Gajraj Singh And Another v. Ashok And Others

 
 
 



! 

"# $%

!&'()"(* +#,-  ".("./ !0,"!$"!#,( # !( 1( )  ,2"!$#,(  3!$!#
4& 564/
1 7/6 ( !#& 4(4, #"(0-$ %"#

(#,3# !(  4(/)8 #/"!09"!-$ %"#

(#,( 3!$!#  7/6-:6;

,  "  %

 (

!  3# !  )!$(  (#   +    #,
! # #)# !$ " ( ## !0"

$#,($($"#$ <  3" $'* #( 
)(#- 

$  9, %,  #,  "33

%"# ! 

$  '*  #,  3# !(  (  #, ="8 !"# #,

!0(3( !#=3(#," '!$ $  ,3

>3# !( ,"$

$" ) ($% "("# !'* !0)3!#,

8!#9, %,9" "

0$ *"((

$"# !#,*"(

"!$(0"($ !09, %,#,(9" "9( !0$"#$ 

, "

) # 9" 

! #,  *"(  <  ! #,  9( ##! #"#8!#

$ '* #, %!# # !0( 3!$!#  "!$>$ !$"!#  "!$- #9" $!

$#,"# "!* )%,

8!# (#23 "%"!$ #9"  #"#$#,"#! )%,

8!#9"  0!$'*#,"! 9( !0$ !$"!# (#,( 0"

, ( "!$#, "

8!#9" !

((

%#$ !#, !)(%($ " %!#83 "#$)!$(/%# ! ? #,)!."'6"!$

 !)%#- @@+ ?

!# !$ 3)##,"##,3

$!%"!$

! 3 # #,"'  #"!$#"2!'*#,%!# # !0( 3!$!#  "!$ >$ !$"!#  "!$-!

!0(3( !#=3(#,"$'!="8 !$'*#, 3# !(  "!$  #  9"  !

*  9,!  #,  %"   9" 

=$  (  (')##"

 "!$ "(0)8!# #,"#"!"33

%"# !:!!=)(AB;9" 

$'*#,3# !( # ="8 !#,

!0(3( !#=3(# !(')##"

$!%, "

$"33

%"# !9"

33 $'*#,( 3!$!# '*

!0"(3 *:!!=)(A ; !9, ,"$'! #"#$#,"##, 0!"#)( !#,"

8!#,"$'!

$!

$'*#,%!# # !0( 3!$!#  (8#,'0 !!

!0"!$#,3

,"$"

$" 8"!*"  B33(#)!

(8 @

 # @ < ?"!$ 9,!#,%" 9" "##, "0!$-#,3( !#"33

%"# !,"$'!

$- 9, %,9" !#8"

!#"

!"'

 B ,#(

$($($"#$ <  ," (.%#$#, "

"33

%"# !'*' (

!0#,"##, "8," '!

$"##, "0!$-9,!

#,%" 

=$ ((')##"

"!$"(0)8!# "!$#,"#"##,"# #"0-!

$!%9, %,#,3

 ,) $,"

!#,"

%) $'

9$#' $ #," "

'!!# %$#,"##,( !"

"

## 8!#$"#$ 

," !#'!3($)%$!(%($"!$#,"##, (3(#9, %,," '!3(3"($'*#,3

","!$9( !0=3(#,"

'!3(3"($9 #,)##,3(8

#,
)(#

6"(!$  %)!

(  #,  3# !(  ,"  )'8 ##$  #,"#  #, 3# !( ,"$8 $"!"33

%"# !#="8 !"

!0(3( !#=3(# (')##"

$!%"!$ !%" #,9 #! 9,," "

("$*3(3"($#, (3(# !#"%%3#"'

- !%#,3(8

!9" !##"2! (8#,
)(#-

?

#,!-#,3# !( 9) $' "#

!%" #,3# !( "(3(8 ##$ #  ="8 !  "  ( , 

!0(3( !#  =3(#  !  (')##"

$!%  "

#(  $) 3(8

! 0("!#$  )'8 ##$#,"##, 0!"#)(  #,$ !$"!# !

#, "

* #"#8!#"(!% "(

*(C) ($#'3( !#,3( !# %"   #   #,)  3("*$  #,"#  #,  83)0!$  ($(  '  #  "

$  "!$  #, "33

%"# !

$'*#,3# !( '"

9$  6"(!$%)!

(#,( 3!$!# -!#,#,(,"!$-,"

33 $#,3( !#3# !"!$,"  )'8 ##$#,"#" 3(#, "9 $$9!

'*#,

!!%, !



! ?

