High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3356/2012dismissed

Rakesh Kanda v. Allahabad Bank And Others

2015-08-06Mr. Justice Krishna Murari13 pages

! "#$%$!

!() +

-! ..

/ * "* ,! +

1# 231 4114 55

#5 1, )( // ,&4,*6

( 1, $, 61 "'

&*6

, 0

, 1,4$8

&*6

,, 1,9 :1"% "*1, " "!

.&*6

! ,, ; 1,) ", &*6

,, 55

& !.

0,0,

, "*$!

! ( ! 0, ,, ( ! 6 ! "0

"$"* ,, < "!

$ ""* ( "% "%

,* ,0 !!

*/: .$,

*1 ,(<&= ""

>$, 5;?

,* ,0 !!

*/:.7 ,00

$, *

*1 :&= ""

>$,

5? * !8 !! "% 00.

" 0.

5 0

, $"* , ,* , @

! "* , .:!

!0 ,( !0.

* "%

( ! 80,

,, 78

. "** 5, ! "* 4 8!00 ,4 "*4:"

,% "*$!

.4 ,6 * , !0

.: ($%( !

! /$ "% ,$" /: !

,!" 0 !

%,$0 80 : >0,

,! 5, ;51 :

" "' "% ! "

"** ! 4( 00 "%80 ": (,$%(7( (

!$00.

"** ! ,7 ,* "% ""* 7( ( ,

7 8

. ( 0.

5 0

, ! , %" 80,

"* 7 ! , A$ , ,, "% 3

, , 5 5..

/ * "' ! "0 " "%/ "'7(( * !!$ *3

, ( ( !!$%(

,0 ,8 &8

,: ,0

$ . "9$"

", " "%* ,0 " "% "*("$, "%

,!,

, "%@< @*

*6 8/ ,<& "* @< ; *

8/ , & "* , " "%* ;& "

"% "',8

' "% ":

", ' "% ":0 :8 $"* /6 *3

,!, % "%

, $*( !/

"88

*/:* 5, ! ! 0.

5 0

( ! * "% /$! "

!! " "

"* !

"*$!

"* ! "% * " "$

$, "% * "% 00 , 7 , B ,* .$8 "$8 7 , ! /:

80, "%, 78

.,8* 5, ! "*( 80,

"! 7 * " 3

,! , 0 * /: 0.

(,$%(( !/ "'

,!..

/ * "' * 5, ( 0.

,( *0.

*,* ,7 (* ! "*7(7 8 "%

:( ** !0

%*!/$ "

" "* 6 (,$%( "

' "% 0.

7 ! " " 0!

'"7 /$ ,%"

,!($! 50

. !,* */:( 8( !"

*/$ 7 !/ $0" ,

" 6$,* "* .

8 "%

( ( !/

"* , $* *!

'! , ,8 ,

! "% 3

,! , .! !$%( " "

, 8 "9$"

", " "%* ,8("$, "%

*6 8/ ,<& "*

8/ ,&

(,$%(1 "* .

:( */

" ",8 /$ , $*/ "%0.

*$0" 0.

, 8 ( 6 "% "

" !$00.

%*!

: ( $, , "6 :

,: / "' * ;& (7 ,& " , 7,

" !

7 ! $," !( * /: "' 5, " "*0

: :

' "% .

( .$, $!

%, ": "

, 8 "9$"

"" %,$"*

( !% A$ ..: $!, *: /.

( 8

/:.

8 "%* ! "* "%"0, 8

" 6$, & ( ! 00.

"$"* , ,* ,@ $.

! "* 7 !* !8 !!

* "

.7 !0, ,, */ , ,!

$, ( ,!

' "% "

"! *

! * !0!

./:0 !! "% ..7 "%,* ,#5 C " 6 7 /6 * !$!! "&

. ! * !0!

* /: * ,

"% * "

7" * ! " " 8

, ,

"% ,

! "% , ((.* "% " , !0

,! , ((.* "% " , !0

*< "*&/: ,

. "%7 /6

,& "',

$ (,

*!( ../

. / : !' 0

$," !( *$8 !,

. !8 :/ A$ , *,* * "% /6

, ( "' !( .. /

. / : 80!

!$( "* " , /

" !$( ": !$( %$

, 8"

: !8 :/ ,,

* " ,* 0,6 ! "!.

7( 0

* ,

,/ , 3*, .$, " .. "&

!$0 & *$ ", !0

,! , !( .. "

* /: "' ! ,

* ,

", ,* "%"",

! "%

", !0

,!, ..& ! /

" !!$ * 8 .: 7 6 7 !

%$ ,*

! 0

, !* /:

% 6 7* :!!

": 0 :& 7( "! * ,! / %%, * /: ! " "'& "!

' *: ",

! 0 0,6 ! "! .

7 ! , & ,

& /6 "

, 8 * ,

" !(

$ 8

..:

,5!

, %( "*.

/ .

! 0

!!(

/ %6 */: ! " ..

