← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3290/2014dismissed

Ajay Partap Singh v. Gurdial Singh And ORS

2015-05-13Mr. Justice Krishna Murari20 pages



       

  ! "#$ %&' ( %

*+ ",- .

"

/! 0)1 2+ ",- "1 )! .

!*"1  $#  34$  +$$+ 55 

#5 $)/ 6 ! -2&+)17

8 - $) !- ),&17

 ) *

"

) $)+0" 2- 1- &+)17

8 - $!+8

/ )9 &17

 ) !*"1 ! 55  -  !-)  :0 " 8- - ! ) :0 )  ;

 1

)9 "

1 " *) 7 ! "*

" !8-

)*

)1 ", !!9 *)7 ! "

021;

")1 )0"1 +

" <= < =    0"( ; );

"  & 

**2 - "1 , )-&)!-) > 3&

2 ", ,,) 1* )!"

1%

20"1

"'<=<;= )8-

 !0- ")1 )021;

 9*0,"

1;% 2 ", 7 ! "*

" "  ,- 0) 0"1

"'<'=   - !*) )) - !) 7 ! "*

"0"1

"'<'=  & "!

)1

1*) 2&*

!! ", *)7 ! "

1 

!8 02%9 6 ", *

"

)2 * % 

2!09 !&'&?@A5 ))

)!8 - "

"1!

! - **2   1 !)1

)!  ;

 *) 9 !

! 8- *

"

) 8 ! "10

 7 1  ) , !

1 2

 1

1 1

7 9;

)'&1 !) ;

!;

+ @5&+

) - "1 , )-- 2 "12)15) !*"1

-  !!0 "

" $ %?&'1

)9 " ", 2

8 

9;

)&'- 2 9

5 *

"

) !

 " 0"

  ) :0  "

))0* "! " *

020!

) ;

)99 2*0)*!

" 0"

;% 8!;% 19 " !

-)

!&) 8 ,)

;

!?'A5* 9"

-8 %

)BC - 

)9*) 2&?& *

!90 22%

"- )9 !?'A5* )9"

- !A5* )9"

--

5*

"

)2 9!

!

90"

8 !;

",* -)0,-)!!5 :0 ! "  70)  0)1 2 + ",-& ;

",

)"

% ) 22  2 "12)1! 7 "*

"8 ! 2 2 "12)15) !*"1 !" "0 )%&?  ,)0"1  ""5* %9   )  ! "

;)0 )%   -  !

(

*

"8 !) ! !

D*

"

)2 9 ",

 "12)1! -  )

1 )  0*  + *

9;

) & ?& ) 2% ", 0*" * %9 - ;

"9 -)0,-- :0 "1;

"6!

! -

) " 2 ,-

 (01,9 +0*)  0)  "      ! "

#$  %&'() '*'&(&<='+ ))

)!) & "

!

!&'&?@A5* % ;%$ %@&&8 -0 *) (01

"1  ; -  *

 ;

 1

)9 "

  "

2 !

 

1(01

" *

" 0"!

2 ) ; -  *

,)

 *) 9 )% "

)7 )!% 8- - !) :0 ) ;

!27 1 " *) 7 ! "*

"8021;

; 2 %   ) 7 ! " *

"!

" )1 ) 

 "

6 ", !!9 *)7 ! "

!* (01,9  "

  + <!0*) = $) / 6 !  -2& 2

)"

1 !

" ) 0"!

2 )  *

"

) - "

"1

 "7 8 7 ! " "-(01,9 - !0)  ",(') ("-  !.'#   &'&<=  < 7 2=@@& "

)9!"

"1

1*) 2&?&)1 )!*

 "

)0"1 ) +

"!& &  "1  2"

 " ; -  +

!  0"( ; "1  )% 22 )! * 1 ;%

 "

 "  !0;(

 9

) 

2   22 )1 )! 8- - 1 "   22 8 - " 9;

  ;7  !

1 +

"! " ;

1 !*0

1"2%;%8 %) 7 ! "*

"

 )- "1&$)+0" 2- 1- &2

)"

1!

" )0"!

2)

!*"1 !- !*2

1!

)",) " (01,9 +0*) 0)  "/'0(&("1**) -%*)&<=  < 7 2=?