# "  #"(/ !0,"!$"!#,(1( ) "

/ !0,"!$#,( $% $$!

   B- !

*9 #,( 3%###, ) #,!)  !#, !$"!# "!$(0"($ !09, %,#,3

 3%

%"

*( ( 0,#"##,# 8 %

$!%("#" #"03( (##, !$"!#  #"(# !0#,

$!%-#,"#(')##"

$!%%) $'3(8 ##$ "!$ !#,3( !#%" -#,3# !( ,"

!#'!"'

#, 0,

0,#"!*

)  #,  !)    9, %,  9"  !  #,  $ !$"!#  (0"($ !0  9, %,  #,

>3# !( 9 ,#

$!%  )'8 ##$#,"# 9" #, #"!$ #,%!# # !0( 3!$!#  !#,9( ##! #"#8!##,"##,

8!#9" !# 0!$'*#,( 3!$!# "!$#,)  9"  !%)8'!#)3!#,3

# "$"

$!%9 #,( 3%# ##, "8 )(#,( )'8 ##$#,"##,( !#, !0!(%($# ,9#,"##,3

,"$( ( ((

$!%

)(#,( )'8 ##$#,"##,3( !#3# !( >3

,"$"(

("



 ) #! + 

%,9" $ $!< ? ?"!$ !#, "

%" "

-(

"!%9" 3 "%$)3!#, "

8!#9, %,

9" !#'

$  )'8 ##$#,"##,3# !( "()!!% "(

*#(* !0 #$ "*#,3(%$ !0  + ,

!!%, !#,%"   #"(/ !0,"!$ "!#,(: )3(";- 9,

"! 9( !0#,( (!%,"

!0'!8"$##, 

!!%,-, $#,"##,3

," "!3# !# "$, !#

$!%!"

#, ) "!$ !%" , !#!$ #

$!%( "! 9(#,

$!%#,"# $'*#,$ !$"!#9 #,( 3%###, ) #,!) #3( )3!#,$ !$"!#-#,!-, ,"

( ( ,

0,#9 #,( 3%###, "8"!$#, "

$( ( "# ( 0,#," #'

#,(9,!,%   

!"

( !"!*%" '

(#,#,( 3"(#*'0 ! ,

$!%"!$ !%" ,

#( (  )%,( 0,# !#(8 #,3(

!  ($( @) ?

-#,!, ( "$

(')##"

9) $ #"!$ (

#$,(

"!#3(# #, "

$.)$08!#

(3($)%$,( !'

9&A DE) # !  9,#,( 8"!$"#(* (#,#( %)(##3(

$"!

33(#)!

#*##,3

# "$

!(')##"

!

* !#, %"   9,(,,"$( ( $, ( 0,# (')##"

 

!!%, %)(# !/)(.

#/ !0,5 %" : )3(";-9,

(A

!0)3!"$%

"!"(

(

!!%, !" 9"!#7")("!$"!A #,( 

!$(/ !0,-  <@?)!."'"!$"(*"!" :;"!$"

/ !0   !%,  ! "# !"

 (#

G(  6#$    4)!

3"


88 ##- ,"# !$""!$"!#,(-  <@)!."'"!$"(*"!"B?: ;-%(* #"

G$ #,#() 83(# #,3(

!  ($( @) ?!$#,3( !%

"9#,"#," '!!)!% "#$ #,"#3

," #,3# !# "$, !A (

$!%!"

#, ) -"!$ !%" -, !#!$ #

$!%("! 9(#,

$!%#,"# #' $'*#,$ !$"!#-" (0"($ #, ) #,!)  3( )3!#,$ !$"!#-, ,"

#( ( , ( 0,#)(#,(-, ,"

#=(% , 3# ! #,( 9,!,%   ,

!"

( !"!*%" '

(#,#,( 3"(#*'0 !  # 

$!%)#

,

#( ( "!* )%,( 0,#- !#(8

#,3(

($( @) ?

-, ( "$

(')##"

9) $ #"!$ (

#$ E) # ! 9,#,(3

%"! !$3!$!# * "$

(')##"

( )%, ) -#,!)  3)( *!#,$ !$"!#F (8"3 !("$ #,3(

!  ($( @) ?

"!$#, 3( !% "9!)!% "#$'*#,

!!%, !/)(.

#/ !0,5 %"

: )3(";- "= 8"# %#,"# !"%" -9,(#,("( ("

) -"!$ #,')($! 3(  8

 )3!#,$ !$"!#-3

9,

%! % ) ##,

"!$"

##,8"##( ! )-,%"!"$$)%,

!!# (#*

A"A

"

#, )  !% )$ !0#, !)  3(

9, )3!#,$ !$"!#(,"

!0 $#,

!"

