High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3304/2018disposed of

Tilak Raj (Deceased) Through Lrs v. Sukhwinder Kaur

2018-05-18Mr. Justice Satpal3 pages

!"#!$%&%'() %*+ ,&%'$!#!$!&!# -./0-*!0*.!1.!&!' %2!& ! % %'!.

2& 3/+-4%'#!.5/.

!&1'#!'

.6( '78*! ./& %$!.%'#!.3%'0-3%#-/

.!&!' (9

.0, 3%'0-:**%;#2$ ! ". -!1! % %'!.&

-%& .!2%&%' 1! % %' -& 8!!' "%*!# 8< -! 1! % %'!.& %61/0'%'0 -!.#!.# !#=>''!?/.! 9 1&&!#8<*!.'!# ##% %'*%2%*/#0!3!'%.%2%&%'

*'#-.4-!.!8< -!%.#!"!'$!

%' !' 11*%$ %')@# !#)@-&8!!'& ./$+"""."%*/.! "%*! -!4.% !'& !6!' -!.!&1'#!' "%*!#1! % %'/'#!.3!$ %'" -!&

/',8 .8' !' !& .%$ %'$ ;==".!,!$ 6!' "%*+ , -!

!''

".6 -!1.!6%&!&%'A/!& %' -!1! % %'!.&.! -!4%#4;&''##/0- !."&%#%*+

,;4-#%!##/.%'0 -!1!'#!'$<" -!!2%$ %'1! % %' %$! " -! !2%$ %' 1! % %' 4& %&&/!# '# %*+ , 11!.!#'@ -./0--%&$/'&!*'#&/0- %6! "%*! -! 4.% !'& !6!' -!$&!4&#,/.'!# )@ ')@ 4.% !'& !6!' 4&' "%*!#'# -!$&!4&#,/.'!# =@ &=@4&#!$*.!#&-*%#<;& -!$&!4& +!'/1' @ '# 4& #,/.'!# @ ". "%*%'0 -! 4.% !' & !6!' %& -!$&!" -!1! % %'!.& - '@ -!*4<!.& *'#-.8&!.2!#7B.+<7;& -!$&!4&#,/.'!#

99 99 => 0%' 4.% !'& !6!' 4&' "%*!#'# -!$&!4& #,/.'!# => &/8,!$ 1<6!' " &C9 & $& &

!'4-%*!;%*+ ,#%!#' @> -!$&!4&#,/.'!# >".!'8*%'0 -!*'#*.# "%*!'11*%$ %' 8.%'0' .!$.# -!*!0*.!1.!&!' %2!&" !'' %*+ , D%#!.#!.# !#@>> -!1! % %'!.&: &"%*+ ,

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

<-#2%*!#"'*< 411. /'% %!& "%*! -!4.% !'& !6!' -!%61/0'!#.#!.4& 1&&!#!2!'8!".! -!!?1%.<"=#<&".6 -!%.11!.'$!!& !& - -! "%*/.! "%*! -! 4.% !' & !6!' 4& ' %' !' %'* -! 1! % %'!.&4/*#8!0.2!*<1.!,/#%$!#%" -!<.!' **4!# "%*! -! 4.% !'& !6!' !"/. -!.& !& - " !.1&&%'0" -!%61/0'!# .#!.; -!$&!-&' 8!!'1.0.!&&!#'#'*< 44% '!&&!&" -! 1*%' %""-# !'#!.!# -!%.""%#2% &' @-!$&!& '#& #,/.'#". -!%.$.&&9!?6%' %'". #<%!

99 99 '&%#!.%'0 -!".!&%#"$ &'#$%.$/6& '$!&% 6<8!%' -! %' !.!& ",/& %$! - -!1! % %'!.&.!0%2!''!*& 11. /'% < "%*! -!4.% !'& !6!' $$.#%'0*<; -!.!2%&%'1! % %'%&**4!#-!.#!.# !# =>''!?/.! 9 -!!? !' "& .%+%'0"" -!#!"!'$!" -! 1! % %'!.& %& &! &%#! -! *!.'!# .%* $/. 6< 0.' '! *& 11. /'% < -!1! % %'!.& "%*!4.% !'& !6!' ;4-%$-6<8!"%*!# '.8!".!)-%&&-**8!&/8,!$ 1<6!' " &;C9 &$& &; 8!1%# -!.!&1'#!' 9*'#*.# <6!' "$& &&-**8!

-!$'#% %'1.!$!#!' ".0.' %'0%'#/*0!'$!%'"2/." -!1! % %'!.& "%*! -!4.% !'& !6!' -%& .#!. -& 8!!'1&&!# 4% -/ %&&/%'0' %$! -! .!&1'#!' %'.#!. 2%#/''!$!&&.<!?1!'&!'##!*<$1<" -%& .#!.6<8!$'2!<!# -!.!&1'#!' ' -!!2!' "-!.-2%'0'< 8,!$ %';&-!6<"%*!'11*%$ %' - !""!$ '.!$!%1 " -! 11*%$ %'; -!&6!8!*%& !#".-!.%'0 .%'#!.3%'0-3%#-/

) /#0! #%'!&- B-! -!.&1!+%'0C.!&'!# !&C B-! -!. !1. 8*!( !&C