 2 9

 * E 0)  - ! - 21

 ! *  **

0 -) %  1

)9 "

 ))

!!  )  1

)9 " ", *)7 ! "

;%

) ),0

!0- ")1 )* 0"1 (01,9 +0*) 0)  "   + <!0*) = 8021 ;

 1

 ;

" )1 ) * 1 ;%

 "

) "

) !

*8 )!0"1

"<=< =  - ),0

(01,9 * E0) 1  ! " 7 ! " "-8 "! 1 1;% ) "- ! - !0) - !;

"- 21

)9 " ", *)7 ! "

2 )  !

)  " - ! "

 - *2

1) ",( ',  '-0.'2%'& 7 2

7 ! " ?B  & 1 1 "7 9;

) &   "  !

&  **

 0 -) % ) ! ", *8 ) 0"1 )  )% );

<"

)2

"17 "= &?- "- *)7 ! "

!1

)9 "

)" 2 ,- ,(')("- +

<!0*) =;(

"8 !) 1;

)  ,-0) 2 9 ",

**

0 -) %1 1" - "%(0) !1 1

2- ! ",2  "-

6 ", "

"! 1

(01,9  7 ! " "- " ,(') (" - +  <!0*) = "1 (01,9  " /'0(& (" 1**)+ <!0*) =- 21

)*)7 ! "

!!9 )  !

")1 )8- - !* 10"1 *)7 ! "!+

" !0- 8021;

) 0"!

2 )  2 "12)15 ) !*"1 ! $) - 1-  - !0;9

-0,-+

"<=< = 1

2!8 - (

,)0"1""5* %9 ) *)7 1 ",

 "  ))

)! "1 "

 )

  BF * ""09 2",8 - !

! 

**2

" ;%

) !

"1 1"  )!

1

) ",&- 8 22;

1

1 - 102%* 1)

"1 8 - " * ) 1 *) !) ;

1 0"1 ) +

"  <= < =      -  "

*  

)9 "

"*)7 ! "

8 ! "

1)  )!

 "(01,9    + <!0*) =;% "

)*)

",+

"<=< =   - -

)12

)"

10"!

2) *

022%,"

-)0,- (01,9  ",(')("- + <!0*) = !8 22 (01,9  " /'0(& (" 1**)+  <!0*) =& " )1  1

)9 "

8-

")1 )*

)1

)9 " ", *)7 ! "

* % ;%

 " ) !

*8 )!0"1

"<=< =  ";

:0 "

1 "

20"1

"'<=<;= ) 8 22;

7 !

)0"1

"'<'= +

"

1

2!8 - "

"1  ,)0"1!+

" <= "1<=< = 8- - ) *0)*!

1  ! "

- ! &)

1! !228!#5

G 5(6&( ,&#55<=

 "*!!

!! "   ;0 21 ", ) )

1 2 "1 !- 22 "  ;

)9 " " 1

* 1;

) )

99 - ! ) )8 !

"18-

);

) )

)9 "

"

"%& *  " )1 8 - *)7 ! "!  - !!

"&<) "*0)!0 ")1 )9 0"1 ) +

"   0"( ; );

" &?& !!0;!

:0 2% "1 1= =  2 "12)1 8- !

6!  - !

 !- 22

**2%  "

) )  1 )

" "

;

2 )&

), 7 ",

!"

 **) 0"

%  !-8 ", 0!

"!

**2 & !!

! 15 = -

- !" * 1)

"1 10 ;%- 9 ") !*

;0 21 ",))

"18 - " 

"1 %!

E* )%  E 1 " ,)

"%8 -- !2 "12)1 ) " ;!

  "% !0- ,)

& ;% 1 % 9"

-"

228 ",

)8- -

 !* % H

)7 1

 

 "   )!

 -

) ", 

**2

") (

)10 !

)7 * %!)

"1 )! ))

)!  ) "1 "

 ! E *

* ""09"!0- ))

)! ,

)8 - !

**2

)&

 !- 22 ;

 1

 -  102% * 1 )

"1 8 - " ) 1I "    +  <!0*) =&  * E 0)

)*)

", ;7  !

1 *)7 ! "! - 1 - 21

 " +

"  <= < = *)7 !    &  8)1! G 1 ;%  "

)I :0 2 % " 2% 8)1! !

**2

"3;0 *)

1 ",*

   ))

)!) "1 "

! E* * ""09"!0-

))

)! ,

) 8 -  !

