High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1329/2020allowed

Balvir Singh Garcha v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-05-16Mr. Justice Namit Kumar27 pages

!"#$

&'( )

& ,(

&''( ) *#-

&'''( ) *

!"# $% &

)

&'( ) * %#*

&( ) * #

&'( ) * +

&''( ) *#+$$* # + " &'''( ) *#+$1*

& ,( # $ &

# $)+ &'2( ) *%# $*

&2( ) * 1% *

+ $, -+. % /&

' ) # $ &2'( ) * 1+*

# $% /&

/0+'(

) # $)

, 34,

5,6 ,

1 2"3) %' +4/5678)7668) 59::)7;<: 7;8=7:7: 2

) %' +4/656:)6868)=6<5 <56>7:7: +4/58>=>/7:75 2" ) 2 ) +4/58>;/7:7: 2 ) ) 2? $) 6 +4/7668)5678 59::7:7: 2 !) 5 7 +4/58>;/7:7: 2@ ) / # $ +4/<56>)=6<5)6868) 656:)7;<:)7;8=7:7: +4/58>=>7:75 ,6 , 7

/ 3

)

A 3 B ! ) ! +4 56787:7: 7 77> + ? ! 3 A 07>:97:58% C/;' 7;577:58% C/5:')3 $ 5 7 6/ ! " # $)

% , # $'3 3 $

$ # $ B 3

3 3 $ ! $ $

B +

# $ 6 )3

) 3! 3 # $ $ !"# $ % /&

$ )

& # $3 , !"# $

)58>8- % , 58>8

-' 3 # $

$ 58>8

# $ 58>8

) $ ) B +

# $ 76 $)

$ # $ $ # $ 5> 76 58>8

B +

" " # $ % & " !

'(& " " # !

( " !

( "( !

% ) ( " ("(

(

( "(

" # (

& &

& + (&

),& -&(

" #

( &

& & + (&

. (( (&

( & /( & + (& && /(

& " # & /(

+ (& !

"0'"

10.'23 1'"1'%4'1'"0'"5 1'#260607%'63'2"38 10.'233

!"# *9!

:0;

;<;

(

:;2 =1 (%

( - "( (

#$%&'("%(!#(# (")(

*+)" *

>?!@@@

$ >!"(

& ( (

(!A = 5> ! $ )" @

( D $ ) " B % 5 7' B +

# $)3

$ $) 68 $ $ 3

$ # $ $ $

$0 3 $ /+ ) $ )

)

$ < . 595758;8) B +

# $)

5 7 ) >8

# $

3 +

B +

$ $ & 1/ % ( #&

( % ( , -.-(

*+!

B9!

( (

( ( (

1 C 0 3 (

( ( .&-

( !!9CD

((

(( 6!*D=>=C9=2.

2 ( (D!?!9C9 %

.&-

!A ) 6= 55577::5) $ $ )3 3

$ # $

$ + & 6= 55577::5 1/ :3

(

( "(

(

.&-

" !A )B +

# $ 7:

59:67::> +

3 + & 7: 59:67::> 1/ :3

( $

( "

( )?

*? (( )?

)?!!!

?!?>!)??B<&(

)??B )??C ( ( ((

(((

" #!

.&-

- %

"( : $ 7> 59:67::>)

7: B +

$ # $3 $ 0

$ $ # $ $ 595:58;8 & 7> 59:67::> 1/ :% &

#6%( !

6!)? (D!*!?B

( (!3

(

= (

( !"( (!D!?!C9

( " #!

( !

(!: > 595:58;8 % C/7' 59:67::>% C/='! $ $ # $) 3! $ # $

$ 3 +

$ $ 0

$03 3

$ + ? $ 0 $03

$ 3

$ + ) # $ $C # $

$ 3

$ + $ $ # $ ; 565:7:5: 5<577:55 $

$& 3

$3! ) B +

E ) 3 ) D +

$3 $ # $

$@3) 5/@

( " ) ) 7>:97:58) + # $) ) ! " # $)

# $)+ 3 3 $ $ 0

$ 1/ .6F0<#5'26G'6 13#1'2'%0356%'.02G'6 '(& <

.&-

)

#& &6 $%

.&-

( !

G6!*=*)=9 >=EEBB>C= * % ( ( )B!?D!9 "&

3 &

2 -(

8& ( &

&( .&-

# ( ( *!?!)?? ( ( ( E!)!)? ( ( &( &

( H&

:# .&-

(((

$ .&-

( " 0

( 0+& ( !

(

$ .&-

( "

;

" .&-

2 - < 4

( .&-

& .&-

- ( 3 &

" .

