← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3273/2015dismissed

Hardev Singh v. Sukhdev Raj

2015-09-07Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih5 pages

  

      

 !"# $#%&'&()  *

!+$#,-&(./ 0#"&"&(#+ 1#+'2' -23/$#,!4 0#'5($#("  ) 6 7 -  77 +#'#(") +1&4!8-/!+9!: $,%!"#: +"/#5#"&"&(#+ ;;;

 </#"/#+ +#5+"#+'   =%!= 5!5#+' 9!8 ># !==?#$ " '##"/#42$.9#("@  >#+# #++#$""/#+#5+"#+'+("@ -  </#"/#+ "/# 42$.9#(" '/2=$ ># +#5+"#$ &( "/# $&.#'"@ ;;;

 77 +!= 1&$# +$#+ $!"#$  A

A: +#($#+#$ >8 #(" ("+==#+: 72$/&!(!: #,&%"&(   "/# 5#"&"&(#+ "#(!(" ?!' +$#+#$ +9 "/# $#9&'#$ 5+#9&'#' ( !%%2("   5#+'(!= (#%#''&"8   "/# +#'5($#(" =!($=+$ 55#!= 5+# #++#$ !.!&('""/#'!&$+$#+ !&=#$!($?!'$&'9&''#$,&$#42$.9#(" $!"#$  

/&'&'/?:"/#5#"&"&(#+"#(!("&'># +# "/&'%2+" ( !( #,&%"&( 5#"&"&(: &=#$ >8 "/# +#'5($#(" =!($=+$: #4#%"9#("   "/# 5#"&"&(#+ ?!' '2./": !' "/# =!($=+$ +#B2&+#$ "/# $#9&'#$ 5+#9&'#' + /&' 5#+'(!= 2'# !($ %%25!"&( !' !=' + /&' '( -/!9 -2($!+  " ?!' 9!&("!&(#$"/!"'( "/#=!($=+$?!'+2((&(.!>2'&(#''

 #9>+&$#+8 !($ "/# 5+#9&'#' &( /&' 5''#''&( ?!' &('2

&%&#(" " 9##" /&' >2'&(#'' +#B2&+#9#("' ': =!($=+$ ?!' !=' !''&'"&(. /&' '(: "/#8 >"/ &("#($ " #C5!($ "/#&+ >2'&(#'' !($: "/2': +#B2&+#$ "/# '/5 &( B2#'"&( + "/#&+ >(! &$#(##$ ( $# #(%#: &" ?!' 5=#!$#$: &("#+ !=&!: "/!" (#&"/#+ "/# '(   "/# +#'5($#(" ?!' #(.!.#$ &( !(8 >2'&(#''  #9>+&$#+8(+"/#5+#9&'#'&(/&'5''#''&(?!'&('2

&%&#(" "9##"/&'+#B2&+#9#("( !%":-/!9-2($!+?!'+2((&(.!  &( ! '/5 "/!" " +9#$ ! 5!+"   "/# '!9# >2&=$&(. /#+# ?!' 8#" !("/#+ '/5 "/!" ?!' %%25&#$ >8 !("/#+ "#(!(": ?/ ?!' %!++8&(. >2'&(#'' &( "/# (!9# !($ '"8=#  

!>>2.-/52+"/#+:"/#'/5"/!"?!'&(%%25!"&( "/# +#'5($#(" ?!' +#=#" " (# !9!( D29!+ !($: "/2': (##$ "/#+#'5($#("?!'("%(%#&,#$&(.$ !&"/ ( ! %('&$#+!"&(   "/# 9!""#+ &( &''2# !($ "/# #,&$#(%# ( +#%+$: =#!+(#$ #(" ("+==#+ !++&,#$ !" ! %(%=2'&( "/!" ( $2>" "/# '/5 "/!" ?!'#!+=&#+ %%25&#$ >8!("/#+"#(!(":&("/#(!9#!($'"8=# !>>2.-/5: /!$ !==#( ,!%!(" $2+&(. "/# 5#($#(%8   "/# 5+%##$&(.' ?#,#+:&"?!'5+,#$"/!""/#'!&$'/5!'!='"/!"?!'&( 5''#''&(   "/# =!($=+$: ?#+# '9!==#+ &( '&E# "/!( "/# $#9&'#$ 5+#9&'#' 2+"/#+: "/# $#9&'#$ 5+#9&'#' ?!' 9+# '2&"!>=# " "/# (!"2+#  >2'&(#''   "/# +#'5($#(" !($ /&' '( !+"&%2=!+=8: + &('"!==&(. >&..#+ 9!%/&(#' " +2( "/#

 >2'&(#'' '+#.!+$':=#""&(.2" "/#'/5"/!"?!'!=+#!$8 &( 5''#''&(   "/# +#'5($#("=!($=+$: &" ?!' %(%=2$#$ "/!"!9!(D29!+2+&/!$4&(#$=!($=+$-23/$#,!4!($ /&' '( -/!9 -2($!+ !' 5!+"(#+: 52+'2!(" " ! 5!+"(#+'/&5 $##$$!"#$F



