High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3389/2016allowed

Taran Gupta v. Satwinder Singh

2017-02-23Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari4 pages

"# $

"&'()$* +(,&$ -"$(.$$ "

&"#($&/0&1* +1&,&$-"$("#. $

"# $",# .$$ '2$($ $#"$&+& #$$( ""&$3 45

67" 89:;("'2$( $"11"(&# #/##$(&..1&$ 7 " "" 3 71 !- -""&11 + $( ;$ ## &/12 *&$; " * +( -" '&1& - $( "##< 6&/ ;((&.. #$'$(1& 1"

("&# +, '2$( $"11"#$(&$ &"1"

&# $(&..1&$ ;&##/## 3 4& $("-"$ ;&#&" +12(1$(&$# & $("&..1&$ ;&#/, & --" $-"/$("-" "+($6#$ $(".&"$2$"&11& 6&/ & 2#7(;$ ## &..&"$' $( +1# '7$ & 1&2 + $&$ $( .&"$ - $( &..1& $ ;(( ;&# $ ."/##'1 #71$& $12$(&..1&$ ;&##/##;$(#$#-

# 8< ;(( ;&# $ ' .& &# $ ." $ -" -7"$("

7$-&#'2$(&..1& $<&"& 7.$&

7 #1-"$(.$$ "(&##7'/$$$(&$$(&..1&$

;&#/,$(&$$(7 #1;&# $."# $# (;&#'7#2 & $("

#$-." +# ;&##/## 3 4

&7 $-$(-&$$(&$1& 1"(&' ;&$ +$11 ./ & $( 7"$(& .;"$",;$#""

$##7'/$$$(&$$(##7- 1&2&##7(;71 $&"#& &.&"$2#(71 $'.7$$1##

&7 $-$( <&,&1&'1$2-$(7 #1&$$(&$. $-$/ 7 #1-"$("#. $ $("(& ..#$(."# $ ",# .$$ $(+"7 $(&$$( 7$-&##7(;&#$(&"&## $(1& 1";((&' ;&$ +# /"

+-""##6&/

("-"$(/.7+ "";&#)7#$- $(&"1""";&# .&## 3 4

"7#&1-$(.&."'=;71+ $#(;$(&$

4*&$; "* +("#. $(&' .&"$12"##<6&/ "/& +"##<6&/ (&#' -""$ 3 4-"

;& $ - "$& 7/ $# " +12 $ ;&# "$ $(&$ $( "/& + >#;71'."7 $(&$-6 3 4 ."7#&1-$(?/ ""#."7'2$(7 #1;71/&=$1&"

$(&$$(#&;$ ##;&#."# $&1 +;$("@7#$""'7$ $("

$ $ "& 2'21# (#'(&1-;&#."# $$"##<6&/ (/

(-1;&#$&= 7. -7"&# #'-"17 (& $("&-$"&$ &'7$ ./ $(/.7+ "";&#.&## 7 #1-"$(1& 1"< "#. $(&$( 1#(#, & &#;&#&" +12-6 -"$(, -$(."# $.$$ "<$ $

."7#&1-$(".12-$($ $<.$$ ";71+ $

#(;$(&$')$ ;&#$&= $(".12$$(" $.$$ $(&$' -"@7"/ $;&# $)7#$-& $(&$$(1& 1"(&+"7

+ '7# ## &7'1#$"2#(.& &#/& 2&##, /.12#;" ;"= +&##&1#."#

;&#(&, +-7"$("#(.#;$(. #.& ;(( ;" //"&1 &$7" $ # ',7# $(&$ #7( "7/#$& #$(""' + $&,&1&'1;$($(1& 1"$(&# (&' -6-";& $-"$& 7/ $# ("&# +$(7#;(( #' ++, '2$(7"$$(&$$(";&# #7( $"&11$( ;$ ##& $(6&/ #$'$"&$&# 11# $&..&" $12 #/#$')7#$- $(-&-$ $##$$1." .1$(&$.&"$#71 $'.")7

$(&$-$(7 #1 &# $-""##6&/ +$( 1& 1";&#-1 $(#&/&25

67" <: ;(($(&#'

/ $ $(&$((&' &11 $(7"$-*%-"7"+ $/&$$" .#$17 (-""&11;((;&##/## $(+"7 $(&$$(7"$ (& .;"$",;$#""

(- +;(((&#' "" $(&$1&2;&##7+($$'&7## $#/$')7#$- $( -&$#& "7/#$& #-$(&# $##$$1." .1$(&$$("71#- ."7"&"(& /&#-)7#$& $(7"$#$&)7&$$( /&$$" $(/"$#& .&"$2&

$$&=' -$ &7 $-& $( &1$2 #7("7/#$& #$(#7"$#-$(. $(&$""

.&##'2$(7"$'1;# $)7#$-;("'2$(&..1&$ -"

"&11 +-;$ ##;&##/## ( $"11"#"$$+, .."$7 $2$ $(.$$ "$"##<6&/ $(1& 1"#7')$$.&2/ $-#$#-

# 98< $ # #$&$ $(&$ $( &# # ; -6 -" 3 4

" +12$( $"11";11+,&&$-""##6&/ - $(1& 1" $#/&1&"$(&$ 12 .."$7 $2#$'+, -"

$(#&.7".# -$( -71# $ $(&"1"""#;11/ '&= $."&$

#71$& $12=. + ,;$(&',$(."# $",#

.$$ -17 ""$1!-$( #$$7$ - &#&11; '$( $( ""# &$ 3 4 & #7'#@7 $ "" &$ 3 4&"#$&#

! "#$%"&"'(") *$+, !

# >($("#.&= +8"&# #8 >($(" ."$&'1 #8