Tirath Singh v. Arjun Singh










 





 











































 

            

  
          

!"#$
%
&'%()$
$* 
)((#
  



  !"#

  ! $

    

   !"  #$ %$!
&' ( "$) *+,-.* $$ / *#*#$0+,-.* 

+++++
$* 
)((#,
&


*##!$ $$ *#*$*

,1 &23**



,1 &24* 5   ,$$*#
$-$# 6 ! ($ %$-$$+ ) **+ $"$$! *#$.*$   $$7  $!*  *  ""$! . &,
(  $$ 8 # .  *  7#*$$

$#* $ .-5 4+

72*#!8$ $* * 49* " "$  ## $ *!$. # *#  .   !

$"   $$7 * 

: 4

+ *.. 8*#***"  4+

72.*"  8* $$*$ $!*+ *1. * 8$$!7.$$ *-  7#*$$



;   8$ *" $# 5   $$7 *+ $

*#* #*$$

 8"5 "$"$" *  $  #$*$#$5  *5 * *"     3+3+ 4472 * 

4;$ ! **$ 8$1  *$* $ .#*$" * $ . 1*"$*$+ * *"$ $ $!*  *.. $!"*$*$5 $$$!* "5 8 5    " $"  $"  <8-+      *"$ $!*    ,$#+ $ + 8  .$- "5 $!     * * $ $!*   ; $ *!   * $ $ 1$ $   $    $.  * *"#7** $!*  ,$#*."*8$ $$ $!* *-*$#*#$ $"*"#5,0* *$!
"*5 .*5$!  $ 
""$$,!.5;$  *!   #* $*#
  .""$ * !  *  $##!*#$5 $ $"$$!   *#$.*$  $!*  *  ""$! .

 &,
( *=+) **+$. ,..  : *$$!,$# ,   +    .*5+ *  "$ **$"$#**#$.*$8* $#5 $$**#$..*$ *.

 ,1  &23    $$ $  .

*##!    *

+   +   . *#$.*$ $# 5 $"  *" #$ .*"*$*$* *$!

#5$"$5#*$*#
 ; **!  *$ .#*$"*5

 $# *5 .  .#*$" 8$  !*  *##! #$*$#$5    *5 * *"     3+3+ 4472 *  

4+

 + $$$$#* .*5-$.> **##! #$*$#$5  ;+. # * "$ *#$*#$.*$8*$"$5 $*#
  !  $!$*# *..  0 "*$*$ 5   *#$.*7 * *  *-*$#*#.?*+ $!$*#*.. 0 *- . *$-$8 .

*!.$. "*.+ $$$." "*$*$ *  *#$.*$  $!*       ; *- *. # *$+  *20 *$. #*#5 $" !,1 &23*&24   7#*$$

$# *  $  .-5  4+

72 8* $.    . # 5 $"   !

.""$$ *!.5   $$  ;   8$ *"+  $$7 **0*#* ***"   3+3+ 4472*  

4 $  *$! *!*$   7#*$$

    $  $!. !!$- *. $#* $

 .-5    3+3+ 4472 
.#5+ $   
+  $$ * $   !

 *5  

  $# * .  .#*$" 8$ !*  .-5  * *"    3+3+ 4472  7#*$$

$ $.21*"$*$ **"$ $$!* $ $" $$  7#*$$

$**5$ #$$!*$   $$ *#$ $# * *#$.*$ $!*  * $  *"8*$"$5 $*#
 -$*

,1 &23$"*$#58

 ! *"#5 **  *$ .#*$"



$# .  .#*$"+  
  *$#  * 8 *  #   8 #  - 5 *0$!   #*$$

 * $   !$- .$" $!*   ."*$ 8$  $!*  8 $.

 *##!#5 ** $  *.. 0"*$*$5 *#$.*7 *, * 8$!

$ "$ $*#
 $ *.. 0$$!$*# *.  * * * $*#
 $"$ *#$*#$.*$.*1$8$  .$ $!$*#*..  0  $*#
 
 # $$$$*$$  $ 5 $#$! .*#$.*$$ *. -*$ $*#
  *  # 8 #-5*0$! #*$$

*

$   !$- .$" $!*   ."*$ *   *7$$ *$ .#*$"

 $#*. .#*$";

$"$$.$  * $! $.  *

+   $$ $  ."  "*$*$ *  *#$.*$0$!."*$ $!*   $ 8$ *##!$!* $ $"  $**+ $*#
  *$!

#5 # ** *$  .#*$"

 $#*5. .#*$" *$ *##!$$  *..  0 "*$*$ 5  $"+   #   8 #  -5."*$ $!*  7#*$$

 $  $$ *  "* *5  "$$ 8$  !*  .$  $ .#*$"  0$!  .$   . " &,
( *$$!,..  : ,$# , ,*#5@ "*5

*!#+; $*5" .

#$##!*#$5$ $" ! 8**$!$-$ A !$!*+ $$ *$#*$*..$!#5 $"$#*-$! *$* $8.



















 


B%) #*$C