Rakesh Kumar Batta v. Madhu Walia And ANR
!"
!"# $"
%& ' "( !"#
!"
!"# $"
%& ' "( !"#
"
*+,"-.,( */)0 1*
!"# 33333 - ) "-*44) "( " 0
4 0
"6 7* )6 76 2 /*"1 9,"
24*5* ) 4* 2*1 "* 40) :
" 50 /2 : 0
+/ 2*1 "-*0: *; 2 8 40
6 7 2
-*" 2 - ( " 0
(
*<* =,)<8 )* ) > (*"") :+ 4* ) ((44* ,
+/&,)- * */5- :+ -*((*42 4):+
*<* =,)<8 )* ) ? @ (*"") :+
44 / -* * 5*" "") 5
2* 4, - (*
(*+ * * " *4 <5
"
* )1 "/*"(
*44+*"""") @/0 )=,)<8 )?
5*")
0*1* -)8 ")( 8 ""* )
-* ) 0 -0*1* ( """"
-"*8
- "( 4* )4 )5
8
(*""
)? @ 24+ "
)/ - 2*1 - 1*" * - "- ( 9,"
*; :+
2 8 "( 2 "
*4 (, ( " - +* 7?> - :*"
*4 * 1+ 5) :+ *1 ,*4 ( """"
A "@
B ( 8
-/ *" - *2 / 5*" -* 1)2 8"@
"
B ( 8
- 52 18: /
"( ;( "", 1 ( "2 (*
- 8* ) - C ) 4*
"- ( 24* )4 * ) : 5 "( * )
"( "
4) "- (/"- 5 *"D E/
- "5 2/ "(
/0 )"*4)))* )6@
-"- ("- 5 )1 ,
(4* *4 < 5
- "
8 *)=
< ( - < , ) 24
* )
2 24
5*" < ) *5*+ :+ "(
- " 5 2/ "( / 0 ) < )) )* ) @
> - *2 /
"
) (*+ <
"( *)-, %*4 * A
6 "
B ( 8
- -,"/ - C " 4*
"- ( 2 4* )4 ) * )
: 5 "( * )
- "( " 4* )4 ) "
,<- =1
2 ") ( 8 -< , ) --*"
(* 52@ A "
"(
2 (* ))8* )"* ) 9,"
"8*):+
-8 (
1 -=1
/(
:=1
""
- -"* )(
8*
*:4* )
-"*8-*": 2 2*4"* )24 8"+< , )" 5*"",:8
-4* )4 )-*": ( ""
-* 1 - *
-(
, 2"/
-* )*4"
22 )
"44 -(
50 /5-
-*)"- 5 - *:
(, 1-*" -( 9,"
4* )4 ) "( " "
- *
) "( """"
-",
( 44<*44+* )2 :4+ 8
"/
"(, -( 9,"
*; -+* 7?> A"@
8$* ) ,8* A*4,/5- ":
- "( -"- (5*" *;
:,")*"*< 5 * ) - 2 24
( ) "(, 5*" *; 2 (, ( " 28* ,2*1 2"- "5- -4*:
, "8(4 +):+ "( "* "
448* ,2*1 -"- " -* 18 "@
B
"
-5*"*)8
)4*
"- ( 24* )4 * ) : 5 -(*
"5*"*4"
) ) %- 4 - (
5*" ( ) </ 4* )
44 0 ) ) @*"""") -(
/51-
> 5*" 9,
: ) ) :+
* ) - 1*" 5*" *)= , )
? @2 ) ?
2*
)
*"""") :+
44 / 51- 4)
=1
0 )
)? @
"42-(
5*")
-* ) 0 0*1* ( """"
") ( 8
- "( 4* )4
8
-=1 )? @ << 0) 2 - *2 "* ) ?
( 2 ) * *((*4 51- 5*" ) "") :+ ((44* ,
+0 )=,)<8 ) > -" 1 1,8"
* 1"/
-*" 2 ( " 0
*<* -=,)<8 ) > (*""):+
-((44* ,
+ &* )1 , "42
-*"* <,) 4* ) ((44* ,
+ -*" ) "") - *((*4 2 4) :+
/,(- 4) 20
(*""):+ -
44 / *"
-*)
- ) ) ? @ 4)* + *((*4 1-*44 < 2 (
*4 *""""8 )* @",:8
-1*41,4*
-(
< * ) - 2 /
1 ,4)
- "*8 ? @-(
-*") - 4*
"- ( 24* )4 )
: 5 - (*
" * ) ",:8
2*1 - "( -*0: ( ""
-* 1 - *
,
2"/
-/
- 5 "/ -4* )4 )5 44"44 -( 9,"
&* ) 1 , "4 -*" 2, - ",:8
9,"
*; -+* 7?>A"@
- :
- 2 "( / *" - "( " 5 "
* 1- * ) ",:"9, 4+/ - 5*" -* 1) 2 8 "@
B
"
B &* )
44 -*" *"""")
) ) @/ 5- :+ * *8 2 "?@7B 5*" *"""")/- -0 +1*41,4*
"2 -(
5 5 < - 40* C *1 ) (*"") :+
44 *)"*", )
! ""# %
$
&
' ( %)
%
1 - 1*41,4*
" 8*) 54 2
*4 ) @ 5 5 </
1 ,4)
)(
-(
*44+*"""") 2 C) ? * ) ,<- * *)= , 8 *11 2 - 44 "" , "
44/
44 *44 5)
* ))
-* ) 0 - 0*1* ( """"
") ( 8
"( 4* )4 ) 5
8
- 2 - )* - =1
) ? @ - (
2 4) * *((*4 * ) 54 1-*44 < 20
)? @/- <-4 <- -2*1
@ - -*) 11*"
*44+ *"""") *" 1*41,4*
-*""""8 ) 5 5 </:, "
44/ -"* )*((*4 5*" ) "") :+ - ((44* ,
+ 0 ) =,)<8 )* > ",((
2 - " 1
/ - 4 ) ,( =,)<8 E:4 -(C -1*"" 2
!"#!" $% & ""'$ &!" $$(! )"* +,,-+ !& +.// 0$&$!* 11%!)1 ! 23++.