/ * "',/:

,* ,! ":& !!$ */: .$, , ": ,80

$, .

7 !$, ,.

"!8 ( /6 !( ..( "/

, "% 8 ! 0 "* "% / , 3* . $, ( ,* .$,

$,"

."%7 0: ( ! ,*

. / "! %"

,* 8D 0 ,$!

. /6 *,* , "*

,!(, *$,

"7 !%,

..1 :&, A$ , "% 5,

! 7" * ! " ,

"% ,

! "% , 7 ((.* "%

", !0

,!,

*6 8/ ,<& "*

&%%, */: ,* ,0 !!

*/: .7 ,00

$, & 0.

( !0, ,, 0,

. ( 6 ! " 0

" ( ! /

" 6 .: 00!

* /: ;51 :

" "' "% ,( *& .

8 "%

" 6 7 9$*%8 4$0, $, "

! " "# # "$#%#&& 4 "*4

";40

& !$ ! 0, 8

" 8

! !$( "

, 8 , %,

" , !(, *$,

" /: .7 , 00

$, ! " !$!

7 ( 6 ! " 0

" 7 ! 8 ".: 00!

* " %,$"*

, / "% /$:

,& , !!$ "% "' ( 6 "% !!$

,!, &, ! "*/ "%!

,! "*, ;

, %" "' 7( ( * "

,! , %

"% "'& "'!*

. "%7 *$8 "*" (%*! "*3

, "% " "* "

"'! !!$( "'!

" "

* 7 "

/$:

, , 86 %*! !!$("

,!$ !8

", ": "9$"

$.*/ %,

* 1, ( // , ( ! *, 7"

" ( ! $, 0.

* "%! !7 *$8 !7( ( *7 " ,*

/. !(

( !% 0, 8

,"% "( ! 6$,",*

/. !(

, $*( !/

"0.

*" &

"( !/

"*, 7"

/,$ ,:<& .

"& 1 :!

!(8 $!$ ($.

8 $!$ "

,! * 5 , , %( % ! =1? 4 &1 :!

7( (( !( 0 78

. "* (,

/ ..! * "%&,% */:* 5, ! "* .! ,%$

" 0, .&& ( * .

80.

, 88 !! "

&3$*( &,, % !

" $"* ,4

"!;&;<&;E& ;< ,

*7 (4

"!;B "!

! "*&

>0,

,, 78

.,81 :!

& "3$*( ( *, 7"

" ( ! $, "

! 7( ( ,

*! ..7!#5 C (

/6 * *$8 $," !( */: >0,

* "1 :!

,!&

3$*( & 00.

& $"*

,* "% *$8 !,

*/:

"'& "! %"8 "A$ "7 !!

/ "

* " "

, << =- !!

.4- ?13 ; =- !!

. 4 -@? "* 7(

' "%7 !8 " "

,* "%

$! "! %"8 &!

* " /6 * "

,& 7 ! $"*

7 " ",8

" "

,* "%

$! "! %"8 $, , "A$ ,

,8 !( 00 "% &1 :!

/ .. .

* "% ! $," !( * /: >0,

/ "'

,! $"* ,! %"

7 $"* "*! 8 .

,.:& !( 00 "%

3$*( &" *,: 0, .! %"

* %",

/$ "

, "$8/ ! 7 "! %"8 ! " A$ " ($!&

>0,

, *7 ,: "%

$"* ,! %"

* /: !$/8

"% *$8 ! 7 "'

,! $"* ,! %"

( "

: !8 "6 !$"* .

,!, % !!$ /: $"* ,! %"

* / "'

, 7 ($ "* "% ":

. < (

" * !6 ,:

*, $*/:

>0,

!$/8 !! " ,% /,

**$8 !& $"* ,! %"

00, ( ! / "'

,! " 8 0 :8

>0,

,$"* .

,, "*7( "/ * *" %,

A$ $"* ,! %"

*&( 00, $, , %, "9$"

", " "% "',8,

! "%

" 6$, >0,

, ( "2/.

) $,

3$*( ( .,

*:, ,8,

! "% $"* .

,, !!$ */: D ( .!!$/8

1B!1 ..

"" $8F , != ?3 8

"*4

, * "%,0,

""* = 0

!"7(8! 8 .

,, $* ! 88

* /: * " 0, ? ( * .

!$ " .( %( $, , , " ! 8 .

,8! %( $, ( %,

* , ( .! 0.

* , " ,* , *

,( & ."%7 ( 8 8 0

!& ""

>$, 5E 7( " %( $, ( *0 !!

",*

7$.*/ *,8

' "% ":/ ,

' "% ":

"$"* 3

,!, $"!

. , * 5 , ; ( ! 6 .: 00!

%, ":, 50

8 "%

!$ !" "8

"** ,6 * !8 !!

$"* , ,* ,< $.

( .! ,%$

".:%,

, !

!/,

/:, !"

