High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/319/2023allowed

Executive Engineer v. Janak Singh Deceased Through His Lrs.

2026-03-18Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja3 pages

1 1 1 1 : : : : +'%13 +'%13 +'%13 +'%13 139C9 139C9 139C9 139C9: D!

D! %2* *1&"

%2* *1&"

%2* *1&";

;

; C: 9C9 9C9 9C9 9C9<

%'*'*1&%$

!" !" !" !"

$% %&'" !$ !$ 31$ ! ! ! ! # !

# !

! ! ! ! ()*&+,+-*+ +$.+& &+ )+*-%&/%$*&0)*--/,12+'

'% '

+44*/%1+-- $% 41&/%&'1 ')$180))+'

AAAA $+- $+- $+- $+- 56 . 7+. 13 4$% %&' $%,* *1& 4%'*'* *1& 3*-%/ 8&/%$ $'*2-% 99E 13 ')% 1& '*'8'*1&13 &/*+2)+--%&0%)+ (%%&-+*/'1 1')%1$/%$/+'%/:C C 9C94+

%/ (.')%-%+$&%/ //*'*1&+-* '$*2'8/0%+*') )+->28B>F%28'*&018$'7)%$% %(. ')%4$*,+'%$% 1&/%&'1 =-+&/17&%$(%*&021 1> *&')%+2?8*$%/-+&/7 7+ 318&/ %&'*'-%/ '1 ')% 0$+&' 13 *B*-+$ (%&%3 3*'

13 %&)+&2%/ 21B4%& +'*1& 13

9:9;;<=> 4%$ +2$% +-1&0 7*') +-- '+'8 8'1$. (%&%3*'

8&/%$ ')% $%-%, ,+&' 4$1,* *1& 13 ') )% 2' *& '%$B 13 ')% 7+$/ / /+'%/ :C CE 9C@ 4+

%/ (. ')% -%+$&%/ %3%$%&2 2%18$'*& + %1 913 39C: 596 %* *&0+00$*%,%/')%$%13')%4%'*'* *1&%$4$%3%$$%/')%4$% %&'$%,*

*1& 4%'*'*1& 5:6

%+ +$&%/'+'%218& %-31$')%4%'*'

'*1&%$ 8(B*'

')+'1&2%')%4$*, ,+'% $% 41&/%&'=-+&/ 17&%$/*/&1'2)11 %'14$%3%$$ $%3%$%&2%8&/%$%2'*1&;1$9;

;> 13')% +&/2?

?8* *'*1&2';@)%218-/&1 1')+,%(%%&+7+$/%/')%(%&%3*'

'13

%&)+&2%/B+$G% %',+-8%/%'%$B*&%/*&3+,18$1 131')%$21> 31$')%+2?8* *$%/ -+&/B%$%-.(.4 4$%3%$$*&0+&%F%28'*1&+44-*2+'* *1& 5@6 ) )+,% )%+$/ -%+$&%/ 218& %- 31$ ')% 4+$'*% +&/ 4%$8 %/ ')% 4+ +4%$ (11G 56 )% %+31$% +*/-%0+-*

8%+-$%+/. '

'+&/ /%2*/%/(.')%1&H(-%4 4%F 18$',*/%/%2*

*1&/+'%/: C 9C9< : C 9C9< : C 9C9< : C 9C9<4+

%/*& &*,*-44%+-1

: *,*-44%+-1

:>:;

;13 ;13 ;13 ;13 9C9< I -4 9C9< I -4 9C9< I -4 9C9< I -4 1 @:9 1 @:9 1 @:9 1 @:9>@: 13 9C9:

@: 13 9C9:

@: 13 9C9: '*'-%/ K +B4)+- D $ K +B4)+- D $ K +B4)+- D $ K +B4)+- D $ %$ %$ %$ %$ $

$ +$.+&+'+'% +$.+&+'+'% +$.+&+'+'% +$.+&+'+'% &/8 '$*+-&/&3$+ '$82'8$%% &/8 '$*+-&/&3$+ '$82'8$%% &/8 '$*+-&/&3$+ '$82'8$%% &/8 '$*+-&/&3$+ '$82'8$%% %,%-14B%&'1$41$+'*1& *B*'%/ %,%-14B%&'1$41$+'*1& *B*'%/ %,%-14B%&'1$41$+'*1& *B*'%/ %,%-14B%&'1$41$+'*1& *B*'%/ /D /D /D /D $ J $ J $ J $ J7)%$%*&') )%1&H(-%4%F18$')+ (%%& &4-%+ %/'184)1-/')%2-+*B B +/% (.')%21> $ 7*')$%0+$/'1%&'*'-%B%&'13

*B*-+$+B18&'1321B4%& +'*1& &+ 0$+&'%/*&3+,18 8$13')%*$21>17&%$ *&')%+2?