  **2

"    8 ! ;!

)7

 8-

, "0 "

1 !*0

)1 ",

) &:0 09)

 "!0-  !;2 ,

)%"

9 !!9  ))

)!) & "

"1!

2

"1 E*)7 ! "

;

*

" )!

1

-

) ", 8 !2 ) 

 )!

1

) ",& 8021 9

 1

  22 ",

 *)7 ! "

2 )1 ) 

"

) - 1;

";!

)7 1 " !

1(01,9

)* %9 *)7 ! "

2 )  ;%

&

 "

) 8 22 "  "

22% 1(01

))

)!) "1 " " "

1(01

" )  !0"19) *)7 ! "

&

8 22;

, 7 ""

9) **) 0"

% 9 0* "% * ) " "/'0(&("1**)+ <!0*) =& +0*) 0) 8

1 0*"  1

)9 "

 "

)7 )!% 8-

)   E ",

*)7 ! "

;

9 ! "

"1021" ;

- ", 1!0;!

:0 2%& "

2- ", ", ) "- :0 "8- -8 !) :0 )

;

1

)9 "

* E0)  "/'0(&("1**)+ <!0*) = !228!#5 G - 9 ":0 ")1

)9 "

" " - !

2& ;%!*

22

& !#

1 !" 2- !) 1%

- ", ) *)7 ! "

 E 10"1 +

"<=< =*)7 !  0"( ; );

"  &  <) !-) & J

  K= $9 ()("**)% '6&( 3:

;:$; (&('1 %! )9 1

  !0- )1 )& 8-

)  E ", *)7 ! "

;

9 ! "

"" ;

- ", !0;!

:0 2%&* )2%& "

2- ", ", )1 ) "< 9*- ! !!0**2 1=I -  "3;2  +0*)  0)

6 ", "

 "! 1

*)7 ! "  +

"  <= < = "1 +

" ' <= <;=    (01,9    + <!0*) =&*)7 ! "!+

"?&  "1' ;!

)7 !228!#5 G +

"'<=<;=

*)7 1

* )!" ,,) ")1 )*

)9 %*)

**

0 -) % 8 - "  *) !) ;

"H 1 ! "  !

%

  "% ,,) 1 * )!" ;%



)20 )% )1 )*

 "

)9 8- -

2 2 ! 1 ! "

)9& -  !- 22

) ;

 *) 1 )9 1 !*0 ", !))

!!-  !"*)7 ! " " +

"'<=<;=& *)7 ! "2 6 +

"'<=

"1+

"? 1     "1 " 9* 1 9  ) ,,) * )!"& " )

1 ", +

" '<=<;=   

&

" "

)20 )%)1 )8- -- 1" ;

-0,-

22 %&021" ;

", 1 "

2)9  "

2)1 )"0) * " "& +

" '<=<;= 1 ! "  9 9*

 0*"  * )!" ,,)

)9 " "

)20 )%)1 "1& - 1 !" 1 !&- !) ,- ,

!)

18- "- - ",  "

2)1 )   ! )0

")1 ) "228!

)0)!

   !""59*2 )1 ) 1

)9 " ", *)7 ! "

2 )  ;0  8-

- ", )

2!- ", ) E

"*)7 ! "

 5 )  "& " ! "

0) & ;

", * "1  "  ))

!!  )  E ",



*)7 ! "

;

"," "1

 "

)% " +

" '<=<;= 5  90!

 ;

*  **

 0 -) %  , "

))

!!!0-*)7 ! "

2)1 )8- "*0  " !!0 I - * E0)  "/'0(&("1**)+ <!0*) =0) 21 !228!#5 G -   ,- 0) & -8 )& - 21

1 1" 2- !) 1% - ", )1 )  E ", *)7 ! "

2 )  10) ",  * ) 1 ;

 1

  "1 1

  E 1 ) * %9 &  **

 0 -) % 021 "  - ,"

 "

 9 !  !0- 1

)9 "

"1&

)1 ",2%& !

! 1 )   **

0 -) % " 0) 7 8&   ,- 0)   22 "

,) ))) "8-

- 21- 2 2*!

"& " 0) * " "& ! - !# C-

 1 ! " ", )    E

"  *)7 ! "

 * 1 0"1 ) +

" <=< = *)7 ! "

2 0"1 ) +

" '<=<;= 2!  2! 9*2%8 -

)& ) "90!