. < )

( (

: H& (

" .&-

# # .&-

( ( .&-

# "

(

!A *! 7 &

&( .&-

# (

= ( %

. < )&

$( $

? (

3 &

## " .

5 ='

&( # !

"(= "& (A 9

7>:97:58) ! " # $ % &

' (

$ )

78:97:58)A + $ $ 3 3 $ # $ $)@

( D ) ) ".78:97:58) 3) 3

7;577:58)3 + # 3 3 $& 7;577:58 1/ .6F0<#5'26G'6 13#1'2'%0356%'.02G'6 '(& <

.&-

)

#& & 6 $ %

.&-

( !

G*=*)=9 >'=>C* >CE % ( ( )C!)!9 "&

3 &

2 & 6!*9EE=6'

! D=' >

( ( )>!9!9 6! C?=)9!D!)?9 ( # 6! *=*)=9 >=EEBB>C= * ( ( )B!D!9 -(

# )! 7 & # ( ( *!?!)?? ( ( ( E!)!)?

- ( 3 &

" .

< )( 6!?=)=)?9 .)=E>9>D=

( (>!D!)?9

(= ( (

: H& (

" .&-

# # .&-

( ( .&-

# "

(

( ( &( ( ()B!D!)?9 ( &

$( $

3 &

" .

5 ='

&( # !

$& %

&( ( %

. < ) ( 6!

?=)=)?9 .)=)99 ( ( ?9!)!9

( (

:0( %

( ( %

;

( ( ( >!D!)?9 +

(

(!&

& ( ( # .&-

( ( & 6!9=D=)?? ')=*C*E( ( )E!>!)??* ( &

& # ( ( & 2 ( '

)?9 )? ( <&( )?)? )!:

3 &

&( .&-

# (

= ( %

. )<

- & H& ( $ ( &( # $!

"(= "

" 1 '(& A 8 3 $

7>:97:58% C/;' 7;577:58 % C/5:' 76:57:7:3 $ $ 3 5: . $ 5F7 6? 3 $ 5F7) 1/ ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ )!

( !,!.6!*)9 )?)? 1;

( H&

( ()B ?D )?9. C

( ( ()C ) )?9. ?(

(

!I) (( (

(!*!!#& &6 $ % ( "

(

( &

& (

( ( "

( # .&-

(" 0

( .&-

$ .&-

" .&-

( "

" .&-

2 - < 4

# 2

( .&-

( !*=?=? E.)=CDB 9( (E ) )?

(

(" .

!!!? ) )?)!

(

(& (G (" " (

(

( ( ( &

&( #

" 0

( ( ! 1 (& =

(& =

" =( "

(

& $( 1;

1 (

(

" 0

0 2

( " .

.&-

# !

& .&-

(" 0

.&-

(

$ H& (

" 0

( #!.&-

!1 (.&-

# "

(

! .

6* . "&

#& &6 $% 0

.&-

( ( " # ! 2

( +

.&-

B! 3 ( ( & .&-

&( ( !9=D=)?? 3')=*C*E( ()E ?>!)??* ( &

& 0( ( ( (

( .&-

# !

.&-

#! (

++ ++ ++ ++ ++ *

6! >

( &

.&-

! 0 & > & 0

(

"( =

& ( (

" # ! G

& 0

("(

( 2

( 6! ( ) ( &

(

.&-

#$ ( " 0

(6!* !A 55 # $ $

57 D

$ $ 3 )3

3 # $

$ 0 $03 3

$ + 3 ! $ # $ # $ @

$ +

/ # '$ 0() 1

+*# "2'( (!( -- 34 55 (*(*

6(!( &*## ('$ 0()( &*# -- 34 .

$ @ - + ( '$ 0()( ( &*# (*(* 6(!( &*#773 748 @ A $ $

$ $ ) $ $3

$ # $ + 595758;8) ==$)3 ! 3

5 73

B +

$ $ 3

$ # $ + ) ) @

$ + ( / ( ( &*## ((*"( (( &*#7 8354 . 56 ) 3

$ # $ 3

$ + 3 5= ? 3 5<

$) $ # $

B +

) 0 595758;8 # $

3 +

$ 5F73 B +

& ) $ 55577::5 59:67::> # $

3 +

$B == $)

$ # $3 $ 0

$03 3 + 3 ! 3

5 F 7 @3) 5 F 7 $$ # $)

7>:97:58 7;577:58 ! # $ 3 3 $

#- # $ / / ( 7:58/7: 7:7:/75 A

$ # $ 3

$ + 5>

+ 3

# $ =5 (*(* 6(!9#%(#3#$ *(4 1/ B! ( ( &

(

" &>!" # ( -& ( (

++ ++ ++ ++ ++ 9!

