High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3624/2013dismissed

Balbir Singh Wasu v. General Public And Others

2015-08-07Mr. Justice Harbans Singh Rai12 pages

#$%&'()

*& +& ,&$* %$(& -

#"$%"&'%!'!

#(')* '%%"+ ,"#

-.,/( 01 2 "* $

#" 0"1 3

-.,/( 0# ".%,* !"

,40

4/ #1 *& &.') ! /!

&(-& &* .$!'& /0( &') ! /!

&(&- 5&$

1(-&%&($$&/&&- %2(&$ &(-&%- 1(-0 $%2 (&-4 &&&%-( 5 67* *

0(((%7(% ((/%7(% /((2( $%&8 %84%2( -&(50((5%$2 ( 5(&$& %%2( $&.

!(&(%2(&& 3

9(($5 5%5%$!/ & 50((0&($5%$ 1(&&0($$ % & ( & 3:

( & &8 ( ($$5(&/- :

: )(/&$00&75% &( &%$0!

&(%804 -&&(&$%84 (7(%* *

(/%-&-&$2-&/(2( $ % &/ / 1( &! & &( ( %8 && ( &$&8 5 (& & && ( &&67* *!(20& 2&$ 5-& 5%$67* ( &%&/07(67* 05&0((') 0(5$ -&2&2 ( 5((20&5%$67* :0(((% &$$2&5%$0-(&-((/ ( % %;

$2 $! ( & ($ ( 67 * : 0 $ 5%$67*3*

0(((%-&/ $2($% 5%$0&& &&%2(.

$&%2(6

& 0(((%-&/%2*)"!0(0.

& (6

67*

* 50(((%&$$2 % 5%$! -( - ( 5 %2 ( <5 17 55&0&&$&($5%$3

&(& /(%/%2( -& 54(55%$ ( ( & %&/ ( ( 5 0 $ &5 5%$ /67* "0&& (< &$$5

&!.$(&!

67* 0(&& ('$5

&67* 0($& (

($'$555& 1(2(% -&/%2*) 0(0$&4('$5)(%$ / 67* :!* * "* (%&$&($% 5%$67* 0(-(-2 (&$-0& &2 7 %29&5'() 0(0(&* 0( (&-(-27 %2(5 67* ""0&$-(

-(2&55%$!(&08 -&/ & $$2- <(5& -$!0 $%!(& &!( & ( (&- 57(%0((0(/& &&%/ %5%$(&5 57(%( % %;

$2-&/!(& &!(2(%/$$2&/ 1( & ( $ & && ( ( 8 && 5%$2( %$&25%2(&. !0((0 &5&/((5&%&- &(

<0 $(( & -&% $( 2& 33 1((($($2 &(- &-

7(% 5 &&/%8 (-&<0 $% 5%/ 0((%( &(4 $2<(/ /$( %525((-&&% $& 5 &(5-$&/2 8 &&$;

4&$

5%& 5!(%($( 50((7(% &7(% 5%&-0((-& 5 =' 1&8 >(5( (& +& ?$5& '25$'22(& 3 '" !@< < & /5*$'(#

' A < 5( 5 0((0&7(%!5 (5!&-&%8( 5%$2!0&5%$ &2&!(0 $$02% -%$ &-&(( 50((&7(%& 0&($---&(&0 $%() (/ 5 %2

$ 5 & ( $& &5 & %2 7-$ 4 '/&$& $%&% (5%

&(5&0((0 &&$(00

& 5 & ( &$ -& 1( $$ & (0-&2%&0%( & -&% &$( " (%84%2( $ &(-&!< 0$$ (67*"*:&(&%- ($&0&%2 (&(6

&( &(&(5&$ (5$/ & (5! ( &% -! 0(( 0& $2 &2/!%&0( (8

&(&-& (5&5-$ &'" ( 6/ 1(&0/ 0(2(&$ $% -& !(& &!&%- $(/%&/67 *3*

&$&0&%2(6

&9&5'( &> &((-& (50%& ((& ( *)"!-&0&4(6

1(%8&40( &&/&2 5 &0((( & ((0(/ % 75 (& (0(5-&-&7(% 5%&(/%/ 1(5& ((/&(&< (& 50&$$%( 2 ( 5&/ ((/%&/&$ $%5(5!( $(/%4(5

