← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3157/2018dismissed

Rishi Raj Chauhan And ANR v. Arun Sharma

2018-08-18Mr. Justice Arun Monga12 pages

 

     

 !"##$%&%'(   

%&)% !*)!+)!'!',!'")#-  #"%"%'#-&  .#-&+& -+'/)!-0!

 #&1',#'"

 (



    

    



 

   

 

 

 !



   



" 

#$ #% &# '

 ,-" .,-

/

0 1--"2 () + 



 - 3 &%

-+ %  

2  &!

5 + 

- 3 &%

-+ %  

** 

 -"

++"

&6 #7 &# #  

+ ,-" .

/

0 1-"   &6 #7 &# #  #' #& &# %   +

%!

+ 8  - 2

-

 8

 +  -  )   -( 2

"2 ++ &# &##7 ( 6!

/- )

-    (

&6 #7 &# # 5   - 2    )   2+)



 *- 2 * +     ) ( " -

    (  



 

:

- #76<  $ 1-"

(

+  #% &##6 "2

++ &# &##7 #$ & &##7  =- (  ()  " ++ - 

 7######8< - +) "" >5* :

- ?

 > / -+ )

- -  



  +

 -

- -+

( @;

/- * @  +

 -

/ -+

(  2 



- :) A( /+ 2 - ) .:A/0

 -

9     +



 -

B-

) -   -

 ++ )   2

=-

"



+ 

 -  +

 -

2)    

- + :A/  - - 

 " B-   -  +

 -

-+ 2+) -  B-

+   

 64#####8<

"

)

 +

4!

+ - 2

-

 -   2 +   "

 -  5 - 2

-

  (

++ 2 

<  

    

      

    

  

 

  !



  



         

   "  

  

 

#



"

 

!

" 



 

 

#

  



$%&' 

$"

       !!   ""

( ) & * +

 

 

+ "

, 

  # 

     

   

""()&* 

 -"



  "  !!

   

 +

 " 

 

 ""



    . 

  

 

   /    

 ! 

  

"

#

   +   + "  



 " !

 

    

 

  !





        

  

     !

"

  

 

#

 0 

  

 " "

 



 

  

+



!

  

    "  +

 /

" !

"

#



 

  

+

#



  



  "!



 "!"  

 



"

!

"  

      



 

   

 

+ 

  

  

  "!" 



!  

 !1





  

 " "

      

  

    

  +   "  

  2

#

  3 C!

3 (

   (   -" -+ (   + 

2 2 ( 

=

 

+ ,-" .

/

0 1-" 

&6 #7 &# # ++ <

  45 *6"

7 +*+ 

!   5   !7 +*+ 

  



-!   !!



 

 

"+

  8 

"   

  !

   

 !  

     "!""

! 

 '"!"9/ '

 ! 

 

   

  !

  

   

  !   

 2 

!   :+ 

  

"         

  !   

!        !     "!" '"!"9/ '

"

!

 

    "!   "  .;  -0

+ ,-" . /  0 1-"  &6 #7 &# # D $!

 2

 +

-

(

 2+   9  + 

- 

%%  

4  4& 4%   + 

   + 

++  

#' #& &# % B-  #' #& &# % 

 '!

5 =-

 

(

%# &# % :  

 

=-

 

- 2

-

 + +

  2

-

 + "+ " =-

 

- 2

-



+) ( =-

2

3 &

-+ %& /

+ ++" - 



 -  -+

++  )   

-  )  

 7######8< /

++"

"(  )

  "

- 

 2 = - ) -  

   )

-) - --+ 2 : - ++" "2

++ &# &##7 #$ & &##7 -+2) "2 ++ 4 #& &# #  =- - =+

-

+) +

( /

- ++" 

-  )

++)



B- 

 (- B-

- 

)

 ++" -

-

  





B-

 &4#####8< 2  - - ) 

   #$ & &##7 ++ #% #& &# #   





#% #& &# # + 2+  

 &4#####8< 



) )  B-

-2

 %#####8<

 &&#####8<  +)

7!

/ & +

(

"  =-

&' # &# 6

(

 &  +

 -(

2

-

=-( )

 

- 2

-

 #!

(

  

 !

E=- 

#7 #$ &# 6 2 

(



 8



6$#%

&# 6 :

" 

(



8-"2 ( 

+ 

 - 



2

-

(-



()

"

 " "2 ++   )

=-

+  "  8-"2 ( 

2  (+



 

-+ % 3 &% <     +) - 

+ 

      

    !"

#$%%&'() '

)&(%'*+) # ,  -

!

  - -  # . !"

#(/0% ') (&01

  + 

  )

"

++)

+-

2 -( 2

 (   + )

 

-   ( B-



=-

  "

-  2  ( )

- =-



 ( B-

 E=-

=-  ( 



-  "

B-

   + 

-"

- - 

(  (  5 + + +

-

 +(+ -"2 (

=-

 + + 2+) (- - )

- 2

-

  -   2  (

2 +  + 2 )

 ()

2

+2 "



 +

2  (+

(

-"2 ( 8

  2  :

" 

' #& &# 4  &!

9  + 

- 3 &%

-+ %  

2

(

(+

8





-  B-

 &4#####8< "+ "

   

B-

 &4#####8<





#% #& &# # " (  

)



 &&#####8<

 %#####8<  + -" ( =+ 

" -



(-  

(  (  



 -+)

    + +

 - 



B-



 + 



 +

+  2  -+)  +

(

   

=-

  2  E=- 

#7 #$ &# 6 "   

6$#%

&# 6 +

2  :

"

' #& &# 4

 %!

9 +  + 

" F

+ 

- 3 &%

-+ %  -



 

?

+)

(

 

+ 



  -+ 2+) 

-+2 

2 + E=-

#7 #$ &# 6 :

"

' #& &# 4

6$#%

&# 6  +) ++"

8





 

 &4#####8<      B- C 6747 #$ & &##7    

-  (-  2+  

(    )

 - )

 &4#####8<  



#% #& &# # - (+

B-



 

/    ++"

 2+ 

  

= )  (



2+    +) 



 ( " -  +-

=

++"  ++"     ( - = )  

+"

 

9 )

(

 + (  E=-  "- (  :

"

 6!

-2 E= G 8H   

2+

  + $ & &#

=

    2 

"2 ++ #$ & &##7 

 -

 64#####8<   ) E )

- B- # &#& # &#&&

 &' #7 &#

"

(   - + 2   +"2



 )    )2

 64#####8< E

  22- 

-2

++" -

=

 &4#####8< F<<  (





#% #& &# # +

 4!

9

 )

 -2





(

8" - (

+ 

- 3 &%

-+ %  

 +) (   (  E=-

2

(

   2 

#7 #$ &# 6



6$#%

&# 6 "  

+ 2  :

" 

' #& &# 4 5

(

(  E=- -  )

(

  ++)  5

(

 

 -+ "

 ) " 8

 "



2

+ 

- 3 &%

-+ %  

+   + -+ 



(

+  #' &#  +

 =

 C!

5 

( 

2-"

#$ #% &# '



 ,-" .,-

/

0 1--"2

- ( - ) 

-  

- ( 



) 



  9 



- ( ++) 

2 

  "+) 2 

-"- ' &# '

 /



 G 

"8  I8;

G  (+ I8;