?8*$%/-+&/)17%,%$$% '$*2'%/ ')% +7+$/ 13 *&'%$% ' %-%,+&' 4+$+ '1 @ 3 3$1B ')% +31$% +*/ /%2* *1& /+ +'%/ : C 9C9<+$%% %F'$+2'%/)%$%8&/%$"> K & 3+2' 7% )+,% (%%& *&31$B%/ +' ')% +$ (. ')% -%+$&% &%/ 218& %- +44%+$*&0 31$ ')% +4 +44%--+&'

7)*2) * &1' %$*18

-. /* 48'%/ (. ')% -%+$&%/ %&*1$ 218& %- +44%+$*&0 31$ ') ')% $% ')% 3+2' ')+' ')% -+&/ 7)*2) 7+ +2?8*$%/ )+ (%% %%& 8'*-*L%/31$')%48$41 1331$B B+'*1&13*&/8 '$*+- *'% +&/+--1''% '%/ '1')%&%%/.4%$ 1& *&+221$/ /+&2%7*')')% 8-% ')%&4$%,+-%& &' & 1')%$ 71$/ ')% +2?8*$*&0 0 (1/. * +- 1 (%&%3*'%/ '1 2%$'+ +*& %F'%&' 7)*2) * +& *& '$8B%&'

&'+-*'. 13 ')% '+'% )8 ')% 2+- -% )+,%'1(%(+-+&2%/*&')* 2%& &+$*1 9 % +$% 13 ')% 21& *

*/%$%/ ,*%7 ')+' +4+$' 3$1B ') ')% 21B4%& +'*1&')%+44%--+&'

7 718-/(%%&'*'-%/'1')%*&'%$% '31$ $+ 4%$*1/133*,%.%+$ '1(%$%2G G1&%/3$1B'1/+.(+2G7+$/ +&/7 7% B+G%*'%F4-*2*'-.2-%+$')+'')% )%+44%--+&'

+$%&1'%&'*'-%/31$+& +&. *&'%$% '31$+&.1')%$4%$*1/ %718-/+- 1)+ '%&'1+//')+'') ')% +44%--+&'

718-/ (% %&'*'-%/ '1 +-- 1')%$ 21& %?8%&'*+- (%&%3* 3*'

7)*2) 3-17 3$1B +7+$/ 13 21 21B4%& +'*1& +&/ ')% $%

+8')1$*'*% )+--21B48'%')%21 21B4%& +'*1&+ )+ (%%&/%'%$B*&% &%/

(.')%+7+$/4+

%/8&/%$%2 %2'*1&;13')%2'+&/=1$B1/*3*% *%/ (.')%*0)18$'1$')* 18$'

'*&%F%$2* %13+44%--+'%M8$* /*2'*1 1& : )% +*/ /%'%$B*&+'*1& & )+-- (% B+/% (. ')% +8')1$*'* *% %F4%/*'*18 -.+&/+'+&.$+'%7 7*')*&+&18'%$-*B*'13')$%%B1&'

') 3$1B')%/+'%13')* 1$/%$+&/ /')%+B18&'

1/%'%$B*&%/ )+--( (% /* (8$ %/ 7*')*& +& 18'%$ -*B*' 13 ')$%% B1&') 31$ 82) /%'%$B*&+'*1&7*')*&'%$% '+

4%2*3*%/')%$%*& @ &')%%,%&'13'*B%-*&% %7)*2))+ (%%&3*F%/(.')* 18 8$' * &1' +/)%$%/ '1 (. ')% $%

+8')1$*'*% ')%. )+-- ( (% -*+(-% '1 4+. *&'%$% ' I &*&% % 4%$ 2%&' N 1& ')% +B18&'

1 2)/%'%$B*&+'*1& J /%'%$B*&%/3$1B')%/+'%13 5<6 &, ,*%713')%+31$% +*//%2* *1&$% %&/%$%/(.')%1&H(-%4%F1 8$' ')%4$% %&'4%'*'

*1&(%*&0/%,1*/13B%$*'

* )%$ $%(./* B*

%/ 5E6 )% %-%+$&%/F%28'*&018$'* $% %?8% '%/'1%F4%/*'%')%$%-%+ %13 21B4%& +'*1&+ B18&'*&3+,18$13$% 41&/%&' 1 >-+&/17&%$7)*-%G%%4*&0 0*& ,*%7 ')% 4%2* 3*2 +&/ 2+'%01$*2 /*$%2'*1& *

8%/ *& +B4)+-H 2+

+B4)+-H 2+

+B4)+-H 2+ %

$+ 4%2*+--.7)%& &*')+ &1'(%%&/* 48'%/(.')% 4%'*'*1&%$

')+'$% 41&/%&'1 1 > -+&/17&%$ )+44 4%&%/ '1 (% ')% 21> 1 13 ')% +44-*2+&'

7)1 4$%3%$ $$%/ $%3%$%&2% 8&/% $%2'*1&;13')% +&/2?8* * *'*1&2';@+&/%&)+&2%B B%&' 7+ 1$/%$%/*& ')%*$3+,18$ 41&/%&'1 > -+&/17&%$ )+--+- 1(%%&'*'-%/ /'1 ')%+7+$/13B+ +$G%',+-8%7)*2)7+ 3*&+--./%'

'%$B*&%/7*')$% 4%2''1')%$%-+ +'%/ +2?8* *'*1& 5;6

%& &/*&0+44-*2+'*1&

*3+&. )+-- +- 1 '+&//* %/13

! !+$2) !+$2) !+$2) !+$2);

;

;9C9 9C9 9C9 9C9< '*G ) ) )%')%$ 4%+G*&0=$%+ 1&%/ %

)%')%$$%41$'+(-% %