228 !* *)7 ! "!"

1 " 

;0 8-

- ",

 " "

2! - ",

)1

)9 " ", *)7 ! "

&  !" *  **

 0 -) %  ) 0!

"! 1  2 % "1 7 2 1 % 

)9 " ", *)7 ! "

" ,)0"1

))

!!!0-)1 "" ;

9 "

!"

28 ! 2 1)9

-0,-

22 % )9  " 

! *) & **

0 -) %1 1" 99 "% ))) " 22 ",0*"

 "

 1

)9 "

))

)!  & "

"1 !

) !-

K!

  * %9 8 )1! )  )9 *) 2& ?8 !"

22) )) "1"! 1

) )  ,-0) 228 !

"1& 8021 ! " "9 "  "(0!

"1 ) !02  " 9 !

))   (0!

!90-

8021;

-)8"0

1*) 9 !

-0,-- 9 %" - ;

" "

))

)!  )  "   )09!

!& )

)9 "

" ))

)!) & "

"1!

;%

 "

)& ! 1 )

1 ;% **

 0 -) %& 8021 !0;!

)7 "1! 

 (0!

")

)9 "

"&

 !0"1 ))

)!  ) "1 1 ! "  1 *!

A* %

90"

! 1

)9 "

1 ;%

 "

) "

& ! 9 % ;

 1 )

1& ;7 0!2% -  8021 !0 ) "I * )0!

2 (01,9  "/'0(&("1**)+ 2

)2% "1

8- 2 , 7 ", ;7 !

11 09& * E0) - !*2

" 7 ! " "-(01,9  ,*0) ,-0)  "9  9 <'(  &' 20$('(("('

%0("2&'(9   ,*0)&8- 8 !;!

)7

  ) ,-

2 ! "

" )) " " ;!

"% - ",0)

2 ", &022**) 0"

% 90!

;

)1 ,,) 1* % ) !

- 1 ) !

"1 !0

1& "% !0;!

:0  *)

1 ",! 8- - 9 2

"!

"% ) ,- !- ;

"! "

2 22 ,)0"1...8- 2 8, 7

* )!" 8) !-  !

2- 9!

2

) 90"2 !!

%  ""! !

 + (01,9  ",(')("- + <!0*) = ! "

)"

1& * )0!

2 !

1(01,9  "1

 7 ! " "-

" "

"! 1

"7 ) 0!"

"!)9*) 2&? 22 *) 2&?B ")1 1

)9 "

8-

(01,9 /'0(&(" 1**)+  <!0*) = 8021 ;

**2  " 7 8   !*    "

"!- 7 "," ;

" "

"! 1

" 8 !;!

)7

"3;2  7 ! " "-

"

"! ") !*

)1 )!8- -



&8 " "! 1 * E0) !!0-)

1 ", "

"

 !!0 !) "11 1& (01,9 /'0(&(" 1**)+  <!0*) = 1 ! "  2 % 18" "% *)*!

"  2 8

22 )1 )!*

- ) "  7 ! " "-(01,9

1! !228!#5 G< =   "

" 1

1 ? ! !

22 -21 ",   21 ;% 8- - "2% " )1 ) * 0"1

"!&&L !9

&

" 8-

22 )1 )! * 1 ;%

"

)- ;

9

 "

)9! "

?A55?BA?'

?B !!0 7 )"9 0"( ;M <;= C-

 ;!

)7

"   +0*) 0)  "* '  )( + ",- 2/! "0* "!

2<+0*) =  <=+B?&EEE EEE8- 2 )) ", +

"'<=<;= 

0"( ; );

" &"2%& !

";!

)7

" ""



!

8 !" !!0 9

; 2 %

) ) 7 ! " ) ! ", 0    "

)20 )% )1 )! ;

)  !") +

"'<'=  )+

"'<B=  )% );

<"

)2

"17 "= &?M

<= C-

)! * 1 ;%

"

) 10) ",  *)

1 ",! ) ! ", "- *8 )!2 6  " "19 *2

1 ",!& 9*2

*

!&!

", ! 1

E *

 *)

1 ",!& ) )

"  *



 7 !

