M/S Max India Ltd. v. M/S Exl India And Another
! "#$% &'(&)*
,! &'()*
!-".
&# /*& (00
#1&+
- 23 - +4.5
+ -
+ &+ (6+"4.5
+ !-".
77777 004 3 5 ! "-
" ! "!
" +.
.
:; <6+ <<= "8 !-".
!6:!
6!
< =3 33 .:
".
! + :
.&'()* 3+683 (3 6< & <3 ! +
+ !
+ !6 "!
. " > ". ?6!
" <4 "
" +
6!
< !9 .
!6:!
"
-6+<.
"+ "!-+ 9- "; + 5
* 9
".-+.6
< " 3+ @
" 6<& <3 + "
"6 "8= 3 !6 3
"
"+ !
"
+<< "8 9- ";=3 3= !+ 8 !
. 9- ";= ! -6+<.
"+ "!-+
9- "; + 5
* 9
.:6 ! .
"
!&'()*3
3 . :
" "!
. 3+683 ""1
; ". !36<. :
- +9
!6:!
9 !.
! + - "
3 . 9 :6 3
-< 3 . "
.
!6:!
" =6<. " 6!
-+ ?6.
! "
&'!)* !" < <
;:6 "<; -6+ <.
"+ "!-+ 9- "; + 5
* 9
.= ! 9- ";+ 8 !
.
6".
+ 9- ! ".3 4 - +!"= 3 " 9
" "8
9- ! ". 9-
"!
!6 5 <6+
!+ A6 + .6".
+ +.
+ ". 6< > 3
"+ !+.
"..
!
88+ !
!6 3 .:
" < .:;""1
;4
=3 3 6<.
"<; +9 .
!6 3
"= <<+ !6< !6 < 9:
"8:
++ .:;< = ".3
!< :< :
?
.3 85 +" "8-+5 ! "+3=
- + .< 9
"= <<:
6"
. ! <
+<;:+683 6".
+(
* 9
" + -+.6 !6".
+#1
! "
#
$ %
& $ %
< 6!
BC !" :< + "
= 9- ";=3 3:
"!
" !! 8"9 +.
5<6 "4 < 6!
BC-+5 !-
!4 !6
96!
:
"3 5 "8:
"5 < .<; "!
. 3 !!6 =3
9 !! " " <6.
"
= -< ! !6:!
. = 3
!6:!
."
!.6 9 !
9 .
"8.
3+" !
9 D .A6 "
".< = ".= <<<
:
.
.
.
<"8= 3 + !!6 !:; <6+ 3 .
!
< ? " !!6 " "
"
= !" :"
.
+. .
" + !
.6 . < 8 +" !
"8"
";6". ! <!
.
+-+
"
".
< 9
" "" :
D <6.
. :;
"-+5 !3 <6+ = << "! .
+ !
.+ !-
"!-
! "..
.
" !!6 < 9
" <"8= + !!6 !
?6.89 < 83 (
"
* 9
" 3 +.
+6+ :
<==3 < 9
" "8 !
< + :5
". 5 ! "-
" !. !-!
.
=6<. --
+
!"!- !!6 +. "8< 9
":6 "
< 83
! <<= ". " -+!-
.
! "8 " !!6 < 9
"4 6+ 9 ;+ !6 3 !!6
--+-+