C G %%+$&(.=8:"/##,&%"&( "/# 5#"&"&(#+?!'+$#+#$

#&(. !..+&#,#$ !.!&('" "/# '!&$ +$#+: 5#"&"&(#+ 5+# #++#$!(!55#!= 55#==!"#!2"/+&"8+#,&#?#$"/#9!""#+&( &''2#: #,&$#(%# ( +#%+$ !($ ( !( !(!=8'&' "/#+# : 2($ &"'#=  &( %(%2++#(%# ?&"/ "/# &($&(.' +#%+$#$ >8 "/# #(" ("+==#+('#B2#("=8:"/#!55#!=?!'$&'9&''#$ /!,#/#!+$=#!+(#$%2('#= +"/#5#"&"&(#+!($ 5#+2'#$"/#5!5#+>3 7#!+(#$ %2('#= + "/# 5#"&"&(#+ '&95=8 '##3' " +#&"#+!"# "/# '2>9&''&(' "/!" ?#+# !$,!(%#$ ># +# "/# %2+"' >#=? !($ +#4#%"#$ !

"#+ ! $2# !($ %95+#/#('&,# %('&$#+!"&("/#+!+.29#("?!'!$,!(%#$ ( ! $2# !($ "/2./"

2= %('&$#+!"&(   "/# 9!""#+&(&''2#:!9 "/#%('&$#+#$,&#?"/!""/#5#"&"&(&' =&!>=#">#$&'9&''#$ +"/#+#!'('"/!"!+#>#&(.+#%+$#$ /#+#&(!

"#+ ( '/+": "/# %!'# '#" 2" >8 "/# +#'5($#(" ?!' "/!""/#"#(!("#$5+#9&'#'?!'+#B2&+#$>8"/#+#'5($#(" + /&9'#= !'!=' +/&''(-/!9-2($!+:?/?!'#(.!.#$&( !(#9>+&$#+8>2'&(#''/#'/5"/!"?!'&(%%25!"&(

A "/# =!($=+$ !($ ?!' >#&(. 2'#$ + "/# '!&$ >2'&(#'' ?!' &('2

&%&#(""9##""/#&+.+?&(.>2'&(#''+#B2&+#9#("'/# +#'5($#("!($/&''(:?/?#+#4&("=8%($2%"&(."/#'!&$ >2'&(#'': &("#($#$ " #C5!($ "/#&+ >2'&(#'' ,#("2+# !($: "/2': +#B2&+#$ "/# $#9&'#$ 5+#9&'#' /# !%%99$!"&( &( "/#&+ 5''#''&( ?!' &('2

&%&#(": !' "/#+# ?!' ( '5!%# + '"+!.# .$':+!?9!"#+&!=!($ +"/#&+=!>2+"'&"!($ 5#+!"# "/# 9!%/&(#'  7!($=+$ -23/$#, !4 !55#!+#$ &( '255+"&(/&'%=!&9!'< !($5+,#$/&'%=!&9,#(:/&' '( -/!9 -2($!+ !55#!+#$ !' < !($ $#5'#$ &( ( 2(%#+"!&("#+9'"/!"/#$#'("?(!($5''#''!(8"/#+ 5+5#+"8 &( "/# '!9# 2+>!( !+#! !($ /!$ (" ,!%!"#$ !(8 '2%/ >2&=$&(.  42'" "/!": !=>&+ -&(./ < 2==8 %++>+!"#$ "/# %!'# '#" 2" >8 "/# +#'5($#(" !($ 5+,#$ "/!" "/# '(   "/# +#'5($#(" ?!' &($##$ #(.!.#$ &( !( #9>+&$#+8>2'&(#''&((# "/#'/5'&("/#&+5''#''&( !9!(D29!+2+&:"?/9"/#'/5"/!"?!'&(5''#''&(  =!($=+$?!'!==#.#$"/!,#>##(+#=#":!55#!+#$!'<A !($"#'"& &#$"/!"/#/!$(=84&(#$"/#=!($=+$&#-23/$#, !4 !' 5!+"(#+: ,&$# 5!+"(#+'/&5 $##$ $!"#$ F



: C G/#'/5"/!"/!$ !==#(,!%!("$2+&(."/#5#($#(%8   "/# #,&%"&( 5#"&"&(: !' +#%+$#$ >8 >"/ "/# %2+"': ?!' '9!==#+ &( '&E# "/!( "/# $#9&'#$ 5+#9&'#' !($ ?!' (" '2&"!>=# #&"/#+ " "/# =!($=+$: #,#( !' +#.!+$' /&' >2'&(#'' (##$' ##$=#'' " !''#+": (%# "/# +#'5($#("=!($=+$ /!$

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

  "/##(" %"#"&"&(>#&(. $#,&$ 9#+&"&'!%%+$&(.=8$&'9&''#$ -#5"#9>#+ :

!4!(  +2(!==&  2$.#