& 5 1(-& 54%8&/ 5 / &-&&0-&/$5- 5% 0 (/ $ 5 %2 ( ( '

-&5 & (5$/ -& 0(2- 5 $%&$/0(2-

5 $%%8<0$$2(2 ($0$

00 $%5%$!%5-& &5/ ( &!% <5 2(('

-&5 &$ 0 (0$02&%(/(&$(0(2 $5(-&&< 0#-'($$*($+& ' , 8&

$0(5%$2 5(&$&5$ -&!0(( &0&/&$$( %& &-&&(00$$$0(%80(&& 5%$2 5&$ 1(& 0 $2 &5$% 0 $(0$20$0 ( ($$ %--$ $$ &$ 0&4!%( /$ &5$ 1 $5$2(&$! &$ %2%& %2( -&!( &&B5$(-& &$0 & C)(/&%8& &/4 && (5%$2 25&$ &5 &$ /!

(&$ &54 (%8 5&4(%8 5/$27(%( &&&(%8-& (&$/ %8 ( %8%($( $8 5 < ( & ( $((%8& %$(8 &5&4- (/ 7$ &5&< &/0(&$$$2 - ( &90/&!

(%8&$ 2 5- 2 5 ( &((%8% &-&

&(& D&$$(&%8(-& & %/%

$$0

1(%/-& &! $$0!0$$(/0 /D& ((5 (&$ &! & /4!0 $ %0

& (%8( & 75 (01(00 &$( &!

2'(( -&& &!0((5 %8&B/&&--$&&/ ( $8 5 (&$ &!&5( && (/04%2(&$ &&&( %8!0( %(&&5((&$ & & &(-$E 1(0$$!(& &!$/ &((& 0-& $& 0(&( &% 48 (/55$21(0 $%0(& & 5 0(( 5-! ( & % %/ (

5- 5&/0( %8!((

5%$2$ 0$$%%&&%2$0%2($ 5-$2 ' (<'5- D&2(& 5&& 5%$2! ( &455& $ 5%$2!(&$$$5 -&&< -&(%8% (5%$2!( (5 %($$ $$5! ( 5 $5$2 & %(5! $%4 & --$ /$%$ & '

" ( /$ *& & &(&F

", 1(& &/&$%2/& 5-&/ '

" (1(($$%(

&&(%-/&$2(&&-!( $(/

%- (1(5-&/ & (55 0 &(-&%& &$-&(((&

& 5%2 -&$$0 &((& 0( &$<(%(& 0(&( &( 4/0 1( &(4/0% (5%$2 ( 50(((//< $(/&&/( $( ( 8 5 #- '($$ *($F -& % &(5 & 5< 04/0!5 (/ %$$-%$ &(-&0(0&&/(2&$ $ % -$ 5%$2 5 & ( 5

& 5(( 50(((/%&// ( (/%&/( $%(01( &0 $(% % -& (&$( $%-$( 5 (5 $/&2 8 5< (8 5$&&& 54&$ 5!0((( $(/!(& -&//$%$ & --$(5&& &&%/(& ( '

" ( (5& 5( & --$ : 1($/ &&0((&(&2( & &/ & &$ ( %&(-0& ( &&7& ( -&/&28 &!($$% & 5- (54 & & &$2 (&/$20((&&&&&&$$$2(&& -<(%(7-& & &(0(0-%$

" (0%& (- $2(& ( &$ ( 1($%&$--&(520$$%55/

54 -- $ --&( < 0 $ $4 %& -$ ( -& &( &F50%2 &/$ &/ - 1( (0( 5 $%$0(0(( &2/-& 0(&&$0(0%/

/$%$(%&%2( &$ /&$8 5 0((&&-&1 0'5&*$'(+& 945'(

3 *@" !'* &&+& '%&'(

"" ! 5 (& (@+& 5'& -(& ((@

! -5.+& > $0, -!/$/ 33

" 1( 8 5! 0(( & -& &&-&& &% $

&-&& & %&.

