← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3148/2014dismissed

Sukhdev Singh v. Darshan Singh And ORS

2015-03-12Mr. Justice J.C. Verma4 pages

      

!"# $#%&'&()!*%+,

- ./+$#0&(1+  0   

    )

 

  

 



*#'#(") +*&+$ .'!

,$0%!"#, *"+#2#"&"&(#*    

   *!3) &'4&''!3 !22#!3!1!&('"*$#*$!"#$

"+#35#* %.*"("+#1*.($ $#3!6*#7#%"&(1"+#!223&%!"&(.($#*#%"&(- "+# 8&4&"!"&(%",9: *%($(!"&( '.%+$#3!6&'.($#*%+!33#(1#&( "+&'*#0&'&(2#"&"&(

"&'5*"+("&%#"+!"&(!'.&"2*# #**#$;6!*'+!(&(1+,(5 *#'2($#(",$# #($!("',&(%3.$&(1+&($#*&(1+'&(%#$#%#!'#$!($ *#2*#'#("#$;6+&''(./+$#0&(1+,2#"&"&(#*+#*#&(,#<=2!*"#$#%*## 5!'2!''#$22#!35!'2*# #**#$!1!&('"'.%+$#%*##;6'!&$+&($#* &(1+!($"+#*$# #($!("'!

"#*4*#"+!( &0#6#!*'5&"+!(!223&%!"&( .($#*#%"&(- "+#8&4&"!"&(%",9: *%($(!"&( $#3!6 &($&(1(1*.($ *%($(&(1"+#$#3!6,"+#!223&%!"&(5!'$&'4&''#$ !($'#>.#336,"+#!22#!3!3'4#""+#'!4# !"#  ("+&'*#0&'&(2#"&"&(,&"&'(5%3!&4#$"+!"!1!&('"$&'4&''!3  "+#'.&",!*#0&'&(2#"&"&(+!$5*(136;##(2*# #**#$!($"+#$#3!6&(

&3&(1"+#!22#!3%%.**#$$.#"5*(1!$0&%# +&'%.('#3,5+&%+'+.3$ (";#"!/#("+&'2*#7.$&%#"&'.*1#$"+!""+#&42.1(#$*$#*'.

#*'

*44&''&("!22*#%&!"#"+#;!'&%2*&(%&23#"+!"!2!*"6'+.3$("'.

#*

*"+# !.3" +&'3!56#* ?+#(  2!2#*  ;/  +!'  ;##(  2#*.'#$  $.*&(1  "+#  %.*'#  

!*1.4#("'!$$*#''#$;6.('#3 *"+#2#"&"&(#*,&""*!('2&*#'"+!""+# 4!""#*&'("!''&423#!'+!';##("*&#$";#2*7#%"#$ !"+#*,"+# !22#33!"#  %.*"  ;#35  "/  2!&('  !($  1!0#  .33  22*".(&"6  "  "+# $# #($!("',  2#"&"&(#*  +#*#&(,  "  '.'"!&(  !($  '.22*"  "+#&*  23#!  

%($(!"&( $#3!6# #($!("+&($#*&(1+5+&'(5$#%#!'#$!($ &' ;#&(1  *#2*#'#("#$ ;6 +&'  '( ./+$#0 &(1+, 2#"&"&(#* +#*#&(,+!$ #("#*#$"+#5&"(#'';<!'?5+#*#&(+#+!$%(%#$#$"+!"+#!($"+#* $# #($!("'+!$$.36;##('#*0#$&("+#'.&"!($5#*##0#(*#2*#'#("#$;6! %.('#35+3!"#*$&$("!22#!*!($"+#65#*#2*%##$#$!1!&('"#<=2!*"# ( 99-("+#4#!(5+&3#,"+#'.&"+!$;##($&'4&''#$.($#**$#* @.3#  (

99 +#$# #($!("'+!$4!$#!(!223&%!"&( * '#""&(1!'&$#"+##<=2!*"#*$#*!1!&('""+#40&$#!223&%!"&( -99: - 8!"#*,  "+#  '.&"  $#'2&"#  *#'&'"!(%#  *4  "+#  $# #($!("'  5!'

*#'"*#$,5+#*#!'!223&%!"&( "+#$# #($!("' *'#""&(1!'&$#"+##<=2!*"# 2*%##$&(1'5!'$&'4&''#$(

 "&'%3!&4#$"+!"*$#*$!"#$

5!'%+!33#(1#$;65!6 *#0&'&(2#"&"&(!($5+#("+#6$&$("

!22#!*;# *#"+#35#*%.*",#<=2!*"#$#%*##5!'2!''#$!1!&('""+#4( A-

: : 0#*4#("' "+#!22#33!("=$# #($!("'!*#("%**;*!"#$;6 "+#&*%.('#3+*&.*7&"&(1+!&5+!22#!*#$&("+#5&"(#'';<!'? !($+!'%!"#1*&%!336'"!"#$"+!"!(!223&%!"&( **#'"*!"&( "+#'.&";6 $# #($!("!*'+!(&(1+5!''"*(136%("#'"#$;6+&4 *"+#$# #($!("'

;.""+#%!'#5!'*#'"*#$

A #+!'%!"#1*&%!336!0#**#$"+#*#!

