Shiv Kumar Bhandari v. Kailash Soni & ANR
!"#
$ %!
&
$
' '
()
' )!
* ( ) + ' ! $!
() ' %"() &
!
, &
& - -. & /
00 0 1 2)
3!$/4+ !
56!7+
$ "
&
-.
/&
-
+
, 0+ &+ ! + + " -. & & "
.
- & 00 0 0. - !"
!0 - 0 0 +
!"
+ - -.
+ +-.&. 0!!&
& & "
+ !
0 ! ! + !
.- + +0 +
,
& !- " !-3& 0 !
&:! + !- ! 0 + + ! 0 -!
"( + + " 0 !!-:
&."
(/
!
!0!
! - "
( !
:!
+
& .
& - -.
&
/&
.!0
& &&
8 +!-"
" 0 00 0 & +
. + ( -. ! "
+ -
-. 9 & &
&&- 8
;0 "" 9& 0 +
"- 0 .-
-. "" * - +3
! &
& - &
!
&
/&
!-"
-
& -. ( + && " 0 " !0
&& !-<!
. + +
+ -. -
&
+
& - !
+!
! + 0 .
! - "
- + "
+
+ ! . !
. ! , "
+ ! & "
! & . 9& 0 +
+ 0 !0 - + +. &
+
& +
.+ - "
/&
+! !-"
.+
0 &0 .- 0 &!& " 0 & & .
, &&
.( . 3" &!
- + !
, &!
!
7 3 ! &
& -. - /&
+ .
!
+ + 0
. &
/&
+ &
; !
( +*+ 0(* , &
-
8
= + &
- & + )"
. 6
1 !+ &
& &
+&&
9
&
& & " & +
.+
0 - 9 "&&& ! &
&!& "
0 ! &
,
.+"- 7
+ +3 ! &
&
, + 0-. !
7 0 !
0. !" +&
&
+ ! & & .+" 6
! " & . *
- -.
! -
&. !+ 0!0
+ -.
, !
0 !
- 3 0 0 & ! " !
- 0 ! "
- 0
" 0& & .+ !-
, &
" !
= " &
& & . !0 <! & . !0
7 & & & & +
.+& 8 + + -.&
0
""-
+& !
0 - "
.- & & +
.+3
7-.
= - 0
0 " 8 >"-. " -
8 . " &
!."-
1 &+ +3
+
+00 !
, ! +0 -
& &.! &!& ! "
.
" ! & & .+6
, & +
0 +
.& 0 0
0 !-. >"-. = 9 & & +
.+ .
&!& "
! + !
0 !
+ - !!
. & +
.
- 0 &!& !
, (!+" && "
+ + & &+ !0 - .
&!& - & . &&- 8 ;0 "" &!&
.
)0 + " &
& !
0 0 "&!0 & +
.-
&
+ .
, && + && -. 9 0 &
! - " &&
"
- 0 , &
/&
&&- 8 ;0 ""
& +
.
(
&"-
, !+
+
! - "( "
+"
-
- . "
.0!-. !-"
+ & 56!7$(
!
&"
! 0
! "
0
- & !& :!0"
" #!$
%&"'(%& $!
)
*$ +"(,-./0.1.23& " :!0"
)&3 ! '!
45!
*$ +"('( 6 $
*$ +"0,--21 ,7-2 :!0"
&"!
)
*$ +"
'(8$"!
) ,--9031 :,; (< %&"
*$ +"'(*
+"
%&"
*$ +"(,-.7021 0!8! 1,23/
)&! :!0"
+ !0 + " +
-
& - + !- -.+. 0 !"
, -!
&
56!7$
!0
+ !
" +.
-" :!0"
)&3 ! +8 !
)
*$ +"('( * "!
)
*$ +"0,--:1:72;+
+ + & . !"
.
( "
!- +
-" - + -
- !
?# +& + (+".
&
56!7 $& "
& 0
- + + ! .
@ (+ 3" (
(
.
8 && "
. !"
.
!
@ " ( && !
+
0
! !
-. ;0 !
, !
, & (
!
& 56!7 $ !"! - " " 0 ! (3" +
( 0 !"
0!"
)
(& . !"
(+
. :
"
+
+ & 56 !7 $+
+& + !
! + "
+
. 0 & 0
, :!0"
'!
45!( 2!&4 0 ! 3" + !" !
6
& 0& .
!0
0- &+ "
&
- !
?7 #. $ ! 2)"
4)
( 2)
4( $"
&
5%8!7 (+ !
B$ && "
- +
(!
!
"
! & !0
( & . !
"
-
" . "
, ! C:!
+!
&& +.!
&
(D ( "! "
!
& !0
!
"
-
@ " &-. ,*!0(
&
- - ! &
, <! ( (+
+
8 ! & (
, + ! "
$ $ ! 0 9 ! &
0 & @ 0
! 3" +
( ! & (+ !" !
E
& 0C
, ! &
!0 ! -
"-!
-
!-&& "
"
& ( &
+ 3& 0
0 !0
"+
<!
.( &
+ !
. & :! !&
. <! !
+
.+0 + .
!.&&
"
&!
- +
!
"
. 0
!
!
&
& " .
7 ! + "
+ . "
. <!
.+ +" & .9 0
, &
&+ + +8#++$& &!
+"(+8+ *<+"('("4 ( 64(* (
*$ +"( 0,--21.- ;7 + + 0 " & 0
!-
0 "
- ! 0"
+ ! :! , &
& + ?67 5 . .D 0- > 0 8 ( " - &
& "0 + !0 -
+ + 0 :
0 && "
24F
!0 "& & &
:! G 24F "
- " G 4, "
!
!!
&:! +
- "& <! . " "
.H 214! 0"
+ !
:!
"! & 0 24 F & & "
. !!
. 0 !
G 264)0 !( ! !
! "+ !---."
&&
6 , " "&
+ ".-9&
" + 0+ && !
5%8!7
, .!
3 !
6 , && "!
5%8!7 . !:! 3 3 !
-!
!"
7 F
! ! ! -. - + 0&& "
! "!
! - ( 0 " ( . "
! &" " ( + /
"
1
". 6+( %&6")" '( #6 =<*"$( 8$ $
*$ +"(,-.,0,1<+=*&"$& )6+ $(9.> "+ -
+
+ + + !
9 .&
&& -&& !- 0 !& .+ !- "& +
&
+
3& + "
. + & !0 "
.- "
". &
( &!
& +
& +
.+0 &
+ "+ . &!& " 0 -
" !
& & .+ + "
/&
+
"+ - -.! "&
. !
&
+:! -.
& 0
!& & 56!1$+ & .
& + .&"&
(!(- ! ( +!! !
! !
! -3"&+ " ,
!"+
+&
8 ;0 "" +
.+
+ !- .
!
( + !-<! -&& . +
. + 0 "- -.
" "" (* 0 !
- !.
-. 8 ;0 "
!
. !
!
+ ! . "
! +
+- 0 0 -
" !
= +
+ + "! !
. & , ! & ! ++:! +
& .9& 0 +
0 .
6
!& " #!$%&"( 2!&4+ !-
(& "
! - " &
C
- + 3 3" + "
+
+ + 9 +0 - 8 !
!0
( & "
. 0 !
- !&
+ !
. 0 7
". &" !
) ( 2!&4( "
+
.
". (< %&"( 2!&4(
-. ! && - 0
+
.- 3" - "
&&
)
0. 0 "
+ !& , !(
+ .- " "
!
.(9& 0 + - - ( &
& - 0- " "
2I
) ;)F)J8)4 $9 *=I>