

6

(

, @

, &

@

( (

,, 3.

555

( ,,

!!

,,

(

, ,,,

, 6 &

(

,,,

(

&

&@

,

,

&

@

6 (

(

7?& 6

!' )%

' )% /+4+23 2-13:4,

# 2$ (

&

&

:

, ,

7?& 6

" 0 -)-! ) 0 - ) " %- 1

! ) #-# .'0 /+4,2+3 2-13:6;

, ,

@

# 5$ 7

4

,,,

, 9

,

( ,,,

(

G

,

,,,

- .

''

&

,

, 9 <-%" # - )% 1

= %!

)% )/ +44:23 2-1356, 7?& 6

%1-)(1

) -)(/+4462,3 2-1988 7 -

1

)0' )%

/2+44;38894

& 7'! (( $ 1

7 %-/+4462+3 2-1- ;55 )% +446 685

7 @

&

,

(

, ,,,

9 6

,

(

, , ,,,

,&( 6

@ >

@ @

(

6 ( @

&

! %1

- -) 1

)-) )%- / +44;2,3 2-13;,4 & ( , &

( & (

(

&

7?& 6

'-)%7'! 1

0 )-)(/+4423> ' ') 4459

- .

''

,

@

,:

(

, @ &

&@

,

4

@ &

7?& 6

,

=-

"1

= =-

"/2+4,36;/ '!' #!$ 9

, &

& ,

,

,

/

&--)(1

!/::82,3= +6

-)(? )&--)(1

#-)(2%-%3#" )% )/::52,3 2-1656 )&-7 ' )% 1

1)7 ' )% /+4462+3 2-13+5:

# $ >:

:

,

@

@ &

#$ (

1 4 !% ! %

'

( ) * +

- .

''

*,& 3 ! =

5

0

( 6