"*/$ *$8 !( */

"0,

*/:414 , ; 7( (7 "

,8!3

,, !!$( "

*/: ;"6 8/ ,@&7 (, !0

3, 4G @<<;@< "* "

8/ , E& 7 ( , !0

, 3 , 4 G EE; 7 ! 0 ,: 414 =, ! "* ? ! , ; 7 "

"% "' ( *$8 !7 ,7 ,* , "*( *" ,8 */:

47 1 !!

*$8 ! ( * /

0 :8 "*$

/,$ ,:& "*1 ,(& " ,* 8

,%$8 ! 1, (( // , , ,* "% , $*& .

* $"!

. , , ; ( ! !$/8

! "

"$%( , $*/$ 8$!

6 * /

, $* !7 "'!'"7.

*% !$(, $* .!

,* , "9$"

", " "%

. H

" "'%$

,!, !($.*" ,* "

, .:8 ( *$8 !( .,

*:/

"* 0

, ( 8!

*$8 !!$ "% / "' 6 * 47 1 !!

8/ ,&& "$ ,:<& "* "$ ,:& $"* ' 0 : *$ $"* ,38

$, :

/,$ ,:& "*1 ,(&"!$00, ( !"

"!, ,* "%/. %

"! !!$ "% / "'& , 7 ! 0.

* " * #& %%+#

# & @E 4 ; "*

,! =!$0, ?

"9$"

"" %,

* " %,$"* /,

(

7 .! 0.

* " & & - # " . &# ! #

#/%0#!&=;?3;=?&7( 6 ! " "( .( %( $, ( * $0( .*

" 0.

"* 6

, 8,* ,!

,* !$!! "% .

7"3

,!, ( *,* ,7 !( "% */ , 4$0, $,

!0.

9$*%8 4$0, $, 0 !!

* " !& ; ; $0(.* "% ,* ,! .( %($,

,"! * , "% ,%$8 !.

*$"!

.,/

$..:% "% (,$%( 9$*%8

*/:.

*$"!

. ,/ 0

!& 8 0 " "

$, 6 * ,*

* 1 : & ( ! , %( .: * . "

%, "

, 8 "9$"

.: " 6 %$

"! , $* "* /,

( "

/: ! "*1

* "%, $* !" !$ "$%( %, "9$"

7( 0 ,,8 3

, , !

* "%"

! * !" * !.!

": $!

! "*;( .$, "& & - # ". &# ,! =!$0, ?( !,

$"* , ,* ,<

"! 8 .

, ,$8!

!( *,* ,7 !$0( .*/: .( %($, !7 !/:4$0, $, "! "*; ( !0 "

, /: $, ! " , " "% "'! ,8 ("$, "% ,88 "*%$

! !6 ,:8

, !!

0, " 0.

"'! 8$!

0 ,8

("$, 88 7 ($ "

, /: $, > 7(

!, $*7( ( "'8$!

( "

( , !'!

"/:

,( "" 80!

*$0" "'!4 '"7.

*% "'0

" "% *, $* !"

*& (

/. !( * ",* !

' " "

, ,8 $, !! "9$"

. H

" / "' %$

, 3

,! , ! * " ( ! "

> & " / 8 ..7 "% 9$*%8 !#5

? - $#%#& ! 1& +23 4..

& -#1/

&5!& @@E4;" !( .*

"""5 !$00.:%*!/:!

/$:

,* *" /: .

, $* !$"* ,!

*/:

, "( / "' "% .

7 : 8 .:

, H "% ""586 %*! ! , $*&

"' "

, , 6 ,: " ! !

,, "" .

"/ *", $*,8 !, 0,

"( '"7.

*% "' , ,* "% , $* (

/. !( * ? "

,! =!$0, ?& !( .*

/. %

" !!$ "%/ ("$,

, , 4 * 9$*%8 7 !/ *$0"

0,6 ! "! 8 " " ,8 $!

!,$8

,:, 5=

5? , */:" /6 *9$*%8 & 0 > $, ( * ( .*

" ,* /

"9$"

!!$ "% / ! .7 :!

,: 0,6

"'( *'"7.

, $* !/ (, $* "*'"7.

*% 7( (

A$ ,

/. !( */ ,

' "% ":

"9$"

!!$ "%/ "' !.

* "

*9$*%8

!!$ "% "'(

*$8 ! 7( ( 7 0,

"% / "' /: ,& * / $.*" $,",$"* "*, $!

" %,$"*

" $, , !,$ ": 8 /: ."%

*/ "'0

*7 8"

:7 !7,"% ? " & & - # " . &# # ,! =!$0, ?& , .: "% $0" , " ,8 $!

!,$8

,:, & !/!

!" .: "$%( , $* /$ 8$!

6 *

* / "' ( * "

, '"7.

*, $* "6 7 /6 *9$*%8 !& ! , A$ ,

' "9$"

"'!( *'"7.

*% "*"

, $* ! /!

* "%! !7 !,8

.7( (( !/

0,*$ */: 50

, "6 7 /6 ,$8!

!&*" "* ":%,$"*

, " 80$%"

*,* , !8 !!

* $%$!

& =114? !

"9 :