1(9( & 05 &-& $8 5 &&5$- &-

&0$%&&2< &(-&&& $$0<0 $ ($%&- &-$2 3

-&20(5 &(&& ( &&-&&5%$2 & $ &5 -& $(&$ &($$(%8&%& (--&-& 5!0((!52/0!0 $(/%( & 5(

$ # (!(-&(&-(

5%$2 5(& ((9( &0- &&&$&/$/3:

0( 5( 5%$2&&$2((2$$&-&0$$%% & & 554<%-&5&5 (9( &-&$$ & &(8 %2 %& .

$ 0((((& & 5($&21(& 5

/ %2 ( $& $ 0 $ -&5 && %& &0$$&&$ 2(( (9( &-&0(&&&$&!( 57(%/0((0& %5%$ $%&B-% (9( &-&-&$2& (51( %;

- $%2(-&0 $52 &< (&&2 50((&&/(& (0 0(0 /$%$ &&B75!0 $%-%$ &( -&& ((/ (-&0(0 /$%$ 0( ( 75 ( $ % %& ( % & /<(/$$&2($00(& &(8 5

-&5 &( 50((7(%- 0(-& &$$0 &(-&0((%(7(% 5%&! (% &$0( ;

$2%& -& (5(5&&;

&%2$0

<0 $(& & 2/& (& 5((& &7(%0((&$$-&/< (2&-&/!& ( -&! ( ( 4 (5$ & ( ( (& &5& (-& &4/ (5( 5 & 51(-&0&&2 &((&((2 5-54&$& 50( --&-&-& < (0( & &4%2(-&% &( &%$0!

(20$$4(;

(&0&

1($& $ &(-&-$&$5 5 ('

-&5 &! 0((0((&-

$0&$(7(% 5&$%$2<(5

&(&-&( & 5 -(0( /&( (%& &5( - 0(( < (/ &4 7-& ( %/ -&&-( < /&'((&+& G <

" !( &0($( &%& 5&2/ &&!(55 $2%5%$% (5 % &0($01( $0 $& &( (00( -4% ()$$( 5($-! ( 40( ()$$! (0$$% 7(% (& ( (51(-&-5$&$20& %$ 0 &;

&40( ()$$1(5 (-&( & ( 5<(%($%2 (*&/2 $855$+'--( "@.3 ( &((0(&-&(50((7 & &%(40$51(&(&(4- ( ()$$&$$ &0$2& & 50(&((<0 $!(& &!&/(- &-

7 ( 50$$(5$-2 (-&0( 7 ( 5(&;

&40

< &5$8 > &+' *(&

-&5 &"":!( &0($(-& 5

(07 5-%2($& $(-&/ - (9( &52(/

$& &% (5%$2 5 5 ( & 2 -&2 ($$ ( 5 % & ( %& &<(/- (% &2 (& 5

(&$&-& 8 5< $&&B-& <'&@4(#& ((&+'&*5>>$(& <

33'

-&5 & "!( &0($(& -2

2&$ 50$$%-& 5- &'3 ( 6/ <(/;

&&$0((5(8 50(( (-&520$$ 2&$5( 50(( $(/%&$ < 9&(&*&'((&+ &*&(& < 3"'

-&5 & "!( &0 ($0(7 -& 5-0((0 $% /$%$ &'3 (6/ 1(8 50$$%

&(57&$& @& $( (&8 50((&&$/ &(- &- -$

(&/-% 52/0$2/&0($5( &0(/$ 5/- &-$5 5%B8 5%

<-((&/-0(((&/ 1(-5&$ <-&25- 75-$&2!

$2 % '"B ( 75- 75-$&2 &( &/-<5(&/-0( !"

HB 7(&( $0((5$ (-&( -$2&-%$ (&$!%(/-& ( /& "2& -& ./.#65278 9: