M/S Shastri Construction Co. Th Its Sole Proprietor D.P Singh v. Union Of India Th Chief Engineer Bhatinda Cantt

   
   
 










  ! !"#$#%&!'()(*+,

 -.$/0$ (#
%$ ()" #%
 ! # #%!( 1!($)$ %#% %2# !$3%2!%
-&45-/
/ 565 


 
  

 





  


 




 
  


 




/ 565758


 




 
!

 

  "# $"

"$ %


&
 


' 
(' 
) *




"

+ ,  


!











-


 
.

$%

./0
(1
-"*



&
 
& 

 
&2
!






 

 )
 
$"

"

.//
(1
-3* 
 
& 

 

 



4

3
 

  !

5 
 


 & 



  

 
 

6
 

  


     





  

    !"#$  % &   

      7

8
 
!


  




!

9

 9
 

 


 



&
&




&
! 


 
 
 
& &






!

:


5 !


 



1 



!

 

&
 
1 

 
  !



& 

&
 


 


 


 

&


(
4

#""

"$ $*
 




&
 
 


 
& - '( )          #*+"*,-   "#$   

 ).     +/

     0    1               

#*+"*,-

     +/        

        "#$   

           

      ).                         "#$          &)              +/



      +/    


                    2. ) 
   




     3 "**"  4+5  )  67*                   

 %              


     

 %     
          

 #*+"*,-    )))

  

  #*+"*,-#"#"*,,                                     86*   ' 9 1         #"#"*,,  )
   

         

:

 )           #"#"*,, 1    :

 )";*#/"/9 #


;1
 
 




 
!

 

   

 
 


 





&

&

& 6
 

       3<   

         #,/7"**#            

+ ="""*+*60&>    #+/,#/"/2.2  )       

       #*/+"*,-   /#"#"*,,!

"#$ 

                   ="6+776,#                        2                     2.  2   )           2   

             2.  2   )  

               

 #*/+"*,-/#"#"*,,

                3<

         ="6+776,#        3<   2              

#+/,#/"/ 2.2 )   ="6+776,#          3<      

/#"#"*,,

    ?        

           %     )             

3<    

         9 %









 



3%::3 /"

 
 

<
"=




!
 
 


 

 
 

 

 &


 
!

 




 




&
 



 

  



9
&
 

1  


!

& 



&


  





&




>- ' !
)& 




 


&!



6        

        

 7

/

!!

?
 


 


 


 



6 


 
  

 7



2  


 


  
&



 
 



 



 
 



.

8





 
  
& 





 
 
&


 
 


 
!
 








@ 9&
A !
 
 6      


    !
"#$%&
'

#()*




 
@
 
 



&
 
 1
 
 &


6@

                

3 (         7

$




 9









@ 9&
A !
 

6+       

 ' !  7
,*((%-##
''#.#
 



&&

 6      

      ()1#"&*&#//7          67                   

                       

                      9 4:



B !


 









 

6/ 0  '   !     1   7
*((#,#-','  -2(*


A  ' 





 
 
 


 
   - 



&
 6= 

 %  %  %   

   &           ";$         )  

 *$       

   7

"

C
 




 -  
+

  

6
   13   

'

 4

  '

 7
*(#(,2)-','  -..25
 




&
 



 
 

&


   



!
 



&
 
& 
  


 
& - '                        

                    

  &        

                       


 

     )            !";$         2                            )  

         

     9

 
 


9




 
! 



' 
+



@ 9&
A !
 

66 /'

 

,7-! 

 5
 0  '4

 7
*(#8",
'-.8%


@

) 
 '



&
'3$

       & 4-5  6"   "**+      

1 45    A    ) )  45       

1 45  <  45      A         .   .  

  B  C8D) 45   "*7/             "**+1 

:

)(  
  45     & 4-5  6"   "**+                    

1 459

:


 


  
 


 
  



&



8
!


&
! 



& 
 

 

 



 
 & 


.:$

 


 


     9,-
 & 
 

 


  
!
 
 



 
 



 

 &
 
 

;


 

 
 

4

::

 

+            ,-
 









 
 



 
 



 

 





 





 
 


& ! 





!&



#


 

 
 

A 

 &
( *
  

&
!





 

& 
2 

& 




 
 1


& ,  




  



 
 









     


 

&

 










 



  
 
 






 



  


4

"


 


- 6= &)          

 

             )                               #*/*"**, 4 ?&"5 =#*6,*"70&  !";$  /#/+"**/4 

 

   5  

   

 

 

  9 4 









 

#=


!
!
 
 
 

!

 
 







 !
 









6
 
 

7
 

&
 

& 
  

 &



 
 !
 


6 

7

%

8
 
 


 

 


& 

"=
!
 
 



 
 


 !
& ! 99

 
 
 
2!

 


A








 

 
 
& !
1 &
!
 !


!

&



 



 


 
 
& !

9 
9
&
 

9


 9

D
!


1 !
 
 !

 !!











$$5-

 
 
  



 




$=

@








!
 





 






 
 



!





 

 !



$$5-E

$5F

$5-

8 






 
 



$5-



 
& !
 
9 
9

 


 &

 &

&
 
!


 


 
  

  

 
 !



&
1

 



/

C



 


 


  

!

 
 






  
&
 
 

!

9

 
 

99
 

& !
  

 &
 
  

! 
 



&
 
&2

 
 
&


 



  

 

&


 



!




9


9



5' !
)&

.

;
 
! 


/!+': 6/ '

 

,7-!9,-
 

 
 1

 

&- 
0

A 
3


4
& 


..%
 

 


 


.:$

8


 
!

  



 
 

!!

?
&
&




A


'

 




 
 1

 

A 
3 (0*


 



 

!


&

 &

! 
 

&

 


 


.:$


 !&  







 
&

!


 
& 


 
+ - '-* @  
 

          

( 3: %

 

  (   3             A  
 

         





   ,/ =       A    E@       6"4-5       )      "**+  4    ' E5   E EF ,"   A  

    6"4-5      G 6"4-545H  

   



    

         

                   

            45                    

    

E ,7                     

       E E          E C E                                              EE    E E     ,;   

         EE       E E       6"4-545   &  

      

    ,+  
     

  6"4-545    E E   

 ,- ) &  6"4-545     E     E& 45 E  E EE       E E    
     6"4-545  E   

 E    

  EE
        6"4-545   EE
 & 45

 E E      E E    & 45 ,,  

 E   E     6"4-5           

     9 "$

& 



 
 
1



 
!

   !

5
@
 
(GH*
 9
 
( *



 

&

 



 



 
 




 
1






  
&
  

9 !

9



& !

99
  ! 
 


 !





  9 
9
&2
 
 




 
9
9

 "


!

 



&
 
;1
 
 










-)
@ 
 






3%::3 /"
  


&  


! 
   


 

 


& !

99

""



 





 & 
!

 7/ 5658 !'()(*+,

     
 , 5  I54

 


 & I54