Rakesh Chander Misra And ORS v. Dharam Pal And ORS
!
" #$% &' () *+,&+- . !/
&011&2+$+&#'1+ ''+ 3+, 1&+&4 &#'1+ 52'
! "#$%&!&%'
+') $+ +&'0621.2(&'.
+'15''+ $+7&+681.2(&'.
++52'!'9 ::::: &%' ("
15+'+5''1&* 2 +''8;&2'1 +2+2&'2 ! !
"<,+ ;!%.=1+*-&55(&' 2,2+ 6('!
! ++'+&' $(55(&'/ >.=1(1 =&2422 &,'! /.1&*242
''+;5&'
2'1,' +2(&+&'''1
('
'1&''1-&+=+5?,&1&+ &24&,+8 0&&!
4&+&&2 +''8;&2'1&222&'2 @ ! &2 '1+ & 22 / ! ='1 (?,'& + 7,(' +'+&8'1+52';2 2&' +4'+ +8'5&( ,&2 &= ,5'=&&82'1&''1,'&2=&5+,-=2 &252*-'1 &'1+ '15&'
.&4-. &+'&4&2 & '+12&'1.=&1+'2*-'15&'
?,&1&+15&'
.
*8 .&+88&2&2,2'(42&&2+
&55'22 2&'! &'1+&''+- &2&+&6&1&& 32-& &+0&1 5+5&+2 & +82 &2 &*+(&'2 5=+ &''+- &82-<(,'2*-'15&'
&2&*'&2+8'+&' +4'1
( 6,* 8'+&+.&&21&+&2,((22<(,'8'1&22 ,2+(1&8 $+ +&'0621.&+2(, +'15''+;5&'
,*4''2'1&''1,'=& 2!9 .=1(1=&242 2 &,'!
! >&55(&' ++'+&'&8='1&
2&'
'1 2(&' =& ,*4''2 !@ >. *,' , +',&'- '1 &55(&' =& & 242 2 &,' ! / 1 & +4'2+2+=&(1&82'1+'1,+'.=1(1 =& 242 ! ='1 *+'- ' 4 & &55(&' + +'+&'&2&((+28-'1(2&55(&'08+'+&' '1
+'&55(&'.2422 &,'.=&,*4''2 / ! 1 &41&++,-*242 ! ! 1&*( '1 5&'
=&'1+''&+= ,.*,' +'1+&<5&2 &+&>./&2! '1&55(&'1&+4&25+7,2(=,2* (&,2(&'145,82+2+';&2&2'1&55(&' + +'+&' '1,'+2+2'*+'+2,*7(''&-(2' =1(1'1,+'4&-24 ' $+7&+681.&+2(,&55&+8*1& '1 +52'!'9,*4''2'1&''15''+;5&'
&2'5&( +(+2&-4&'+&'1='1&''1-=+'2&&2(,2' 5,+,'1&55(&'&2,'1-=+2+('2' (5- 5&5+' &8 &2'&21+''12+('.'1+=,2*'+,'1'1+5& 4&2'1&55(&'.4,(1'1&*( '1(,=&&
''& 1&1&+2'1&+2(, +'15&+'&2&55+&2 '15&5+*0 1&55(&' ++(&8 '1+2+2&'2! / 2 ! ! 1&*2(22*-'1'+&,+' ! ! ..& '+
-&+ '11+'8+,2.'1(,+'*=1,2'1&5&2& 2'&2+2+&2&2 (,'1 +'&55(&'08+'+&'
'1,'=1(1=&2422 &,'!
! >1=15,+5 ' (,' 1+''1+- '15&+'''1*,'''05 '1 &55(&'+'1'8&'528 +2+'5+'4(&++&8 7,'(&2'+2+7,'(.
'145,82+2+2&'2 ! !
';&21&55(&'&+ &=2 ,*7(' ' 5&-4' . A;. =1(11& *&(2' 5+(2'?,'-.'1,'+'+2''+8&,4*+ 6('1,' '1-&+ .'1'+&,+'2+('2' 2(2'1&4&<52',-&5* 15&+'.'1+,81'1+(,.&+2+('2'&55&+* + '1'+&,+' !/
5'''&2&=2 )*+,-+.(/ &%' +-01 "#23!
'141+5-6 78+- 9 :8
'141+5 +4-*
:8