-"

(0"($ #, ) -#,!)  3( )3!#,3

,

- ,%"!( ( , ( "$

!(')##"

$ ) #" (#-

"$ !0

!(')##"

"

"3"(# #,3

5 

$!% H,#,(, "$  !!0C)""

#, ) "!$%  ,

$!%( ( ( , (

$!%I @ (8#,"' $.)$08!#- "33"(!##,"##,( 0,#

(')##"

##,3

A3# !( 9) $'9 #,( 3%## ) !9, %, #,!)  !#,$ !$"!# "!$#, "

$( 0,#9

#' 3%

%"

( ( $"##,# 8 % !0#,

!"

("##, #"0 3( (#9, %,$ !$"!#  "$#,

$!% !%" ! )%,( 0,#

( ( $-#,!#, "

$( 0,# (

#$ < , "9 $$9! !#,"' $.)$08!# )

*"33

#,3( !#%" - ()3, !0#, 83)0!$($(- !" 8)%,"  "(!$ %)!

(#,3# !( ," !#'!"'

#3 !#)#"!* )#,!) %,9" !#,$ !$"!# - !(')##"

#9, %,#,3# !( %) $'

3(8 ##$# "$

$!%9 #,( 3%###,"

8!# $"#$ 

9, %,9" (

$)3!'*#,3# !( #,8

#, (3 !# #9) '(

"!##!##,"##,%!# # !0$ !$"!#  "!$,"$ !#, (9( ##! #"#8!# 3%

%"

*$!

0!"#)(

 !#,"

8!#"!$,"$ )(#,( #"#$#,"##, "

0$

8!#9" !

((

%#$ !#,( !)(%($" %!#83 "#$ )!$(/%# ! ? #,)!."'6"!$ !)%#- @@+"!$#,) - #9"

!%)8'!#)3!#,3

#,"

!#,"

# 3( #, "

8!#4( (- "(!$%)!

(#, 3# !( ," !#'!"'

#( (##, 3%

%($("##,# 8

$!%(3( (##,

$!% #,$ !$"!# ,"$ #"(#$# ,9#,"##,3# !( ,"$( ( ((

$!%!#, )- %,-#,!)  !#,$ !$"!# $$ !"

*-

#9) $'(

"!##!##,"# !#,( !"

8!# !#!

(%($" ," '!' ( $'*#,#( 
)(#

, !J'

 /)3(8
)(# ! #,%"  /,"

 /,*"8 /,##*"!$"!#,(1 ".!$("/,"!2"("#

(3(#$" :

;@/)3(8
)(#
"  ?<-,"$' ( $#,"##, 0,
)(# %"!!#-"##,$(3 "

,"#- !=(% # 39(  )3( !#!$!%)!$((# +
! # #)# !- !#( (9 #,#,($(  #( ')!"

(%)(#  (# #( %"! #- !=(% 39(-"%#" "%)(# "33"

(#,($( 

%)(#(#( ')!"

 )'($ !"## # #9" "

' ( !#, "

$.)$08!# #,"#  "  #"#)#(*  "8!$8!#  9 #,  ( 3%#  #  /%# !     #, 

(%$)(
$$ !#"!$%"!!#%)#$9!#,"8' #  0,
)(#5 39()!$((# +')#"##, "8# 8- #8) #'(88'($#,"# )%, #"#)#(*"8!$8!#$ !#%(( 3!$ !0 *=3"!$#, 0,
)(#5 .)( %#  )3( !#!$!%)!$((# +,39( !#( (!% )!$(#, (# #'23###,8 8)8#! )(#,"##,9,

.) # %$ !#%8#","

#"!$#, )!#"

! .) # %(8"

! 3)("!$

+ )!3

)#$ !($(#8"

!#"

!3)'

%%!

!#, )!%# !

#( ')!"

"!$%)(#  )'($ !"###, 0,
)(# #9" "

' ( $#,"# #,39()!$((# +8"*')!

##($')# # =(%  )'.%## , 0,$0( .)$ $

! 73 !0 !

9#,"' -#, #,3 !#,"##,

83)0!$($($  !#%"

("!* !#( (!%'*#, 
)(#9,

=(%

!0 # 39( )!$((# + #,
! # #)# !$ ""!$ "%%($ !0 *-#, 83)0!$($( )3, $"!$#,3( !#(

!3# !

'

!08(  -$ (  #'$ $"!$ "%%($ !0 *$ $ '()"(* +#,-  :1 7/6;

)!#   H,#,( 3"2 !0>(" !$ &  > H,#,((3(#"'

&  >