0"1

"'<'= 

0"( ; );

" &MI

"1 ",  7 ! " "- ! !228!#5 G? - ;7  1 2 "

1 *) " *2 !  2 8 :0 ) ;

6 *  "7 8;

) "%)  ! *2

1 0*"  (01,9    "K;2  +0*) 0)  "  )(  + ",- 2K!  <!0*) =& " :0 " 8 ! ) 1 ) 1 ;

22 )1 )! * 1 ;%

 "

 ) "  -  "

"! " ) !*

  )1 )! 8- -

 8  "  ;)0,-  "

 

"K;2 0) -  "1 ",!) )1 1- ;

 )

1 "  "

   !!0 ! ) 1 - )0"1 ) - ",  8 " )1   E

"  *)7 ! "

2 )  * 1 10) ", * "1 "% "*

"+0-)1 )8 ", 1 "

"!

 "

2)1 )

" "

)9!   "

" 1

?& ")1 ) " !

- 0)  - ! - 21

)   E

"  *)7 ! "

2 )  021 ;

 - ", 1 "

"!

)  "   8 ! " & 8- "2% ")1 ) E

"*)7 ! "

! !0;(

9

)  - ",  -  "K;2 +0*)  0)  - ! ) ) ) * 1 ;%

 **

 0 -) % 8- 2  !

", ! 1 )1 ) * 1 ;% - ! 0)  "  ) 7 ! " *

" -  ;!

)7

"!

 "

)20 )% )1 )   E

")  !

 ! ";

)& ! "

) &

28 ! 2 "!

 "

)1 ) "&8- "- ", 8 !9

" "

)20 )%)1 )* 110) ", * "1 "%   *)

1 ",! - ) &  (01,9  "  )(  + ",- 2K!  <!0*) = 1 ! "  2 % 18" "%*)*!

"2 8

22)1 )!* ;%

...  - ) &8 "!8 :0 "!) ;%-21 ",

 "

)9! "

"1

?& )1 )! *

 "

0"1

"!&&L 2"

"; - +

! 0"( ; "1 )%

22 ))1 )!*

" !0;(

9

)

2 )1 )! )1 )!8- -

& ";

1 !*0

1"2% ;%8 % 7 ! "*

";

) - !0) I -  7 ! " "-- -0!- 21

) E

" *)7 ! "

& " "

)20 )%)1 )&- 21 ;

;% * E 0) & !"2%;

) - (01,9  ",(')("- + <!0*) = "1

"% )1 ) * 1 0"1 ) +

"! & &  "1       !

) ; - " +

!  0"( ; "1  )%

22  )1 )!*

" !0;(

9

)

2+

)1

)9 " ",*)7 ! "

 !"

)"

1&  ! ")1 )* ;%

 "

) " ) !

 *8 )! 0"1 ) +

" <= < = *)7 ! - !

1)1 )9 %;

)9 " "

)20 )%)1 ;0 +

"'<=<;= "%* )!"  2

"!

!0-)1 )8 - "'1 %!)9 1

);

) **

0 -) %- ) "/'0(&("1**)+ <!0*) =8- - !;

") *)10 1- ;7 2

)2% "1

+0*) 0) !"! 1 *)7 ! "!+

"<=< = "1+

"!'<=<;=

   8 -  2 2 !

)% *) !09*

) 1

)9 " ", *)7 ! "

2 )   E 1 0"1 ) +

"  <= < = *)7 !     !

)0"1

"'<=<;= 

- :0 "8- -8 !1

)9 "

1 "

8 !8-

"%!0-)1 ) E ",*)7 ! "

8021;

 "

2&" - ",

 "

28- 2 - ", ",  "

2)1 ) "- ) !

" ) *)10 1 - 0"1 ) "1

",

)  !!9   *)7 ! "

 !

)0"1 +

!+

"'<=<;=

1 !" 9 1 !

";

")1 )* 10"1

& "

"1 "

)20 )%#5 G - 9 ":0 ")1

)9 "

" " - !

2& ;% !*

2 2

& !# 

 1 ! "

2 - ! ) 1%  - ", )  *)7 ! "

2 )   E 1 0"1 ) +

" <=< = *)7 !  0"( ; );

 &<)!-) &J

K=$9 ()(" **) % ' 6&( 3:

;:$; (&( ' 1 %! )91

!0-)1 )&8-

) E ", *)7 ! "

2 )  ;

9 !  "

""  ;

", 1!0;!