( ( ( .&-

06!)9B9!( ">E0

+& ( (

(

( & ( !

"9 ( $ (

( " &

(

:9! &

( " # ((

)"( $ ((

" & (

" & !

* > (E!!!!!( B' " & ((" &

(

" &

(

& ( :!

#+ ?! " )* ()E

( (

(

:)*!" # ( & &

& + (&

),& -&(

" #

(

& &

& & + (&

. (( (&

( & ( & + (& && (

& " # & (

+ (& !

)E! & (+ (&

(

# &+ ( &(

# ( ! &

&((

# /:!

! 0 &

(& " & & ( " # ! 1 "(

$" &

(

+ " & !3 & ((

B " & ( "( H& (

!")* & " # ( + (& !

( " )E & ( + (& ( " # + ( &(!6

(& # ( ( ( (

++ ++ ++ ++ ++ >! 5 &

0 (" & > & (

+& ( !3+

( ( & (

(& ( ! " #

( (&( !5

& ( + (& " # + (

&(!1 & " # ( (

(

!3 &

(

( (

( " &

(

33!" &>

( ( 0& !" #

E! 3 & " #

& (+ & ( (

+!1

& # ( 0&

( (

(

" # :

# (

" # :!3"(

2 (

( (

-& ( ( ( $(

" #

-& ( ( !

B! (" &>

!3 & 0& & (

( !(

& ! ( &

((

& & &

( $ (

(+ ! " &> ( ( 0& & (

!3 (

!3 #

$ (

(

!"&

( ( !

C! 0((

$ !5&

( ( !

( ( ( $! + ( &

& + !3

(

( &( !3

(

0& ( " & !1 &

& (

(

+ !

D! 3

H& ( & ( ! 3 ( " #

-& ( ( ( (

(

9! 0 (

(! &(

(

(! 3

( ( ( ( (

& (

(

( !A 5;

$ @ - + "

('$ 0()( ( &* # (*(* 6(! ( &*# 773 74 8) 3 1/ G!3

" .&-

H& ( " #

((

& &

(( & " # &( " & &

( &( J

)! " # & &(

& " 9 )* ()E#& & $% 0

0 9B9 : 0: (

((

( ( & (

" #

& &( ( (

*! ( " & " &>(

( (

(

( & "(

2 ! " # &( ")E0 &

&((

(

& (

(& & ! " # &( ")*0 " # ( &

& + (&

( !

G " #

(

( & + (&

" # & + (& (

(( " & ( " &

"( 2 ( " # ! && ( (

" #

(

( ( " # &( ( & ( &

" &

(

" # !3& &

" # && " ?1 (.&-

0 & &

( & ( " #

+ ( ( ( " # ! " & #& & 6 $ % .&-

! <& 1 ( .&-

0 & &

(

( ( " # $ (

( " & ( (! &( -&( !0! 6!

E?DD=9B

(

( & #

(

>! ( (( 0

(" & (

( &

( ( &

" #

" )* ( )E 0 & ( &( ( " #

&( " # &

( ! 3

( &

&(-&( 1&

( & !

( ( (

(!A 59 &

/ 9#%(#3#$ *(4 3 3

$ # $3

3 1/ >! 3 , .6!>99?9DE% !2

" ( !" .&-

(

99B"EC.I1(((B!!99E 3 (

(

!!!!!9C*! $

( ( 2 !C?? B?? !!9C* &

(( (

!!9C* (D!!9CD!5

(

( # & (

!!!!!9C*!0 $ #& & 6 $ % 0 9B9 ( " & (

(

: 0 (" &

"( (

(

$ ( ( $!

-& ( &

# (

!!9C*

"( (" (&H&

(

2 !C?? B?? !!9C*!:

E! 3 (

(

( "(

(

2 !D?= !

2 &0+& . )

( "(

( & #

(

(!0+& . ) H&

(!3 (

(

2 !

D?= 2 &0+& . )

( ( (

(

( ( 2 !H 58 ( 3 # $3A 3 + 595758;8 == $ $ ) ) 3 33 ( /( 9#%(#3#$ *(4) $ B 5F73

B +

$ !

1 ) $$3! # $ $ ! $

$ + 7: ? 3 ) 3

0 7>:97:58 % C /;' 7;577:58% C/5:' $& %'

$ &,6 , ( #$

! 0 I0 I0