$%$ 2-/* )=,)<8 -1*" 2#)1
&$!* 4!(& % $0$!"
"50 4!(& 23++2 $%$ //3
1
) 0 5 28*C D+ "# (,5- - ")2*,4 )(
2* * " ),
- + 8 *; 2 1*41,4*
=1 1 ,4) :
) )/*" - 5*"- +8 *; 1 8(,
2* * "-,"/ 5- - " * *((* 8 *; 1 8(,
2* * "/ =1 1*
: ) )* ) ) "(*""):+ - ":4 51*
","
-+" 24*5, - /
"
< -: 2
*; 1*41,4*
"8*):+ -
44 -*0-* )4* )1 , "42
* )( ,")
8(,< )=,)<8 " - *""""8 ) @ 5*" (*"") ( " 1
* ) - ) 4 2 *""""8 2 (
*4 *""""8 5*"< 0 -"*
"42/51- "*4 *)+ ( ),1) -*2 "* )(* *< *(-
)
1-*44 < 2*""""8 2(
) @* )
-,"/ ? - -*) (*"") - 0
) / 51-
) 2 *4
+
1
2*
)
*4 *""""8 ? @/ - 5*" :
, )
: 0 ) 2
)8 ")( 8 ""-0 +
-*": 2 4)2 -=1
2 ") ( 8 *11 (*+8 2* * " 52@
6 @* ) - "(, *:
-*)8
) * "
-/51-
5*"
- 5 " 9,
- 2 )*+ -* < , :+
9,"
-*" <- 4+ : ) )
: 0 ) 2 ") ( 8 ""
-*)
1-*44 <) ) @:2
20
) (*"") ? @-=,)<8 "1
):+ 4* )1 , "4*
*((4 1*:4 -2*1 "* )1 1,8"
* 1" 1*"
2* *" -=,)<8 (*"") #)1
&$!* 4!(& %
$0$!"
"50 4 !(& !#. " 1 1 )/ 1*"/ (
5*"*""""):+ -
44 5
*""""
- C*1 *8 * )
"
/ 5- *" - 1*" -* )/ 4* )
44 -*" *"""")
*4 < 5
"
* )1 "- 8 *;54*""""
/:,
4+548*;
<1*41,4*
*4 </"
88 *;-*" 11, )/ :,
-*)
) "(, -*""""8 8*), ) ) 22 -*)"
4* 4+/ -=,)<8 (*""):+ E:4 -(C
-1*" 2
!"#!" $% &""'$ &!" $$(! )"* !#./ "*4"
*
*1
-1*" -* )/*" 1*"/ )2*,4
2 * * " 5*" ),
- + 8 *; 1*41,4*
/5- *" -1*" -* )/
-*"
)(
* +*8 )"(
-2*1 2*""""8 ) @ 5*" (*"") :+
44 - " ( " 1 * ) * * "
? 52 @
6 @ 2 @8
-"A"
( 8
5*"1*41,4* )* )
1*
*; -: 2
2*8 *;
*4 <-,"/ -2*1 8*
5*"1 "1
," 2*1 - " 9,
(*+ * * " 52 @
6 @/:, "
44/-)
)(
* +*8 -
44 -*" *"""")
0 ) - @ "( 8* +* <,8
1 ,4)
)(
*"
5*"5 <4+1*41,4* )"(
/ -*8 ">/
B !
* * " 52 @
6 @ 2 @
-" A
B ( 8
-# -*"
: 14,)) - *""""8
) ,
"
<4+/
- 1-*44 <) :2 - )* 2 C) 2
- / *" ) ) :+
44 - ) ) ) - 1-*44 < *""""8 ) :2 - )* 2 C) 2 ) - ? @ "0 5 -8*
/ " )" 44<*4
8(,< )=,)<8 "(*""):+ - ":4 5 11 <4+/ - 0
"* ) "") *+ / !" ) %- - "(*;
<B *"
)F G"B
%- - (
*:4F G"B