:0 2%&* )2%& "

", ", )  " < 9*- ! ! !0**2 1=I  * )0!

2  ;7  !

1 * "

  1

)9 "

"20! " )) 7

 "/'0(&("1**)+ <!0*) = "1

;!

)7

"   * E 0)  *

" ",  9

; 2 % 

0"1

"'<=<;=  !" ;!20

2%2 9

1) 1  ! "

*)"0"

1- ;!

)7

" "/'0(&("1**)+ <!0*) = "" ;

"! 1 ;

9 !

%;!

)7

"&  ,") ;%;!

)7 ",

""

"!)

",

2!0"1

"'<=< = " "! 1 * E0) - * E0)  "('6&'  &&)#&-. &' -**' &'& + '@- 21

1  ! " "(01,9 +0*) 0) "" ;

 ,)0"1

!*

! 8  "  "! 1 1 )  ) *)7 ! "!8 " ;)0,- "

0)  ! * E0)  "/'0(&("1**)+ <!0*) =-

" "

"! 1

22 !*

! 2 8 "201 ", +

8& 1  ! " +0*) 0) "" ;

- 21 ;

;

)1

 !& ) &- 21

(01,9 +0*) 0)  "/'0(&(" 1**)+  <!0*) = ! ; "1 ", 0*" - ! 0)  0"1  *)7 ! "!  )     "!

"  "1  ;

",  *)

  7 "   ! *) !09

"%;!

)7

") )1 ",9

; 2 %

2 !   !

22 8 22- !0;!

2)   (01,9  "/'0(& (" 1**)+  <!0*) = !

" "

 "! 1

"  -   ,- 0)

""

7 8

1 !" ; "1 -

)9>2 81 139

"! " "2%     1  ! ";0  "201 " 

2!*)7 1  !0*" * "

),0 1" - !"

" ;

 9  (#) 5(  &%'5 (   ' 22 ;

1 B& 2('=) 5(.

 '

'&#%'&(" # %'&(" ''22'&$%>  )%#(&'

 B22@?& %(" &&& B22& %   &&&   ?B 9;

%  "1  '

 (" =#$  1(    (&  ' + ?    8 ! 9  2

);% +0*)  0)  " ! 5)  2?# ' '& ?+@@

"%, 2;!

)7

"" **2% " "

)*)

", *)7 ! "! " 0"2 !!  +0*)  0)  - **2 ! 9 "1 2%N *)7 ! "!

* )  " *) & *)7 ! "!+

"!<=< = "1' < = <;= " "

    +  <!0*) = - 7 ", ;

!* 22%

" "

 "! 1

"1 1 1& ""  ;

 !

+0*) 0) 1 1" **2%9 "1 " "

)*)

", *)7 ! "!2 8

""  ;

 !

 * )9 !! ; 2 % 

"!

) 0"1 +

"<=< = ;

",

& !"2% ";

)1 09 "7 8 ;7  )09!

!& "1 ",9%!

2;0"1;%

(01,9  "/'0(&("1**)+ <!0*) =& - ;

- 21

- ! 7 ! "*

" !" 9

 - 7 ! "*

" !1 !9 !!

1  !- 21

 "7 8 (01,9  " /'0(& (" 1**)+  <!0*) =&  "

) 9 )1

)9 " ", *)7 ! "

 ! ")1

0"1

"'<= <;= 

7 ! "*

"!

!

1)1 ) !" 9

0"1 ) +

" ' <'=      -  *

"

) ! -0! )

)"

1% 2 ",

2;

) **

0 -) %"

(0!

&  !)1

 "

) 9)1 )1

1$ %B&

 8 22) "*

22  2 ",

2

2- 7 ",;

 2 1& 8 22;

1 !)

"**

0 -) % * !! "%)1 ) "

)1 8 -2 8  !9 2

 "

2 !"  2 18 - " * ) 1'1 %!

* 1*% )& "

) 9 ,)

17 1 )1

1$ %B&8 22

*

  - ", 9 "

1 " - ! )1 ) ) "  "

) 9 )1 )& 8 22 -8 )& *) (01 1(01

"   ) ,- !   *

! ;% **

0 -) % " ) !

*8 )!0"1

"'<=<;=   $ %&' <$$+= !

"( %