"#*"+!"$# #($!("+&($#* &(1+!($"+#*'$&$("!22#!*!($5#*#2*%##$#$!1!&('"#<=2!*"## +!'  !3'  $#(.(%#$  "+#  %!'#    "+#  $# #($!("'  ."    5+4  (#  &'

*#0&'&(&'"+#*#&(,"+!"+#+!$ &3#$!(6*#0&'&(2#"&"&( !"+#*,+#+!'

'"!"#$"+!"+#+!$!$0&'#$"+#4" &3#!(!22#!3;.""+#6%("&(.#$$#3!6&(1 "+#4!""#*!($(!22#!35!' &3#$

"&'5*"+("&%#"+!"#0#(&(#<#%."&(2*%##$&(1',"+#65#*# '"*(136%("#'"&(1!($+!$ &3#$;7#%"&(2#"&"&(;."+!$(" &3#$!( !22#!3!1!&('""+##<=2!*"#$#%*##,5+#*#&("+#6%.3$0#*65#33%+!33#(1# *$#*$!"#$

5+#*#;6"+#&*!223&%!"&( *'#""&(1!'&$##<=2!*"# 2*%##$&(1'!1!&('""+#4+!$;##($&'4&''#$ +#!22#33!("+!$!*&1+" .($#*.3#= *$#*@8 ;."$#3!6%("&(.#$("+#2!*" "+# $# #($!("'"&'*!"+#*5*"+("&%#"+!""!0&$#<#%."&(!($ *.&"' "+# $#%*##!($"%*#!"#"+&*$2!*"6&("#*#'"',"+#$# #($!("'#<#%."#$'!3#$##$ $!"#$999-#0#(!

"#*2!''&(1 $#%*## '2#%& &%2#* *4!(%#!1!&('"

"+#45+#("+#2*2#*"6&( !%"5!'3(1!14*"1!1#$&( !0.* !;!(/ "  (36 "+&',  "+#*#!

"#*, "+#  2*2#*"6 5!'  4*"1!1#$  %3!($#'"&(#36(  99-  #"!("+#*4*"1!1#$##$5!'#<#%."#$;6"5$# #($!("'

0&B.*$#0&(1+!($ 1&($#*&(1+(

:+#'#40#';6"+# $# #($!("'2*0#$&((%..'!"+#*,"+#65#*#&("#("&(!336;.*$#(&(1"+# 2*2#*"65+&%+5!''.;7#%"4!""#* $#%*##$!"#$9-

5&"+!0&#5" "+5!*"&(1 &"'#<#%."&(+#"+&(1'$&$("'"2"+#*# 9 (*$#*"'!

#1.!*$"+#&*&("#*#'","+#!223&%!("=$# #($!("'

+!$#0#(#("#*#$&("!("+#*!1*##4#("5&"+"+#*&1&(!35(#*,(!4#36 4"&!(C!.*!($"+#*'5&"+!(&("#("&("+!"& "+#2*2#*"6!335#$" ;#2.*%+!'#$;6"+#4!

"#*"+#!1*##4#(""'#33&( !0.* *#'2($#("= 23!&("&

!*'+!(&(1+1#'!5!6,&("+!"'&".!"&(4"&!(C!.*!($ "+#*'5&33;#.($#*;3&1!"&("#<#%."#"+#'!3#$##$*#1!*$&(1"+#&*

2*2#*"6+&' !%"+!'%3#!*36;##(!$4&""#$;6 +.2&($#*&(1+?&( +&'%*''#<!4&(!"&(  "&'!%3#!*%!'#5+#*#40# "+#!223&%!("=$# #($!("' * %($(!"&( $#3!6&'4!3!= &$#!($&'!(#

*""0#*=*#!%+"+#3!5!($ 3#1!3*&1+"' "+#22'&"#2!*"6+#*#&'3!2'# 4*#"+!('&<6#!*'," '.

#**#2#"&"&(,5+&%+&("+##<#%."&(2#"&"&(,"+#$# #($!("'&(%3.$&(1 "+#2#"&"&(#*+#*#&(,+!$4!$#?+6(!22#!35!'2*# #**#$!1!&('"#<= 2!*"#$#%*## 9-

&'(".($#*'"!($!;3#  "&'!23#!$#$%!'#"+!""+#65#*#&("+#/(5 #<=2!*"# 2*%##$&(1'!($#<=2!*"#$#%*##!1!&('""+#4!($+!$;##($&336=$#3!6&(1 "+#4!""#*5+#*#,&( !%",(*#0&'&(2#"&"&(+!$;##(2*# #**#$!1!&('"

*$#*$!"#$

+#&*23#!+!';##($#(.(%#$;6"+#&*5(%.('#3  *$#*  $!"#$  A

  $#%3&(&(1  "+#  !223&%!"&(  * %($(!"&( $#3!6!($%('#>.#("$&'4&''!3 !22#!3,$#'("'.

#*

*4  !(6  !%".!3  #***  *  3#1!3  &( &*4&"6   +#  *#0&'&(  2#"&"&(  &'

%('#>.#("36$&'4&''#$